Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Francis Bebey/Joan Soriano

High Hurdles

By Xgau Jun 8, 2012 1:09AM

Francis Bebey: African Electronic Music 1975-1982 (Born Bad)

I first encountered this genial Camerounian savant via his pioneering if romantic 1969 overview African Music: A People's Art. But though I knew from the book jacket that he'd worked for UNESCO and published novels, the albums that trickled my way‑-sanza exhibit, wan protest songs, retrospective miscellany‑-seemed too schematic musically. So I never grasped that this public intellectual was a successful creator of singing commercials and African hits until this conceptually cockamamy attempt to stir up the hipsterati by linking songs notable for their jingle quotient to electronica. Created on a primitive synthesizer in Paris, they're above all winning and catchy, their sonics almost as quaint as thumb piano by now. Though half are also on La Condition Masculine, which is generally deemed Bebey's best album, this selection is hookier from the just-released "New Track," whose subject is white starchy foods, to "The Coffee Cola Song," whose subject is the cash economy. Dieu merci, both are in English, which helps the French ones fit in‑-the instrumentals too. And "Divorce pygmee" and "Pygmy Love Song" have it both ways, clarifying between them the bemused respect with which this cosmopolitan Protestant regards his native continent's profusely musical peoples. A MINUS

 

Joan Soriano: La Familia Soriano (iASO)

Usually I find bachata too mild‑-a homogenized and slightly speeded-up MOR in which sentimental Dominican bolero slackens tensile Cuban son. But Soriano's guitar is so nimble and articulate you forgive him his pleasantries, and on his second U.S. album his sisters add sweet and spicy accents to his beseeching vocals, which may deliver the Spanish lyrics but seldom leap any language barriers. Bright, playful, feisty, flirtatious, Nelly and Griselda are the love objects the graceful runs and articulate phrases Joan's playing imagines. B PLUS

 

205Comments
Jun 10, 2012 11:55PM
avatar
"Can I just emphasize that all of this is very, very, very boring and time-consuming?"

Boy, is it ever. Which is why I hope to Yod I'll only have to mention this once. (Because, unreflective as I apparently am, I cannot bear the thought of the standard narrative being that I attacked a stranger's parents online. And that I'm too arrogant to explain myself.) My snark at sharp was, unless you want to put a real mean-spirited spin on it, about his sense of humor, not his parents. Months ago he made a "joke" about Takoma records -- he never got to Fahey because school peers kept pushing the weaker members of its roster on him. I'm very interested in how peer experiences with music shape taste in teens and pre-teens. I honestly, believe it or not, read it as a straight statement, not a joke. So I think sharp's a smart guy and I ask him to followup that remark. Instead of rolling his eyes metaphorically and saying, "it's a joke, son" he growled at me and basically claimed I was just trying to "pick a fight" with him. (My question was a kind of lie, in other words.) Struck me as way harsh. But with a particular flavor -- which I much later identified as that, "nobody's naive" tone of academia.

Spent some time the next day trying to figure out what the hell happened. Oh, it was meant as a joke. Then, much later, gratuitous snark hurled back. Case closed. Let us never speak of it again.

***********

Funny Page/Plant/boss story.
Jun 10, 2012 11:54PM
avatar
What's this I hear? Jazz pianist Matthew Shipp muscles his way up to a Farfisa organ, and joins forces with the guy from Spiritualized and the guy from Spring Heel Jack to detonate a 38-minute organ-guitar-drums one-off called "Black Music Disaster"?

Fellow noise fiends, let's dive in.

(I fully realize this could well be unlistenable).
Jun 10, 2012 11:34PM
avatar
Michael Tatum, we had hootenannies at our elementary school, always did "This Land is Your Land".  I was shocked later to learn that the original words weren't "From Bonavista to Vancouver Island/From the Arctic Circle to the Great Lake waters."  This was not many years after Neil had his epiphany seeing Roy Orbison here in Winnipeg.
Jun 10, 2012 11:16PM
avatar
A couple of times I've been taken aback by shots Milo's taken (not at me yet, that I've noticed anyway), and he's being a trifle disengenuous about them, but the rest of the time his plainspokenness is refreshing.  He also writes better about music than I could ever hope to.
Jun 10, 2012 11:04PM
avatar
RE The Clash. Get the UK version of The Clash and then start your own singles mix tape (idea stolen totally from our genteel host's 1979 review of the US version of The Clash). Mine's evolved over time and I realize that I need to add "This is England" to it. More often than not, the single versions differ from album versions where that is relevant.  Here 'tis:

White Riot
1977
Listen
Complete Control
City Of The Dead
Remote Control
London's Burning (Live)
Clash City Rockers
Jail Guitar Doors
(White Man) In Hammersmith Palais
The Prisoner
Tommy Gun
1-2 Crush On You
English Civil War
Pressure Drop
I Fought The Law
Gates Of The West
Groovy Times
Capital Radio Two
Time Is Tight
London Calling
Armagideon Time
Justice Tonight
Kick It Over
Clampdown
The Card Cheat
Lost In The Supermarket
Bankrobber
Rockers Galore...UK Tour
Rudie Can't Fail
Train In Vain
The Call Up
Stop The World
Hitsville U.K.
Radio One
Police On My Back
Somebody Got Murdered
The Magnificent Seven (Edit)
The Magnificent Dance (Edit)
Lightning Strikes (Not Once But Twice)
One More Time

Jun 10, 2012 10:29PM
avatar
Get both Clash records if you can. The UK flows nicer, yes, but the US has "Complete Control" and "White Man in Hammersmith Palais" and your life should not be without those songs.
Jun 10, 2012 10:25PM
avatar

"Can I just emphasise that all of this is very, very, very boring and time-consuming? There are better things to do. Like, y'know, talk about music"

 

Tom Hull's Neil Young blurb is far more insightful and funny than others I've read.  Maybe by this time tomorrow, he'll post it.

Jun 10, 2012 10:24PM
avatar

This may seem semantical, but old men can't really be sassy, can they?  Hairy Irene, now that was some sass.

 

Caliban was noble.  He was used by Prospero, so his self-pity was somewhat understandable.  Who's the Propsero in this scenario?  "The Man?"  Educated people? 

 

I personally don't think Milo knows how much he hurts people, truthfully.  That would take a layer of self-consciousness/self-reflection, wouldn't it? 

 

Once again, I must urge everyone to separate Milo the writer from Milo the poster and Milo the human being.   Believe me, that sort of compartmentalization helps.  I'm not sure I'd want people judging me from all the **** I post here, either.  (Well, maybe.)

 

LB -- my wife wishes sometimes I was more serious.  lead from strength, son!

Jun 10, 2012 10:16PM
avatar
"Can I just emphasise that all of this is very, very, very boring and time-consuming? There are better things to do. Like, y'know, talk about music"

True. Enough for now.
Jun 10, 2012 10:13PM
avatar
I never thought a Walking to Clarksdale memory would get mentioned here, but since it did a couple days ago ….

Back in 1998 I had started a new job and was on a business trip in Grand Rapids, MI with my new boss. We were sitting in the hotel lounge one Sunday evening, discussing our plans for the next day, when I noticed the guy sitting about ten feet away looked just like Robert Plant, and I told my boss so. The Plant look alike was close enough that I could hear his conversation. “This is truly weird” I said to my boss. “That guy even sounds just like Robert Plant.” 

After a few more minutes my boss turns to the person next to him and says, “This guy’s trying to tell me that Robert Plant is sitting right there.” To which the person replies, “That is Robert Plant. Jimmy Page just went upstairs.”

So it turned out that Page and Plant were on tour in Grand Rapids, MI, promoting their Walking to Clarksdale album, and we’re surrounded by band members and what Plant would later call “Traveling Led Heads.” There’s a Page & Plant show the next night literally right across the street, and my boss is so excited that he wants to see the show. I tell him I’ll see what I can do, and talk to some of the fanatics. One of them calls my hotel room early the next evening with two extra tickets, so I make the transaction and my boss and I then head over to the show. As we are about to enter the arena, we have this dialogue:

Him: So these guys used to be in Led Zeppelin?
Me: Uh … yeah.
Him: Huh. So what songs did Led Zeppelin sing?

At this point I’m in a bit of a panic, as I don’t really know my boss, and frankly if he’s not a Led Zeppelin fan then I feel like I’ve just ruined the evening for him. Then the show starts, and it sucks. I mean it really sucks. It’s almost exclusively songs from the new P&P album (I recall one called “Heart in Your Hand” that was even worse than its title), but then they start playing almost exclusively Led Zep covers, and it’s good - these guys, particularly Plant, are pros. I’m relieved as my boss seemed to be having a good time at that point. After the show we’re walking out of the arena, and had this dialogue:

Him: So those are the songs Led Zeppelin sings.
Me: At least the ones in the second half of the show.
Him: Didn’t they also sing “Stairway to Heaven”?
Me: Yes, but they don’t play it out of respect, or something.
Him: Too bad.

A couple years later my boss came into work and declared himself the “rock n roll guy” after seeing Journey/REO Speedwagon/Styx in a marathon show the night before. (I would not have survived this event even under heavy sedation.) He then asked me where one buys CDs, so at lunch we went out to a local Borders and I helped him buy the first CD of his life. He ended up with the Best of Styx. My boss was a kind-hearted soul who just had no interest in rock music. I remember him fondly.

Jun 10, 2012 10:02PM
avatar
"I said I thought you were over-invested in polls. It wasn't some arbitrary jab out of nowhere."

True! You didn't go after what my parents did for a living (electrician and stay-at-home mom, if you want to have at it) or being congratulated by others for obtaining a degree (University of Montreal, 1993 - go crazy!).
Jun 10, 2012 9:57PM
avatar
Can I just emphasise that all of this is very, very, very boring and time-consuming? There are better things to do. Like, y'know, talk about music. (Which is what Cam has said like every time this has come up.)
(Edit: fixed my grammar, in case anyone cares)
Jun 10, 2012 9:53PM
avatar
Milo, I don't know if I really want to engage in another lengthy dialogue with you. Just a few points and I'll shut up, because I don't think it's really my place to be taking this on:

I think you're right that I misrepresented the Cam/Kevin John/Alex incidents. Regarding the first two, I actually said that you had used "stern words," which suggests that your replies were condescending/confrontational. They probably weren't. And I agree that Alex's post about Obama was ignorant and racist, so it was unfair to say that your reaction was unprovoked. Nevertheless, I'm not sure that your reaction helped. Insulting someone rarely changes their mind.

"I admit it, getting called an a$$hole tends to plant a seed of hostility in me. Being accused of lying when I'm not. Having my proposition slanderously misrepresented."
I think that's a bit histrionic.
--If I remember correctly, Nicky called you an a$$hole (it's ridiculous that a word of that spelling has triggered such a serious argument) because you had already insulted Sharpsm in a fairly hostile-seeming manner. (Do you really know the guy well enough to make a jab about his parents?) The seed had already been planted, so to speak. And as far as I'm concerned, "a$$hole" is nearer to meaning "nasty person" than "turd"/"worthless person" as you suggested. Sure, it still isn't nice, but I don't think you can be self-righteous given the context.
--Who has accused you of lying?
--Isn't slander (well, technically libel) something that is done intentionally? I think most of the misinterpretation here is accidental. People often don't read carefully when they're angered. That's not entirely their fault, given the way you write.

"Likewise, I've posted things I would call sassy more than insulting"
You would call sassy. But clearly, a lot of people have construed your writing as insulting on several occasions. Your humour is easy to take the wrong way, and if it is I imagine it could be very offensive--like you say, words can hurt. You assume that other people will get the joke, which really isn't a given because you know very little about them. Several readers here don't speak English as their first language. And when your words are misinterpreted, you often get oppositional rather than simply explaining what you meant.

"I donno -- you notice I don't repeatedly argue with the same poster over and over and over. If I risk not having a good dialogue with somebody, I try not to interact (you know, the troll option)."
Fair enough, you do tend to keep it brief. But let me use the Nicky thing as an example. What on earth did you gain from that? 

Michael--thanks. Honestly I'd like to crack a few more jokes (I feel like a friggin lawyer writing this stuff) but, as I've emphasised above, when it comes to internet writing, especially in arguments, I think it's best to be as unambiguous as possible.
Jun 10, 2012 9:49PM
avatar

"...there really was only one great artist in the Faces."

Nobody could confuse Ron Wood with a great artist. In an earlier post I did reference Lane's superiority to Rod post-Never a Dull Moment (what a sadly unprescient title). But the quote above is dubious. "Miss Judy's Farm" and "Stay with Me" are no better than "You're So Rude" or "Debris" (just typing the word makes my hair stand on end), but those first four Rod Stewart solo albums are the work of a major artist.  Very very briefly, but he major. What's easy to forget is the empathy in and humility of so much of that work. And he was a great singer, and he rhymed "phone ya" with "Minnesota".

Thank you for the tip on "The Passing Show".  My mother's name was Ann, and I'll always regret not having the courage to sing "Annie" at her funeral.

Jun 10, 2012 9:38PM
avatar
"the fact that they're so often received as you taking a sh!t in some random person's cereal bowl oughta tell you something."

It tells me that people I've pissed off want to promote this notion of free-floating hostility from me. I said I thought you were over-invested in polls. It wasn't some arbitrary jab out of nowhere.

And I think there's a big difference between being provocative and Calibanish on occasion and hollering "yeah, I'm an @sshole, you got a problem with that?" And in fact, I think that's a misrepresentation of what I've said.
avatar
Milo, if your provocations are genuinely intended as sassiness and nothing more, the fact that they're so often received as you taking a sh!t in some random person's cereal bowl oughta tell you something. And when they're compounded with that "yeah, I'm an @sshole, you got a problem with that?" attitude, I run out of reasons to believe your actions are not in bad faith.
Jun 10, 2012 9:13PM
avatar
I have both so I burned a cd of the UK with the US cuts tacked on at the end. Too bad the record companies can't do the same.
Jun 10, 2012 9:06PM
avatar
Thanks Cam for the recs, the Ronnie Lane doc is streaming on Netflix so I'll be watching it soon. Anyone else see Bob and the Monster besides me.
Jun 10, 2012 8:43PM
avatar
"I have to say, going to a forum filled with people one clearly considers one's intellectual inferiors"

Well, that's one of those assertions which, if you want to believe it, nobody can say anything to change your mind. But I'll try anyhow -- that's just not true.

Likewise, I've posted things I would call sassy more than insulting. But it now really gets exaggerated. I mean, somebody said I had some clash with Cam -- and that's news to me. We've had a couple grown-up disagreements that I recall as salutary, not negatives. Kevin John and I had a tussle where we were talking past each other -- but it wasn't an attack on a poster. I was disparaging a position he did not, in truth, hold. Then, way back when, there was a post I considered racist that pissed me off. But I hate dragging up old incidents Not least because, if somebody's made up their mind that you're a jerk, you're blamed for trying to make excuses.

"then complaining that the place does not feel like a community"

No online place feels like a community to me (none that are open to the public, anyway). No place. Not just EW. I understand that probably most people don't feel this way. I don't think they're deluded. We simply don't have the same perceptions/reactions.*

"I really don't understand why you become so hostile sometimes."

I admit it, getting called an a$$hole tends to plant a seed of hostility in me. Being accused of lying when I'm not. Having my proposition slanderously misrepresented.

"it doesn't seem to accomplish anything."

I donno -- you notice I don't repeatedly argue with the same poster over and over and over. If I risk not having a good dialogue with somebody, I try not to interact (you know, the troll option).

Finally, to be honest, considering the florid fury and aggression that seethes all over the internet comments and chat, I'm kinda mild.

*Here's an example of an internet phenomenon that seems utterly bizarre to me:

A couple people start to have an argument in a chat room. Almost instantly, people not involved in the argument zoom in and take sides. Often one position prevails and it ends up being a sort of gang beat-down of the loser.

It's as though you could not prevent every person walking by you in the street from hearing every word you say. If I was having a heated discussion with somebody on the sidewalk and a third (fourth, fifth, etc.) party jumped in and took sides, I think both the original arguers would say (even if we knew the interlopers a tiny bit)) "Butt out! All you're doing is pouring gasoline on the fire."

And yet people sit around scratching their heads saying "Gee, how do internet discussions get so out of control?"

*****************

'The other is “The Passing Show: The Life and Music of Ronnie Lane”,'

 A perfect description of this documentary. You probably do have to be a Lane fan, but I sure am one and it made me cry.

 
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap