Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Odds and Ends 019

Legacies and leavings

By Xgau Jan 4, 2013 5:38AM
This One's for Him: A Tribute to Guy Clark (Icehouse)

Legend gets the country-canted alt-star lovefest he deserves (Ray Wylie Hubbard, "Homegrown Tomatoes"; Suzy Bogguss, "Instant Coffee Blues"; Jack Ingram, "Stuff That Works") ***

 

Shonen Knife: Osaka Ramones: A Tribute to the Ramones (Damnably)

Temporarily unannoying J-altpop post-geishas chirp the classics ("We're a Happy Family," "Blitzkrieg Bop") ***

 

The Bachata Legends: The Bachata Legends (iASO)

Thirty years later, DR icons re-record their bittersweet acoustic hits like the nostalgic professionals they've had the opportunity to become (Leonardo Paniagua, "En un quarto dos amantes"; El Chivo Sin Ley, "Tirale bajito") ***

 

Enoch Assembly: King Elvis Dead (self-released)

Twenty-four Elvis-Beatles-Herman's Hermits interviews and ad snippets ask why the King never visited the mother country, among other things (Elvis Presley, "Perfect for Parties LP 10-56"; Paul McCartney, "Ram Ad") **

 

Paul Simon: Live in New York City (Concord/Hear Music)

Old perfessor's enjoyable survey course in his own legacy, only he should never let the world forget "Peace Like a River" ("The Boy in the Bubble," "That Was Your Mother") **

 

Taj Mahal: The Hidden Treasures of Taj Mahal 1969-1973 (Columbia/Legacy)

A dozen previously unearthed semiprecious stones plus ramshackle concert ("Sweet Mama Janisse," "I Pity the Poor Immigrant") **

 

Mighty Sparrow: Sparromania!--Wit, Wisdom & Soul From the King of Calypso 1962-1974 (Strut)

Got paid every time he walked into a studio‑-still does ("Dancehall Brawl," "No Money, No Love") *

 

Lowe Country: The Songs of Nick Lowe (Fiesta Red)

New-country hopefuls impart more life to old new wave songwriter than he's shown in 20 years (Caitlin Rose, "Lately I've Let Things Slide"; Jeff the Brotherhood, "Marie Provost") *

 

 

120Comments
Jan 8, 2013 3:25AM
avatar
Polls are CLOSED.  Fifty-seven ballots cast!
Jan 8, 2013 12:22AM
avatar
HURRY UP AND GET YOUR BALLOTS IN

POLLS CLOSE BY THE TIME I HAVE ALL OF THE BALLOTS IN MY INBOX COUNTED
Jan 7, 2013 8:20PM
avatar
I'm finally going to start subscribing to either MOG, Spotify, or Rhapsody. I've been using Spotify for over a year now so it's my frontrunner but I have an open mind and concerns. I'm primarily concerned about audio quality, ease of use for MOG and Rhapsody and their catalogs when compared to Spotify. If anyone has pros and cons about any of these three services please be completely candid with me. Keep in mind my baseline of experience is with Spotify's free service.

Right now,  I'm planning dropping eMusic to pick up the service and I want the best quality sound with the best catalog and the easiest interface.... I don't want the world I just want your half!



Jan 7, 2013 8:14PM
avatar
The Jazz Critics Poll linked to below is great - that top twenty is solid through and through, my only quibble being that the Chick Corea/ Paul Motian / Eddie Gomez quasi-Bill Evans tribute coming in at #45 seemed a bit harsh. Oh well. Seeing the great new trio album from Fred Hersch lodged at #12, Tim Berne's Snakeoil project at #8, and good old Branford Marsalis at #7 was a nice balm. 
Jan 7, 2013 7:53PM
avatar
Someone is apparently upset that I'm going to take three whole days to set up the top albums page.
Jan 7, 2013 5:37PM
avatar
And speaking of jazz, jazz fans might find themselves shitting themselves when the top 2012 albums list goes up on Friday.
Jan 7, 2013 5:37PM
avatar
Today is the last day of voting!  In honor of 2011's songs list taking until CHRISTMAS EVE for me to get up, I'm gonna let you in on a little secret...

The top 2012 songs list will be up TOMORROW.
Jan 7, 2013 5:05PM
avatar
Tom:  I got the link to your results page via Twitter on January 3 from guess who, the winner, Vijay Iyer!  (Vijay Iyer's Twitter: https://twitter.com/vijayiyer)

What is kinda funny is that Iyer did not mention that he had won.  He got the link from Philip Booth.
Jan 7, 2013 4:54PM
avatar
Rhapsody's Jazz Critics Poll isn't up yet -- should be sometime this week. I host the individual ballots, as I have for several years now. I put some preliminary stuff up for proofreading, and evidently didn't do a very good job of securing or obfuscating where it is. I have a few errors fixed locally but not publicly, since this isn't supposed to be public yet. On the other hand, Francis has already passed the link around to the voting critics, so I'm not the only possible leaker. So enjoy your scoop. (By the way, I didn't factor any inside info into my metacritic file, but if you look closely -- e.g., at the jazz subset -- it's all there too, plus a little extra noise favoring Neneh Cherry and Robert Glasper.)

By the way, big thanks to Chris Drumm and Greg Morton for getting me out of that playlist jam. Haven't heard back yet, but I can't imagine they won't be blown away.

Also, Jazz Prospecting up, including three A-list records I didn't get to before the deadline. Happens every year, almost instantaneously. Two of the records were flagged by other critics, and I was just slow to get to them. The other is a December-released import from Lithuania -- safe to say, nobody got that one in time.


Jan 7, 2013 2:53PM
avatar
A different Rhapsody jazz poll link: http://goo.gl/14eAF

Note that this goes to Tom Hull's site, not to Rhapsody, which as far as I can tell does not have the poll and accompanying essays up yet.
Jan 7, 2013 2:37PM
avatar
Can't get the link to the jazz poll to work, but did dig up a detailed version of Chuck Eddy's Metal Picks. Turns out the Mekong Delta is a best-of remakes by the current band lineup. Okay. Still intrigued, but not as excited.
Jan 7, 2013 2:02PM
avatar

I was reading through Andrew Sullivan today and came across a mention of Christgau from his 1976 Ramones review in regards to defending "Zero Dark Thirty:"

 

 

andrewsullivan.thedailybeast.com/2013/01/in-defense-of-zero-dark-thirty.html

Jan 7, 2013 2:00PM
avatar
Francis Davis' Jazz Poll on Rhadsody is up. I found it here:
http://hullworks.net/jazzpoll/12/index.php

Jan 7, 2013 1:11PM
avatar
Thanks to all of you for commenting so much on the Standard Fare thing! (Esp. the Dean.)

I decided that [SPOILER] I'm gonna vote for it [/SPOILER]. Though I am not an American, the argument that critical reception is more important than the exact date of release convinces me.

If Joey, as the guy who puts all the work in counting the ballots, thinks otherwise and will not list Standard Fare, I am fine with it. A demarcation line has to be established somewhere, and so it be. But in this case, my love for the record is stronger than my very German disposition to technocracy.
Jan 7, 2013 12:49PM
avatar
New Yo La Tengo album streaming at P4K.
Jan 7, 2013 11:01AM
avatar
FWIW, the test for whether something could appear the year after its official release in my time was: if it got at least half the points in, say, 1983, as it did in 1982, it counts as a 1983 record. That means that if it got all its points in 2012 and none in 2011, as I presume will be the case with Standard Fare, it counts as 2012. In addition I would tend to say the same goes for a 2010-released record that only gets noticed two years later.
BTW, I've been told that somebody's copy of the Ned Sublette says 2010. Mine says 2012, and since I and a great many other left-inclined people on Ned's vast emailing list only learned of its actual as opposed to projected existence in September-October, I'll go with that. Postmambo is definitely one of those undercapitalized labels that sometimes has to delay release. Ned's about as undercapitalized as it gets. His books make great presents, I find.

Jan 6, 2013 10:42PM
avatar
I voted for Standard Fare in 2012 and hope that if it's one of your top ten albums for 2012 you will too. And if Big Boi makes it next year, I will vote for it. If there is a consensus that an album deserves votes for a given year, I defy any election administrator to prevent that consensus. Why is release date more important than the year large numbers of people actually listened to something?

Jan 6, 2013 10:39PM
avatar

Speaking as someone who has wasted his gray cells in retail for many years, I can explain the Standard Fare paradox.

 

The 2011 date you see corresponds to the actual release date for the record in the UK. 

 

However, because it's an import, and because not all imports immediately get funneled into domestic channels, it sometimes takes a little while to catch up with having them available to us.  Amazon (for example) immediately got the UK Joni Mitchell box because there was a great deal of interest.*  By contrast, Standard Fare being more obscure, it took domestic channels a little while to catch up with the "demand" -- said demand being smaller, and their label being a microindie.  Hence, a 2012 release date for Americans.  How this differs from a 2011 record being released the next year domestically on a US label (like Lily Allen's record) you tell me.  But then again, the whole "Pink Flag is 1977" scandal didn't mean **** to me.

 

* Personal to Jacob -- I passed on that one.

Jan 6, 2013 8:47PM
avatar
By the way, my metacritic file is pretty authoritative for what records are actual calendar 2012 releases: /ocston/nm/notes/meta2012.php -- I decided this year to ignore everything that didn't have a 2012 release date (that reviewers were merely slow getting to), but I did include still include some 2011 releases that were re-released in 2012 (e.g., UK 2011 releases that didn't appear in the US until 2012 -- the first examples in my file are Bombay Bicycle Club, Gotye, Royal Headache, the Unthanks' Wyatt/Antony album).

I'm not taking a position on whether you should consider late 2011 releases in your 2012 year-end lists. That's pretty much a hopeless problem no matter how you slice it.


Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap