Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Black Stars/Sofrito

Disco Sin, Sans, and Without Dollars

By Xgau Nov 8, 2011 6:32AM
Black Stars: Ghanas Hiplife Generation (Out Here '08)
The African ability to manufacture major exhilaration out of marginal economics is a skill young American musos should wrap their minds around. These 14 tracks, selected by ace German compiler-annotator Georg Milz from the decade-plus history of a broadly conceived genre that's not about to quit, modernize highlife with electronics, rap, and the occasional excursion into reggae. Their only program is getting parties started. These parties are as raunchy as they wanna be‑-"Toto Mechanic" means "Pussy Mechanic" in Ga. But they're markedly more relaxed than, for instance, the HI-NRG bashes evoked by VP's new Ultimate Soca Gold Collection‑-as if they've figured out that the toto feels better to both partners when all day and all night includes breathers. A MINUS

 

Sofrito: Tropical Discotheque (Strut)

The title means exactly what it says. Selected by a London dance collective called Sofrito, which is also the name of a fatback-based Puerto Rican staple, two-thirds of these 15 obscurish dance tracks are from the disco era of 1976-1980, almost all sound it a little, and all are from Africa, Colombia, and the Caribbean. Like a DJ set designed to blast rather than lure you out of your seat, they start strong, end classic, and let you sit down in the middle. Whether they achieve their pan-tropical goals is unclear; I probably prefer the African tracks‑-especially the Zaiko Langa Langa spinoff "Je Ne Bois Pas Beaucoup"‑-because I always prefer the African tracks. So let me now praise two barn burners I would never otherwise have checked out: a lead cut featuring cumbia stalwart Lisandro Meza and‑-from Guadeloupe, whose music generally leaves me feeling like I haven't eaten‑-a speedy call-and-response workout by gwo ka drummer Ti Céleste. DJ-annotator Hugo reports that this is his crate-digging crew's most-played track. You can hear why. A MINUS

 

105Comments
Nov 8, 2011 6:53PM
avatar
Interesting - maybe we'll add that ingredient one of these days.  I can also mention that when I told my girlfriend I needed to buy an album called Sofrito, she knew immediately it would be a various artists comp and she was as excited as I was to find out the lead track is by Lisandro Meza, one of her favorite cumbia artists.   (I think there was an "r" left off of Lisandro's name above).
Nov 8, 2011 6:55PM
avatar
Not that this space should turn into a recipe swap, but sofrito is also a braised meat dish from the Ionian Islands of Greece, identified specifically with Corfu. Rump beef or veal, lots of olive oil, white wine, parsley. Heavenly.

I believe "sofrito" is sort of a catch-all term for a method of cooking similar to mirepoix (refogado in Portugese, soffrito in Italian, etc), with various cultures using the word for their own purposes. I also believe all sofritos are created equally.
Nov 8, 2011 6:57PM
avatar
Sofrito -- history and recipes --

burraburrahttp://latinfood.about.com/od/seasoningmarinade/p/What-Is-Sofrito.htmspice of life

Nov 8, 2011 7:39PM
avatar
Who is this phantom thumb bomber, man?
Nov 8, 2011 7:49PM
avatar
Like the Checkered Demon, I enjoy chewin' up thumbs, so the more the merrier -- up or down taste the same.

(See "Thumb and Tongue Tales" in Zap comix.)

Nov 8, 2011 7:59PM
avatar

Jason -- I just thumb bombed your last comment, because I feel you are instigating a fiery McCarthy-esque witch hunt for thumb bombers, who are only trying to express their highly worthwhile opinion in secret, because they're passive-agressive to the point where they don't want anyone to get mad at them.  Have you no sympathy for these people??

 

Other than that, I have no idea who the thumb bomber is. 

 

EDIT, 9:16:  I just thumb bombed my own comment to add to the two already there, just to make things more "dramatic," to appear in this thread's "most controversial."

Nov 8, 2011 8:36PM
avatar
National Heavy Metal Day Countdown:

4. Dio: Holy Diver

 

I instinctively disliked this record for most of its existence. But I enjoyed it when the That Metal Show guys put it number one on their best-of heavy metal this-or-that lists. Not because I was being kitschy, I just got a kick out of these ingratiating metalheads having opinions so obviously divergent from my own. I say I disliked this album instinctively because I barely ever heard it, certainly not all the way through. I turned the sound off when the Dio videos popped up on MTV. Nothing could be worse than a histrionic European (well he sang in Rainbow and Sabbath but I didn’t know he was actually from New Hampshire) singing songs of Satan over clunky sub-Paranoid guitar churn. So then RJD up and died through no fault of his own, and come to find out the guy was a saint. A champion. A passionate metal crusader. So I bought a copy of Holy Diver on Amazon for next to nothing to have what was definitely intended to be a kitsch-fest. And boy did I feel embarrassed and stupid when I fell in love with the CD first time through. It opens with Motorhead-worthy riffage, the sound is stripped down for circa 1983 metal, sparing on the guitar overdubs, and let’s give some serious props to the drummer, Vinnie Appice, who is just totally wicked here. But the songs are what really sell this album. Without ever deviating from post-NWOBHM orthodoxy, RJD (who produces here as well as singing and writing) carefully structures his songs around awesome chord changes (the riff that drives “Gypsy” is power pop-ready), sing-along chants (“Holy Diver”), and—wait for it—hooks galore (“Caught In the Middle”, “Rainbow in the Dark”). If you require some suspension of disbelief to get through the vocals and lyrics here, then so be it; underneath that is a glorious testament to a heavy metal hero. 

Nov 8, 2011 8:44PM
avatar
I feel old in two ways.  Heavy D died at 44.  I'm 44.  And on the baseball message board I go to, most of the posters were saying 'Who's Heavy D?'

Cam: Holy Diver.  Wow.  I think I just had some post-traumatic stress disorder flashbacks to junior high school having that (formerly) treasured album brought up.  Heh.

Nov 8, 2011 9:32PM
avatar
Just curious, are the people who hate Dio the same as the people who hate Hawkwind, or are there two separate pools of hate out there?
Nov 8, 2011 9:38PM
avatar
are the people who hate Dio the same as the people who hate Hawkwind, or are there two separate pools of hate out there?
It's the Dio/ Hawkwind/ Beefheart / Sofrito Vortex of Hate.
Nov 8, 2011 10:05PM
avatar

Not a Dio fan by any stretch of the imagination, that said I would never thumb bomb the man who gave the community a copy of Live at P.S. 122 broken down track by track. Can't wait for the top 3.

Current listening- Those Darlins-Screws Get Loose & Superchunk- Majesty Shredding

Nov 8, 2011 10:33PM
avatar
Lisandro Meza typo fixed. Really a typo this time, at least. I know the guy's name.


Nov 8, 2011 11:23PM
avatar
 I just thumb bombed my own comment to add to the two already there, just to make things more "dramatic," to appear in this thread's "most controversial."
Dog, Michael is the Pete Rose of controversy around here.
Nov 9, 2011 1:46AM
avatar
I haven't listened to the album, but I'm fairly convinced this is going to wind up having been the best thing written about Luluhttp://www.grantland.com/story/_/id/7146312/lou-reed-metallica-album

If MSN wanks the link, just head to Grantland and look for the Klosterman piece.
avatar
Re: Jon Huntsman's Beefheart fandom. 
Al Gore claimed to like Frank Zappa, circa the PMRC hearings, though he was less specific about it. Zappa wondered publicly whether Gore was just bluffing.
avatar
Re: Strawberry.
I think it sounds great, but can anyone identify a lyric that doesn't have at least 20 betters on the first three Wussy albums? This is a challenge, but also an honest question. Maybe I've missed something.
Nov 9, 2011 7:53AM
avatar
Much like creole cuisine, the Puerto Rican version of sofrito is a melange of Spanish, African, and Carribean influences. In fact, it's not hyperbolic to call it history on a plate--colonialism, slavery, miscengenation are there in every bite. Only tastier! It's also worth noting that traditional Puerto Rican cuisine is known there as comida criolla. 
Nov 9, 2011 8:09AM
avatar
Nice to read Klosterman mount a cogent defense of the traditional music industry. I do, however, have a convincing explanation of Reed's motives, courtesy of a waggish fellow writer: "Anyone -- absolutely anyone -- who tells Lou Reed he's a genius and they'd like to work with him, he's all ears."
Nov 9, 2011 10:49AM
avatar
Nice Klosterman piece. Should have mentioned Berlin, though. grantland lulu got me there.
Nov 9, 2011 10:51AM
avatar
I don't know if anyone here was planning to shoot some 1990 points to Steve Coleman's Rhythm People (kinda love it myself: hell of a band and mad complicated beats) but I thought I'd let everyone know that Coleman is offering it, and another twenty or so albums, for free download on his website, www.m-base.com/download.html. He also offers a well-thought-out and articulate defense of the music-wants-to-be-free argument. That address again:

http://goo.gl/nPdmV

Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap