Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Odds and Ends 029

In case you were wondering . . .

By Xgau Fri 1:16 AM

Jenny & Johnny: I'm Having Fun Now (Warner Bros. '10)

Just because she loves him for bringing out the folk-rock softie in her doesn't mean we have to ("Big Wave," "Just Like Zeus," "My Pet Snakes") ***

 

George Jones: Cold Hard Truth (Asylum '99)

Begins with two all-time keepers and a fine novelty, after which the songs need more than the scratch vocals he was stuck with after he ran into an abutment playing his stepdaughter the tape ("Choices," "Cold Hard Truth," "Sinners & Saints") ***

 

Lil Wayne: I Am Not a Human Being (Universal/Motown '10)

His throwaways beat their keepers, from solitary yet, but the true classics are all in the middle and the Young Money promos are filler ("I Am Not a Human Being" "Popular," "I'm Single") ***

 

The Go! Team: Rolling Blackouts (Memphis Industries '10)

Exceeding their emotional reach, musical grasp, and conceptual limitations whether softer or more elaborate ("Apollo Throwdown," "Bust Out Brigade") ***

 

Bassekou Kouyate & Ngoni Ba: I Speak Fula (Sub Pop '10)

At ease with himself and in synch with his people ("Jamana Be Diya," "Falani") **

 

They Might Be Giants: Join Us (Idlewild/Rounder '11)

Kiddie songs becoming a habit, clever fellows service the grownup market ("When Will You Die," "2082") **

 

The Old 97's: The Grand Theatre: Volume Two (New West '11)

If you'd been doing this since 1994, wouldn't you front-load volume one? ("No Simple Machines," "Visiting Hours") *

 

Liz Phair: Funstyle (Rocket Science Ventures '10)

Not a good sign when the skits stand out and your old demos are a welcome add-on ("Bang! Bang!" "White Babies") *

 

97Comments
26 minutes ago
avatar
I'm a White Sox fan.  The White Sox are like a low-income, social pariah C-student who happens to live next door to a kid whose friends throw him a party every time he sets his own pants on fire and whose parents think it's adorable that he sometimes forgets how toilets work.  Being a mostly-ignored underachiever isn't so bad; living in the shadow of a beloved total ****-up is perplexing.  The White Sox are the (less-competent) Frank Grimes of baseball.  I picked correctly; the ChiSox suit my personality.
avatar
Here's a good argument that if you have a soft guy you give a break, Nascimento isn't a bad choice:

http://goo.gl/nQ24O

avatar
"(Sixpack, BTW, doesn't care much at all for Nascimento)."

A real lapse some of the time. Does admit that the first Club on the Corner is Nascimento's "masterpiece".  But Nascimento has indeed made many terrible records. (Joe Sixpack has a weakness for the mild 'n' mellow, but seems to hold it against selected subjects. Blames Nascimento for getting too jazzy. And I've mentioned Joe's Disco-Is-Satan problem.)

"Carmen Miranda's "The Brazilian Recordings" "

Strongly second hearing these. Different from the slightly silly movie icon (but related in an instructive way).
5 hours ago
avatar
"Nascimento's *Clube Da Esquina*"

Gracias! I picked up a few old Brazilian records last week, all from further Joe Sixpack scouring (Sixpack, BTW, doesn't care much at all for Nascimento). Nara Leao's "Des Anos Depois" is just too subtle Euro-bossa. Carmen Miranda's "The Brazilian Recordings" proves that she was something other than a fruitbasket with a voice-- these early songs show her to be cute and gutsy, staccato and sweet. But the one that I fell for is "Elis & Tom", that's Regina and Jobim respectively. I still prefer the landmark "Elis Regina in London", but what "Elis & Tom" lacks in breezy extravagance it makes up for with the tunes and finely wrought arrangements. Imagine a Brazilian Warwick/Bacharach.
avatar
Since we're doin' miscellany and I notice Dr.  Cam is around, I want to note that I played both volumes of Nascimento's *Clube Da Esquina* this weekend, and man, do those sound better and better as the years go by. And I loved them from day one.
avatar
My Bloody Valentine, *ep's 1988-1991*

I'm keeping the vinyl, but nice job on a useful package.

7 hours ago
avatar
I'm totally ready to love this album: goo.gl/079L2
7 hours ago
avatar
A different twist, I put this together a while back, the best baseball team I could field of players born in Alabama. Irvin is a slight stretch, he was an outfielder but played 3B a bit. Only two non-HOF'ers, and Rudy York is a 7-time all-star who would probably have gotten in if he'd lasted a year or two longer:

Hank Aaron- RF

Willie Mays- CF

Billy Williams- LF

Willie McCovey- 1B

Joe Sewell- 2B

Ozzie Smith- SS

Monte Irvin- 3B

Rudy York- Catcher

 

Pitching rotation:

Satchel Paige

Don Sutton

Early Wynn

Jimmy Key

avatar
Rickey shoulda been MVP in '85, too.  And '81. Rollie Fingers? Fingerfcuk.
9 hours ago
avatar
Forgetting what? Henderson was on the 89/90 teams - his MVP was for the 1990 A's. Conseco was traded at 26 to Texas. McGuire hit a bunch more homers for the Cardinals than the A's. Which leaves the very unusual example of Stewart, who indeed did not move anywhere much after Oakland - he played seven years before he ever pitched in Oakland and was already in his 30s when he became a fairly surprising star. He may be the one person who actually did give all of his best years to the A's, where even Rickie (who otherwise comes closest) split them with the Yankees.

The tone of my post was a joke, but the tendency I was speaking of is clear: great players associated with the Yankees, Cardinals, and numerous other teams, spend the bulk of their careers with those teams. That wasn't true of the A's even in their heyday, and by definition can't be true of the A's under their present management.  (This is, by the way, why it's hard to maintain an allegiance to the A's, and explains much more about why so many A's fans have abandoned the team for the Giants than either the newness of AT&T Park or the size of the city/area. But that's really another conversation.)

And yes, I know full well that what I just said is true of many teams other than the A's. Partially about budgets/revenues, partially about management styles, and partially simply that the old teams like the Yankees and Cardinals had long histories pre-free agency. (Someone might claim that Philadelphia A's belong in this conversation, but it won't be me.)
10 hours ago
avatar

Kenny: You're forgetting the great late 80's-early 90's A's teams. If you want to leave off Canseco and McGuire, fine, but Dave Stewart--four 20-game-win seasons in a row--should be remembered.

 

11 hours ago
avatar
If you're an Oakland A's fan, it goes without saying that your greatest players spent substantial periods with other clubs - in the 1970s because Charlie Finlay was insane, in the last decade because cultivating players and watching them leave when they get expensive is conscious strategy, and in between because, well, Oakland is Oakland and I suppose has better things to do then worry about its baseball players. (OK, that's putting spin on it.) So it's a given that our drop dead fan favorite born and raised in town #1 player, Rickie Henderson, gave four and a half of his best years to the damn Yankees. (14+ in Oakland.) Then there's Reggie, Catfish, Giambi: we're just the AAAA farm team for the Yankees. nb: Sabathia is from Northern California/Oakland 'burbs, but was never in the organization.
11 hours ago
avatar

I'd love to make a list for the Red Sox, but only if I can include Bill Lee and exclude Roger Clemens

avatar
Changing the subject --

We saw "Silver Linings Playbook" for the first time last night, and I had a couple of music-related thoughts.

Led Zeppelin's "What Is and What Should Never Be" from LZII got my attention first. Plant's voice and the odd arrangement added just the right touch of insanity, menace and uncertainty to the scene where DeNiro and Cooper first fight.

And then the very unexpected "Girl from The North Country" for the romantic face time the two leads have in the dance studio. Never in a million years would I have thought of that song for that scene and boy did it work. Cash and Dylan. I don't know why that doesn't come to mind more often as an American(a) standard.

From the s/t I learn that there also was two from Brubeck and one from Les Paul and Mary Ford.

Rare Earth is a waste of time, plastic and vibrated air molecules though.

avatar
Just noting that A-Rod, who could be on either or both the Seattle or Yankee list, has become invisible. Talk about character influencing reputation.
avatar
Duke, I see the wound is fresh, yes.  But really this ended up being pretty good - you had the guy at his absolute peak, you don't have him in his decline,  and you have two WS! Hornsby didn't win two, and probably wouldn't have won '26 if Ruth hadn't tried to steal that base...

Jeff, lots of testimony to what a sh!thead Hornsby was.  Christ could the guy hit, though. I suspect when things die down Pujols will take his place as the 3rd-greatest Card.
13 hours ago
avatar
The simplest answer, apart from the reality that the wound is fresh, is that Pujols hurt the team and in our eyes betrayed the club for money and status, not even that we can see for better baseball. This means that while he was still a great player he turned out not to be that great a Cardinal. One thing I've noticed, though, hanging out with Yankees fans, is that Cardinals fans might still be a little old fashioned about these things.
avatar
If you're getting that Hornsby character rap sheet from Bill James, you'll have to inform me, b/c I don't have a copy of James around; as I crowd-source his character, he strikes me as a modern man, not particularly likable, but no Ty Cobb.  
14 hours ago
avatar
My team is one that has a lot of depth, plus it has two players who could legitimately be considered as GOAT. 

1) Willie Mays
2) Barry Bonds
3) Christy Mathewson
4) Mel Ott
5) Willie McCovey
6) Juan Marichal
7) Carl Hubbell
8) Will Clark
9) Orlando Cepeda
10) Gaylord Perry
avatar
But Jeff and Duke, if poor character comes into it, what's Hornsby doing at #2? 

(Gibson was my first favourite player.)
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap