Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Listen . . . Oka!/Oneohtrix Point Never

Post-Everythingism Meets Nature

By Xgau Feb 3, 2012 7:06AM

Listen . . . Oka! (Oka Productions)

This beguiling piece of post-rock is neither a proper soundtrack nor a field recording‑-not with the African musicians offered the chance to hear their own inventions on headphones and add overdubs. It's a soundtrack-based Bayaka Pygmy audio collage, very much doctored by producer and frequent co-composer Chris Berry, a Californian adept of Zimbabwean thumb piano. With their dream songs, 54-bar structures, and propensity to turn anything from a babbling brook to a scrap of plastic pipe into an instrument, these culturally threatened Central African Republic hunter-gatherers seem to live music even more than most Africans. Women are the chief creators, which has major consequences as regards both prevailing pitch and how much the music hunts and how much it gathers. But either way, it pervades their lives. By manipulating recorded sounds and songs and inviting the Bayaka to do the same, Berry translates that pervasiveness into a form comprehensible in a culture differently pervaded by music‑-ours. A

 

Oneohtrix Point Never: Replica (Software)

Daniel Lopatin may be a deconstructionist, but he's no ascetic. Unlike too many post-rockers, he has a taste for content as well as form and for creation as well as contrarianism, harvesting a healthy plateful of diverse sounds and textured note sequences from his beloved analog keyboards and then arraying them in songlike tracks that stay in the four-minute range until the quietly celebratory seven-minute finale. Chugging, grinding, crackling, swelling, bubbling, babbling, these tracks don't sound like part of the natural world, but they certainly sound cognizant of the natural world. And although I may be missing some of their formal interrelationships, I swear they behave as one thing. A MINUS

 

239Comments
Feb 5, 2012 3:45PM
avatar
In compiling my top 25 GOAT ballot I've fallen into quandry and looking for Witness wisdom.
Sonic Youth. Certainly one of my top 5 favorite bands of all time. Problem is, I love so many of their albums and from so many periods. A Thousand Leaves might lead the pack, but I so love Daydream Nation, Washing Machine, Murray St, Rather Ripped, Sonic Nurse... gosh, it never ends. In other words, no single album is definitive and my 25 picks as so limited, I've decided not to include artist repeats. So my inclination is to list "Hits are for Squares" which is the Starbucks (****!!!!!) comp that includes great stuff both old and new. Nothing from A Thousand Leaves or Rather Ripped, but great nonetheless. And it holds together as a great listen from start to finish.
Naturally, I'd have picked other selections ("Theresa's Soundworld!" "Karen Koltrane!") , but heck, I'm leaving a lot of Stones on the table too by naming Exile on Main Street. Anyone else in the same predicament? Thoughts? Dean?

Feb 5, 2012 3:32PM
avatar
Man, this thumb troll really has an erection.
Feb 5, 2012 3:05PM
avatar
Joe, I'm not entirely sure that is the case. Obviously, these are both our opinions; it's up to Xgau to concede. For example, in the case of NERD, I believe it would still be a B−, but it was an album, that Xgau was just hooked to, and couldn't omit from the list. Again, my opinion.
Feb 5, 2012 3:01PM
avatar
Alex, Christgau likely would have given the formal bump to A+ to Tha Carter III if he had revised various grades from this past decade for a "Guide to the Aughts" volume.  That's based on his end-of-decade list that he made for Rolling Stone, and also based on the Deans List placement for the record.  That was consistently the process for records from the earlier decades.  Many records were revised in grade, up or down, and that grade revision was almost always consistent with their placement in the end-of-year lists that were compiled for the back of the books.  Likewise, the end-of-year Deans Lists may reflect changes in Christgau's opinion from which letter grade revisions can be inferred.  NERD's first album is still a B- in the database, but its presence in the middle of the A- records on the 2002 Dean's List means he was effectively upgrading it to A-.  (Of course, it could ultimately get a further revision had there been an end-of-decade book published in 2010 or something, but that's just speculation at this point.)
Feb 5, 2012 2:48PM
avatar
Richard, I really don't understand this whole 'if something is above something something else, the grade must have been bumped' thing! I mean, Tha Carter III was an A−, but was 2nd place on Xgau's year-end list. I doubt it was bumped to an A/A+. (Correct me, if I am wrong, Xgau.) If something is written, I will take it as that—unless otherwise stated.
Feb 5, 2012 2:39PM
avatar
Marcus was really writing about 10 things he had stumbled across in the pop culture arena each month with little in the way of relative value assignment within or between columns. I was offended by this for a long time, but it makes more sense when you think about it as Marcus telling us how to listen to things rather than what to listen to

Yes, I had that exact response to Marcus's Real Life Top 10 when it initially appeared.  Marcus began to interest me in that when the column itself started changing venue (if not syndicated, it should be -- but then if it isn't wouldn't that speak the difficult currency of cultural history), and became the ten things he noticed every month, from fiction to film to performances.  I think I began to get the knack of its connection to Casey Kasem and the list as an architecture of musicking.  Musicking of course Christgau had brought all our attention to through his writing on Chris Small.   Don't get me wrong, the geekery round here is purt-near instructive at times, and when it's not I never doubt the benefits of sharing music.  My lurking is no more than anthropological, and it comes from admiring Christgau as much as I do.  I'm just curious that my admiration results so differently.   
Feb 5, 2012 2:24PM
avatar
Richard, a related Christgau Geekery question: were Dub Housing and the US edition of the Clash upgraded to A+, or was Rust Never Sleeps downgraded to an A, based on their Clash-Dub Housing-Rust Never Sleeps sequencing in the 1979 list in the 70s guide?
Feb 5, 2012 2:02PM
avatar
Alex, Rubber Soul is in both the '70's and '80's essential guide.  The write-ups before the lists leaves little doubt that he is listing only A graded albums.

And, if he places an album in a list and the album is surrounded by A albums, I don't think it is a leap to assume that the album in question is now an A album.  In fact, it is pure logic.  He's done it time and again (even Parallel Lines started out as an A-).

Thus ends another edition of "Christgau Geekery."

Feb 5, 2012 1:23PM
avatar
For Joanie Sommers apologists only: The song that follows "Johnny Get Angry" on the album of that same name is a mature version of "A Nightingale Sang In Berkley Square". Low-brow pop to high-brow pop without missing a beat.

EDIT: Why does all this make me think of Lana Del Rey again?
Feb 5, 2012 1:19PM
avatar
Bradley, not to say you are wrong, but when were they upgraded? The only one I am not sure is an A is Rubber Soul, but I'm thinking most Beatles stuff are As. Just because something was placed high in a year-end list, doesn't mean it got upgraded, IMO!
Feb 5, 2012 12:15PM
avatar
Richard: Ah, good catch. Talk about unsettling politics, although I quite liked the psychodrama that kd lang made of it later on. That's probably what rescued it for me.
Feb 5, 2012 12:13PM
avatar
Greg, Nick's poll rules are similar to the previous polls and the P&J: you can give up to 30 points to a record, and no fewer than 5.  And you get 250 points to spread out over the 25 titles you list. 
Feb 5, 2012 12:09PM
avatar
Since I mentioned Marcus, let me share a comment I ran across in an article in the San Francisco Chronicle that I guess shouldn't have surprised me as much as it did:

Marcus sold off most of the vinyl when he moved from North Berkeley to just over the line in Oakland this year, just before he wrote "The Doors." He has CDs, mostly live bootlegs, but he doesn't volunteer to put anything on.
Feb 5, 2012 12:06PM
avatar
That said, and I do understand how this undermines our host, ranking qua ranking ain't where it's at for me, which is actually how the iPod in a sense brought me back to music when I wasn't able to afford my "currency" in album-listening anyway -- that started happening to me about the early Nineties. 
This is a good point, and it reminds me of something I thought a lot about when Greil Marcus's Real Life Top 10 ran in the Voice. I took the "Top 10" in the title to be ironic: Marcus was really writing about 10 things he had stumbled across in the pop culture arena each month with little in the way of relative value assignment within or between columns. I was offended by this for a long time, but it makes more sense when you think about it as Marcus telling us how to listen to things rather than what to listen to. In a way, it's the opposite of the Consumer Guide, but complementary to CG as well. In my case, the two columns had a lot to do with developing and trusting in my own ears.

Lists are a formalized method of communicating about music (or anything else), so I think they stand out more in discourse here and elsewhere. This contrasts with the in-the-moment-snapshot conversations that reflect more closely how we really intake music. I haven't thought about this much until now, but most of the music conversations that I have with my face-to-face friends are of the casual sort about real-time interactions with music: exchanging notes with my barber about what we're listening to now or talking with my wife about the latest female country music singer she is obsessed with. Because listiness (the propensity to make lists, yes I just made that word up) requires formal structure and rules, it works best when the list sharers are more or less equally well informed about the subject. Which is one of the reasons why listiness breaks out in places like this, and why most of us feel like we get something out of both the giving and receiving ends of the process.

So, listiness doesn't happen in exclusion to the contemporaneous appreciation of music. Jacob is a case in point; he is a notorious lister, but I also love the FB comments he makes each morning about what CDs he's taking with him to work. That's like coffee to me. Patrick's and Joey's and Nick's lists are like a bottle of scotch-- I'll need a couple of weeks to work my way completely through them.
Feb 5, 2012 12:03PM
avatar
Greg, "Johnny Get Angry" is the song to skip on Girl Group Greats.
Feb 5, 2012 11:10AM
avatar
Ioannis, LOL, I believe there are 5 As and one A minus.

If I may reveal my total list nerdiness, I think we can all agree that Xgau's subsequent year-end and decade-end ballots reveal that at least 5 of these 6 have been upgraded to A+. And the Aretha? Maybe that one, too. (Love you Alex!)


Which is not to say that Christgau wrote, performed, or released any of these albums. All 25 albums are super great, of course; sometimes it just takes a superlative critic to point that out to us and, even better, offer a compelling and informative explanation for that opinion (EDIT: and create a context for them as some kind of unified something, a context that I believe many of us here enjoy, or perhaps even obsess over). (Love you Bob!)



Feb 5, 2012 10:52AM
avatar
I just think fealty to the album-as-album defines something that might be described as "rockist," a label that has a lot to do with jazz history, as rock criticism emerges from (see, e.g., The Little Sandy Review) jazz criticism's collector's sensibility.  The emphasis on lists I find really interesting to the experience of list-ening to music, and I understand that a premier salutariness of this bulletin board is the thing that is so strong in musicking, i.e., sharing pleasure.  That said, and I do understand how this undermines our host, ranking qua ranking ain't where it's at for me, which is actually how the iPod in a sense brought me back to music when I wasn't able to afford my "currency" in album-listening anyway -- that started happening to me about the early Nineties.  I really enjoyed my friend (and fellow former music critic) George Yatchisin's Friday Random Top Ten list, which he would post to an earlier incarnation of his blog,  I'm Not One to Blog, But -- just the Friday version of what his Shuffle came up with on his Friday work commute.  I loved that way of sharing music -- the ten items (and their provenance) the shuffle came up with that morning.  
Feb 5, 2012 10:23AM
avatar
PS Someone help me here-what's the max points you can give an entry?
Feb 5, 2012 10:16AM
avatar

Now how to divide it all up between Dylan, the Stones, The Who, The Beatles, The Clash, The Kinks, Miles Davis, Frank Sinatra, , Neil Young, The Band, Husker Du, The Replacements, The Gang of Four,Television, The Ramones,Elvis Costello, the other Elvis, Prince ,Jefferson Airplane, Oasis, Cream, The Allman Brothers, Zeppellin and many others-imposible. Oh yeah- The Vibrators "Pure Mania". Oh, baby.

 

Feb 5, 2012 10:06AM
avatar

Given that this "best ever" poll was my idea to begin with I'll gladly take the credit

Given that someone else is doing the work

Priceless

 

Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap