Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Phil Spector/Etta James

Girl You Are a Woman Now

By Xgau May 20, 2011 6:49AM

 

Wall of Sound: The Very Best of Phil Spector 1961-1966 (Phil Spector/Legacy)

This one-CD Philles comp reflects the murderer's loss of his mad grip on his overrated legacy and brings its limitations front and center. Of course there are great records among these 19 oddly sequenced selections‑-by a generous count, as many as a dozen. But there are also three Bob B. Soxx and the Blue Jeans tracks, including the regrettable "Zip-a-Dee-Doo-Dah." Especially given the Crystals classics here that feature La La Brooks or Barbara Alston, these should be enough to convince you to skip the simultaneously released Darlene Love best-of. The Ronettes songs are the only ones in which the lead singer is personable enough to carry material less inspired than "He's a Rebel," "Uptown," and "A Fine Fine Boy." Sometimes, anyway‑-their much better best-of is spotty nonetheless. Too often, Spector's wall of sound was a miasma. Respect him as a girl-group maestro even more gifted than the Shirelles' Luther Dixon. The great exception isn't the Righteous Brothers, who have worn poorly. It's "River Deep Mountain High." A

 

Etta James: The Essential Modern Records Collection (Virgin)

With awe for the atypical Arlene Smith and respect to the late-breaking Wanda Jackson and Brenda Lee, Jamesetta Hawkins had the most physically remarkable female voice of the '50s. "So gritty it was filthy and so sweet it was filthier than that" is what I came up with to promote 2000's Chess Box. But on these 15 pre-Chess tracks, the first recorded when she was 15 and the last before she was 20, the grit is sometimes a gurgle in a soprano on its way down to alto, a serration in an instrument she used  to cut‑-quite a weapon for jailbait whose flirty ways survived well into her long junkie decades. Relieved by straight novelties like "Shortnin' Bread Rock" and "The Pick-Up," where Harold Battiste's tenor sax plays the part of the mack, the material tends boilerplate r&b, and half a century later, Leiber-Stoller's "Tears of Joy" doesn't sound all that much craftier than Davis-Josea's "Good Lookin'." There's too much of the same on Flair's 25-year-old R&B Dynamite, which omits "Shortnin' Bread Rock" and adds only the very early "Be My Lovey Dovey" to her A list, though it includes all the obvious keepers. I prefer this in part because it's shorter. Makes the voice easier to treasure. A MINUS

 

227Comments
May 24, 2011 2:11AM
avatar
I'm an unapologetic cannibal.  I'm letting this controversial bit of confessional out now, in the hopes that it will be ignored when Xgau starts up the next thread. 
May 24, 2011 1:09AM
avatar
Alex - eating meat is not like smoking, a bad analogy for many reasons. The health effects of reasonable amounts of meat are debatable, as is whether humans are omnivores or herbivores (most scientist fall on the side of meat eating and omnivore).  Simply saying something does not make it so.  The health effects of smoking is not debatable. 

As for the raw/cooking argument, cooking degrades, or leaches, the nutrients in vegetables, but it also makes the vegetables easier to digest, therefore allowing your system to grab more of the nutrients.  It's pretty much a wash, and also a good example of why the idea that we are suppose to eat food raw is hogwash.
May 24, 2011 12:20AM
avatar
I really like your Hal Blaine mixtape in theory and will be testing it out in practice as soon as I can.

Belated thanks for the (theoretical) praise, JY47NY! A couple of tips, though--don't get too attached to "I Got You Babe" (since Blaine's not on that one), and if you come across something you think you can't stand, concentrate on the drumming.
May 24, 2011 12:12AM
avatar
Issa joke, son, I say, issa joke -- you know, a funny, for laffs alone (pay attention when I'm talkin' to ya, boy). I keep pitchin' 'em and you keep missin' em. You know, like cry an' the world cries with you, laff and you laff alone? (Aside) ((I bet this kid spends lots o' time laffin' alone.)) (/aside)
*kicks stone (you mean to say people who listen to Gaga are neanderthals? Why not say low-brow?)

Richard Cobeen/jose louis: I tried to write a well-detailed argument last night, but I got spammed! Basically, what I have learned is that, cooking food degrades it. Like, melting plastic makes it useless as Tupperware? Basically, food is meant to be ingested raw. We are herbivores, not omnivores like everyone believes! Cats, and such, have very high levels of acid in their stomachs and have incredibly short intestinal tracts. We, on the other hand, are like cows! I am not trying to lecture you on whether or not to eat meat, I myself eat meat, on occasion, I just thought it was an interesting topic of conversation! It's just like smoking—like it or not, it's still bad for you!
May 23, 2011 11:03PM
avatar
A quick point before this thread ends. I generally agree with Christgau that a tight, well-selected comp beats a sprawling, barrel-scraping one.  But anyone who loves the Etta James set should really consider going for the two-disc Complete Modern & Kent Years--lots of tunes that stand with the ones on the single disc, a handful of Alternate Takes you can zap at will, two great Harvey Fuqua duets (as Betty and Dupree), and the above-mentioned "Be My  Lovey Dovey". Too much of the same, as Bob says? I guess, but in this case the same is pretty great.


May 23, 2011 8:00PM
avatar
That Foghorn Leghorn clip Milo quotes in full was on Youtube last time I checked.  Dang thing is sublime.

Edit: Or perhaps I am thinking of this one: http://goo.gl/of70E (goes to Youtube, probably makes noise, etc.)

May 23, 2011 7:33PM
avatar
Monobrow Culture
Divulge.
Issa joke, son, I say, issa joke -- you know, a funny, for laffs alone (pay attention when I'm talkin' to ya, boy). I keep pitchin' 'em and you keep missin' em. You know, like cry an' the world cries with you, laff and you laff alone? (Aside) ((I bet this kid spends lots o' time laffin' alone.)) (/aside)

May 23, 2011 7:16PM
avatar
Happy Gaga day, all. Non-original thoughts after one listen to the 22-track extra-monster edition on Rhapsody: (i) that's a lot of album, (ii) I suspect those of us who think "Child ballad" refers to Desmond will react to this differently from our esteemed elders, (iii) the Lady can sing.

Now I'm going to listen to the Replacements to remind myself that there were human beings in the Eighties.

May 23, 2011 5:50PM
avatar
I'd thought the longevity cognoscenti had been turning away from what you eat toward how much you eat (i.e. the fewer calories the better, short of malnutrition/ starvation).

Your post was blocked because it appears similar to spam or other caloric food products. If this is not the case, revise your post and try again.
May 23, 2011 4:39PM
avatar

I shouldn't get into this but here goes.

Basically, why eat meat (which, at the very least, is a bad source of protein [if not bad for you]) when you can eat vegetables instead

Meat tastes good. Why not eat both? Since when have they become mutually exclusive? To this palate they're complementary.

Although, thinking about it, the same could be said for smoking?

I don't recommend eating cigarettes.

 About the meat/age thing, there are well-documented studies that show,

Yes there are plenty of those. I don't have the time to lay out a proper history of nutritional admonishments -- there are two Portuguese steaks on the grill -- but remember how trans fats derived from hydrogenated vegetable oils were promoted as a healthy alternative to animal fats? Liquid plastic - yum. Call me a sceptoid,   there's a danger in making glib historical analogies linking causal relationships to incredibly complex biological processes. Don't assume there's a scientific consensus. The debate is as fragmented and polarized as ever. Our knowledge is never complete. We chuckle at some of the beliefs of the past as surely as future generations will mock ours. So enjoy whatever it is you like to eat Alex -- dinner smells ready.  Bon Appetit.

 

May 23, 2011 4:07PM
avatar
Okay, I am checking out that Live at the Main Point, 1975 and yep, it totally supplants the You Can Trust Your Car LPs -- sound, content, packaging (except for the spiffy drawing on the vinyl jacket, the only reason to hang onto it).

Though a transition for Springsteen and the E Streeters, it's a precious moment. I'm very fond of the young Springsteen's voice (he does sound like a holy innocent at times) and had forgotten the graceful touch of Suki Lahav's violin. And I confess I remain fond of the era when Bruce did all the guitar work. Plus, this would be my sentimental favorite slice of his material, when the Spirit in the Night is still alive in his mind.

May 23, 2011 3:52PM
avatar
Alex, the problem with your protein and meat/vegetable comparison is the amount of protein in each.  Taking your percentage of absorption as correct, you would absorb 10 grams of protein with a typical 4 oz. piece of meat.  You would have to eat 3 cups of asparagus, 4 artichokes, 4 cups of beets, 7 cups of butternut squash, etc. to get a similar amount of protein.  Only green beans and peas provide anywhere near the level of protein as meat, and they are legumes and seasonal.  As a society we eat too much meat, but it is still the most efficient vehicle for protein.
May 23, 2011 3:01PM
avatar
Because I still wouldn't live forever
True. (Although, thinking about it, the same could be said for smoking? Perhaps it's just to make sure our children have the best health?)

Monobrow Culture
Divulge.
May 23, 2011 3:00PM
avatar
Is Lady Gaga the Queen of the Mono Culture or Merely the Queen of the Monobrow Culture?

Maybe the Queen of Molded Horns?

 

May 23, 2011 2:31PM
avatar
why eat meat when you can eat vegetables instead

Because I still wouldn't live forever -- it would just seem that way.

Another topic:

Is Lady Gaga the Queen of the Mono Culture or Merely the Queen of the Monobrow Culture?

May 23, 2011 2:29PM
avatar
Somewhere a kid in a ripped Pink Floyd t-shirt is plotting a reaction to this. I hope.
surely that should be a kid in a ripped Radiohead t, no?

May 23, 2011 1:29PM
avatar
jose louis: I don't know why Firefox isn't letting you view this page? I'm using it right now, if that's any consolation? Tongue out About the meat/age thing, there are well-documented studies that show, during the war, a sharp decrease in cancer (rationing of meat)! There are also multiple studies on how it is an insignificant source of protein/toxic/too fatty, etc. Basically, why eat meat (which, at the very least, is a bad source of protein [if not bad for you]) when you can eat vegetables instead (the amount of protein you absorb is around twice the amount of meat [~30% absorption; meat, ~80% absorption; plants]). I'm not against meat, it's a nice topic, though!
May 23, 2011 12:55PM
avatar
Now I feel sorry for kicking off the authenticity discussion and then disappearing.  We spent most of this weekend trying to deal with a bed bug infestation, which for those of you who haven't had the pleasure takes an awful lot of work.  All seems to be going well so far . . .

Since the term "dad-rock" has come up, I have to mention one of my favorite tongue-in-cheek microgenres of recent vintage: "neo-psychedelic dadcore."  Try saying it out loud.

Also, I must say I'm surprised at how many Wussy fans think that their self-titled album is their weakest.  It doesn't have any songs on the level of "Airborne", but it still made it to my top 3 albums of the year.

I don't think the reason why Wussy is so underrated is the style of music they play, or their mode of songwriting.  I think it's that the appeal of Chuck Cleaver's persona is lost on a lot of people.  Rick Anderson's review of the s/t album at allmusic.com, for instance, cites Chuck's vocals and lyrics as the weak point, seemingly immune to his peculiarly Ohioan sense of humor.  Me, I grew up in Cincinnati, and both of the singers sound like they could have been people I knew.  They may not come off as very sympathetic, but they get my sympathy 100%.
May 23, 2011 12:45PM
avatar
Culturally, it is the closest we'll get to having a mono-culture these days. You know its big when people who are out of the loop are talking.
May 23, 2011 12:29PM
avatar
 It is the soundtrack to our lives. No matter who or where we are. That's a cultural triumph.
Somewhere a kid in a ripped Pink Floyd t-shirt is plotting a reaction to this. I hope.
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap