Page Turner

'Gone Girl' is up for prestigious British prize

Gillian Flynn goes against heavyweight Hilary Mantel for renamed Orange Prize

By Mary Pols Mar 13, 2013 6:06AM
The wildly popular American novelist Gillian Flynn--whose last two books are among the hottest properties in Hollywood--is up for a prestigious British prize for women's fiction for her character study turned thriller, "Gone Girl." The longlist for the prize formerly known as the Orange (which is far more prosaic than it sounds, having been named for its corporate sponsor, the UK telephone company) also includes British heavyweights Hilary Mantel for "Bring Up the Bodies" (which just won the Booker), Zadie Smith for "NW" and American novelists Barbara Kingsolver for "Flight Behavior" and A M Homes for "May We Be Forgiven."

Because the telephone company apparently wasn't up for sponsoring literature (the Guardian says Orange is concentrating on cinematic philanthropy this year), the prize has been renamed the Women's Prize for Fiction, at least for this year. A bit boring, yes? But the reason for the generic name is that the prize is now being sponsored by private individuals, among them the popular writer Joanna Trollope and Cherie Blair. But the nominees (here's the full list) is loaded with American writers--the prize may be British, but the rules allow any women's fiction published in the UK. It includes two novels, "The Red Book," by former photojournalist Deborah Copaken Kogan, the story of a group of friends meeting for their 25th Harvard reunion and "Where'd You Go Bernadette," former TV writer Maria Semple, a wonderfully whacky tale of a Seattle misanthrope, which are about the farthest thing from stuffy.

Bing: More on Gillian Flynn

The new Kate Atkinson, "Life after Life," which comes out in America next month (can't wait!), also made the longlist. Also on the list, something a little controversial, Sheila Heti's "How Should a Person Be," which some consider more of a memoir than a novel. It received mixed reviews along the lines of, it's genius, it's garbage. I haven't cracked it yet. Another longlisted book that has had an iffy reception, Smith's "NW." I tried it before Christmas, but my library only let me keep it for a week since it was brand spanking new and I wasn't enraptured enough to try to get it out again. I can't read the Mantel until I read "Wolf Hall," since "Bring Up the Bodies" is a sequel. The Flynn novel is a fantastic read although I had some trouble with the ending (and would slick Amy ever been duped by her fishing buddies? I think not). I have my fingers crossed that Reese Witherspoon plays the lead in the movie version. She's optioned it, so there's a good chance; she'd make the perfect Amy. I don't think Flynn's book has a chance against the Mantels, Kingsolvers (loved "Flight Behavior") or Zadie Smiths, but we'll see. What do you think? Please, weigh in in the comments.

The actual panel of judges is chaired by actress Miranda Richardson and includes Razia Iqbal, Natasha Walter, Jojo Moyes and Rachel Johnson. The prize comes with a cash prize (30,000 pounds) and will be awarded June 5. Richardson announced that the group has already faced "daunting" work while whittling 140 entries down to 20. "I don't anticipate the job becoming easier at the next stage!" she said.

Bing: More on Hilary Mantel
7Comments
Mar 14, 2013 6:25AM
avatar
Totally loved the book until the end.  Bad ending!!  Very disappointed.
Mar 14, 2013 7:06AM
avatar

Loved the way the book was written but was totally dissappointed with ending!  Really - another coniving selfish woman having it all!  Why do men stick with these women???

Mar 14, 2013 1:58AM
avatar
GONE GIRL is certainly worthy of all the praise it's garnered.  It's like a Cassavetes film scripted by Jim Thompson at his most toxic.  That said, I hate to see Flynn, whose previous novel DARK PLACES, was also excellent, transcend the overcrowded suspense/thriller genre, only to be pigeon-holed as a writer of "women's fiction."  Is there a separate prize for men's fiction?
Mar 14, 2013 9:36AM
avatar
such a great book, but the ending blew the whole thing for me. 
Mar 14, 2013 10:30AM
avatar

Dreadful book...terrible ending

Much better literature out there (James Burke, CJ Box, etc)

Tragic

Mar 14, 2013 7:30AM
avatar
Found gone girl to be predictable, how was this a thriller? I guessed the ending before I even got halfway through! Not thrilling. That having been said, her first novel Sharp Objects was amazing.  Dark Places was fine.  I would say against Kingsolver's Flight Behavior there should be no contest, Flight Behavior was far superior to Gone Girl. 
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?