Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Ry Cooder/Note of Hope

Fighting Depression

By Xgau Sep 27, 2011 1:09AM
Ry Cooder: Pull Up Some Dust and Sit Down (Nonesuch)

Folksingers are pretty mad these days, at times to the point of pushing back at the ravening rich people who are sitting on their heads. Some even refer to class or (can it be?) speak up for unions. But not one has topped a sardonic satire like "No Banker Left Behind" with a murderous ballad about Jesse James and his illicitly retrieved .44 taking every bonus-hogging fat cat in heaven to hell with him, or despoiled a Christmas corrido for GIs on leave with anything as gruesome as "I'd like a mouth so I can kiss my honey on the lips." A few tracks drag and one or two misfire. But from John Lee Hooker's campaign song to the earned nostalgia of a lonely old Chicano who'll forgive you for driving a Japanese car, Cooder has brought his longstanding obsession with the Great Depression into the present, where it unfortunately, tragically, enragingly belongs. Kudos too to drummer Joachim Cooder. This doesn't rock, and it shouldn't. But it rollicks, skanks, and two-steps just fine. A MINUS

 

Note of Hope (429)

Bragg & Wilco? The folk-rock of dreams. Jonatha Brooke? Singer-songwriter. The Klezmatics? Er, his wife was Jewish. But assigning a Woody Guthrie "celebration" to bassist extraordinaire Rob Wasserman? Trailing the likes of Kurt Elling, Madeleine Peyroux, Tom Morello, Studs Terkel, Ani DiFranco, and Jackson Browne behind him? Reads like a jazzbo recipe for leftwing piety. And proves instead yet another winning realization of an idea I had doubts about from the first Mermaid Avenue rumors. Wasserman is all over a record that's less sung than spoken, providing a musical identity as distinct as any other in this motley series. Once again Guthrie's words are set to music, although sometimes these words were prose and sometimes they're rapped or sprechgesanged. They're sly, sexy, down-and-out, up-and-at-'em. Terkel and DiFranco deliver diary jottings of breathtaking acuity, and the Pete Seeger recitation ends: "There never was a sound that was not music. There's no trick of creating words to set to music once you realize that the word is the music and the people are the song." Then Jackson Browne sings a formally static 15-minute ballad about the night Woody met Marjorie and all the dreams he had. I said Jackson Browne. It's magnificent. A MINUS

 

235Comments
Oct 1, 2011 8:21PM
avatar
I missed the whole Stones discussion (which I agree is excellent and necessary) for a number of reasons.

My fundamental defense of the band and their borrowing from black culture is that, in high school in the '60s in little-town Montana, I had almost zero exposure to black people and anything about their ways, through any medium. Motown and the Rolling Stones were champs at introducing me (cramped though it was, radio couldn't resist prime hits and media celebs). It presented a seductive, positive side -- free, sexy, defiant of convention because convention was constructed to exclude you. A fine lesson I've never forgot, thank you Stones and company.


Sep 30, 2011 10:33AM
avatar
David Fricke gives Loutallica's "The View" four out of five stars: http://goo.gl/htzoe

:l
Sep 30, 2011 6:55AM
avatar

Not sure if it's been mentioned and I just missed it but there's a xgau review of Mates of State on NPR. I'm on my third spin and it sounds great.

Mates of State could find its way onto the lower edge of the Top Ten for me this year.  The oooh-oooh's and la-la's are like honey.
avatar
Expert Witness takes off for Rosh Hashanah? 
Sep 30, 2011 12:59AM
avatar
richard, jcarru (?)

Thanks a bunch. You made my year that much more fulfilling.


Sep 30, 2011 12:20AM
avatar
Phil, I believe that show is at The Ultimate Bootleg Experience 2 (it's a blogspot). 

Ah, here it is http://goo.gl/BY420, now you decompress it and there's a text file with the proper links. Idk if this show is better than The Name of This Band is...those versions are definitive to my ears. But such is the fun of bootleg listening! 
Sep 30, 2011 12:14AM
avatar
Phil, I think this is the link I found from a couple of years ago.  It sound good. I've always loved how Byrne follows "Other peoples problems, they overwhelm my mind" with "My little mind."

http://andykaufman.posterous.com/rockingto-talking-heads-9161978-sbd

Sep 29, 2011 11:50PM
avatar
The Tide Is High is way way way worse
Sarcastic Huh! Sorry dude, I love that song. I hear you've been listening to Rush? Can't stand him. Glenn Beck either. Wink
Sep 29, 2011 11:25PM
avatar
Richard,

Absolutely. You don't happen to have that concert any more, do you? The cassette I recorded it on disintegrated around 1986 and I've been trying to find a replacement ever since. Rhino commercialized the Boarding House KSAN Television show, but not the Talking Heads one, and I've been waiting ever since...
Sep 29, 2011 11:12PM
avatar
Phil, I recorded that same Heads show off KSAN in '78.  It was recorded at the Boarding House and was amazing, better than the stuff released on The Name of This Band

Also, I started at SFSU in 1979.  Loved KSAN back then.

Sep 29, 2011 10:56PM
avatar
Just got home from work & read the bad news about Sylvia Robinson. To tie it to an earlier thread of conversation, it's too bad that the singer of "Love is Strange" (with Mickey "Guitar" Baker") and "Pillow Talk" (solo), guitarist on Ike & Tina's "It's Gonna Work Out Fine" (with special guest Mickey Baker as the voice of "Ike"), and founder of the seminal hiphop label isn't in the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame already. Maybe not in the regular performer or non-performer slots, but a "lifetime achievement" citation would have been nice.

EDIT: Just checked Wikipedia and found that Robinson & Baker's exact contribution to "It's Gonna Work Out Fine" is debatable, but I should have mentioned Robinson's pre-Sugarhill label All Platinum and her production of the Moments' "Love on a Two-Way Street for that label.
Sep 29, 2011 10:16PM
avatar
for what it's worth, The Tide Is High is way way way worse. Way. Actually listening to Rush right now. Not bad. Not bad at all. I like those drumfills that make me feel i am riding a roller coaster and about to fall down. Not very lasting music, but if I were on a road trip this would be the sh!t!. Then again, I like prog. I blame salsa for making me like all the stops and starts. Good idea/bad idea: Salsa + Rush. 
Sep 29, 2011 9:56PM
avatar
Just checked on Xgau's Ian Dury: "salacious humanism". He's good our host, isn't he.
Sep 29, 2011 9:48PM
avatar

Not sure if it's been mentioned and I just missed it but there's a xgau review of Mates of State on NPR. I'm on my third spin and it sounds great.

Sep 29, 2011 9:45PM
avatar
The first three songs on 'Parallel Lines' are for the ages but Ryan's post made me think . . . Guilty confession time: I have never really liked 'Heart of Glass'. (A group of us meet every second Thursday - so yes we're getting help.) I acknowledge it as a classic, a landmark, everything. Just can't stand it. There. I don't feel better, but we must say it.

Sep 29, 2011 9:44PM
avatar
most enduring impulse buy of all time?
The Wailers Catch a Fire for the cover.
Sep 29, 2011 9:30PM
avatar
So pleased to see some late love coming in for Ian Dury - the master of the single entendre. He's top 10 for me. Best short story writer in music that year - even though for Anglos, that year was actually 1977.  As it was for the mighty 'Pink Flag'. (Unpleasant wooziness from having sense of history tampered with.)
Sep 29, 2011 9:29PM
avatar
Parallel Lines

I know it's terrific, I can hear it, but there has always been a major distance between me and this record. Maybe it's Debbie Harry's voice, which deftly sums up that thin plexiglass artifice every neato little pop triumph Blondie ever recorded is trapped in. I love the Jack Lee songs unequivocally. Everything else I can sing along with, bop convincingly to and have always lent my respects. But after 60-odd plays over nine years my favorite is still "Heart of Glass", and the only moment that gives me an erection that part where she says it soon turned out to be a pain in the ****.

most enduring impulse buy of all time

If "getting my dad to order it for me on Amazon" (I was an unemployed 12-year-old at the time) counts as an "impulse buy", that'd be 69 Love Songs, by a band I (and most others) had never of heard before, with no other records of theirs in my record-abundant household, after reading only Rolling Stone's 3-out-of-5-star pan (probably the worst review it ever racked up). Too cool a concept to ignore, I thought. Years later, here we are -- my very favorite album this side of the Go-Betweens.

Sep 29, 2011 9:22PM
avatar
What is your favorite, most enduring impulse buy of all time? 
Well, I was watching late night TV, and Pat Boone came on...
Sep 29, 2011 9:14PM
avatar

Ballot finished and sent, whew!

I love that you guys brought up Zevon. "Lawyers, Guns & Money" is top 5 songs of 1978. 3 others are almost as good. The rest though is just ok.

All this "Faraway Eyes" talk sent me back to "Evening Gown", the one Mick "country" song that doesn't sound like a parody. Love that one.

I don't see a lot of humor on Some Girls, Pure Pop on the other hand has me cracking up (pun intended).

 

Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap