Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Burial/Saint Etienne

The Varied Glories of British Disco

By Xgau Jul 17, 2012 4:34AM

 

Burial: Street Halo/Kindred (Hyperdub/Beat)

Two EPs from the mysterious William Bevan, six tracks divided evenly between his 20-minute 2011 return and his 30-minute 2012 stride forward, cohere almost seamlessly as the album they become when you don't have to turn any plastic over. The accomplished recapitulations of Street Halo‑-faerie electro-soprano and vinyl sputter-crackle laying their dream and disquiet on the nervous beats‑-pause briefly at what is now track four, which takes seven seconds to achieve liminal audibility before slowly building into a peppier elegy than anything he's previously dared. And despite the lamentable title "Ashtray Wasp" (please, I don't want to know), the 12-minute finale begins as a distressed house anthem‑-not literally uplifting, this is Burial, but inspiring nonetheless‑-and then trails off into something more lyrical. Thoughtful, even. A MINUS

 

Saint Etienne: Words and Music by Saint Etienne (Heavenly/Universal)

It's not like they ever disappeared‑-in Britain they've been minor fixtures, regularly releasing albums that all sounded markedly inferior to 1993's So Tough from here. There's even a best-of no Stateside bizzer ever touched. But they clearly regard their first proper album since 2006's Tales From Turnpike House as some kind of recapitulation or theme statement‑-a looking back that's warmly affectionate but too cool to melt into nostalgia. Announcing her intentions with a striking half-spoken reminiscence of a fandom that began at 10, Sarah Cracknell devotes most of these songs to the young clubbers and music lovers she was and knew. But at times you suspect her subjects and personas are older, still caught up in the same dreams. And the subject of "Twenty Five Years" is the time in front of her. Her male partners Bob Stanley and Peter Wiggs provide reliable disco-inflected pop or vice versa that the remixers on the optional bonus disc trick up with more wit and fidelity than we who avoid remixes sagely expect. A MINUS

 

134Comments
Jul 20, 2012 4:57PM
avatar
Carpenters Apologists of the World, Unite -- You have nothing to lose but your social standing!
Jul 19, 2012 11:51PM
avatar
Got my Saint Etienne double CD set in the mail today.  $ 20 ppd from a seller in UK.  Nice package.  Official title:  Words and Music by Saint Etienne Deluxe Edition.
Jul 19, 2012 9:28PM
avatar
So when Together Through Life was released, there was some casual reporting that it would be the then-68 now-71 year old's final album. Which begs the question -- think the new one's title is a reference to the fact that historians believe The Tempest was Shakespeare's last play? Or was it just picked out to match the tacky cover art?
Jul 19, 2012 8:35PM
avatar
Peter G., I'd have no problem with that...I think it'd be an honor if the (former) members of Sonic Youth started posting here.  I think they might take issue with the term "apologist," though.

Last SE mention before the thread ends and I shut up...Scott C., I've been focusing on Turnpike House the last couple of days and it's gone up a notch or two for me.  Love the little duet about the couple debating a move to the country, with Sarah and a creaky-voiced David Essex.
Jul 19, 2012 7:43PM
avatar
1. I just found out that Georgia Hubley appears in the "Glory Days" video (ever so briefly), which isn't as anachronistic as it might seem, since the bar scene is filmed at Maxwell's.

2. Dave Marsh also appears in that video.

3. At the end of the video, Georgia kicked Dave Marsh's ****, but Springsteen edited that part out.
Jul 19, 2012 7:09PM
avatar
“… in just the short time this blog has existed people have owned up to liking just about every artist that's ever been declared verboten by the Cool Police, and I think that's a great thing.” - Allen B.

All good and well, except now when you make what you think are interesting points about, say, tUnE-yArDs, and someone follows up with a far more lucid post on the same subject, you may end up realizing that you’ve been schooled about Merill Garbus by a Carpenters apologist.

So there's a downside.
Jul 19, 2012 6:04PM
avatar
As a sucker for sad songs, I have to add two things --

I've mentioned it before but Iris' so-real-life "No Time To Cry" is the one that gets me every time. Especially the second half of the extended third chorus that goes --

"And I'll take a beer from the 'fridgerator,
And go sit out in the yard and with a cold one in my hand,
I'm gonna bite down and swallow hard."

And it's probably too obvious but the Elton song that does it is "Empty Garden". Not the "insect" line, since that's sad itself if you're related to Mark Chapman. The chorus is what gets me --

"And I've been knocking but no one answers
And I've been knocking most all the day
Oh and I've been calling oh hey hey Johnny
Can't you come out to play"

Plus his vocal performance.

And, Hey Raul. How you been? Too long . . .

Jul 19, 2012 5:08PM
avatar
Why are we talking about Al Stewart again?
Jul 19, 2012 4:11PM
avatar
Welcome back Raul, just talking about you!

Thanks for heads up, Walter.  I don't get to many gigs at the moment, missed a few great ones lately, but will put that in the diary and live in hope.

Jul 19, 2012 3:26PM
avatar
Hello there! Long time no see everyone, but I'm always checking here every now and then. Really happy about september in music now: Jens Lekman and PSB, two of my favorites, will release new albums! "Erica America" is quite beautiful, although for me "The End of The World is Bigger Than Love" still is one of my favorites of him and I'm grateful that it's included in the album. I sincerely don't know what to expect from it, since looks like it's a different record from the previous ones released by him, which were always bittersweet rather than melancholic. Even though, he doesn't look sad, but someway exhausted, isn't he? As I mentioned sometime ago, I'll always love his music and what he's got to say, anyway. On the other hand, PSB is releasing "Elysium" in the early september and it's cold here in Brazil, considering we're on winter now, but we'll be on spring at that time. So far I'm anxious for the album, even with some dislikes here and there, although a fan will always be a fan.

Through these times that I was out, I happened to know a brilliant electronic producer/DJ artistically named Kaito (Hiroshi Watanabe) which has a body of work pretty solid and amazing. His works are released through Kompakt and his albums - in total, 3 ones that I remember - while generally mix house, techno and trance, has an "alternative" version "beatless," which implies more focus on ambient/chill-out. For me, he's an incredible artist that made me know everything he released until now, a thing that don't happen with me frequently. Here's a preview of what has on "Trust," his last album: http://goo.gl/kWzAX (the boy in the video is his son and also features in his artworks since the beginning - by the way, "Kaito," according Discogs.com, "is a project dedicated to and named after his 3 years old son." And means, in japanese, 'The one that is able to explain the universe'" He's a slightly soft artist, that's probably why I listened and I'm listening so much him recently. This is the exactly style of electronic music that I'm very fond (I still have a deep love for this track: http://goo.gl/aBnPz).

I'm also pretty much enjoying the new one Frank Ocean album, including the Hot Chip one, "In Our Heads," Gambino mixtape "Royalty" and now Saint Etienne! I don't think "Channel Orange" is better than "Nostalgia, ULTRA," though, but it's amazing nonetheless. The entire record is great, but my highlights are among "Thinkin Bout You" (a very gentle track) , "Sierra Leone" (oh, the ending is so delightful!), "Sweet Life" (I don't know if I would say "that's" mainly irony, but could be. The line "So why see the world, when you got the beach" has a bitter side taste to it, but the sun is magnificently shinning through the chorus), "Super Rich Kids" (another ironic one), "Pilot Jones" (oh, a pleasant flight, I'm mad about the soundscape in this one!), "Pyramids," "Lost" (my first favorite one! I can sense all these countries and how lost she looks traveling around so much) and "Forrest Gump" (another brilliant association with images while I was listening. And Forrest keep running in the end). The album is massive, but his mixtape was double-massive! Hahaha.
Jul 19, 2012 2:53PM
avatar

Walter, my apologies if the following completely misses the point of your post:

 

No, I most probably wouldn't lose it at the (now past) last Bee Gees show, but I can't say the same for a big Bee Gees fan, and it's impossible for me to say that Al means more to me than the Bee Gees mean to that fan, because I don't think it's true.  Also, though Al definitely means infinitely more to me (and I've spent much more time listening to him) than the Bee Gees (or, say ELO or Cheap Trick or the Cars), at those times when I want to hear the Bee Gees or ELO or Cheap Trick or the Cars then Al isn't going to cut it.

Jul 19, 2012 10:48AM
avatar
Hey Paul H. Great minds think alike. Or something like that.
Jul 19, 2012 10:44AM
avatar

Greg, one of my favorite Xgau lines is from his L. Armstrong box review: "Ask yourself whether high and low mean any damn thing at all."  Because it takes aim at an argument that has wasted far too much of far too many people's time, and also because it provides a very useful template: "Ask yourself whether cool and uncool mean any damn thing at all." :)

 

I might lose it at an Al show, too.

Jul 19, 2012 10:25AM
avatar

In a bit of consumer news I ordered the one-disc Saint Etienne along with Django Django's disc from Amazon UK for $28USD.  Bob's comments re DD plus the three songs I heard via You Tube were enough to sway me.

 

Greg T:  That Vaccines album (my #1 of last year) is their only one but their follow-up is out in September.  Many fall releases look promising from LCC to Dylan to Iris DeMent.  Can't wait.

Jul 19, 2012 10:14AM
avatar
Irene, this is how it was explained to me:  We decided a little while ago when these reply buttons were instituted not to use them. Christgau (and everyone else) wants to keep the conversation open and available to everyone. Get your voice heard man. 
Jul 19, 2012 10:10AM
avatar
Zevon possessive + "Hit Somebody" =  Zevon'****omebody.
Jul 19, 2012 9:54AM
avatar
Walt and Frap, I played Warren's "Knockin' on Heaven's Door" a couple of days ago. I challenge you to listen to it without at least a lump in the throat.  Just yesterday (nothing to do with tears here) a friend mentioned her trip to Honduras and my first thought was, "I'm a desperate man, the sh!t has hit the fan."

An egregious omission a few threads ago when hockey songs were bandied about (get it? hockey players are bandy-legged ha!)(I think maybe five songs got mentioned) was Zevon'****omebody".  What's a farm boy from Canada do?
Jul 19, 2012 9:42AM
avatar

Excellent stuff from our host re: Roskilde. He hit that great combination

of an overview- with on the money specifics-the holy grail of criticism/journalism of that type.

Thanks.

I look forward to seeing footage of Roskilde on my very nice television screen sooner rather than later-via the Palladia Channel which shows concert film-and has always shown plenty of stuff from the various European music festivals including Roskilde.

BTW-still listening to The Vaccines and their recent or is it their only release. I'm a sucker for that kind

of power pop and hopefully will always be. Glad Xgau enjoyed them in Roskilde.

Jul 19, 2012 9:27AM
avatar

Walter: Zevon could probaby wring some tears out of me, especially, "Play it All Night Long," but I was thinking of current bands in particular. It must be generational too or I cry at the wrong moments. I never take anyone's advice on music if they base it soley on emotional response. If that were the case my two favorite songs would be Elton's "The Last Song" and Janis Ian's "Some People's Lives" because I tear-up when I hear them. But, they aren't my favorites, because they're smarmy and treacly std penis probe kind of songs. 

Jul 19, 2012 9:16AM
avatar

From the BSN Fiona Apple essay:

"Post-MTV, you'd figure all these women must work harder at their looks than Laura Nyro."

 

Hah! I don't think Nyro worked on her looks at all. It seems like the only color she knew was black - which was almost admirable for a girl singing jerky pop music in the 60's -- and had the same haircut for almost two decades.

Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap