Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Tommy Womack

No, Not That Womack & Womack

By Xgau Mar 23, 2012 2:02AM

Tommy Womack: There, I Said It! (Cedar Creek '07)

Rising from the icky depths of the lyrically, vocally, and harmonically abject "A Songwriter's Prayer," a 40-year-old Nashville lifer finds solace in a forgotten WTF he wrote at 28 and by age 44 comes up with a bunch of new ones about bad jobs, fluorescent lighting, and low-grade cigarette, beer, and Xanax dependency. The climax would be the proud admission "I'm Never Gonna Be a Rock Star" except that the climax is the seven-minute must-hear "Alpha Male & the Canine Mystery Blood," a world-historically unromantic rocker about rock after 40. Also crucial is "Nice Day," about his boy and his wife and a friend's swimming pool. It won a prize. A MINUS

 

Tommy Womack: Now What! (Cedar Creek)

Reflective without wallowing in might-have-beens, his nasal drawl weary and at ease with itself, he's an established failure who's calmed down considerably for a pimple on Dylan's ass who believes the best thing about ADD is that it never bothers you too long. "90 Miles an Hour on a Dead End Street" is no advertisement for chianti just as "Pot Head Blues" is no advertisement for cannabis. In one strong song, he feels the heat of an old flame on a checkout line and is so glad the burns have healed. In several other strong songs, he pitches woo wifeward. A MINUS

 

120Comments
Mar 23, 2012 8:41AM
avatar

Another problem with ADD - the thumb-downers who

act before they think.

Mar 26, 2012 9:26AM
avatar

Outside of convenience, price, space saving and a few other things why would anyone listen to a format

other than vinyl?

PS MegaMillions jackpot is up to $356 million. Drawing tomorrow night. Worth a buck or two. No?

Mar 23, 2012 9:05AM
avatar

Danm it-I lost the bet. I thought someone would

thumb-down me sooner. Sht.

Mar 25, 2012 1:35PM
avatar

Because it is, at least if you're not acclimated to it.

 

And these audio snobs used to say it like it was some mystical, undefinable thing

 

 

Mar 26, 2012 11:52PM
avatar
Milo hand me your zip code and I'll point you to the nearest VD clinic.
Mar 23, 2012 11:49AM
avatar

Tickets to Jack White's May 19th show in Asheville just sold out in less than five minutes. To which I say...

Mar 25, 2012 11:13AM
avatar

For what it's worth, I would say "none" for vinyl.  Probably a ton of personal reasons why but my preference for music is totally digital, and when I buy a CD it's so I can rip it in high quality.  I have one small rack for CDs and right now it's holding 8 jewel cases.  After I rip them, they just take up space and I've even thrown some away.  Many have been lost. 

 

I think in the beginning, the whole vinyl thing was a response to terrible mp3 quality.  At that point (up to about 2006), vinyl often did sound better.  Also, you're more likely to play a turntable through better speakers than crap powered computer speakers.  But when affordable disk space allowed for great mp3 quality, a lot of peoples music collections became digital.  Vinyl usually sounds pretty bad to me now.  Dust on the thing, old and beat up needle, and this "warmth" that people talk about is really constant, low-level distortion.  I have a small vinyl colletion that is on the top shelf of a closet, and my turntable is down in the basement with other stuff.  

 

A few friends have turntables and it's like a conversation piece, it's more fun to take out the big sleeve and make a big to-do about putting it on.

Mar 26, 2012 3:35PM
avatar
The copyright cops are coming:  http://goo.gl/KfIZI

One wonders how this will affect stuff like free mixtapes (yeah, probably legal, but try explaining that to your ISP), sharing of out-of-print vinyl rips, etc.  If the article's to be believed (fwiw there are dozens of similar articles out there from more-or-less reputable sources) this deal was "coordinated by the Obama Administration."

Mar 26, 2012 5:43PM
avatar
You know it sure does echo "We Can't Make It Here Anymore", doesn't it? Way more fun, though.
Mar 25, 2012 7:54PM
avatar

Hello, to add to Dan's question on what records I still turn to in spite of the digital options. The classics that were analog to begin with...I have the Beatles on CD, digital, mono, stereo, you name it and yet I still yank the records off the shelf when I want to hear them clicks, pops and all. Abbey Road needs to be heard on vinyl. No CD captures the bottom end of that record like the vinyl does..IHO. Ditto for Born To Run. My copy of that album is well worn and yet I rarely pull the CD off the shelf. I don't even own any Zeppelin on CD or digital. CCR, Hendrix, Floyd, Marley. Jazz goes vinyl for sure if I have the option. But records can be a pain in the a$$. They attract dust like crazy. Static. They are easily damaged. You need a fairly good rig to get the most out of the medium. It's certainly not plug and play nor portable and modern recordings are less night and day. The whole "vinyl sounds better" is partly a consumer hook. My ipod sounds pretty damn great running through my amp and so do CDs. That said, on Record Store Day I have my eye on the releases of Hell On Heels and especially Funeral Dress on the black circles

Mar 23, 2012 10:30AM
avatar
 Anyone here interested in Wussy?  A week ago, I sent them an email via their website suggesting that on their next tour of the SW- I live in Phoenix- they aim to also hit Tucson.  Today Lisa answered and gave me a thanks for being a fan and said they'd keep Tucson on the radar for future tours.

 FWIW, The normal route for a touring group playing their size venues is California to Tucson, followed by New Mexico and/or Texas.
Mar 23, 2012 2:24AM
avatar
the best thing about ADD is that it never bothers you too long
Right on right on.
Mar 25, 2012 10:40PM
avatar
Second on the terrific Darnielle post, though if you've been paying attention you've noted that Duke doesn't strike out. As it happens, I marathoned through the '02 trilogy portion of John D's epic canon just yesterday -- All Hail West Texas (which kicks off with "The Best Ever Death Metal Band Out of Denton", a pitch-perfect populist anthem you already adore even if you haven't heard it yet), obvious titan Tallahassee, and the Extra Glenns' Martial Arts Weekend, a hidden treasure which exhibits a few surprise dimensions worth investigating for anybody more casually enamored by the master in question (see #s 7 & 12). And re: Eternals, I still go for "Damn These Vampires". Like a madman. 
Mar 24, 2012 7:59PM
avatar

A few random thoughts:

 

1. Loved Jim’s comments about Glen Campbell. Dementia is hell, and Campbell’s tour is indeed brave. I only ever got into his solo stuff as a hokey thing when Kris and I lived in Galveston for a few years, but for a brief period of time the Jimmy Webb material really clicked for Campbell. That’s the Jimmy Webb peak, probably, and Glen Campbell ain’t no Dionne Warwick, sorry Jimmy. Campbell’s guitar work gets short shrift though—very much in the Bakersfield style and pre-dating (and certainly influencing) surf. I can do without “Rhinestone Cowboy”, but go ahead, give it up for Glen Campbell one time y’all.


2. I just watched a guy playing trumpet in the middle of the intersection between State and Washington in downtown Chicago until the cops ran him off. Awesome. There is blues in my future tonight.


3. Gmort’s edit of The Promise sounds really special to me in the afterglow of the Springsteen show. Thanks Greg.


4. My eyes are bugging out at the posts today: Paul, Ryan, Bradleun, JeffJohnChris, all of you. Standing O.

Mar 25, 2012 12:38PM
avatar
I think in the beginning, the whole vinyl thing was a response to terrible mp3 quality

Let me assure you that that wasn't the case when I started buying vinyl in 1984. Later on, I kept doing vinyl because charging $5-10 extra for a CD was f**king  robbery that I still don't understand why anyone tolerated (of course nowadays prices are the other way around and I pretty much ignore vinyl).

this "warmth" that people talk about is really constant, low-level distortion.

You say that like it's a bad thing.


avatar
Speaking of vinyl to digital conversions - here's a question for Witnesses: which pieces of vinyl keep drawing you back despite having the digital version? And for what reason? Sound quality? Emotion? 
Plenty. And it doesn't have as much to do with sound quality these days as to do with the act of playing records and listening to music, as well as the wish to have and maintain a physical, tangible library. And then there's cover art, liner notes, lyric sheets.

Putting on physical record is also likely to color your listening process in certain ways, since you have to do more than search and press play. Even more so playing vinyl; dust jacket, cover, placing it on the turn table, dropping the needle, getting up to change sides (unless you have a fancy Bang & Olufsen player). I like listening to music that way, especially when I want to listen to a record I know and love.

That said, I have no problem maintaing focus listening digital files - reviewing records being part of how I make my income, these days digital is quite often all that's made available to you. It'd be unprofessional of me to allow my concentration to wane, not to mention detrimental to my listening pleasures (and sometimes dis-pleasures).

BTW, I believe there was an episode of Stanford's Entitled Opinions podcast that discussed vinyl and the listening process, but alas I can't find it at the moment.
Mar 24, 2012 7:40PM
avatar
Veteran rocker Jerry Lee Lewis engaged
If Cooley doesn't write a song called "Cousin Rusty's Ex-Wife" based on this, I'll be hella pissed.
Mar 24, 2012 11:21AM
avatar
With my Dad two years into Alzheimer's after a few more than that with gradual dementia, I appreciate your Glenn Campbell post, Jim. Even from a distance, I can sense the empathy from you, his family members and his audiences. Never was much of a fan of his pop songs, but that doesn't mean I can't admire his courage and purpose.
Mar 23, 2012 10:59AM
avatar

As partial and wholly inadequate payback to Cam for all the goodies he's posted here, which I have been very happy to download, I offered to send him something in return from my meager collection. Amazingly, there was apparently one item he didn't have: "It Will Stand" Minit Records: 1960-1963, Xgau's top reissue of 1986 and resident of the "Gone But Not Forgotten" section of the 90s CG collection.

 

Allen Toussaint is all over the record as producer and songwriter, with 9 of the 14 tracks credited by Toussaint to his father or mother (Naomi Neville; no relation to those other Nevilles, as far as I can tell), and all but 2 of the others Toussaint originals or cowrites. It includes a couple of Aaron Neville's first recordings and the originals of "Lipstick Traces" and "Fortune Teller." It has never been reissued on CD. Enjoy: http://goo dot gl/4P4gw

Mar 24, 2012 9:06AM
avatar

Glen Campbell performed at our venue last night. Best description I could come up with is bittersweet. Great to see him out there still doing his thing but heartbreaking to watch him struggle. His guitar playing didn't seem to suffer but there were a few moments when he got lost with the lyrics despite the teleprompters. A glance at his band members then a gesture or helping hand from them got him back on track quickly. His daughter and two sons are in the band and they very obviously look out for him. He joked and rambled a bit between songs but seemed very appreciative of the audience's support. Sad, but at the same time, a stirring tribute to the human spirit.

 

Cam occasionally speaks here of the importance of his work in researching and treating heart disease and we've all been impacted in one way or another by cancer. It's vitally important that we continue to fight these horrible illnesses, but let's not forget the toll Alzheimer's and dementia takes not only on those afflicted but also their caregivers. What a cruel, cruel fate for anyone to be stricken with. An old friend just lost his mother last week after a 10-year bout with  Alzheimer's. Fortunately, his dad was able to take care of her the whole time but the last 5-6 years were not pretty. Even though her personality did not turn "nasty" as sometimes happens, I admire the old man so much because I can't imagine how difficult it must have been for him.

 

Sorry for the sobering digression.....

 

We had Wilson Phillips the night before. God, they're awful. My co-workers commented how friendly the ladies were, but I found their stage presence/patter amateurish. The less said about their music, (mostly rehashing their parents greatest hits), the better.

 

On a more positive note, I enjoyed a few Tommy Womack cuts yesterday and look forward to hearing the rest of the two album picks soon.

 

Two "Young Frankenstein" performances today, so I need to sign off and get ready to do my thing. Should be a fun show but will be a long afternoon and night.

 

Have a good weekend all and "Go Gators!"

 

Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap