Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Al Green/D'Angelo

The Roots of Songless Soul

By Xgau Feb 24, 2012 3:54AM

Al Green: Al Green Is Love (Hi/The Right Stuff '75)

I never got with this album, which in the wake of the late-'74 grits-and-suicide incident kicked off Green's quick commercial decline with its only pop hit, the catchy, slight "L-O-V-E (Love)." That one sounds like it was waiting in the can for just such a disaster, and though eventually the post-paranoid "Rhymes" and the Afro-percussive "Love Ritual" caught my ear on compilations, the two other conventional songs here did not. Then I spun David Toop's midnight-soul concoction Sugar and Poison late this Valentine's Day and finally registered a genius piece I'd played 20 times before: the fluttering, vocalese "I Didn't Know," which makes eight minutes of impossible poetry from lines like "I didn't know that you feel like you do/Feel like you feel when you feel like you feel." Along with Sly's "Just Like a Baby," "I Didn't Know" is the linchpin of Sugar and Poison, and also the Rosetta stone of this album, which explores four or five other versions of the same idea. "Love Ritual." "The Love Sermon." It's all L-O-V-E. You got a problem with that? A

 

D'Angelo: Brown Sugar (EMI '95)

After getting religion about a precursor of songless r&b, I thought I'd revisit its modern wellspring, and wasn't surprised to have warmed to it‑-D'Angelo's concentration is formidable, his groove complex yet primal. But because it's bass-driven rather than voice-led, Brown Sugar is less subtle than Al Green Is Love, and less sociable too: D'Angelo, who was leading a great band through these songs by 2000, laid down all the instruments on four tracks and on two others brought in only co-producer Bob Power's guitar, which loosens things up nicely, though not like the string section on "Cruisin'"--a tune that originated with a pretty darn good songwriter named Smokey. A MINUS

 

213Comments
Feb 27, 2012 1:17AM
avatar
Apropos of nothing but my inexplicably disliked earlier post, here's a playlist of (substantiated) Chris Collingwood songs that spotlights a very different writer than how you might usually hear Fountains of Wayne. Interesting though it is that the guy who sings all the songs writes less, he does provide a delicate, surprisingly literary counterbalance to Adam Schlesinger's parody-leaning formula-pop, which is probably the way both haters and proponents define/regard FoW. But Collingwood's voice stripped of Schelsinger's characters and well-wielded cliches highlights how easy and obvious Adam can be. So even if the archives imply that Adam is (unknowingly) Christgau's favorite, give this a shot. For volume consistency I've taken off the more grounded, goofy "Radiation Vibe" and "Joe Rey", though the pre-Utopia Parkway era is represented by a couple of '96 b-sides off of Out of State Plates. If you love the band it's a dimension worth attending.

1. Troubled Times
2. Red Dragon Tattoo
3. Valley Winter Song
4. Kid Gloves
5. Places
6. Hotel Majestic
7. Fire in the Canyon
8. Seatbacks and Traytables
9. Someone's Gonna Break Your Heart
10. Workingman's Hands
11. Cemetery Guns
12. A Dip in the Ocean
13. Killermont Street (a. camera)

I'm posting this here, in lieu of say a much more appropriate few words of tribute to our dear David, partially because we're still a music club and partially because I have no sufficient words of tribute. You've all expressed it immaculately, and with the sort of deeply felt prose both the senseless cosmic act and the beautiful writer/local presence merit. And though I assume most of the thumbsdown were because people don't like me, I certainly hope my big honking irrelevant comment in the field of reaction to his passing didn't strike anybody as insensitive. I hadn't read the news until after I posted, and there is of course nothing more profoundly distressing than the premature loss of an elegantly lived life. Would that he were here to witness the sincere outpouring of fond remembrance. But it does remind one that there is nothing more important than loving those you're with, Stephen Stills be damned. So let David's peace be sweet. I love you all. I hope you know.
Feb 26, 2012 4:13PM
avatar

Last night I posted a Facebook status update in which I stated that if I were ever to do a single-artist covers album – a project that, really, anybody can and should try, competitive musician or not (eat your heart out K. McCarty) – the single artist in question would either be Stephin Merritt, Grant McLennan, Chris Collingwood or Stephen Maffei. The choices are thought-out and exclusive; not only are these the writers I find myself identifying the most with (though my love for their work is still wholly subjective, even in my dad’s case), they’re all artists whose songs seems like they could generally survive a transfer from one mouthpiece to another, even if I’m not the mouthpiece for the job. Anyway, I wondered if maybe it was an unposed question anybody else had their own answers to. Dan Weiss did. So I pose it here, and encourage you to pursue your own particular foggy notions.

 

add’l lazy Sunday notes: my second EW comment ever was a thrown-together top 25 albums list I don’t stand by even if I still at least like everything on it. At the bottom I separated #s 23 – 25 into a “guilty pleasures section”, which to be more forthcoming now that we’re all amigos (aren’t we?) was basically designed to relegate the three artists Christgau never got with (I’m too yella) to a sort of face-saving purgatory. His dismissals of each of these artists are hardly dissimilar – for the most part, they’re sincere white wimps who were idiosyncratic (and good at it) enough to establish adoring cults but never to give our Dean the sense that he should give two ****. I played all three again today. You could make a fair case for Destroyer’s City of Daughters as objectively unlistenable, though there are good lines and I’m still bizarrely fond of the grating voice with the bad guitar. His out-of-nowhere New Pornos triumphs notwithstanding, my affection for D. Bejar might be almost entirely personal. The guy just charms me on levels that I’m sure hold no importance outside of my own head, and which have little to do with music. Bejar would soon give a solid stab at hard fey, a Bowie invention Ziggy himself failed to perfect prior to its feckless death throes at punk’s unforgiving hands. I often daydream about patenting the revival. Soft, hit-you-with-a-flower-if-I-hit-you-at-all fey is still N. Drake’s main issue even on an album as captivating as Pink Moon, easily his best on account of a production (if you can call it that)-induced atmosphere that accentuates the guitar Luen was crowing about before and makes his lyrics sound like appealingly cryptic Brit-poetry epigrams rather than his usual lofty hackhood. I hear an out-of-thin-air peace in this record I admire and envy, even if we all know Drake wasn’t exactly at peace. It thins out the more you try to pick it apart, but just let it float into your ears on a gorgeous late afternoon, absorbing it at an aesthetically rewarding location of your careful choice, and it’s pure beauty. And finally, E. Smith’s Either/Or is just a masterpiece, from the writing to the execution. If an effort this felt and complete and crafty isn’t worth your respect just because it picks sincerity over showmanship, then I’m more than satisfied operating without your system of assessment (whoever “you” may be).


Your post was blocked because it appears similar to spam or automated messages (really?). If this is not the case, revise your post and try again. 

Feb 25, 2012 5:53PM
avatar
I'll come clean: The rumor that Sam is a woman originated with me about a week ago. Part of my man-hating plot to feminize the world and eventually make men extraneous. Or maybe I just misread something. I tried to correct my mistake when someone else corrected meeee, but I guess Joey "****-eating Chagrin" Daniewicz missed that part

I'm sorry I'm being absurd. I'm still ill (like the song—bringing it back to tunes) and cranky and nothing interesting is happening on here right now. But do let's start using that nickname whaddaya say? :-P
Feb 24, 2012 3:45PM
avatar
Great quote from the Lindsay Beyerstein article Milo linked to below: ‎"I'm hearing a lot of 'Rihanna is a stupid famewhore for going back to the man who beat her. Where's her self-respect?' I'm not hearing any 'Chris Brown is a stupid famewhore for using the woman he beat to resuscitate his career. Where's his self-respect?'"
Feb 27, 2012 9:27PM
avatar
Facebook is social climbing, nothing else. I don't know 917 people, and I care for probably about a tenth that number. But we're friends so I guess that means, uh....
Feb 24, 2012 3:51PM
avatar
Great quote from the Lindsay Beyerstein article Milo linked to below: ‎"I'm hearing a lot of 'Rihanna is a stupid famewhore for going back to the man who beat her. Where's her self-respect?' I'm not hearing any 'Chris Brown is a stupid famewhore for using the woman he beat to resuscitate his career. Where's his self-respect?'"

The subtext of course, is this: "How come Rihanna is attracted to Chris Brown and not a nice guy like me?" 

 

I'd be curious to know how many women writers tow the line that Joey mentions above.  None, I expect.

Feb 24, 2012 7:27PM
avatar
I don't blame Joey for worrying aloud about those particular thumbs down. He's being his brave little boy-feminist toaster self, anyway, and I like that about him. I hate to say this, but it would be kind of better to see senseless Brown-supporting comments than mysterious anonymous thumbs down!!! The -ists may be among us!!!!!!! :)
Feb 27, 2012 9:48PM
avatar
Facebook is social climbing, nothing else. 
Pssshh!! Facebook is where I get lauded for posting photos of my cats and my fingernails. MORE THAN I CAN SAY FOR HERE. ;-)

Cam's idea to make a EW fond memories compendium is great--I imagine friends/family would be touched to find out that David left memories behind for a wider circle than they maybe knew about. Lasting impact and all.  I don't really see how something like that would form a clique...of what, people who knew him from here and people who didn't? Doesn't seem particularly divisive to me. Maybe I'll feel left out of the comment compiling and start a riot, though, who knows.
Feb 27, 2012 8:48PM
avatar
Thanks to Jason. We had originally discussed also putting together a section of comments from David's friends at EW about his contributions here or other thoughts. I backed off on that idea because the family had the Facebook page. But now that I see people are having issues with Facebook, let me put the matter up for a vote. Thumbs up if you'd like us to create a EW compendium of out thoughts and remembrances of David, thumbs down to leave it be. If more thumbs up, I'll compile the comments that we can share among ourselves and with the family. If more thumbs down, then we do have an alternative.
Feb 25, 2012 7:28PM
avatar
WOW -- this is a sad and tragic shocker --

http://goo.gl/qD8NM

Feb 24, 2012 5:41PM
avatar
Trying to wrap my mind around the two thumb bombs to my last post.  Here's hoping that it's because, I dunno, maybe it's redundant to quote an article that was just linked to???

Because otherwise we're in trouble.
Feb 28, 2012 6:02AM
avatar
Kenny, that's great. :) If you decide you want to post here, just know you'll be very, very welcome. 
Feb 24, 2012 6:15PM
avatar
You're absolutely right, Bob.  I should consider it less when my knowledge of their use only exceeds to my own, and I know how much of a **** I am with 'em.  Besides, no number of thumbs is worse than MSN telling you that you write like a robot.
Feb 24, 2012 5:48AM
avatar
Oh my WORD. I know everything you do, Bob, is a listening aid, but that transcription made me laugh in delight. I need more of that kind of aid. 
Feb 26, 2012 2:01AM
avatar
During the time in my life I've actually devoted to Zappa, which is age 12 to 14 and then again for some reason in 2006 (same time as the big prog resurgence, a reach towards childhood I guess amid a lot of cheap-thrill aimlessness), I was always strangely drawn to Roy Estrada's distinct high voice. He had all the numbers I admired most: "What's the Ugliest Part of Your Body?", little fake doo-wop passages all over Freak Out!, and -- well, anyway, he sounded a lot friendlier than Ray Collins. In fact as a vocalist "Pachuco" (a word that is still unclear to me) Estrada always sounded like the world's most affable alien dwarf. His presence on the first album by Little Feat made me try the record harder even if the band never interested me. Around age 14 I was starting to write songs and so I wrote a lot, and I actually deigned to write one (loosely) about Estrada. He did time in the Magic Band -- what a cool guy, even if I never paid one second of attention to his bass playing.

Obviously he's not worth a second thought.
Feb 24, 2012 6:05PM
avatar
Joey: You can't worry so much about thumb bombs. For all you know it's besotted Rihanna or Chris occasionals lurking about. I have no interest in banning such surfers from the site. Really, that's democracy.



Feb 24, 2012 10:46AM
avatar
F anyone who doesn't like that Soul Train video.
Feb 25, 2012 8:24PM
avatar
Prior to the Soul Giants, Estrada fronted a band called Roy Estrada and the Rocketeers. The group released at least one single on the King label, "Jungle Dreams (Part 1)" backed with "Jungle Dreams (Part 2)".

Well, at least we now know he left the "Gym" part out.

Feb 25, 2012 3:42PM
avatar
Funny story, I was referring to Sam as a guy.  Then someone told me the contrary and I got all embarrassed.

So now I'm super embarrassed.
Feb 24, 2012 3:38PM
avatar
[Start worthy sidetrack]

Thoughtful comments on the Rihanna/Chris Brown anguish:

http://goo.gl/80Bxu

[End worthy sidetrack]

Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap