Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Odds and Ends 007

Hip-Hop Doesn't Have to Try to Be Hard--It Damn Well Is Hard

By Xgau Mar 9, 2012 5:31AM

 

Speech Debelle: Freedom of Speech (Big Dada)

Atmospheric rapper conveys advanced thought and warm feelings with pliant voice, enveloping beats, and lyrics that have their sharper moments ("Studio Backpack Rap," "Collapse," "Shawshank") ***

 

Danny Brown: XXX (Fool's Gold)

"No apologies/For the misogyny," although students of the class system and serious cunnilingus fans might forgive him anyway ("Scrap or Die," "I Will") ***

 

Common: The Dreamer/The Believer (Think Common/Warner Bros.)

Still on a major label, he's damn well gonna act it ("Raw [How You Like It]," "The Believer") ***

 

Atmosphere: The Family Sign (Rhymesayers)

More memorable than many more interesting rappers as he singsongs medium-tempo of his mature values, his life as an entertainer, and his lost dog ("Became," "She's Enough") ***


K'Naan: More Beautiful Than Silence (A&M/Octone)

Too much to prove, and neither Nelly Furtado nor Nas can help ("Nothing to Lose," "Coming to America") **

 

Dark Time Sunshine: Vessel (Fake Four Inc.)

Seattle MC Onry Osborne ne Michael Martinez d/b/a Cape Cowen meets Chicago beatmaker Zamara for grown-up illbient that makes the most of the world's and its own incomprehensibility ("Vessel," "All Aboard") **


Tinie Tempah: Disc-Overy (Capitol)

Finally grime-ragga-whatevs produces one of the mildly likable commercial rappers we thought we had such a monopoly on ("Till I'm Gone," "Simply Unstoppable") *

 

Buck 65: 20 Odd Years Volume 4: Ostranenie (Warner Music Canada)

Maybe it's me‑-well, almost definitely it's me‑-but I like him better on baseball than on romance and on album than on EP ("Joey Bats," "Legendary") *


 

166Comments
Mar 12, 2012 8:44AM
avatar
Funny about the comments on Rolling Stone articles. Such interesting names:

[Deleted]

Floyd Smoot

Ipso Phakto

Jurassic Pork

And as a matter of fact, the half-dozen comments sections I looked at were a lot better than most. There was a lot of banality and stupidity -- but not many comments that made you wanna rip somebody's lips off. (That is, they weren't like the Henley-Frank Ocean discussion.)



avatar
Absolutely insisting on verifiable real names would solve everything.

You'd think it would help. And then you look at reader comments on Rolling Stone's website.

Mar 12, 2012 7:56AM
avatar
Just to add a tad of info regarding Little Miami. I have some local tribal knowledge of that vicinity having misspent my youth thereabouts. The Little Miami is a national scenic river that I spent a good amount of my youth enjoying. We were either drinking, canoeing, or hanging at my friends cabin along its bank, and had some mighty fun nights having bottle rocket wars there at that cabin. Anyway, the river winds it's way south through a small valley and is now a nice park with biking/jogging paths all the way to Cincinnati. At one point I-71 passes over the river valley and the bridge is quite tall. I"d reckon it's about 300 feet high? My friend's cabin is very close to where this video was shot (http://goo.gl/rTmF4). Is it the tallest bridge in the state of Ohio, heck if I know (giggle the jeremiah morrow bridge). From a five year old's perspective it seemed like the bridge over the River Hades.  Always had a fear/thrill of crossing that bridge on long car trips up to Canton, Ohio, and I irrationally feared we might go over the edge.

Anyway, I'm starting to ramble on so here's the lyrics.

Little Miami
(Walker,Wussy)
It doesn't matter what you call it at all, the darkest day of our summer trip..
but you don't have to turn the lights on..
the ghosts are stationed in the hall..
it doesn't matter which direction you fall..
the sky breaks in two,
 it's the end of you
did you really think that you could escape it today- over the tallest bridge in the state of ohio?
and as the ruins fall around you, you think of something quick to say..
it doesn't matter when you put it that way..
the sky breaks in two, it's the end of you
 everywhere the rocks are falling
and you are just another piece
with all the birds that make a circle
are you not more than one of these?

Mar 12, 2012 7:37AM
avatar
Require readers to post using their real names? "My own view is that anonymity is at the heart of the Internet."

Well, there's his boneheaded problem right there. How to unlock door? Well, can't use a key, that's for sure. Absolutely insisting on verifiable real names would solve everything. There would be a short string of murders (no great loss) and internet discussion would start to approach at least the quality of Letters to the Editor.

Mar 12, 2012 6:56AM
avatar
Wow, thanks Cam! - Sounds Fantastic
Mar 12, 2012 6:37AM
avatar
Aw, here is the Dorothy Love Coates compilation. This is from the impossible-to-find CD:

http://goo.gl/e9DYk

Also, you guys should check out this article, derived from a chat at SXSW with Nick Denton, who founded Gawker Media about the failure of online commentary. It's like he's describing everything that EW is not: http://goo.gl/67aa1
Mar 12, 2012 5:40AM
avatar
Hey Edgar Sargent - If you could point me in the right direction I would happily donate.
Mar 12, 2012 3:10AM
avatar

This, from Andrew Gaerig's Pitchfork review of the new collection Shangaan Shake, a remix album of 2010's Shangaan Electro...

 

If these mixes have found their way into more podcasts and sets than actual Shangaan Electro tracks, forgive the DJs: the Shangaan tempos (usually north of 180 bpm) and organ-heavy instrumentation made them imperfect fits for the European and North American venues in which people listen to forward-thinking, adventurous dance music.
How condescending is that?
Mar 12, 2012 1:06AM
avatar
John -- the live schtick on "Hickory Wind" was entirely a studio creation.  I always hated what they did on that song -- makes me think of the C&W sequence in The Blues Brothers.  I guess Gram wanted a version of the song that he might make a little money off of.
Mar 12, 2012 12:11AM
avatar
Re: "Little Miami" penetration -- I've loved it from play one for its shimmering, simmering beauty, even if you could argue the band never quite brings that beauty to a boil, but I've also always been really moved by what I figured was its clear subject: the end of the world. For me, Lisa's plainspoken lines amount to the most affecting literal apocalypse lyric I can imagine. And yet with plane crashes on the mind (cf. Cassie), I decided to type a few terms into the search engine machine, and found this little item on the people's encyclopedia's "list of American Airlines accidents and incidents":
August 9, 1931: A Ford 5-AT-C Trimotor, registration NC9662, crashed on the bank of the Little Miami River near Cincinatti, Ohio, killing all 6 on board. The cause was failure and separation of the right side engine due to a broken hub. 
Make of that what you will, if there's anything to make.

"It doesn't matter which direction/you fall..."

Mar 11, 2012 11:58PM
avatar
What a gorgeous song.
I know right? Just when you thought Strawberry couldn't get better, another song reaches out and grabs you.
Mar 11, 2012 11:54PM
avatar
Duh. The Little Miami is a river in southwestern Ohio. Thank you Mr. Google. Still haven't penetrated the song, though. It's their longest, BTW.


Mar 11, 2012 11:34PM
avatar
@Marcus

I have a copy of the Coates CD.  I'd rip you a copy if you agree to send $5 to her foundation or something. 

@Ryan and ShadyShack

Thanks for the Magnolia explanation.  It definitely enriches the song for me.  And what's with two songs in two days that turn out to be semi-disgused riffs on famous rock musicians (Brenda)?
Mar 11, 2012 11:31PM
avatar
I'd assumed that with all this "last show" "waiting in the wings" stuff Magnolia was simply an obscurely metaphorical reference to one of Chuck and Lisa's many separations, and any casual listener is left free to hear it that way. As a song about Cassie Gaines, however, it tracks perfectly, though without having done any research I'm not sure what those feathers refer to. Carola and I just read along three times. Had never really registered that faint "engine failure" behind the main vocal. What a gorgeous song.
So now, what the hell does "little Miami" refer to, just as a phrase?
I will tell you that a pay lake is a kind of artificially stocked fishing pond common in Ohio, Kentucky, and Indiana. And a Wrist Rocket is an early, rather successful slingshot brand.


Mar 11, 2012 10:15PM
avatar
Kenny/John S.: You do realize you'll be seeing Geo. Clinton on St. Patrick's Day don't you? That should be one heck of a multi-cultural ruckus that night!
Mar 11, 2012 9:39PM
avatar
 I had absolutely no idea "Magnolia" was about Cassie Gaines -- was I the only one?

This was news to me also, now I like it even more. Would of fit right in on DBT's Southern Rock Opera. If Lisa Walker took Shonna Tucker's place in the Truckers how ridiculously good would they be?

It's not quite a "judas" moment but what came to mind to me is the woman yelling "You're Ugly" during "Hickory Wind" on Grievous Angel. I always assumed she was directing that at Gram, but now I wonder whether the jealous girl was yelling at Emmylou?

Mar 11, 2012 9:17PM
avatar
Ryan , I had no inkling about Magnolia either it was  AN ALtogether surprise to me too. Any way you cAN ALl peruse these lyrics at your leisure (pronounced leh'- zhur think Gang of Four- Not Great Men)

Magnolia
(Walker, Wussy)
this our last embrace
feathers soft against your face
you were ill-positioned in the wings
and I can't help but watch you
in the shallow breaths between
against the backdrops of the fires flickering
cassie, it's just not our night..one look at the landing site
should tell you everything you need to know
skim the treetops till you fall and shatter like a mirror ball..
it's a broken down occasion our last show
i'll miss you on the sweeter notes, smiling as you zip your coat, singing in the
quiet spots between...this is our last long embrace, feathers soft against your face, you were ill-positioned in the wings..engine engine failure..engine engine failure thursday night



Mar 11, 2012 8:54PM
avatar

From Guralnick's Sweet Soul Music:

 

"Legend has frequently suggested that Redding was strictly along for the ride, that he generally served as Johnny Jenkin's driver and valet - but in fact it was as much his group as it was Jenkin's, and he had already had a couple of other records out himself both on another local label (Bobby Smith's unfortunately named Confederate) and as Otis and the Shooters on a California label called Finer Arts."

Mar 11, 2012 8:45PM
avatar
Anyone know where I can find a copy of The Best of Dorothy Love Coates & The Gospel Harmonettes (1996-Nashboro) for less than 44 bucks?
 
I believe Otis was in Johnny Jenkins band and not vice versa.
Maybe at one point in time, but to Johnny Jenkin's eternal dismay, that's not the case anymore.
Mar 11, 2012 8:44PM
avatar
Awright, having compared Sorey and Werner through a couple close listens, I gotta go with my bud Bob Blumenthal on this -- in a live performance, Kenny Werner's five-piece is in a f-ing trance (particularly the leader) and cannot play a wrong note.
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap