Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

SebastiAn/Skrillex

The Big Beat Got Me Dancing in My Seat

By Xgau Aug 5, 2011 3:45AM

 

SebastiAn: Total (Big Beat/Atlantic/Because/Ed Banger)

I like my dance music cheap and with a sense of humor, as on this debut album by a fashionable French DJ with Ed Banger connections. Imagine the not-bad Justice keeping 22 tracks under four minutes as it mixes and matches hardish club fads you lived without going back to 2005. Committed to synth squelch and chary of synth tweedle, it's basically instrumental except when transforming Mayer Hawthorne into the generic soul falsetto he was born to be and M.I.A. into the cheeky disco dolly she's too conscious to become. Even the interludes are catchy. In my favorite musical moment, it segues from switched-on baroque to a speedboat engine. A MINUS

 

Skrillex: Scary Monsters and Nice Sprites (Big Beat/Atlantic)

Having blown his scream fronting drama kings From First to Last, Sonny Moore dialed it down, launching a solo career that has endeared him to Lady Gaga and the Black Eyes Peas. True, he does enjoy turning synthesizers into doom dybbuks and hiring chipmunks to sing "I want to kill everybody in the world." But he also gets winning girlpop out of a sprite named Penny. This EP could use the two new songs on the all too accurately entitled More Monsters and Sprites EP, and Moore should stop milking that woman who goes "Oh my God." But when he swears rock n' roll will take you to the mountain, he's being sincere. B PLUS

 

171Comments
Aug 8, 2011 10:58PM
avatar
Just finished ICE by Ice-T.  Mother****ing good book.
Aug 8, 2011 10:29PM
avatar
First time through Watch the Throne and it sounds promising. I like most of the experimental stuff, the cuts with Frank Ocean stand out the most. I thought Otis Redding was sampled more creatively on "Gone" off Late Registration, might improve with more listening. Only real complaint is the over 3 minutes of silence at beginning of "Illest MF Alive". That kind of stuff is bad enough at the end of a track, at the start it's way worse.
Aug 8, 2011 9:04PM
avatar
Some things I wrote down while listening to Watch The Throne for the first time:

--overblown
--ridiculous
--Frank Ocean sounds great
--way too weird for a profit-taking place-holder
--whatever Dr. Dre's new one was supposed to be, it's going to sound really stupid after this
--Jay-Z sounds great (and has he acquired some politics?)
--Kanye is the strangest mainstream pop producer in history
--way too weird for the most famous hip-hoppers in the world
--what is that waltz thing so many of the songs go out on?
--preposterous
--kinda awesome anyway
--I've gotta hear this again

Anybody else iTune this thing today? Nicky? John S.? Little help, please. 


Aug 8, 2011 8:55PM
avatar
Just put on Mofungo's End of the World for the first time. Explicit and unmistakable reference to Can's "Mushroom" in the very first song. Interesting.
Aug 8, 2011 8:01PM
avatar
goo.gl/YWmQS

Incredibly creative rap from a young no name. Seems doubtful he'll ever be this good again. A syntax sufficiently complicated to be a metaphor for the content.
Aug 8, 2011 6:05PM
avatar
the completist Mofungo and Plastic People "we"
So I'm one of those folks, but I'm at the beach and I just watched a pontoon boat pass by with a full-on air guitar crew blasting AC/DC while the sun was going down. I think I belong there, too.
Aug 8, 2011 5:26PM
avatar
As a blog full of critics and their critical following, I just got done reading this pretty astounding article and thought it should be passed on: http://www.soundonsight.org/the-%E2%80%9Cgray-ones%E2%80%9D-fade-to-black/

It works into the old/new conversation that was just had about the distribution, possession, and enjoyment of music, only the medium it looks closely at is film.
Aug 8, 2011 5:08PM
avatar
Who is this "we" of which you speak? (there's gotta be Xgau readers who don't have a massive music collection... right?)
My bad. I forgot there are different "we"'s here all the time. There's the completist Mofungo and Plastic People "we" who I would expect to be well-endowed with Fela (not having checked how obscure today's free track might be -- I'd assumed not, that it would be something canonical) -- and there's the "we" who use nicknames like "Ye" and "Hov" that I have to consult the Urban Dictionary to figure out. "Hov" short for "Jehovah", Jay-Z's chosen nickname? I listened to six hours straight of Z the other day, so you can't call me a disser, because my respect only waxed (not waned). But sometimes you guys (as opposed, I guess, to my "we") keep me guessing. Good thing there's Google, I say. A lot of song titles get tossed around. Now when I listen to music I never know what actual titular song I am listening to. Quote me the title and I draw a blank but play me it and I probably know I've heard it (and maybe even know it -- to play along with it, anticipating it's progressions, albeit probably too early). In fact, it's amazing how songs I can't remember ever having heard, if I hear them again and they sound familiar -- it turns out I did hear them (and maybe can figure out when). Wow!
The subconscious mind, which is what seems to really dig the music as much as any consciousness, must be the player here.
Aug 8, 2011 4:04PM
avatar
sharpsm:

But Tom, I've got to ask: is Warren Smith's Cats Are Stealing My $hit worth hearing? (What a title!)

I can picture the lime green album cover but can't recall the music, and didn't write down any notes -- at least none I can find now, other than the B- grade, so I have to say not. On the other hand, the reissue in Jazz Prospecting today, Dragon Dave Meets Prince Black Knight From the Darkside of the Moon, is worth a spin if you are into the early 1970s "black power" avant-garde -- it as done later but has the same aesthetic. I don't think it's especially good, but it's not the sort of thing you hear often. The label, Porter, is very tuned into early '70s avant-garde and has found a few really obscure gems there. Most of their stuff is on Rhapsody.

The other Jazz Prospecting record that I think has some upside potential is Aaron Shragge -- imagine Jon Hassell louder sans beats. I played it twice, decided that was as much time a I was willing to spend. The (***) records are much more conventional postbop, well done, but have almost certainly hit their ceiling.


Aug 8, 2011 3:36PM
avatar
 I work all day teaching recent immigrants how to use their new signal to open gmail accounts and find job listings on craigslist. You should see their faces when they YouTube music they haven't heard in 20 years. 

 

Two totally rocking uses of technology!!!!

Aug 8, 2011 3:33PM
avatar
Nice article by Robert Sietsama about Mofungo. It's new to me so I thought I'd share it.

http://goo.gl/yPshq

Edit: In case you haven't seen this yet over on the AV club. It's Bob Mould plugging his book and singing a song; http://goo.gl/BXn3t

Aug 8, 2011 2:58PM
avatar
The SebastiAn album is high-efficiency dumb fun, though I don't see why one would prefer it to Justice's Cross.

Skrillex's housier tracks are low-efficiency: massive quantities of dumb are required to produce modest though non-negligible amounts of fun*. His dupsteppier tracks sound like what you'd play to someone if you wanted them to hate dubstep.

*which is still better than Motley Cruee
Aug 8, 2011 2:45PM
avatar
This is why Motley Crüe is an unpronounceable idiocy. 
Best sentence ever on the Crue, and why I revere Tom Hull. But Tom, I've got to ask: is Warren Smith's Cats Are Stealing My $hit worth hearing? (What a title!)

Aug 8, 2011 1:49PM
avatar
I always thought they were trying to hint at

Blue Oy!ster Cult.

Aug 8, 2011 1:21PM
avatar
For Bradley, et al. The alleged umlaut on reëlected is really a diaresis as used in French. It means that the second vowel is to be pronounced as a separate syllable, as in Noël and naïve. It's an elegant solution to the problem of sticking re- at the beginning of words starting with a vowel -- otherwise you'd be tempted to treat "ee" as a single long vowel sound -- but as far as I know only The New Yorker practices it in the US (I've also seen it used in the UK, where every sophisticated gent since Richard I learns a little French), so it's mostly mistaken here, maybe even considered effete.

Umlaut is a German word, used there on [a,o,u] where it changes the vowel sound. It's interchangeable with adding a following e, as in [ae,oe,ue]. This is why Motley Crüe is an unpronounceable idiocy. Blue Öyster Cult has a similar problem, although it's harder to explain. Hüsker Dü, by the way, is viable in German, but it hurts my face to try to pronounce it that way.



Aug 8, 2011 12:23PM
avatar
I am aware of and concerned by the access gap, which is why I moved to San Fran to intern at an organization called One Economy that turns government and (in an increasingly uncomfortable way) corporate grants into free broadband for inner-city communities. 

Sounds like you're not only more informed than I am on this matter, Nicky, but you're actually doing something about it, too. Major kudos.
Aug 8, 2011 12:19PM
avatar
Regarding Google-as-our-new-epistemological-overlord, you guys could do worse than saunter over to the New York Review Of Books site and read James Gleick's essay "How Google Dominates Us" here:

http://goo.gl/aaO3C

Also, at the same site, Robert Darnton has a fascinating series of essays and exchanges on the Google Books project (he's agin it), most of which are available to the non-subscriber. Search "Darnton", start with "The Library In The New Age" and work your way forward.

avatar
It's painful to spend years and years and years living with a decor that can only be called Early Record Store.
Haha, Early Record Store is totally what I aspired to as a kid. It's an achievement! I grew up wanting to stare at a wall of records that belonged to ME. I still get excited looking at my collection. Or I would if my shelves weren't falling apart, and if the As and most of the Bs hadn't gotten flooded when I moved in the new place.
avatar
 Recording LPs onto cassettes was surely widespread, and it was simply a way to save money.

Oh, absolutely, and I did to some degree myself when I had no other way of hearing an album. But I knew many people (most of whom could easily afford to buy albums) who were perfectly content just owning the copy, and having their entire collection just be a bunch of cassettes with hand-scribbled stuff on 'em, who didn't seem to feel like they were missing anything - that's the part that was baffling to me.

I have never really forgiven the record companies for the insane price uplift when CDs came out. Vinyl albums were running around $5.99, and then CDs came out at $15.99. Ok, new format and all. But it never went back down again, even when it turned out they were cheaper to manufacture then vinyl.
YES X 1000!! I'm still bitter that they managed to pull that off, and that consumers went along with it and cheerfully coughed up $5-10 more for each album.
Aug 8, 2011 11:53AM
avatar
Bradley, the New Yorker uses umlauts over most (all?) dipthongs, still. I'd imagine the ghosts of E. B. White and William Shawn are guiding this, but it does make them look a bit reactionary. It's not a typo, though--they mean it, man.

Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap