Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Todd Snider/The Magnetic Fields

What's So Funny?

By Xgau Mar 6, 2012 2:02AM
 

Todd Snider: Agnostic Hymns & Stoner Fables (Aimless/Thirty Tigers)

Musically, these are not complex songs, and although Snider's boyish air never seems forced and his good humor always comes with laughs, his 45-year-old voice bears the gravelly traces of many sleepless nights. Yet for the third time since he kicked opiates in 2004, he's scored a full album's worth of new material that remains completely in a character unique to him while adding something new to that character. This time what's new is a band sound shambolically anchored by John Prine's New Orleans-raised drummer Paul Griffith and cunningly colored by fiddler Amanda Shires. What's also new but less surprising is an ever more explicit and uncompromising class animus. One song names the Abacus Fund Goldman Sachs and John Paulson conned unions with. Another begs to differ with the privileged canard that living well is the best revenge. Uh-uh, Snider sez. Revenge is the best revenge. A

 

The Magnetic Fields: Love at the Bottom of the Sea (Merge)

These 15 song-puzzles in 34:20 are sophisticated amusements all, although often the amusement is attenuated and one I get bored with before half its 2:38 is over. How amusing they prove over time remains, of course, to be determined. Most amusing: "Your Girlfriend's Face" and "I'll Go Anywhere With Hugh" (tie). Most‑-sorry, it's the right word‑-soulful: "Andrew in Drag." I note for the record that all three are among the first five tracks. A MINUS

 

 

266Comments
Mar 9, 2012 3:17PM
avatar
Wow! I always thought Xgau's beloved Live/Dead would be in his top ten for 1969?!
That was a surprise to me too, although he did post a couple of weeks ago that he played it and liked it less than he used to.  I found Side Four (feedback) to have worn the worst over the years, and still think Sides One and Two in particular feature Garcia's best guitar work (on record anyway).  Much better than Two for the Vault, I have this one filed as high Aminus. I still prefer it to Supersnazz myself. 
Mar 9, 2012 10:06AM
avatar
Wow! I always thought Xgau's beloved Live/Dead would be in his top ten for 1969?!
Mar 9, 2012 1:49AM
avatar
I wonder if we can all agree that those little punctuative shrieks between each verse of "God Wants Us to Wait" are the single best thing on Love at the Bottom of the Sea. (I mean besides the single.)
avatar
(fun fact: Taj Mahal retaliated by putting one out titled "Jorge Ben")
avatar
Playing last.fm's Expert Witness member radio for the first time. Here are the first 12 songs that came on:

Carolina Chocolate Drops- "Sandy Boys"
Jorge Ben - "Taj Mahal" (sweet!)
Fruit Bats - "A Bit of Wind"
Wussy - "Mountain of Tires"
Teddybears - "Alma"
Bill Black's Combo - "Little Queenie"
Low Cut Connie - "Big Thighs, NJ" (2nd best of the bunch)
Yung Wu - "Waiting for the Thunder"
Chris Berry & the Bayaka of Yandoumbe - "Esuma (Wild Yam)"
Funstix - "Funstix Party" ("I'll bring the p*ss*/you'll bring the d!cks")
Willie Nelson/Asleep at the Wheel - "I Ain't Gonna Give Nobody None O' This Jelly Roll" (I guess Funstix isn't inviting him anytime soon!)
Homebody Sandman - "Not Pop"

(what are you waiting for?)

Mar 8, 2012 11:34PM
avatar
And thanks to Patrick as always for a great (and provocative) poll. What he just did!
avatar
Bob U.: That was some truly evil Rickrolling there.

Bob C.: Abbey Road and In a Silent Way top 10, aw yeah! And Dusty in Memphis at #2 - huh, I really need to replay that one (last time was about 15 years ago). Thanks for the list!

Mar 8, 2012 10:54PM
avatar
NYC concert alert: I've just been reminded that Irene Schweizer is at The Stone Fri-Sat-Sun. She's one of the world's great avant-jazz pianists -- I especially recommend her 2006 compilation, Portrait. She specializes in drummer duos, so has Pierre Favre on Sat, Andrew Cyrille on Sun. (Cyrille has two sets on Sun, the other a duo with Oliver Lake.)


Mar 8, 2012 10:31PM
avatar
"The messages in oodles of music are immoral and/or reference to Substance abuse or sexuality."

Like when political songs brag about how many kids the candidate has. Couldn't agree more. I hate songs like that. Hate I tell you!!!

Mar 8, 2012 9:53PM
avatar
Substance abuse
Capital S? Could they be refering to listening to excessive amounts of New Order? I mean who hasn't done that from time to time?
Mar 8, 2012 9:29PM
avatar
Anyone who missed the Wussy show last weekend and wants to hear it or anyone who was there and wants to hear it again can find it by giggling  NYC taper wussy
Mar 8, 2012 9:25PM
avatar

Thanks everyone for the George Clinton feedback, I'm still a little on the fence. I'm afraid it might be a Willie Mays as a Met kinda thing.

Listening right now to the nyctaper Wussy recording and it sounds great. Those with a little spare moolah might want to help the band out with their SXSW pledge drive.

That Rick Santorum song made me wanna throw up.

Mar 8, 2012 9:25PM
avatar

This note was just sent to me from Amazon: 53 people just cancelled their order for Buffalo Springfield's Last Time Around, said 53 then switched their orders to Dusty in Memphis.  Curious!

 

I love that Dusty album, but the last reissued nixed-album bonus tracks, phew.  Bread's "Make it With You?"  A highlight?

 

I always thought "A Sailor's Life" could have been improved by a melodramatic section in which Sandy Denny performed an Oedipal playlet.  "Mother!  I want to...briaughhgughgh come on baby!"

 

 

Mar 8, 2012 9:18PM
avatar
Christgau's list is very Christgau-ish, if I can define that in terms of my own taste. It's half things I really like, half things I know are good but just can't get down to. Which is to say, I think it's a good list. 
Mar 8, 2012 9:12PM
avatar
I'm so happy to see Xgau's 1969 Top 9 list below that I've decided not to countersue Tatum for defamation of character, even if it's against the advice of my own lawyers, Cummings, Mellor & Osterburg. 
Mar 8, 2012 8:34PM
avatar
Great list from Xgau.  Saw the number 2 album and thought, "no fair voting for a compilation!" thinking of Buffalo.  Then went "Doh!" when I realized it was for an album I voted for myself. Only surprise is the Beatles, but not as much after the discussion from a few days ago.
Mar 8, 2012 7:57PM
avatar

Another thing to love about music:

 

You can read all about it as much as possible, and it won't be spoiled.  Unlike movies, where you usually want to stop at a certain point if you haven't seen it yet. 

Mar 8, 2012 7:32PM
avatar
While my attorneys' arguments regarding unauthorized top 10s diluting my brand were largely correct, a back-of-the-envelope calculation indicates that defendant Yanosik did get my top three right, and in the correct order. My very approximate, largely non-relistened 1969 top 9 would go like this:

velvets 14
springfield 13
burritos 13
silent way 11
stones bleed 11
abbey road 10
nashville skyline 9
creedence willy 8
the band 6
Tenth undetermined. Village Green and Unhalfbricking checked out and definitely not. Lewis & Lewis and Supersnazz checked out and in contention. Aoxomoxoa unheard. Hey Jude lost. Stand! a conundrum due to GH problem. Etc.
Great records down to eight. That's impressive.

Mar 8, 2012 7:31PM
avatar
This is almost too sad to post
WTF Bob

their official website says:


"The messages in oodles of music are immoral and/or reference to Substance abuse or sexuality."


Tulsa folks -- they're from your town.


Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap