Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Odds and Ends 012

Been Through Less Than They Think, These Guys

By Xgau Jun 19, 2012 2:03AM

 

Diamond Rugs: Diamond Rugs (Partisan)

Whose songs do you think stick out when the Deer Tick guy convenes yet another roots-rock supergroup with the Black Lips guy and the Dead Confederate guy? ("Christmas in a Chinese Restaurant," "Gimme a Beer") ***

 

The Obits: "Moody, Standard and Poor" (Sub Pop)

Perpetually PO-ed alt lifers get a grip on it ("I Want Results," "No Fly List") ***

 

Wavves: Life Sux (Ghost Ramp)

"A joke a stroke of genius/Probably somewhere in between" is tuneful enough, finally, but make that second line "Or only a waste of time?" and we might believe he's got some brain left ("Bug," "Poor Lenore") ***

 

The Rapture: In the Grace of Your Love (DFA)

Posers have real lives too‑-really‑-only it's really hard to care ("In the Grace of Your Love," "How Deep Is Your Love") ***

 

Herzog: Cartoon Violence (Exit Stencil)

Pop boys are always facing manhood, but that doesn't always spruce up their songs ("Your Son Is Not a Soldier," "Fuck This Year") **

 

Surfer Blood: Tarot Classics (Kanine)

EP embraces a maturity they define in part as saving your winners for Warners ("Drinking Problem," "I'm Not Ready") **

 

Art Brut: Brilliant! Tragic! (The End/Cooking Vinyl)

Guitarist often shines, lyrics often don't ("Clever Clever Jazz," "Bad Comedian") **

 

The Front Bottoms: The Front Bottoms (Bar/None)

Two-"man" Bergen County Nerd Liberation Front cell finish each other's bellyaches, hire or simulate trumpet commentary ("The Beers," "Maps") *


129Comments
Jun 21, 2012 10:53AM
avatar

RE: The Wussy Mercury Lounge show in August. For those who don't know, you can purchase tickets at the venue when they are open for a show that day.

 

Che Vauche: Where did you find those Yoko book recommendations?

 

 

Jun 21, 2012 9:46AM
avatar
I bought the Revenant set after reading Sullivan's piece in Harper's. The main difference between it and the Anthology is that the Anthology records were chosen because Harry Smith thought they were entertaining-haunting-revealing-catchy-creepy-danceable-profound, while the records on the Revenant set were chosen because they're obscure. Which isn't to say that they aren't also entertaining-haunting-etc., and American Primitive does contain Geeshie Wiley's entire six-song oeuvre, which is essential. For listening I prefer the Joe Bussard-curated Down In The Basement and the wonderful medicine-show comp Good For What Ails You, but both volumes of American Primitive are worth having. 

Jun 21, 2012 8:53AM
avatar
When I can wrestle the book away from my wife, I've been reading the mostly, but not exclusively, music-focused essays in John Jeremiah Sullivan's excellent "Pulphead." His reasonably well-known piece on the celebrity cult and grim background of Axl Rose is in there, but one piece in particular, "Unknown Bards," really struck me. It's an impressionistic essay about early-Americana curating and scholarship, involving among other things a profile of John Fahey, reviews of Elijah Wald's "Escaping the Delta" and Marybeth Hamilton's "In Search of the Blues," and a lengthy exegesis of Geeshie Wiley's "Last Kind Word Blues." As far as I know this is the only piece Sullivan's written on early American music. He spends a lot of time talking about Revenant's 2 CD "American Primitive vol. 2: Pre-War Revenants, 1897-1937" (released in 2006)--says it is the most imporant release of its type since Harry's Smith's "Anthology," or that it is the next thing one needs to understand early American music. He does make the case that Fahey and associates unearthed some extremely rare 78s late in the process, and that they did the best mastering they could do with the material. I was wondering if those on this board had heard it and whether it's as essential to understanding early American music as Sullivan claims it to be.
Jun 21, 2012 8:21AM
avatar
An argument for single-payer health care haunts this discussion.
Jun 21, 2012 7:50AM
avatar

Not uninteresting list of five "must-read" books from Yoko Ono with comments from the same:


A First Rate Madness: Uncovering the Links Between Leadership and Mental Illness

Nassir Ghaemi

At first this book first gives you a "reader's digest" version of how the world leaders really were. That's interesting enough. But it goes on to show you how the brain works when a person is depressed, and how to overcome it. It is fascinating and full of important information.


Plundering Appalachia: The Tragedy of Mountaintop Removal Coal Mining

Douglas R. Tompkins

Once our valleys were green - now they look like the bomb-destroyed cities we created in Iraq. Buy this book and see what is quietly being done to middle America because of a few people's greed.


The True Story of the Bilderberg Group

Daniel Estulin

Read this if you want to know about a very powerful group that includes many of the presidents of very powerful countries, and is working to turn the planet into one country. They are systematically trying to make people dumb and poor – letting one group control them all.


Amusing Ourselves to Death: Public Discourse in the Age of Show Business

Neil Postman

We are indeed amusing ourselves to death. This started when Marshall McLuhan stated that the medium was the message. I said right away that the message was the medium. But, alas, my voice was maybe not loud enough, and/or the medium without a serious message is much more amusing to people. So the entertainers became the gods of the people, who screamed: "Keep entertaining us! We want to die being entertained!" The kings of the world wished the same, and they let their countries fall while they were entertained. This is the only book in this list that was published way back in the 1960s. I hope you can get it.


Classified Woman

Sibel Edmonds

A tell-all book by a former FBI translator. A must-read. It's frightening that this is the reality.


Jun 21, 2012 6:26AM
avatar
Walter: I am super interested in what you think about Americana.
Jun 21, 2012 5:18AM
avatar
And thanks to JeffC for heads up on Bob's review of Daniel Cavicchi's new book on music fans of the 19th century...sounds great.

I hope his mention of Lhamon's Raising Cain will encourage some more folks--go Walter!--to pick up this elegantly written book on 19th century minstrelsy.  The first chapter, on African American and white working class youth meeting over a dance in NYC is some of the best historical writing I have ever read.
Jun 21, 2012 5:13AM
avatar
The responses here to David Lowery's piece are amazing.  I'm trying to digest it all--including Lowery's original piece--but for now I just want to join those objecting to his invocation of the deaths of  Vic Chesnutt and Mark Linkous.  I'm a lay person but I know enough to object to the mystifyication of mental illness that Lowery engages in here.  Kurt Cobain's death was met with similar erasures of mental illness as *the* explanation for his suicide.    I don't mean to be shrill but it is a mistake, I think, to look for something *in addition* to mental illness to explain self-destructive behavior. 

I'm a huge fan of David Lowery--I just think he made a much better response to Emily White, before the fact,  in Cracker's song "Ain't Gonna Suck Itself."  Kenny gets at much of this in a much more forceful way than I can, but focusing on consumer behavior in this whole discussion is a mistake, I think.  I mean, that is an interesting um....ethical question. But it is not help us train our eyes where they should be--on those who control the means of production and distribution.

Also unremarked upon so far, unless I just missed it, is the key fact that Emily White is an intern.  I'm midway through reading Ross Perlin's chilling book Intern Nation: How to Earn Nothing and Learn Little in the Brave New Economy.  It is a good reminder of who is benefitting most from not paying young (and not so young) people for what used to be called "work."

Jun 21, 2012 3:23AM
avatar
Chesnutt's suicide-note-almost At the Cut, which as a harrowing, brittle little song cycle rewards far past its basic documentary interest (particularly the gorgeous, starkly-themed "Flirted With You All My Life") is well worth hearing for Witnesses who haven't, and I insist you give it a shot. End to end the thing is a masterwork of the rawest, brokenest streamlined human emotion - sure kicks Pink Moon's winsomely wistful ****. I figure it was overlooked for review because as sound it fails to offer up a number of our host's usual criteria (as did all of Chesnutt's records) - to make a lame and assumptive attempt, not much thrust or punch, little subtlety or cohesion, the kind of thing you listen to and grow to love largely if not only because the interest has already been planted by something other than the songs (or singer) themselves. Pairing it with an interview he did with Terry Gross given shortly before he deliberately overdosed completes an investigation into his story as what David Lowery wields it as, a message-functional slice of human interest. It's also a heartbreaking worth subjecting yourself to if or if not you're prone to a Lowereyesque bleeding heart. (Which is not to say I disagree with his point or the idea that the debate is reaching a point of necessary mutual engagement, though I think you could say that about a great many aspects of the melting polar ice cap that is This Business [multiple meanings] of Music. In any case, I spent money on the album, but only once it was too late.)

As for the rest of Chesnutt's oeuvre, my (Amy Rigby-adoring, since Walter brought it up) dad, who owns all his records, could tell you best - he favors the Lambchop-backed Salesman and Bernadette, which whatever it tells you needed said meatheads to cook, and the more-driven-than usual Silver Lake, while other than At the Cut I found the most value in Is the Actor Happy?, whose versions of certain Sweet Relief II triumphs compare the best. And though inconsistent, SWII /is/ awfully lovely, something you can grow to love whether or not the interest has been planted by something other than the songs/singer themselves - which, to be fair, is exactly what our host's positive rating implied.
Jun 21, 2012 12:08AM
avatar
I don't know whether there's an answer to the downloading controversy but obviously the genie can't be put back in the bottle.  David Lowery makes some good counter-intuitive points but it's hard to regard record companies as having had an ultimately benign influence for artists, there are too many tales to the contrary (although he didn't say that).  The use of two musicians who committed suicide to bolster his argument was ultimately distracting.  Lots of musicians or aspirant musicians never made significant money from music.  I don't know much about Sparklehorse, but I think it's a fair guess that Vic Chesnutt made a significant portion of his lifetime income from the tribute album.  However, his medical condition would have also prevented him touring extensively, which means the alternative source of income available to artists in the download era wouldn't be as available to him.
Jun 20, 2012 7:28PM
avatar
Okay, sure. I think MTV and "classic radio" are peas in a pod in winnowing the variety of music people could discover, but apples and oranges if you put their effects in conflict.
avatar
Milo - You made a genuinely interesting comment about MTV's effect and I wanted to discuss it. No provocation intended.
Jun 20, 2012 7:11PM
avatar
"I think classic rock radio has had a far more egregious effect"

Patrick, this is a, um, classic both/and non-disagreement. Are you gonna get over my comment about you and polls or not? Egregiously gunning for somebody forever is beyond tedious.
Jun 20, 2012 6:53PM
avatar
Actual quote of something I heard a classic rock DJ say once: "I am proud to be a baby boomer, because we are the generation that invented rock and roll!"  
avatar
I think classic rock radio has had a far more egregious effect as far as providing an influential (and obnoxious and inaccurate) narrative about rock history that an awful lot of people buy into. The Eagles and Journey had no visual style to speak of, and that hasn't stopped a fairly large segment of the public from conceiving them as central to pop history.
Jun 20, 2012 6:23PM
avatar
I actually learned about a lot of older artists by watching MTV - stuff like Martha Quinn's Video Vault show, with performances from The Last Waltz excerpted as 'videos', old tapes from Germany's Musik Laden, etc.  Less than I learned from the radio, however.  And I learned less from the radio than from reading about music.  
Jun 20, 2012 6:16PM
avatar
"Wasn't that well under way before MTV entered the picture, though?"

Well, you could make a case that it's a constant in pop -- there were fans who didn't know or care where the Beatles come from (a well-known secret punch of the Brit Invasion is that white teenies had never heard the black source material of a bunch of bands). What MTV did, I think, is throw a permanent whammy on performers who either had a poor visual record of their best (many '50s and '60s performers) or never found a proper video identity (the Ramones and David Johansen. say, vs. Blondie). Telling the whole rock 'n' soul story, forever after, depended more on zesty visuals. (Odd exception: kept Devo afloat for ages, but seems to have waned badly for them in the 21st century.) I don't have super-strong feelings about this one way or the other -- MTV was neither the dawn of creation nor the gates of Armageddon predicted when it was on the rise.
avatar
"MTV (in the sense that a full awareness of historical continuity of pop since Elvis has never quite gotten back on track since video disruptions)"

Wasn't that well under way before MTV entered the picture, though? I don't get the impression that late 70s stoner kids much knew or cared what tradition Van Halen or Ted Nugent came out of.
Jun 20, 2012 4:59PM
avatar
Biggest upgrade ever was from a D to an A for Fabian: The Man, The Music, The Brylcreem - course The Professor denies it these days. But my source is someone very close to the throne.
Jun 20, 2012 4:54PM
avatar
Ham, love the story where Edelstein and Hoberman type his column. I suppose Edelstein is right about Shawn's advice, but I think critics going after each other can be healthy. It can also be a colossal waste of time.
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap