Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Ry Cooder/Note of Hope

Fighting Depression

By Xgau Sep 27, 2011 1:09AM
Ry Cooder: Pull Up Some Dust and Sit Down (Nonesuch)

Folksingers are pretty mad these days, at times to the point of pushing back at the ravening rich people who are sitting on their heads. Some even refer to class or (can it be?) speak up for unions. But not one has topped a sardonic satire like "No Banker Left Behind" with a murderous ballad about Jesse James and his illicitly retrieved .44 taking every bonus-hogging fat cat in heaven to hell with him, or despoiled a Christmas corrido for GIs on leave with anything as gruesome as "I'd like a mouth so I can kiss my honey on the lips." A few tracks drag and one or two misfire. But from John Lee Hooker's campaign song to the earned nostalgia of a lonely old Chicano who'll forgive you for driving a Japanese car, Cooder has brought his longstanding obsession with the Great Depression into the present, where it unfortunately, tragically, enragingly belongs. Kudos too to drummer Joachim Cooder. This doesn't rock, and it shouldn't. But it rollicks, skanks, and two-steps just fine. A MINUS

 

Note of Hope (429)

Bragg & Wilco? The folk-rock of dreams. Jonatha Brooke? Singer-songwriter. The Klezmatics? Er, his wife was Jewish. But assigning a Woody Guthrie "celebration" to bassist extraordinaire Rob Wasserman? Trailing the likes of Kurt Elling, Madeleine Peyroux, Tom Morello, Studs Terkel, Ani DiFranco, and Jackson Browne behind him? Reads like a jazzbo recipe for leftwing piety. And proves instead yet another winning realization of an idea I had doubts about from the first Mermaid Avenue rumors. Wasserman is all over a record that's less sung than spoken, providing a musical identity as distinct as any other in this motley series. Once again Guthrie's words are set to music, although sometimes these words were prose and sometimes they're rapped or sprechgesanged. They're sly, sexy, down-and-out, up-and-at-'em. Terkel and DiFranco deliver diary jottings of breathtaking acuity, and the Pete Seeger recitation ends: "There never was a sound that was not music. There's no trick of creating words to set to music once you realize that the word is the music and the people are the song." Then Jackson Browne sings a formally static 15-minute ballad about the night Woody met Marjorie and all the dreams he had. I said Jackson Browne. It's magnificent. A MINUS

 

235Comments
Sep 28, 2011 9:58AM
avatar
Yeah,  Walter,  in doing this listening in 1978 it's amazing how many people tried out that disco beat.  Stones? Not surprising.  And welcome. 

George Jones on "I Ain't Got No Business Doin' Business Today"?  A little upsetting.

Which brings me to a somewhat random observation:  in Christgau's rankings (as presented in the book, not the original Dean's List), 1978 seems to be the only year in the 1970s that has no Black artists in the top ten.   

Sep 28, 2011 9:40AM
avatar
For about 10 years, I thought the protagonist in "Far Away Eyes" was listening to gospel music on the college radio station.  I like it better that way.
Sep 28, 2011 9:39AM
avatar

Whoops- sorry Frap- errant thumbdown. I still like Some Girls just fine.

 

Returned yesterday after a week in Tennessee visiting relatives. First time up there in almost four years so was good to see everyone. Beautiful weather -about 15 degrees cooler than the sweltering Sunshine State.  However, watching family and other loved ones age, get sick and lose their marbles is decidedly unpleasant.

 

Tried to keep up with posts and new music while I was gone, but there's some catching up to do after today's laundry and yard work.

Sep 28, 2011 9:38AM
avatar
oh lord Jason I didn't even notice that when I posted.   I guess I could try to fix it but it's too wonderful to mess  with I think.
Sep 28, 2011 9:36AM
avatar
Sherm****xie's
Wow. This is starting to approach Soviet era levels of censorship. Where's Osip Mandelstam when you need him?
Sep 28, 2011 9:34AM
avatar
I'm not ignoring the ironic distance in Mick's vocals, but I do wonder how much ironic distance is worth over the course of a career. I mean, the Dickies were all about ironic distance--check out their cover of "Nights In White Satin"; it sucks, but it's funny, in an ironic kind of way.

Sep 28, 2011 9:32AM
avatar
Yeah on Mick and his ironic distance.

Puts me in mind of the main character of Sherm****xie's heartrending story "Can I Get a Witness?"

"On the night his wife had signed their divorce papers, she called him  up and cursed him.  She was drunk and lonely and enraged.

'All right Mr.  Funny!'  she had yelled. 'Let's see how long you can go without telling a joke! How long! How long, Mr. Funny?'

'About seven seconds,' he'd said after seven seconds of silence.

She'd cried and cursed him again and hung up the phone....Why was it more necessary for him  to tell a joke than to acknowledge her pain?"

Sep 28, 2011 9:26AM
avatar
It's never been a particular favorite of mine (I like Black & Blue and Tattoo You about as much), but I played Some Girls yesterday too, and was impressed with it.  You can complain on musical grounds, but I think the tone of "Far Away Eyes" is pretty consistent with "Dear Doctor" from 10 years earlier.   "Some Girls" meanwhile, I find more to be increasingly annoying considering what we know about Mick the womanizer. 

Also, I'd never really payed close attention the lyrics of "When the Whip Comes Down."  With the reference to 53rd street, is it correct to assume that the protagonist is a male prostitute?  Mick apparently claimed that the protagonist was gay, as the first few lines make clear, but that he worked as a garbage collector.  Not sure if he was being cheeky there. 

Sep 28, 2011 9:21AM
avatar
My recollection, which I'll try to check out some night when I'm not working--fam is always happy to hear the Stones at dinner--is that I love Far Away Eyes. And to say Mick doesn't have a sense of humor is to ignore the ironic distance with which he invests every note he sings--which is one of things that makes him great, and one of the things that makes him such a dick.
Sep 28, 2011 9:17AM
avatar
One more thing on Jackson Browne's Woody Guthrie song. 

The sprechgesangy part around the 10 minute mark finally lifts the curse he laid on himself with that horrifying spoken section in "Hold On, Hold Out" in 1980  ("I always figured I was gonna meet somebody here...And I don't know [breaks into falsetto] whyyyyyyyy.....)"
Sep 28, 2011 9:16AM
avatar
RE: Some Girls - Is everyone taking crazy pills? I think the album is superb and even if "Far Away Eyes" isn't the first Stones song I seek out to play (on this album or overall) I still enjoy the humor despite its mocking tone and the chorus is quite catchy, too. Decent? Howsabout bitchin'?
Sep 28, 2011 9:13AM
avatar
Although it didn't make my top 10 (1978 being a most excellent vintage), I like Some Girls plenty--the last Stones album to approach greatness. In Keith's Life, he definitely gives the sense that he considers it the beginning of the end too--the first time that Mick basically brought in music that went against the band's usual process and forced it on the group. In this case, it turned into "Miss You," which you'd have to be churlish (like Keith, I guess) to dislike. I sure don't.  Keith's lament from that point on is that Mick would hear something at Studio 54 or wherever he had partied the previous night and try to get the group to sound like that in the studio the next day, which peeved everyone. One other thing I learned from Life: "Start Me Up" was recorded on the same day as "Miss You," after many failed tries as a reggae tune. That they held such an obvious winner for two albums later is a total mystery. It would've sounded fine on Some Girls.
Sep 28, 2011 9:13AM
avatar
Dogpile on the rabbit: I'm also feeling the hate for "Far Away Eyes."  Always have.  And now I know enough to hear how it sh*ts on the great country moves they had made in the early 70s and their relationship to Gram Parsons and is kind of stupidly classist to boot. 

And not funny.   But that's not a surprise. 



Sep 28, 2011 8:59AM
avatar
I threw on Some Girls just to be fair for this round of balloting, and had the same reaction I've had for thirty-three years: couple of decent singles, lame Keith showcase, and a whole lot of bish-bash (best bish-bash: "Shattered"; worst by an English kilometer: the horrible Temptations cover, which might as well be the Dickies). As for "Far Away Eyes", it's the same cringe-inducer you get every time Mick tries to prove he's got a sense of humor. Unlistenable.

Sep 28, 2011 7:51AM
avatar
Then I listened to Some Girls and it was terrible. Specially Mick's southern shtick on Far Away Eyes.
Heh.  I had the opposite response.  I've dismissed Some Girls for years.  When I put it on--for the first time in about 20 years--for this poll it blew me away.  Still not sold on Far Away Eyes, but my intense dislike of that song melted into mere ambivalence.
Sep 28, 2011 5:37AM
avatar
'I thought "Singer-singwriter" was a play on words: indicating that Brooke was better off singing other people's songs, than actually writing them.'
Xgau always does sh!t like this (you know, his own slang/funny spins); I thought the same!
avatar
Didn't know the Stones invited Cooder to join again in 1975, but I did hear that around that time the Eagles invited Richard Thompson to join them, presumably for his guitar work. Unimaginable. Thompson would have been a far, far richer man, but it wouldn't have mattered because he would have had to kill himself.
Sep 28, 2011 4:15AM
avatar
A few early morning thoughts:

1. I don't know when I'll listen to Note of Hope complete, because I just started with the Jackson Browne song and it is--as promised--magnificent.  I love how the vocal tagline is echoed by a guitar figure that sounds (to me anyway) like the one in "Here Comes the Night." Then around the 10 minute mark Jackson starts reciting like he's Van talking about the letterbox in "And the Healing Has Begun."

2. I defer to Cam on the medical/psychological explanations of Woody Guthrie's disinhibition.  Tragic.  But I also want to note that it is in Whitman that so many of Guthrie's generation of leftist (men) found a very important model of how (and why) to merge the erotic and the political. Allen Ginsberg picked it up next.  There's  a great essay in the book collection Hard Travelin' (Santelli and Davidson) about Guthrie's art and erotic impulses.  ("I'll say to my man come out of your walls and move in your/space as free and wild as my woman.")

3. "Remember the Mountain Bed" (on "Mermaid II").

avatar
Mick's southern shtick on Far Away Eyes
Heh, I think it's kinda funny, like a friend doing a really bad imitation of, say, Bush jr.. 

Btw, you got a link to that Television track? Google and 'tube search engine was no help.
Sep 27, 2011 9:57PM
avatar
There's a new Television track out, it's on the tube. It's called Miracles and it's instrumental (the comments section has Richard Lloyd remembering the good old days when Richard Hell was in and waxing hate on Tom Verlaine, which I find ok, since tv seems kindofadick). This happened the day I listened to Adventure and it sounded absolutely fantastic, even the shadier stuff like Careful and Ain't That Nothin' sounded good, and of course: the guitars!. Then I listened to Some Girls and it was terrible. Specially Mick's southern shtick on Far Away Eyes. Nooooot voting for that. 
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap