Twilight Blog on MSN Movies

Stephenie Meyer Addresses 'Breaking Dawn - Part 2' Ending

Her own words, on her official site

By dazzledbytwilight Dec 5, 2012 12:05PM
On her official Stephenie Meyer website, the 'Twilight' series author addresses the ending of 'Breaking Dawn, Part 2.'

Spoiler Alert!

The question, which I got frequently, was how I felt about having a big change inserted into the story during the final climax. My answer was that it didn't feel like such a huge departure. For me, this moment is already in the book. However, we don't get to see it in all its exciting and gory detail because we are seeing the world only through Bella's eyes. A few of the reporters I talked to wanted to know where in the book this moment was hidden. The answer is page 738, fourth paragraph down:

"Aro stared into my eyes for a long, tense moment. I had no idea what he was searching for, or what he found, but after he had measured me for that moment, something in his face changed, a faint shift in the set of his mouth and eyes, and I knew that Aro had made his decision."

In this short analysis, after Bella has revealed the depth of her power, Aro plays out in his head the probable outcome of a battle with the Cullens. Much like what we see in the movie, Aro foresees a more evenly matched fight than he had expected, the loss of too many of his key players, and—most unacceptable—the likelihood of his own death. Though odds are that the Volturi would have come out on top in the end, Aro wouldn't have lived to see it and the unassailable nature of the Volturi's authority would have been broken, possibly forever. It is this vision of the future—though imperfect guesswork on his part—that motivates his retreat.

Melissa Rosenberg and I have both mentioned the fateful dinner we had (back during the filming of Eclipse) where we hashed out a way to make the end of Breaking Dawn more cinematic. This was the idea we latched on to—how do we make this vision of Aro's into something the viewer can experience? The answer was pretty simple once we looked at it that way—we already had a character who could show us visions. So the only real change to the book ending of Breaking Dawn is that Alice enters the scene earlier, and comes in contact with Aro.

(Are there a few little trespasses against the mythology in this vision? Yes, as some of you have pointed out. The consensus was that a minor deviation from what had been established was forgivable in the name of entertainment. I had a few very elaborate solutions, but they were too confusing and not nearly as cinematic as the final product. And obviously, the result was very entertaining.)


Read the rest here.

What did YOU think of the film's ending?  Chime in and add your Comments.



Check out MSN Movies on Facebook or Twitter.
For more 'Twilight' news, Like the Twilight Blog on Facebook.


9Comments
Dec 5, 2012 6:11PM
avatar
I read all the books, watched all the movies.  I saw previews where it shows them fighting and they didn't fight in the books... so I was expecting a little fight (they also had the Cullens fighting the wolves in part one which didn't happen in the books).  But when Carlile died... OMG, the audience (the ones who read the books) went wild!!  And as more vampires/wolves died, people were going crazy!!  I kept saying... "it has to be a dream, it has to be a dream... they can't end it like this!" And then a huge sigh of relief when we saw that it was a vision... not real.   Very dramatic!  I had to go back and see the movie again so I could really watch it when I wasn't in shock!  Great movie!!
Dec 5, 2012 6:29PM
avatar
I had read all the books, and the apparent ending floored me.  I kept going over the book ending in my head, and couldn't remember even the hint of such a bloody ending.  Thank goodness it was just cinematic license and not my memory going that bad.
Dec 5, 2012 7:04PM
avatar

Why are some of you commenters just commenting on how much you hate the book or the author? Why would you read an article about a book you obviously don't care for? The fact is, it was a huge seller and the movies have also been huge sellers. I doubt the children of America are "illiterate" and that is why they like it. It is a fantasy book, written in a way teenagers and preteens like. Period. If you don't like it (and I don't blame you if you don't, plenty of people don't like the same things) then maybe you should just not click on these stories?? Just a thought.

 

As for the ending (and the original question that some people just COULD NOT stick to) I knew it had to be a vision. There is no way the audience, which is notorious for being rabid, would tolerate a massive deviation from the story. I liked this- it added some action without actually changing the story. In the end, it all worked out the same as the book but with a little more spunk. The reaction of the audience WAS pretty hilarious as well... all those screaming kids, and adults. I just laughed. What else could I do?

Dec 6, 2012 10:21AM
avatar
When Carlisle's head was hanging in Aro's hand I gasped; then when Jasper was killed and torched I cried out, "No!" and literally felt i was going to cry!  I had no idea how attached I became to these characters, and would not have if not for the change.  Don't care about the haters, this brought the fans out of their seats!   Kudos to you guys!  
Dec 5, 2012 6:59PM
avatar
My husband and I read all the books and have seen all the films (even though I personally dislike them lol). We were both ready to walk out of the theater when Carlisle was "killed".  But in the end, we thought it was genius!
Dec 5, 2012 7:07PM
avatar

A friend talked me into reading the Twilight Series and I loved all the books.  The movies not so much.  Only because I am not a Kristen Stewart fan at all. However, this movie was very, very good!! At first I was totally confused because I didn't remember parts in the book where some of the Cullen's were being killed. Then I became totally absorbed in the action.  It was such a relief when I realized what Aro was seeing.  I'm almost tempted to see it again!

Dec 5, 2012 6:14PM
avatar

change the ending?   you dont do that.  imagine the battle at the alamo having a different ending.

 

Dec 5, 2012 9:01PM
avatar

I have been a big fan of the books and have seen all of the movies several times (not AS big of a fan of the movies, yes Kristen Stewart is painful to watch) but anyway....

 

When Carlisle's head was ripped off, I almost walked out of the movie right then.  I was so angry.  And then as it just kept going on, I got angrier and more upset.  And once I realized it wasn't real.... even angrier. 

 

I felt like it added a whole different level of violence and emotional turmoil that wasn't necessary.  Yes the other movies also show similar violence (decapitations) but not of main characters and not to the extent that Breaking Dawn 2 did.  I felt it was completely ridiculous.

 

And what I mean by "emotional turmoil" is -  I sat there watching characters whom I had grown attached to for the past several years die violent deaths and watch/hear the wolves crying out as one after another was taken down.  I HATED the way the movie made me feel.  I continue to have visions of Carlisle's head dangling from someone's hand....

Some unexpected twists is one thing but again, I felt this was WAY off base and unnecessary. 

 

The last five minutes of the movie was the best part.... otherwise, I HATED it and will seriously never watch it again.

Dec 5, 2012 6:07PM
avatar
In other words, you can't write worth crap and you were just making stuff up as you went along. Good thing the youth of this country is mostly illiterate or you'd be out all those big bucks. 
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Myriam Gabriel-Pollock, Twilight Blogger

Myriam Gabriel-Pollock has been writing for MSN since 2006 -- everything from quizzes to feature articles to the Twilight Superfan blog. Prior to that she was a hi-tech geek. She has happily transitioned into a film geek, especially if there are wizards, vampires, mythical places, and spaceships.

showtimes & tickets
Search by location, title, or genre: