Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Ashley Monroe/Kellie Pickler

Putting in the care

By Xgau Mar 5, 2013 6:59AM
Ashley Monroe: Like a Rose (Warner Bros.)
Run through these nine originals a few times and eventually you'll accept that the Pistol Annies are a trio for good reason and her solo debut is unlikely to top "Two Weeks Late," which is about the rent only in the end it isn't. Then slowly you'll realize just how rare it is for a major-label Nashville hopeful to put this much care into every song even if you're not convinced by the one that connects whipped cream and whips. Then you'll check out co-writes‑-Guy Clark, Lori McKenna, hmm. And then you'll wonder who Sally Barris is, 'cause she helped out on a heartsong called "Used" that completes if not tops "Two Weeks Late." A MINUS

 

Kellie Pickler: 100 Proof (XIX/BNA)

American Idol haunts this artistic breakthrough, a sense that she'll always sing what she's told no matter how many composition credits she bags‑-six out of 11 here, including only one of the three tough-talking openers without which I'd never have gotten to where "Long As I Never See You Again" started showing its muscle. But if making nice comes all too naturally, the ones about the daughter she doesn't have and the father she was stuck with say that love is something she's willing to tough out. B PLUS

 

115Comments
Mar 9, 2013 9:08AM
avatar
St marks sounds was the holy grail for me back in the early 80s when I attended NYU. Prices were great, and lots of used vinyl that was extremely helpful for any 70s CG book nut. Also, they were Xgau friendly, posted on the lps there would be village voice CG reviews. Sometimes they would just say what grade the dean gave a record or in the case of Persian Gulf the whole review was plastered on the front. How awesome was that. Bleeker bobs was always kind of pricey for me.
Mar 8, 2013 8:20AM
avatar
Want to join Joe in giving shout-outs to Downtown Music, Final Vinyl, St. Mark's Sounds and yes, indeed, the Jazz Record Center, still in business. All superb shops, particularly rich in experimental pop and world. My wallet always tried to wiggle out of my pocket and run away whenever I approached those places, but I never let it escape.
Mar 7, 2013 11:23PM
avatar

Back in my serious record collecting days (mid to late '80s), I would spend one day almost every weekend making the rounds of local record stores on Long Island - the whole day.  Me and one of my two music-nut friends would load up the car with junk food and hit the road around 10am and follow my homemade map with stops at (almost) every decent record store on the island.  I lost the map (unfortunately - would have been a nice keepsake) but I do have the list of stores I'd visit - Titus Oaks Huntington Station (down the road from me - I'd go there almost every other day after school), Titus Oaks Hicksville, Whirlin Disc in Farmingdale (picked up James Brown's Sex Machine and Live at Apollo Vol II on King there), Record Stop in Lake Ronkonkoma, Mr. Cheapo in Commack and Mr. Cheapo II in Mineola (along with Titus, I got the majority of my collection here - all cheap and all in near-mint condition), Memory Lane in Baldwin (the owner would spin whatever you asked - you could tell he was a big fan and was selling his collection little by little), as well as Tower Records in Melville (also down the street and sorely missed).  There were others (Slipped Disc, Music Trand, Record Collection) but those were the best ones.

 

My record-hunting treks into Manhattan were often solo trips as I would stop at the mid-town Manhattan Public Library first to copy old CGs from their Village Voice collection (and only I had the patience for that). I recall finding some great stuff at Downtown Music (Papa Wemba's L'Esclave for $5), Venus Records, Final Vinyl, Rocks in Your Head, St. Mark's Sounds, Revolver and others.  HMV and Tower were great for buying new stuff, as was Other Music for the obscure new releases.  But my favorite record store of all was Jazz Record Center at 236 West 26th Street.  Not sure if it's still there but I found loads of hard-to-find-elsewhere jazz and blues there and would typically come back with a dozen "finds" after a couple hours in there.  Ah, the days of record-collecting....I remember I found Big Star's Radio City for $2 once.  Heartbreakers LAMF for a buck.

Mar 7, 2013 9:59PM
avatar
I bought "Mush Filmstrip (Frame 1)" (2001, A-) at Wax N Facts on my lone visit.
Mar 7, 2013 9:47PM
avatar
I made the pilgrimage to Bleeker Bob's a couple of times but I find it hard to ferret out the good stuff in a record store like that until I have a good sense of how the place works. The 3 most important record stores in my musical development are all still going concerns.

The Great Escape is right off the Vanderbilt campus near my freshman dorm, although at least back in the day it got little traffic from undergrads. They sell used records, comic books, and various collectorama. This is where I fleshed out my vinyl collection based on the 70s CG book. The son of the owner was a really cool guy who worked behind the counter, and he would let me know if someone brought in used copies of Creem. I hung out there at least twice a week for 4 years.

Wax N Facts is in the Little Five Points neighborhood of Atlanta, once the most bohemian part of town. First time I went to Wax N Facts was when I was interviewing for med school, and it became a regular part of my week. They sold both new and used records and always had a great import collection. The placed was owned by Danny Beard, who also did DB records (Pylon, the first B-52s record etc). Danny was ok, but everyone else who worked there was a total High Fidelity-level snob. I remember walking out of the store with a copy of Fear and Whiskey, my first Mekons record. I remember surreptitiously watching Tommy Stinson bend a Replacements bootleg in half until it broke.

Wuxtry's is/was in a strip mall in Decatur, which is basically a suburb of Atlanta near the Emory campus, right next to Evans Fine Foods, where I could go eat right now (look it up!). They also had (have?) a location in Athens, where Peter Buck used to work. Mostly used records, very funky but less attitude than Wax N Facts. Also closer to where I lived. 1985-1993, this was my second home. 

The only place close to these in Chapel Hill is CD Alley, which has an unbelievably broad collection of new records and the usual used arcana in a room that's not much bigger than my office. Every visit to Chapel Hill should include a stop here.
Mar 7, 2013 9:23PM
avatar
Expert Witnessites, If you dig the Monroe review about (which I no doubt you do), you might want to check out the "Nashville" compilation albums. I know, the show is listless soap opera but the soundtrack is much better. Check out "Consider Me" co-written by one Ashley Monroe.
Mar 7, 2013 8:12PM
avatar
Bleecker Bob's closing? To be honest, I didn't know it was still open. The only period during which I frequented BB's was the summer of 1979-- I bought a bunch of singles there. At the time, I was one of three college kids subletting Jerry Harrison's loft in Long Island City while Talking Heads toured Europe.

The preceding sentence--and yes, I stuck it in because I saw an opening--makes me sound much cooler than I was or am; I only met Harrison once when he showed us how to use the stove, etc., and handed us the keys, and I was the third person my genuinely cool sort-of-friends needed to bring in to cover the rent. Early in the sublet, Brian Eno came around  looking for Harrison--the final production work on Fear of Music was underway. I can't remember anything about Eno other than that he was friendly and unassuming. What do I remember about JH? Him telling us the Ramones blew it because, against his advice, they didn't add a second guitarist. (I can't answer the big question on your minds: why did JH sublet his loft to three college students? I guess he needed the money). 

Ahem . . .  the only record I'm sure I bought at Bleecker Bob's was the Clash's "Cost of Living" EP. Bob must have been in a good mood the times I went into his store because his behavior fell within social norms. And on two successive Yom Kippurs in the mid-80s, when I'd settled in NYC and was still half-observing the Day of Atonement purely out of guilt, I saw Bob at  a temple off of Gramercy Park. 

As for the  video on Jason Gubbels's link, I didn't catch when it was shot and I won't have time to watch it until this weekend, but I skimmed it briefly and was shocked when I came across a scene with Bob. What happened? Well, I know basically what must have happened.
Mar 7, 2013 7:19PM
avatar
Words fail me on this one ...

http://goo.gl/UpXHA

Mar 7, 2013 6:59PM
avatar
I think Bleecker Bob's moment may have already passed by the time I finally got around to checking it out in the mid-'80s.

Or else I was just a Tuge about it --

thought the place was hard to find

was not all that knocked out by the selections

never hung around long enough to bask in any attitude

Always found the nugget-hunting more productive at Other Music.

Mar 7, 2013 5:26PM
avatar
Bleecker Bob's is closing. To be replaced by a frozen yogurt chain. Not sure if that's better than being replaced by a bank. 

http://tinyurl.com/czjhyme
avatar

"Bonnie Tyler to sing for Britain at Eurovision"- a Total Eclipse of the Art.

Mar 7, 2013 1:11PM
avatar
Those interested in the movement to create alternatives to publisher's textbooks should search for "open education resources", and offshoot of the open access movement.

I can't speak for other institutions, but salaries and benefits for all employees at my university makes up roughly 88% of the operating budget.

I have seen many offers for digitized public domain texts come across my desk in the last few months. None of these offers have been close to free.

Scholarly writing may get line edited for grammatical problems, but most scholarly writing is indifferent at best to concision and clarity. Scholars don't write for the general public. I realize there are many exceptions to this, but not that many.
Mar 7, 2013 11:43AM
avatar
I assign public domain texts too! Really, it's unavoidable these days. But I won't if an affordable, well-edited edition is in print.
Mar 7, 2013 11:16AM
avatar
"and let's face it, college professors":  Spotlight on Isaac Goldberg!  

He taught briefly at Harvard (in the Spanish department--some say even with his Harvard Ph.D. he couldn't land a job in the English department because of his, um....surname) and between 1930 and 1931 he published books on Tin Pan Alley and on George Gershwin.  Both books are remarkably good and betray no highbrow condescension.  In fact, Gershwin wrote the intro for the former and called it "swell."  

Mar 7, 2013 11:08AM
avatar
As one of those profs who uses public domain stuff when he can, I wish it were otherwise.  But textbooks are ridiculously expensive (especially in business and the sciences), and publishers keep pumping out new editions to try to undercut the used textbook market.  I hate how much we charge students for tuition (and have no idea where it all goes, because best I can figure only about 15-20% of it goes to me), so I always try to keep text costs down.  Yet, you are right that in their own way, my actions exacerbate the problems.
Mar 7, 2013 10:54AM
avatar
"I did wonder (surely I'm not the only one) if, uh, I'm one of those people 'e doesn't like."

[Looking out the window ...]

Whenever you get anxiety about how people feel about you, consider Old Dad Winter.

Sure he has his beauty moments, but nobody likes him.

Even so, he keeps comin' around, every year.
Mar 7, 2013 10:51AM
avatar
'"Two Weeks Late," which is about the rent only in the end it isn't.'

Must admit it took me three listens to work out what the real topic was. This is perhaps an illustration of why we need critics who are not gentlemen.

(Great song, anyway.)
Mar 7, 2013 10:15AM
avatar
Chiming in to say that the digital age is doing in editors in another way: the increasingly easy and generally free access to out-of-copyright electronic text has, in tandem with the rising costs of print publication, led to a serious drop in sales of scholarly editions--and scholars have contributed to the problem by relying more and more on public-domain texts for their course assignments. Sales, and especially reliable textbook sales, can make a modern edition affordable, so it's a vicious circle: when libraries become the only buyers, the price becomes such that only libraries can buy. Not to blame the problem entirely on digitization (the scholarly benefits of which are still enormous): editing is a labor-intensive, costly activity and commercial presses, universities, and granting agencies are less and less willing to support it.
 
Mar 7, 2013 9:51AM
avatar
Nora: Conflicting opinions should be encouraged, presuming they are presented with clarity and respect (not saying yours aren't, just stating my opinion of the standard), since without them, any group develops hive-mind/groupthink. Cohesion is pretty much always good but not when it demotivates independent thought. We like what we like, so tell me why you think and feel that way and I'll undoubtedly learn something.

(We and you being used generically.)

Mar 7, 2013 9:22AM
avatar
I thought the Nieman interview was excellent, very interesting and didn't take any offense at the idea of not being BFFs. I did wonder (surely I'm not the only one) if, uh, I'm one of those people 'e doesn't like. Dissing Bruce, querying the Loudo box review -- my sins are many. Not too crazy about the last Neil album, either...
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap