Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

The Mountain Goats/Ned Sublette

Crowns of thorns

By Xgau Nov 6, 2012 4:25AM

The Mountain Goats: Transcendental Youth (Merge)

Thorny to begin with, John Darnielle reached some near-perfect threshold of liminal comprehensibility with Tallahassee 10 years ago, then got thornier again, albeit in liminally comprehensible mode. But here he goes so clear Tom Cruise may propose matrimony. If you want songs that hit as hard as "No Children" and "International Small Arms Traffic Blues," put on your body armor, because most of these hit harder. From "Amy AKA Spent Gladiator"'s unequivocal "stay alive" to the title youth rising heavenward on "air gone black with flies," here is all-embracing existential despair that refuses to get down in the mouth about it, peaking with two sunken-hopes tracks midway through that taken as a diptych constitute the greatest song he's ever written. Matthew E. White's horn charts are the musical development Darnielle has in store for us. But the dealmaker is Jon Wurster's spare, inescapable drumming. A

 

Ned Sublette: Kiss You Down South (Postmambo)

My favorite tune here was also Thomas Jefferson's‑-the 18th-century hit "Money Musk," which Sublette appropriates the better to ensnare the "great brain of a brave new nation" in his own sweet trap. Listen faithfully and you'll find more, beginning with the geographical-anatomical title lick. But in truth I wish they weren't so subtle, just as I wish the clave aficionado had enlisted a rhythm section instead of recording these 14 songs as if his 1969 nylon-stringed Ramirez classical guitar was Lead Belly's steel, which it isn't‑-

momentum-wise, anyway. That said, phrasing that stops you short he can do, and lyrically he's something else. "Flow" and "Between Piety and Desire," "Gangster Roots" and "The Auctioneer's Nightmare," "Drugs (Fuck All You Motherfuckers)" and "Hey God"‑-these deliver the requisite lyricism, complexity, and rage, respectively. The Jefferson song, entitled "Sally," delivers all three. A MINUS

 

175Comments
Nov 9, 2012 10:03AM
avatar

There is no question in my mind that

Alexander NM has" friends" thumb up-ing his posts-

and thumb down-ing others. No question.

Milo is on the money-ignore. I must listen to Milo.

Nov 9, 2012 3:49AM
avatar
Note to AN: The right-wing did indeed launch a systematic purge of so-called RINOs in Kansas this year -- a pretty successful one, in fact, getting rid of, among others, my own pro-choice Republican state senator, Jean Schodorf. A decade ago there were as many moderate Republicans in KS as there were conservatives -- e.g., Bill Graves was governor, Nancy Kassebaum had just retired from the Senate. It's worth remembering that abortion was legal in KS before Roe v. Wade, and it was mostly Republicans who did that. Now, I don't think there are any pro-choice Republicans left in office, so that's a pretty complete ideological purge.

I can't think of anything comparable on the Democratic side. There are many prominent anti-choice Democrats (e.g., Bob Casey and Harry Reid) and they routinely get support from all across the party. Democratic primary challenges are very rare and rarely successful -- e.g., Joe Lieberman. And the lack of common beliefs and positions makes any sort of "ideological purity test" laughable. Will Rogers used to tell folks that he's not a member of any organized political party -- he's a Democrat. That's a joke, but it's still true today.

The Republicans didn't use to be so rigid and intolerant -- cf. Reagan's so-called 11th commandment. But they are now.


Nov 9, 2012 2:04AM
avatar
Are we still talking about politics here? Jesus Christ folks. Give it up. Let's get back to the music. How about that Neil Young record? Too long? Yeah... I think so too. 
Nov 8, 2012 10:31PM
avatar
Haven't got to A with Transcendental Youth yet but the good ones clearly outnumber the whatever ones, which wasn't true of the preceding Mountain Goats album; current faves are 1, 6, 9 in that order. Still, after a spin of Transcendental Youth I feel I need to refresh myself with something more populated. Effective choice: The Wonder Years' "Everything I Own Fits in This Backpack", an alienation song that realises there are worse things than neighbours who like ICP.
Nov 8, 2012 7:03PM
avatar
Current listening:  Ray Charles: The Genius After Hours and Otis Redding: The Soul Album.  These supposedly minor albums in their respective ouevres stand as high as their other masterpieces to my ears.  I have to assume the' omission of a mention of The Genius After Hours from Xgau's great Ray Charles piece in Rolling Stone was simply an oversight.  No vocals, just stellar blues and jazz piano featuring great work by David Fathead Newman on sax.  And the Otis is my newest fave of his.  It amazes me how you can dip into uncharted waters re Aretha or Otis or JB or Brother Ray and find yet another transcendent piece of music.  I know their recording history isn't infinite but it sure feels like it sometimes.
avatar

goo.gl/1M46L

 

and now, the most "transparent administration" reveals that a week ago (i.e. before the election) Iran shot at US drones.

"Iran fired on an unarmed U.S. drone last week as it was hovering in international airspace, the Pentagon announced Thursday. "

 

"TEHRAN // Iran has shown US drones it shot down over the Gulf to Russia, a top official with the Revolutionary Guard was quoted as saying yesterday.

"Russian experts requested to see these drones and they looked at both the downed drones and the models made by the guards through reverse engineering," the official IRNA news agency quoted General Hajizadeh as saying.
General Hajizadeh did not elaborate on the number or type of unmanned US aircraft it had shot down, or when or where it had done so."

 

"Russian Attack Sub Off Our Coast As Sequestration Looms

The fruit of unilateral disarmament, appeasement and promised "flexibility" patrols our East Coast near one of our largest ballistic missile submarine bases. Defense cuts and Russian subs — a double whammy.

'On June 1 or a bit later, we will resume constant patrolling of the world's oceans by strategic nuclear submarines," Russian Navy Commander Admiral Vladimir Vysotsky said in February. Keeping that promise, a Russian Sierra-2 class nuclear attack submarine cruised within 200 miles of our East Coast on the eve of a U.S. presidential election in which defense spending and priorities were a key issue.
This is the first time a Russian Sierra-2 class sub, believed to be based with Russia's Northern Fleet and armed with SSN anti-submarine warfare missiles and torpedoes, has been detected near the U.S. coast, reports Bill Gertz of the Washington Free Beacon.
"As was their primary mission during the Cold War, Russian SSNs nuclear attack submarines would likely be trying to track U.S. nuclear missile submarines deploying from Kings Bay, Ga., and to monitor U.S. naval deployments from Norfolk, Va.," according to Richard Fisher, a military analyst with the International Assessment and Strategy Center. Two guided missile submarines and six nuclear missile submarines are docked at Kings Bay Naval Submarine Base."

 

"We have these ships that go underwater called nuclear submarines...."

Seems that Hussein isn't the only one with increased "flexibility" after his re-election.

Nov 8, 2012 4:13PM
avatar
"Prison Play" is on that first album, the one with the National Geographic cover. We had that at our house, not sure why, I don't recall my parents being fans. I used to listen to it all the time, liked it better than their Carlin albums.
avatar

I forgot which EW commenter I was talking to but please note: Rep. (or Alderman, I don't recall which office he held at the time) Guitierez did a number of spots in Spanish strongly supporting said candidate, Glen Poshard. So I am aware "Screwy Lui" is capable of good judgement.).

Poshard in fact was criticized by even Liberal Sen. Paul Simon (another decent Democrap, btw. Yes, they do exist) for running on rumors of Ryan's corruption, which turned out to be true, and lost, largely because he didn't pass the ideological purity test for the Democrap party.  Odd how the Republicans are criticized for just tolerating the "Pro-Choice" politicians, while the Democraps shut out their pro-life members. Or perhaps typical.

Nov 8, 2012 3:43PM
avatar
Brett -- or anyone 

I love Richard Pryor and I have the box set of Warner Bros Lps, 'And It's Deep Too'. To me a lot of the material is enjoyable, but lacks visuals -- it's like 'Live in Concert' with the physical part missing. However, by far -- by FAR -- the standout track is 'Prison Play'. It's sui generis and pure genius. At the time when I got the set I tried to find out more about it but couldn't. The liner notes to the box are not great. I bought a biography which was not great. Who knows this stuff? He obviously wrote it in advance. Did someone persuade him that this wasn't as innovative as his off-the-cuff riffs on his drug habit and self-destructive tendencies? If so, I wish they hadn't. Is there more like it in a vault? Did he write it for tv with Lily Tomlin? Help!
Nov 8, 2012 2:44PM
avatar
Don't It Drag On:

http://dl.dropbox.com/u/31994696/Don't%20It%20Drag%20On.zip
Nov 8, 2012 1:42PM
avatar
I know the election is over (except in Florida) and we're back to the real deal now, such as valuable Chris Smither recommendations and advice on how to build a satisfying music library, but if you haven't clicked over to TPM on the Blog Roll and run through the Stewart and Colbert clips, you may not have completely digested the election experience yet.

It's all top notch but I think Colbert nails the inherent selfishness and fear of us ex-majoritarians with this punch line: “The white establishment, guys like us, we’re the minority now. And we’re helpless against this tide of non-white people who want ‘stuff’ and ‘things.’ They’re the thing-stuff-wanters. Whereas traditional white people — of any race — we don’t want things. We have things. Okay?”
Nov 8, 2012 11:45AM
avatar
I think "Hundred Dollar Valentine" is quite fine. His voice has thickened as he's gotten older, so the backup singer, little harmonica fills and bits of arrangement just help him along. He's always done reinterpretations of his older songs, so if he does 3 this time and no covers, that's just how the spirit moves him.

If you ever get a chance to see him live in an intimate setting, go. Twenty years ago I saw him put on a solo show in front of 10 people in a club in London Ontario, and he was mesmerizing. 

And, yes, "Don't It Drag On" is the place to start.
Nov 8, 2012 11:25AM
avatar
I think Hundred Dollar Valentine is a good enough album, too. Didn't mean to suggest otherwise.   It's just that arrangement of Every Mother's Son I didn't like.  I've heard Don't Drag It On before, and much enjoyed it, at a friend's house, but don't own a copy (yet).  Thanks for the recommendations, though -- gotta find one in my price range.
Nov 8, 2012 10:50AM
avatar
I think "Hundred Dollar Valentine" is a good enough album. Smither returns to his back catalog to fill out his first album ever made entirely of original tunes. And that's probably why this record falls a little short of his very best work-- he's an awesome interpretive singer. If you don't believe me, check out his covers EP from last year, or as Nora said "Don't It Drag On", with its unimaginable-from-this-distance backing band.
Nov 8, 2012 10:31AM
avatar
People like to collect things and records has got to be one of the most fascinating . There was nothing that collectible about CD's especially compared to albums, I thought I knew a great deal about LPs until I started dealing in them and now realize that the subject is endless. Particularly since I cover every genre and format.  If you're in NC check out Father and Son in downtown Raleighwood on the third floor,we sell good records cheap. 
Nov 8, 2012 10:12AM
avatar
I completely agree about 'Every Mother's Son.' It is a wonderful song. I assume you mean that *you* first heard it on 'Another Way to Find You', because it first appeared on what I consider to be Chris Smither's best album, 'Don't It Drag On.' If by chance you haven't heard that album, you're in for a treat -- 'Every Mother's Son' is awesome, but it's maybe not even the best song on that album. Try 'I Feel the Same', or, well, just the whole album really. 
Nov 8, 2012 9:28AM
avatar
A favorite song of mine is Chris Smither's "Every Mother's Son," first heard on the CG-recommended Another Way to Find You, live recorded in studio just Smither accompanying himself on guitar; I've also been listening recently to the Hundred Dollar Valentine version, which Smither arranged with a rolling snare, his own signature boot-tap, harmony vocal, and -- for me, a bridge too far -- cheesy little mouth harp fills.  Why is Smither putting out this busy little version of one of his most famous songs, I wonder.  I'm guessing it must be that in changing labels, he wants a recorded version on his present-day label to secure leverage over the publishing rights, which he expects the label to enforce? 
Nov 8, 2012 8:57AM
avatar
Mountain Goats 'Transcendental Youth' is $5 on ama#zon mp3 at the moment.

I was irritated that the vinyl was $20 for '180 gram': just make it regular, and cheaper!
Nov 8, 2012 7:47AM
avatar
Enjoying a couple of great Motown CDs (which I bought used and cheap) this morning,  both of which were recommended by our host back in his massive CG column of December 24, 1985.  What a Xmas present that one was as I recall.  Scroll down to the "Uses of Nostalgia" section to see the brief but seductive reviews of The Temptations Sing Smokey and the Miracles' Going to a Go-Go.  Most of the great stuff from the Miracles album is also on their 2-CD Anthology comp, but only half of the Temptations Sing Smokey album cuts show up on the Temptations 1995 2-CD Anthology which makes the Tempts Sing Smokey CD a must.   Not a single less-than-superb track on that one IMHO.
Nov 8, 2012 6:44AM
avatar
Except for the 2-fer Stax pressing of the first two Big Star albums.  That one rules.
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap