Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Wild Flag/Mates of State

Indie Alternatives

By Xgau Sep 13, 2011 5:33AM

 Wild Flag: Wild Flag (Merge)

Such is the sad state of indie that two Sleater-Kinney stalwarts can reconnect six years later and just like that power up the most explosive rock album in years. Sure ex-Minder Rebecca Cole's organ adds thickness and punch; sure ex-Helium Mary Timony adds dream and, crucially, ax. But the shaker is obviously Carrie Brownstein, yelping like Richard Hell as Timony shreds like Ivan Julian, and the mover is Janet Weiss, who for some reason never sounds like the greatest drummer in the world with anyone else. Bouncing off each other like loaded dice, they could make you cry once you're away long enough to think about it. But then you realize that Timony is still a space case and Brownstein writes too many songs about music. One that isn't is "Racehorse," keyed to the wickedly non-indie line "We're in the money." Here's hoping she figures out how to keep it. A MINUS

 

Mates of State: Mountaintops (Barsuk)

Kory Gardner and Jason Hammel are strong singers with a weakness for melody who play keyboards and drums, such indie lifers that they went and had two kids on the theory they could just tour with them‑-check Gardner's Band on the Diaper Run blog. Never scrawny like punk (they rolled new wave) or twee like synth-pop (organ is Gardner's meat), they developed surprising muscle tone for a duo without breaking on through. But their seventh album opens with a simulated big-pop anthem and maintains that size and momentum without compromising their ability to play the new songs live. The discord that surfaces in the last few lyrics may indicate bumps in their marital road. But it definitely indicates how hard it is to write 10 near-corny pop songs without a hint of unhappy love. And the wholeness of the music leaves us feeling they're more than OK. A MINUS

 

161Comments
Oct 8, 2011 3:01PM
Sep 25, 2011 7:49AM
avatar
Just saw Sebadoh two nights ago in Brisbane, Australia.  Played most of the songs from Bakesale and Harmacy.  Lou and Jason traded gee-tars thru the show.  It was loud.  And very good. 
Sep 19, 2011 3:57PM
avatar
"Brownstein writes too many songs about music" misses the point. Brownstein writes Brownstein songs like the Ramones wrote Ramones songs -- who cares what the subject matter is as long as they're great? But she got one or two songs per S-K album probably because that's what she was good for. How many secondary writers go on to make great albums when they become the primary? (Okay, besides Lou Barlow). If she wrote four or five songs as good as "Entertain" it wouldn't matter if every one was about her SG.
Sep 16, 2011 4:28AM
avatar
Saw YLT open up for S-K at Tramps, NYC - 5/17/97.
avatar
Seen YLT five times, most recently just after their latest album. They played two days in a row at a small Oslo club in '98 (and covered Wire  on one of those nights), and both are among my fave gigs ever. Every time I've seen them they've been good, though. Love that band.
Sep 15, 2011 11:10PM
avatar
EarthboundBob, Marcus, I wholeheartedly recommend going to any Yo La Tengo show that you can.  I've probably seen them about 10 times since '93, and they're always a lot of fun.  As everyone's mentioned, the covers are a good part of the fun, and I remember when I first saw them I had just picked up an obscure compilation of singles from New Zealand's Xpressway label, called Making Losers Happy.  Just days after buying this album, I see YLT and one of the first things they play is James McNew's cover of the lead track, Dead C's "Bad Politics"!  You may also get something by the Kinks, or Badfinger, etc.  In addition to the covers, they usually mix up their catalog and play a decent selection of their new music with an unpredictable mix from earlier records.  And you may have read about their tour from last year when they spun a wheel and did things like play a whole Condo F**** set, or acted out the "Chinese Restaraunt" episode of Seinfeld.  Not all of their gigs are going to get that wild, of course.  
Sep 15, 2011 11:02PM
avatar
Speaking of that Brad, for the 1983 project, I'd like to plug my favorite Paisley Underground record, True West's Hollywood Holiday (which if I understand the discographical details, is the True West EP plus the "Lucifer Sam" single or something along those lines - like Jason and the Scorcher's Fervor, it was reissued with a little more music shortly after its initial release). I have to dig out my cassette to remember titles, but one of those tracks sounds like Television guitar licks ("Venus," specifically) over a Fleetwood Mac bottom ("Dreams," specifically), and the whole record is great guitar rock with a solid rhythm section and exciting guitar playing along those lines.  Meanwhile, I played Emergency Third Rail Power Trip about a year ago, and it really does stink.  (And I really like Younger Than Yesterday, despite "Mind Gardens"!) 

I'd also like to make a probably futile push for Confusion is Sex, which I think is really underrated.  I played it like crazy in 1990, when I first got it, and dug it out this week after not playing it for many, many years, and was surprised by how well it holds up.  It sounds like it was recorded in a dank cave by alien primitives trying to imitate rock and roll. They only know how to make their guitars sound like bells, and write disturbing poetry about fear and mutilation.  Some of the guitar improvs remind me of the coda on "European Son." Unless there's something in the Swans canon that I'm not familiar with, I think there's really nothing like this record's otherworldly quality.  

I'm also not sure if Power, Corruption and Lies will make my list, even though this is an '83 record that I have played way more than most over the years.  Some of the music is quite lovely, but some of Bernard Sumner's lyrics are Sally Can't Dance-level bad.  (If you can find it online, the bootleg of NO's Blackpool concert from 8/30/82 has great versions of much of this material, including a version of 586 with a longer intro.) Considering some of the horribly dated production I've encountered on '83 records, even the roots rock stuff, I have to say that PC&L really sounds ahead of it's time.  

I've also spun You Shouldn't Nuf Bit Fish a few times this week, and after two decades of listening, I still don't take to this one the way I do to either Computer Games or Urban Dancefloor Guerillas.  I'll give it up for the lyrics and jokes on YSNBF, but UDG has better music and stands as my preferred George Clinton record of 1983.  The electro jams on YSNBF seem static and not funky enough to me.  

Before Hollywood is not one of my favored Go-Betweens records, mostly because Robert doesn't write any hooks till late on the second side, and I think "Dusty In Here" slows down side one way too much.  But the spare, Television-style arrangements are my kind of thing, so I play it anyway to hear the sound of the band.  

And now in the interest of due dilligence, I'll spin Night Ranger's Midnight Madness.  
Sep 15, 2011 10:09PM
avatar
I couldn't make it through one listen of the Rain Parade's Emergency Third Rail Power Trip (say what you want about Younger Than Yesterday, but at least all its songs were under 3:30). Condolences to those who had to put up with the Paisley Underground at the time.
Sep 15, 2011 9:35PM
avatar
Happy to report I couldn't make it through one listen of anyone talking to me since Sunday. I love you, Wussy. 
Sep 15, 2011 9:33PM
avatar
really fkucing jealous about that cosmic kurushi buy though
Sep 15, 2011 9:32PM
avatar
sad to report i couldn't make it through one listen of the new rapture album
Sep 15, 2011 8:09PM
avatar
I got the 2-CD Cosmic Kurushi Monsters comp today - ordered it from the UK for less than 10 dollars shipping included hurrah! I'm scared to put it on though. 
My favorite **** Surfers album.
avatar
I got the 2-CD Cosmic Kurushi Monsters comp today - ordered it from the UK for less than 10 dollars shipping included hurrah! I'm scared to put it on though.
Sep 15, 2011 7:45PM
avatar
This new Rapture is good, and I've only had one listen. Thanks for the info on that sample. I heard Joe Levy likes it a lot too. ;)

Mark926: I've seen Wilco twice recently on the Sky Blue Sky and Wilco the album tours. Definitely worth a see, usually you can find a board tape of your show on the internet if you look real hard for it.

The one on stage left is noisy.
Yes, and when I've seen them that was Nels Cline and, boy, can he play.

Sep 15, 2011 7:35PM
avatar
Yo La Tengo live: I've seen them 8 times over the years. Their shows can be anything-- they can clown around too much, do great covers, do covers you've never heard of, do feedback extravaganzas, overindulge Georgia's slow minor chord ballad fetish. In short, almost always charming, usually rocking, occasionally untogether.

Wilco: I saw their last tour at the Durham Performing Arts Center, which has great sound. It wasn't a top 10 show, but very very good. Hint: There are two guitarists on stage besides Tweedy. The one on stage right is pretty. The one on stage left is noisy. My wife had a stage right show and I had a stage left show.
Sep 15, 2011 7:34PM
avatar
Has anyone listened to the new Rapture album? I was taken by the track "Come Back to Me" which samples the Franco track "Likambo ya ngana" (Francophonic vol 1, disc 1 track 17), the solemn one with the accordian, and female back-up singers. The Rapture's lyrics almost fit the mood that Franco captured and which was indirectly about his deceased brother. It's bitchin'.
Sep 15, 2011 7:02PM
avatar
My earlier comments on the Jimmie Dale Gilmore concert were really meant mostly to be a reflection on what struck me as a sad tempering of JDG's talent by this awkward set up.

But now that a few folks here have thrown down (more or less) in support of Hellman,  I'll take the bait. Boots Riley already said it best: "Princesses are evil."  Nobody gets to be that rich without participating in putting a lot of other people into misery. 

And forget about Lehman Brothers twenty years ago.  A major focus of Hellman's philanthropy today has to do with strengthening the state of Israel.  I can't get past that...

Sep 15, 2011 6:53PM
avatar
Speaking of YLT, anyone have the "You Can Have It All" 7"/CD single? At the time I thought the cover was so strange--some fan with stringy blond hair and flaky clown makeup around his mouth wearing a YLT shirt: http://goo.gl/KIZSv Then a couple of months ago I saw the comedy show Upright Citizens Brigade from c. 1998 (it's on DVD), and there's a skit about Spaghetti Jesus, but someone eats the spaghetti, then someone, um, passes the spaghetti, and then that passing ends up around the mouth of this YLT fan. Who is the fan? It's comedy genius Amy Poehler before she was on Saturday Night Live, and well before the excellent Parks and Recreation. If you're curious, the single was released between UCB and her work on SNL. Who knew?
Sep 15, 2011 6:30PM
avatar

Slate interview with Mary Timony-she mentions a London-based band Veronica Falls that she's been listening to and whom Wild Flag may be playing with when they tour over there. Checked out a few of their videos -not bad, kinda Camera Obscura with a little more goth. Any thoughts/info on them Alex?

Sep 15, 2011 6:18PM
avatar
sharpsm -- I know a couple of people who love opera and get involved by being extras at SF Opera. So you can be on the stage with a spear and breastplate if you're a donor and even if you're just an active lover of opera. You don't get to sing Das Rheingold, but plenty of patrons around us  in the cheap seats do sing little bits occasionally as they listen. I don't like banjo particularly, and I'm not going to go see Warren Hellman play, but I think you are wrong about this. I admit it was annoying to see a poor show by Elvis Costello last year and then halfway through, realize that he had a much, much better singer standing off to the side and singing only one song -- Jim Lauderdale. But he was paying Jim Lauderdale, rather than the other way around.
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap