Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Standard Fare/Allo Darlin'

Jangle On

By Xgau May 1, 2012 5:21AM

Standard Fare: Out of Sight, Out of Town (Melodic)

Tighter and/or tougher‑-the guys sharper and bigger, the gal exploiting her nasality to cut through. But unless you care that the objects of Emma Kupa's lust have become more explicitly female, which she herself makes very little of, what really differentiates this from 2010's The Noyelle Beat is that Kupa's now an old pal even if you didn't think about her once since then. Which she suspects maybe you didn't, because right beneath her forthright specificity lurks an edge of anxiety that portends trouble down the road‑-trouble that may be your fault. Kupa gets around not because she has a taste for the orgiastic like fellow janglers Los Campesinos! but because relationships go awry. She really wishes they wouldn't, or at least that's what she thinks. But partner by partner, she's still figuring it out. A MINUS

 

Allo Darlin': Europe (Slumberland)

The magic of the debut wasn't just that thing that happens with young bands when everything is new and bliss is just around the corner. It's that Elizabeth Morris recognized this illusion as an illusion and entered wholeheartedly into its ebullience anyway. But now the Old World's cold weather and cramped spaces are getting her down‑-her most irresistible new song, taken solo with ukulele, recalls a blistering summer day down under when they found a Go-Betweens tape in the car. Though her tempos have slowed half a turn, reducing the twee factor if that was a problem for you, her melodies are still very much there and her lyrics are sharp throughout. But she's no longer at all confident that talent will out or love endures‑-her "This is life, this is livin'" is more resigned than celebratory, copping to her suspicion that a great night in bed will never be repeated. So let me assure her that at least she hasn't "already met all the people that'll mean something." Some of them haven't even been born yet. And I don't mean the kids I bet she's not sure she'll ever have. A MINUS

 

100Comments
May 1, 2012 10:42AM
avatar
'Some of them haven't even been born yet.'

This is true. The older I get, the more I realise I won't have enough time, to meet all these great people!


(Damn, I wanted, to add Out of Sight, Out of Town to my year-end list, but it's 2011! Yes, I'm that finicky!)

May 4, 2012 12:21AM
avatar
'I want to second this. A highlight of the entire run of the blog so far. Like a first-rate magazine survey. (Follow-up topic sometime: influential teachers?)'

Haha, this isn't even a swing or anything, but I don't know, when you're being sarcastic anymore! (Short bursts would suggest yes, but I'm not sure...)

May 1, 2012 8:19AM
avatar
I just totally love music writing like this.

Now if you'll excuse me I have to mix these two bands with the new Lee Ranaldo and enjoy a busy, productive day. Already got all our nullification projects taken care of sometime back.

May 1, 2012 4:41PM
avatar
A favorite Ramones cover: Rhett Miller combining an acoustic performance "I Wanna Be Sedated" with Pixies' "Wave of Mutilation."  Why do I love it?  Because you could assign Rhett Miller to sing just about anything and I'd consider it special.
May 1, 2012 6:35PM
avatar
 krobcoop-

Sorry to hear of your father's death. Way too young. I'm sure you will always think of him and his influence, especially when listening to all the great music he introduced you to. Having shared the love of rock 'n roll with him is a memory to treasure. Condolences to you and your family.

How many of us here, I wonder, can say our own fathers shared our love of rock? Some of the younger folks, certainly, but I'd venture to guess many of  the Witnesses over 50 may have had some struggles with the old man in the 50s, 60s and 70s when it came to what was on the radio. Or maybe not - perhaps our parents' open-mindedness is one of the big reasons we're here discussing and reveling in the music that we love.

My own father, while a Big Band/Sinatra/Standards fan for the most part, was always receptive to certain pop and rock trends, though the hard stuff was a bit much for him. As I mentioned, he and my mom were at the Costello show last week, but neither one really got much out of it. Some of my peers' folks were much less tolerant and I'm grateful to mine for instilling a love of learning, music, reading, travel and sports that I will always hold dear. I haven't always been the ideal son and I know they wish I was more settled, more successful and more pious, but I guess we're still lucky to have each other to kick around.  When things get bleak, I always try to remind myself that, family-wise, I could have done a helluva lot worse.
May 1, 2012 10:42AM
avatar
Since I'm probably the only person in the world to have The Sellout and The Noyelle Beat in my end of the year top 10s for their respective years (The Sellout actually got zero Pazz & Jop mentions), thought I'd mention that, IMHO, Covered isn't nearly so much of a mess by the fourth listen, and Out of Sight Out of Town was for me a strong up from the beginning (got it two months ago) and is my number 2 to Father Creeper for the year to date. Of course I've also thought all Macy Gray albums except Big at least an A-; I'm a huge fan of hers.

From this plus my comments about college rap and blues I think it is completely obvious how my tastes are positioned vis a vis this blog -- overlapping dramatically with Christgau's, but shaded noticeably toward the feminine and/or androgynous, the soulful, the political, and the unapologetically literate.
May 1, 2012 5:38PM
avatar
Devoted reader and seldom poster--I am compelled to post today. My father died suddenly on Sunday. He was just over a week shy of his 59th b-day. He, more than anyone, ignited my love for music. One of the pros to being born to teenage parents was exposure to a lot of great music as a young child--Beatles, Stones, Hendrix, Dylan, ST-Harder They Come, James Brown, Skynyrd, etc. He loved Keith Richards until the end. Will add that Dad was sober for the last 25 years of his life. Wish this translated into happiness for him, but alas, it did not. He was a pretty good guitarist--favored the blues. One of my favorite teen memories is him schooling (in the best kind way) a kid raised on Eddie Van Halen, on how to play with more soul. I think he really left an impression on that kid. He wasn't much receptive to new music over the past 20-years. I tried to turn him on to the DBT's and Baseball Project in recent years. I hope he is wailing on his Strat somewhere as I type, and if not, I hope he at least has some peace now. 
May 3, 2012 12:53AM
avatar
I don't think of myself as coming from abnormally musical or artistic family the way Carola did, but reading these accounts maybe that's not true. Born 1916 and 1917, both parents played a little piano, as did my very church-oriented Aunt Mildred and to a small extent my showbiz-loving maternal grandfather, a major figure in my life. I had a great-aunt who liked to sing at parties too. To me all this stuff seems pretty normal, but maybe it's kind of a lot--curious to know what people think. (I wouldn't study piano because I hated to practice, which among other things cut into my reading.) Insofar as whether my mother or my dad influenced my tastes, I really feel as if it was mutual. I grew up with parents who actively enjoyed music without being obsessed with it. But when they went out on a rare date, maybe for my mom's birthday, and saw South Pacific, that was big. There was a nice radio-phonograph and a modest collection of 78s, maybe 20 or 30, mostly big band, although my mom loved Sinatra. But soon they bought the South Pacific album, which was still a physical album with a bunch of 78s in it. I played the hell out of it. Eventually Grandpa took me to see it himself.
May 3, 2012 10:25AM
avatar
I've invoked my dad more often than almost anything on this blog, and that's because I owe every ounce of my rock-love to him. In fact if he were drawn to Christgau at all, he'd make perfect sense as a member of this community -- encyclopedic sense of history, a set of war stories that would make Cam impressed, passionate opinions about records and CDs he's filled shelves and shelves and shelves with he'd be all too willing to share. His Facebook feed is just about completely devoted to videos of songs and performances he likes -- last ten posts were Teenage Fanclub's "Hang On", Kelly Hogan's "We Can't Have Nice Things", Pernice Brothers' "Somerville", a video about the Honeydogs, Wings' "Tomorrow", a Lisa Hannigan cover of "At the Chime of a City Clock", a Laura Marling performance from Coachella, Nic Jones' "Canadee-I-O", Bob Mould doing "Man on the Moon" at SXSW and Mark Ronson's "Bang Bang Bang". He subscribes to all the mags and is about as attuned to what's going on in modern music as Joey, which sets him apart from stuck-in-the-past Xgauhead me.

When I was a kid not only was it impossible to get away from all the stacks of CDs (which he played so admirably loud on car trips) but the sounds he was making in our basement (he once invited me down, at age 3, to sing on a song he wrote for me about this toy monster truck I really liked). He loved Lucinda Williams and They Might Be Giants and NRBQ and as such I've known who they (and many more) are for ages. He took me to shows -- got the Breeders to wish me a happy birthday -- and we've been to countless since. He took me to used CD store after used CD store. I'm sure I've said this before, but the way by which I got into pop/rock music in the first place was when I told him on one of those outings that Billy Joel and I had the same birthday, upon which he promptly got me Greatest Hits Vols. I & II and I was hooked for the rest of my life. And of course there were his gigs, which we went to see often, though that phase ended before I was old enough to appreciate it.

We haven't really always gotten along -- we must be too close in age and interest and kindred spirits must really have the hardest time -- and it's been weird to look at the trajectory of his life as both informative and cautionary. When he was a kid he did DJing at Rutgers -- we have recordings of him interviewing folks like Joey Ramone -- and was in band after band after band after band after band. Once those bands folded, around the time I hit tykehood, he was still making demos up until the mid-90s of songs I think are just the bee's knees. So I'm in the unique position of having grown up listening to my father's records even if said records never went anywhere at all. And of course when I started trying out my own music ten years ago he was right there, playing the guitar parts and bass parts I couldn't (I took piano lessons, see, which of course he and my mom paid for). But he's also devoted his career life to corporate managerial/directorial/human resources type stuff, and has two masters degrees and is going for his doctorate now (bleh). He's got as much of a way and inclination with the left brain as the right, and the left brain won. So obviously it's hard not to romanticize an alternate history wherein my dad became successful at this stuff, the rock stuff, though we probably would've eaten a lot less often if he had.

Now, my mother and I get along amazingly and talk openly very often. But she's not into music -- she likes it, but doesn't really have discriminate tastes. Plus she's a physician's assistant, making her queen of a left-brain world I've never taken any natural interest in. So we're close friends but not soul sisters. Though my dad does have a recording of her warbling Lucinda's "Changed the Locks", which I'm not sure how he conned her into.
May 3, 2012 5:54PM
avatar

My wife and I ended up in London for a long work-related weekend, but we made some time tonight for a not-so-work-related event, seeing New Order at the O2 (formerly Brixton) Academy, a classic venue in a rough part of town but close to the Brixton Tube Station. We didn’t even know about the show until right before we got on the plane to London yesterday evening, so this was complete serendipity. It turns out the band has reformed for a brief tour of England and we just lucked out. The great news is that Gillian Gilbert is back on stage for the first time in this millennium and boy has she not changed—on those rare moments when she looked up from the keybs tonight, she couldn’t help but break her scowl to smile at the crowd, but otherwise she barely moved.

 

And Peter Hook is long gone, but that’s not such a bad thing. One less stage hog, and it turns out that anyone who plays simple lead guitar patterns on the high end of a fuzzed up bass sounds just like him, cuz that’s what his replacement (who’s name I didn’t catch) did.

 

I’d only seen New Order once before, at the Fox Theater in Atlanta around the time of Power, Corruption, and Lies, when they were still more goth than dance. And although the band did grow up, Kris and I went to the show tonight expecting a nostalgia trip. In fact, all objective evidence suggests that that is what we got. The crowd skewed older (but only slightly) and 50:50 female to male. The set list was a tour through their greatest hits. And Bernard looks a little bit Boy George-ish around the middle.

 

But hey, even if the tunes were familiar, the energy wasn’t faked—in fact, it seemed brand new. Give credit to the new lineup—Bernard was having a lot of fun with Gillian on stage, and having fun in general in a totally sober way. And give credit to the crowd, which didn’t treat this like an oldies show at all—I sensed guarded optimism at first, making the band prove themselves, but they (we) gave in as the intro of “Ceremony” went from jagged and ragged to rolling and swelling. (After which Bernard said “We’re watching your show as much as you are watching ours.”) Let’s face it, dance music isn’t about being tight, it’s about finding the groove, and then taking a full step higher, once-twice-three times a song. And they didn’t fail for one of the 16 songs they played. The “586/Perfect Kiss/Blue Monday/Temptation” sequence left my heart palpitating, the crowd visibly staggered.

 

And then, they stopped playing. And got called back for an encore, and Bernard said “Hi, we’re Joy Division”. And they proceeded to play “Transmission” and “Love Will Tear Us Apart” like the songs from the front line that they are. I wasn’t there for the real thing, and to hear these songs this one time—not mimicked but resurrected, reinhabited—all I can tell you is I will take those 8 minutes to my grave. “Dance, dance, dance to the radio”, don’t forget, ok?

 

P.S. I’ve got video of tonight’s entire “Love Will Tear Us Apart” (with crappy sound, cuz it was crazy crazy loud, but who cares?) that I’ll try to post over at Facebook if I can figure out how to do it.

 

May 2, 2012 10:04PM
avatar
If your Dad was born in 1890, like mine, recorded music wasn't, you know, much a part of his youth. Likewise if your Mom was born in 1910.

My father was a self-taught painter and did it all the time, which was very inspirational. He also loved literature and read aloud (with great skill) to the family from classic texts, very unusual in mid-Montana in the '50s. My mother understood a child's capacity for fantasy was an escape from her own too-mundane life. Let's dream together. When I was little, I loved every minute of it, Mom.

May 1, 2012 1:33PM
avatar
Standing in solidarity with the Occupy May Day protesters, though I wish they'd focus their message on three-four clearly articulated goals.
avatar
Oh I know the reason we started talking about dads here (krobcoop I'm very sorry for your loss) and had decided to wait until mother's day before posing the question, but since my dad brought it up it is a thing I'm interested in. This is something I've noticed in the past, that people have talked about their dads and music but never really bring up their moms. Obviously for me my dad has been the bigger influence but my tastes align pretty well with my mom and I've spent many good times with my mom listening to Al Green, Imperial Teen, Sleater Kinney etc. I know most of you are guys and so dads are the more obvious influence, but I wouldn't want the girls to be forgotten.
May 1, 2012 12:24PM
avatar
Very distressed to read the sad news about Bobby Vee, a fine record maker and a particular favorite (and very longtime pal) of Bob Dylan's. Someone can correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe Bobby's great "Take Good Care Of My Baby" was Goffin-King's second number one hit (after "Will You Love Me Tomorrow"). Oddly, I've been trying to write something on Van Dyke Parks, and just yesterday downloaded half-a-dozen versions of his psychedelic goofball classic "High Coin"--by Bobby Vee, Jackie DeShannon, the Charlatans, Harper's Bizarre, the West Coast Pop Art Experimental Band, and Parks himself. Best by a country mile: Bobby Vee.

EDIT: Wait. Back up. Not Parks himself--not sure if he recorded "High Coin" or not. The sixth version is by something called the Fault Line. It sucks.

May 3, 2012 1:27AM
avatar
Should we just do this? Things I have shared with my mum (which she enjoyed): Brad Paisley, Steely Dan, Drive-By Truckers, Madonna and, to a lesser extent, Al Green. Things I have shared with my dad (which he enjoyed): The White Stripes, The Black Eyed Peas, The Clash (my dad's a huge The Jam fan), Culture (likes reggae), Kanye West, Lucinda Williams, Sly & the Family Stone, Derek & the Dominos, The Rolling Stones--I'm now trying to think of others things, because I know they are there.

Conclusion: My mum is a massive fan of country & western, so anything like Garth Brooks is a win! My mum hates, hates, hates hip-hop (and I have no idea why)! She, also, doesn't like anything too guitar based. She, also, suffers from 'headaches' very often (I use that loosely, not because I don't appreciate headaches, but because I believe she fakes them), so I have, to turn it down. My father, on the other hand, really enjoys guitar-rock (but had a hard time swallowing Sonic Youth, for some reason), and he also really loves dance music and soul-ish stuff. Basically, I have to say, my dad has the broader sense of musical tastes, and he's more up, to listening to anything--anything with a hook, that is!
May 2, 2012 11:46PM
avatar

As I believe I've mentioned several times, my father's favorite band is the Doors, one of those bands that I find inherently unsavory (though the best of on Rhino does make me give in).  He did, however, turn me on to Buffalo Springfield and Love.  My mom gave me Carole King and Joni Mitchell.  They're probably also to blame for the Beatles obsession I've had since the age of 5 .  They both were hippie types, and my dad in particular found their teenage son's love of the Smiths and the Pet Shop Boys and XTC and R.E.M. unfathomable (to say nothing of art films and Nabokov).  I once mentioned this to a family friend, who pointed out: "You are the son they raised you to be," which is a poetic way of pointing out the paradoxes that separate parents from their sons and daughters. 

 

My mom had arm surgery yesterday and is laid up in my brother's condo recuperating.  When she was in the doctor's office she ran into my father's mother, who hadn't seen her in ten years, and was coincidentally there getting cataract surgery.  My grandmother mentioned how she heard the doctors loved my mom, having taught their sons and daughters.  "You've made such a mark in the community," my grandmother reportedly said.  "Everyone loves you and I'm very proud of you."  My stepmother -- a very nice woman -- stood by, looking slightly uncomfortable.  But hey, my mom, like my grandmother, is someone special.

 

It's nice being the son of someone so appreciated -- an honor.  Love you, Mom.  Grandma, too.  Get better soon.

May 1, 2012 12:13PM
avatar

The new Santigold album is a masterpiece !

Great beats from start to finish, and only one song is over 4 minutes long.

 

But disgraceful as it may seems,

I'm a little turned off by her similarity to you-know-who (and o.t.h.e.r. artists),

guess she's never had much personality anyway.

May 3, 2012 5:25PM
avatar
The discussion of parental musical influence, or otherwise, has been lovely.

 

I want to second this. A highlight of the entire run of the blog so far. Like a first-rate magazine survey. (Follow-up topic sometime: influential teachers?)

 

Did want to diverge before I get caught up in other things to toss some notes about recently reviewed and mentioned players.

 

Lee Renaldo clanging the bells out of the gate.  'Course he keeps his sighs and goodbyes to the past brief (subtext of "Waiting on a Dream"/"Off the Wall" maybe) but mostly he sounds liberated from Sonic Youth. Like the man said, set free to find a new illusion. But it sure feels good in this moment.

 

Spoek Mathambo kicking in the stall now after multiple listens. Something new under the hot, hot sun, I think -- so the tentative or confused reactions are due to freshness, not mess. Weird thing is, this here, there, and all-things-everywhere style is very much like what I swear I  heard when I first checked out The Very Best mixtape and then gradually couldn't hear it as much on repeat listenings (and thought it all but disappeared without the many samples on the regular-release debut). It's a style. It has no name. But I think it's a distinct mode.

 

I find Parson Sound a bit on the historical-interest side myself*, and much prefer a spin-off group, Trad Gros Och Stenar. (*And they remind me of Motorpsycho only in a very general way.)

 

As to Noir Desir, I recommend the 1994 S/T compilation on Barclay as their nosiest, yelping, grunting, guitar-grinding, screaming, hard-whomping-best-French-drummer-ever release. Although 1989's Veuillez Rendre L'ame is a more "varied" and "well-constructed" album.

May 3, 2012 4:49PM
avatar
My parents had no interest in music, although my mother (1913-2000) eventually became a big George Jones fan and especially enjoyed country-gospel. I think the only time my father (1923-2000) showed any awareness of music was one time he quoted Little Jimmy Dickens -- he did, at least, have a sense of humor. They talked about dancing before I was born, and my mother recalled seeing Tommy Dorsey once, but that was about it. They bought a piano and arranged lessons for my little sister when she was five, but it never occurred to them that boys might take an interest in music. We did have a toy that would play 45s, and a short stack of mostly novelty records. In my teens I bought a stereo, but didn't have more than a couple dozen LPs by the time I was 20. After moving to St. Louis a few friends helped open my ears, and Don Malcolm got me to start writing, but nearly everything I've learned about music comes from reading and lots of exploration. Took off, of course, when Christgau saw some of my early stuff and invited me to write for the Voice, and again when Tatum got me to write Recycled Goods.

By the way, new RG up today. Lots of Norwegian jazz.


May 3, 2012 3:01PM
avatar

Recent Xgau A MINUS day at work.   Played Bruce, Madonna and Standard Fare - all final spins.   I had the Standard Fare at A MINUS weeks ago - but wanted to see how they stacked up.   So, for those who care - Standard Fare, Madonna then Bruce.    Oddly, all three albums have stronger second halves.

 

Dad:  Born 1929 - 100% Italian-American.  Owns thousands of records.  I heard a lot of Sinatra, Harry James, Basie, Ellington, Kenton growing up.   Now, he likes some Connick, Diana Krall.  Went to see Michael Buble - but was not impressed.   Dad liked WNEW back in the 70's - but always caught me by surprise with the Top 40 songs he would turn up on the radio - 70's Stevie Wonder, Michael Jackson, Earth,  Wind and Fire, Phil Collins, etc.  There are nearly 40 years between us - so I was always timid about what I would try and play for him.   When I lived at home I remember him liking "Yellow Moon" and some of The White Album but not Sonic Youth or Public Enemy.

 

Mom:  Born 1940.  Grew up with the radio.  Always played the Top 40 station until she turned 45 or so.  Then, went to the Adult Contemporary station.  Owns no records.  Hasn't mentioned a new song to me in years.   She liked the Michael Buble show more than Dad.

 

 

 

Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap