Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Charlie Parker/James Carter Organ Trio

Virtuosi Get Down

By Xgau Oct 14, 2011 1:01AM

Charlie Parker: In a Soulful Mood (Music Club '96)

Compiled by UK music journo Roy Carr, this budget take on Parker's Dial sessions is findable cheap used and has become a favorite of mine by the odd strategy of skipping his twistiest heads. Although the two-disc Legendary Dial Masters is now collector-priced, longer Dial collections designated 1 and 2 are buyable as separate items, and the first consists almost entirely of originals that include the omitted "Dexterity," "Bongo Bop," and "Dewey Square" although not "Scrapple From the Apple." Worth owning. But in keeping with a generic title the label employed for many lesser jazz comps, what happens here is different. Midway through, originals give way to standards that begin with an "All the Things You Are" that's as inspired as Parker ever got and damn right soulful. If he'd had the strength of mind, he could have broken pop as the king of the intelligent makeout instrumental without getting near a violin. A

 

James Carter Organ Trio: At the Crossroads (EmArcy)

This occasional unit's live 2005 Out of Nowhere was a honking session, beefing up the young world-champeen multisaxer with Hamiet Bluiett's bari master class and Blood Ulmer's harmolodic Son House shtick. The most luscious beef on this more contained studio job is provided by guest singer Miche Braden sinking her chops into Fluffy Hunter's playfully filthy "Walking Blues" and a lounge through Muddy Waters's "Ramblin' Blues." The lounge feel is shored up by sometime guitarist Bruce Edwards, who if he ain't Ulmer at least ain't Jim Hall. Gotta admit it's a relief, though, when sometime guitarist Brandon Ross disrupts the long Julius Hemphill-penned closer. Even the organist, who does his job manfully throughout and whose name is Gerard Gibbs, avants around on that one. B PLUS

 

146Comments
Oct 14, 2011 1:26AM
avatar

Bird Lives!  

Xgau - i'm searching for this one used in the usual places and the listings are confusing.  Can you advise:

1. Single disc or a 2-CD set?

2. 18 tracks or 26 tracks?

3. UK-only or a US edition?  I believe Music Club is UK.

4. What year - 1996 ?  Are you not including the release years anymore? That was helpful in the past.

Thanks! 

Oct 14, 2011 1:26AM
avatar
Just ordered the Parker for cheap on Amazon. There are a few left.
Oct 14, 2011 1:32AM
avatar

Did I miss two great top 10 jazz albums contenders on Tom's 60's  list?

 

Erroll Garner: Concert by the sea

Kenny Clarke/Francy Bolland Big Band: Volcano

Oct 14, 2011 1:40AM
avatar
Joe: though on Amazon the two-disc set has the same cover as the one-disc set, and they're both apparently from Music Club, only the one-disc version is a "budget take on Parker's Dial sessions." The two-disc includes Savoy and Verve recordings. My guess is single disc, 1996.

Me, I'm curious where on earth these "All the Things You Are" and "Hot Blues" recordings come from. I don't see them on any complete Dial recordings box sets. Are these live recordings Bob (or anyone else)?
Oct 14, 2011 1:43AM
avatar
Erroll Garner: Concert by the sea
Sorry, I think this one's 1955.

Oct 14, 2011 1:53AM
avatar
If it's the 18- track Music Club 1996 US edition, then I count only two (2) tracks on this one that aren't on the 33-track 2-CD Legendary Dial Masters comp on Jazz Classics labe that Xgau gave A+ to back in 1996, with those 2 tracks being Hot Blues and All the Things You Are.  I guess it's the fact that this one focuses on standards for the second half of the disc that appeals to Bob, but if you have the Jazz Classics double, you can program out the originals for a similar experience.
Oct 14, 2011 3:25AM
avatar
What I find despairing is that any major compilation of Charlie Parker's (especially one such as the Dial Sessions) would disappear/go out-of-stock. The man is as vital an artist if there ever were one and you'd think there'd be some consistency. I understand how Jazz takes only 2% of the musical market (well, it did back in the 90's, not sure how small the percentage is now) and then there's the small suffering labels that can't compete with the larger suffering labels, but I still find it frustrating. 
Oct 14, 2011 8:03AM
avatar
I ordered the single-disc version of the Charlie Parker, but I almost wish I'd gone with the double. I could have burned the single disc down from the double as Joe suggests. Oh well. Meanwhile I've compiled a MOG playlist (http://goo.gl/RcZK0) based on the single-disc. There was a "Hot Blues" on Erroll Garner on Dial that should feature CP (it was listed with CP's songs on MOG). Everything else is from The Complete Savoy and Dial Master Takes, except "All the Things You Are" from Dizz's Jazz At Massey Hall. A little more checking is in order to see if this is the correct version. MOG running time is 7:52. Total runtime for the playlist is 1:00:45 -- probably about the amount of time you might want to spend in a listening, which is I'm sure what makes Music Clubs in general more attractive to Xgau than multi-disc compendiums.
EDIT: I've found another Charlie Parker Dial Masters disc on MOG (Spotlife) [http://goo.gl/rWjau] with the parts 1 & 2 (referred to as worth owning by Xgau above), which has "Hot Blues" but not "All the Things You Are". Guess I will substitute from this one [reduces playlist time to 1:00:00].
By the way, if you want to give MOG a spin, http://goo.gl/ynt8B would net you the free trial as well as me a free month (otherwise $5).


[I'm neither functioning nor an adult, I fear -- as you can see by my avatar; but I do follow the blog as worst I can.]
Oct 14, 2011 8:11AM
avatar
The date is now inserted--my apologies. It's one disc. The rest the functioning adults who follow this blog can only figure out for themselves. Each of them has different resources and priorities.


Oct 14, 2011 8:42AM
avatar
EW jazz poll eligibility question: Ella Fitzgerald's Twelve Nights in Hollywood. Not a reissue since the cuts were not released until recently - yet they are taken from the same live dates as the ones released in 1961 as Ella in Hollywood. Guess I'm hoping beyond hope that I can give it some points.
Oct 14, 2011 8:42AM
avatar

Nice to see Bird getting some love, but I think I don't need this one. I already own the 2cd Legendary Dial Masters and the Rhino Yardbird Suite comp. There are 3 used copies of the Dial Masters for just under 20 bucks. I can't imagine many here slept on that A+ rating back in '96 though.

As for the Carter, I already have 6 of his other cd's that I don't play as often as I should. That B+ isn't enough to make me pull the trigger.

Oct 14, 2011 8:54AM
avatar
Additional consumer news: Out of Nowhere is recorded 2004/released 2005. And worth tracking down. Talk about disappearing fast.
Oct 14, 2011 9:10AM
avatar
isn't enough to make me pull the trigger.

I'm one foot in the door, one foot out.  Jazz vocals are not a favorite as a general rule, but Bob makes an interesting case.  And "Hard Blues" may make it happen for me all by itself.  Love that kind of stuff.

 

An all Duke Ellington day is lined up for me now while I think about it.

Oct 14, 2011 9:11AM
avatar
What I want is the Savoy sides on a convenient, well-packaged CD.  I have the old Charlie Parker Savoy Master Takes double LP from the '70s, but I've never found a CD to substitute for it.  The 3-disc 2002 Complete Savoy & Dial Master Takes from Savoy Jazz looks nice, but I don't want to buy the Dials all over again, knowing that the Savoy's are about a disc worth of that music. 
Oct 14, 2011 9:17AM
avatar
Cam: I think your typically courteous hint is correct. Since it's my general practice to cite release dates rather than recording dates unless they're way out of wack, I've made Out of Time 2005 instead of 2004.
Oct 14, 2011 9:18AM
avatar
Ella Fitzgerald's Twelve Nights in Hollywood.
Dan: anything recorded in the 1960s is eligible for the jazz poll. Doesn't matter when it was released, just when it was recorded. Go for it!

Oct 14, 2011 9:21AM
avatar
What I want is the Savoy sides on a convenient, well-packaged CD. 
Hey Joe, I think the other Joe (Y.) found one of these a month or more ago. Maybe he'll chime in? I have the 3 disc thing. It's nice.

Oct 14, 2011 9:38AM
avatar
Jazz nerds: here is the Charlie Parker discography online: http://goo.gl/aetDy According to this, "Hot Blues" is an alternate title for an alternate take of "Cool Blues" (with Erroll Garner on piano). Okay, check that one off the list :)

Concerning "All the Things You Are," it's likely a live recording (or possibly home recording), but I really don't know--neither is listed on the discography between the sessions for "Stupendous" and "Bird of Paradise." If someone could post that information when they receive their CD, that would be super helpful. Unfortunately for us, I'm certain it's not the Gillespie recording also on Yardbird Suite since this Music Club compilation is chronological and "All the Things You Are" was recorded before "Moose the Mooche." Also, it wasn't recorded for Dial. The mystery lives on!

Oct 14, 2011 9:48AM
avatar
Okay, here we go people: answers. According to Brian Priestley's discography in the back of his bio Chasin' the Bird, "All the Things You Are" is an alternate title for one of the "Bird of Paradise" alternate takes. This implies that "BoP" is a contrafact of "AtTYA"; I'll have to listen to find out.

This means that Parker likely wrote a new melody over the chords of "AtTYA" and titled it "Bird of Paradise," which was common practice among bebop musicians (and musicians in general, actually, but bebop musicians get a term for it ;) Perhaps he (and his band?) wrote the new head in the studio while playing "AtTYA" (EDIT: In fact, the "All the Things You Are" take is take A, and the "Paradise" master take is take C.) I'd have to research more to find out, which unfortunately I probably won't do. I'll pass this task on to the next functioning adult with resources ;)

For one of my favorite demonstrations of a contrafact, check out Ella Fitzgerald scatting the head for "Ornithology" during the break of her "How High the Moon"--she does this on every recording I've heard, including the one on Ken Burns Jazz. "Ornithology" is written over the chords for "How High the Moon," and is therefore a contrafact.

Case closed. Next!

Oct 14, 2011 9:56AM
avatar

Bradley:  I almost nearly just about followed that.  H-h-h.

 

So just to be clear, are you saying that the 7:52 length "All The Things You Are" on the live Jazz At Massey Hall with Parker credited as Charlie Chan, is not the version referred to in the review?

Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap