Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Neil Young/David Bowie

Reclaim Men

By Xgau Aug 2, 2011 5:00AM


Neil Young International Harvesters: A Treasure (Reprise)

Two remakes from Old Ways, two from Re-ac-tor, one from Harvest, and one from Buffalo Springfield, plus six more or less "new" songs, all recorded a quarter century ago. Reads like the profit-taking vault dig it is. What it sounds like, however, is the redemption of Young's lost mid-'80s‑-the countryish album Old Ways was supposed to be, neither rote like Re-ac-tor nor static like that sacred cow Harvest. Ben Keith, Spooner Oldham, and Tim Drummond know Nashville but can play whatever, in this case a loping rock bent and flavored by Rufus Thibodeaux's Cajun fiddle. You bet Young knew how thematic the superb "Nothing Is Perfect" was when he stuck it just before the farewell "Grey Riders," a spooky signal that deep down he was the same nut he'd always been. A MINUS

 

David Bowie: Station to Station (Special Edition) (EMI)

Normally I ignore "enhanced" classics, as should you, so to distinguish among iterations, this is the three-CD boxlet released in 2010. It includes three color photos of the Thin White Duke, a flier hawking Geoff MacCormack's "signed, limited edition" Travels With Bowie 1973-76, informative notes, the original album in its own wee sleeve, and‑-the bait, in a wee double sleeve‑-Bowie's March 23, 1976 performance at Nassau Coliseum, warm New York Times review by John Rockwell included, hot Village Voice review by Robert Christgau not. In addition to an echoing momentum with no precedent or aftermath in Bowie's melodramatic oeuvre, highlights include "I'm Waiting for the Man" with blues uptick, "TVC-15" with New Orleans accent, and a set list that stumbles only on the stone in his passway that is "Word on a Wing." It nails a galvanizing arena-rock that you can almost hear hitting a groove that had dissipated disappointingly just three days later at Madison Square Garden. But please note that I said "almost hear." As we all should know by now, rarely do galvanizing performances live on in artifact the way they do in memory. Whether this one you missed is worth your 25 bucks depends, I suspect, on just how seriously you credit the artiste's Anglophiliac legend. A MINUS

 

237Comments
Aug 5, 2011 5:55AM
avatar
Cyclops and Cam: Let me explain, As a younger guy a lot of the stuff in the CG just wasn't available to a midwestern kid like me. So, here I am playing catch up on these rarities. I am very grateful for any and all sharing, and I only wish I had the collection or a way to repay you for the kindness. Thank you!

And yes that means I now have my first Pulnoc or PPotU. Thanks again can't wait to hear it.
Aug 5, 2011 1:07AM
avatar
Speaking of Lapham's Theater of War, his story there of the time he applied for a job at the CIA is one of the funniest stranger-than-fiction things I've read.


Aug 4, 2011 11:42PM
avatar
 I don't know how how to do the "google mini-links", so eliminate spaces, etc., and then copy, paste and d/l the following Pulnoc.  The link for the pre-Arista album Pulnoc
is http://www.  media  fire.  com/?9e6bvihgieitmbd

 I had some probs with this, so I'm not sure it lists artist or album title name.  In both cases, it's "Pulnoc"; this is the Globus International release that Bob graded A-.  It's in 128k mp3 format.

 And then here's the famed Live at P.S. 122 album.  It's a soundboard 256k AAC format with two long tracks running about 87 minutes

http://www.  media   fire.   com/?7si1z8d9teq88s1

 I won't post City of Hysteria as it's still available new.  In any event, it runs about 50 cents and S&H at "that place" if you pick it up used.  I recommend it highly.

 Finally, I claimed earlier to have a Pulnoc album entitled Nedved Frantisek.  That is the name of an unrelated group who did an album entitled Pulnoc.  (Pulnoc means "Midnight".)
 



Aug 4, 2011 11:26PM
avatar
Oddly enough, I just glanced over at the bookshelf to my left and saw Lapham's Theater Of War stacked neatly next to Frank's One Market Under God. Nobody can say we weren't warned.

Aug 4, 2011 11:05PM
avatar
Jason: I know you're too modest to toot your own horn, but your blog entry for today deserves to be read by everyone here.
Sharp - you're really too kind. I should probably go back and make sure I didn't put that post up with too many egregious grammatical errors. 
I should mention that my wife insists I ration my reading of Thomas Frank--something in his combination of calm analysis and righteous outrage causes my blood pressure to spike every time (Krugman has the same effect--I'm allowed to read his column, but can only dip into his blog every other day).
Rationing the calm outrage of Krugman and Frank seems like a wise stipulation to me. Now that Frank is a monthly contributor to Harper's, I have a nice every-four-weeks blood-raising schedule. Krugman, I'm afraid, I sample with much more regularity. And speaking of Harper's, I believe Lewis Lapham explained his decision to forego his duties as editor of that magazine in order to start up the historical journal Lapham's Quarterly because he claimed he'd "arrived at the point where I would prefer to read Machiavelli than listen to Karl Rove". I know what he means.

Final aside - I think the issue in which Lapham announced his departure was the same issue featuring a cover story by Michael Hudson entitled "The New Road To Serfdom: An Illustrated Guide To The Coming Real Estate Collapse". That was May 2006. Prescient stuff. I know our host has had his differences with Lapham (put it down in print somewhere, although I can't remember where or in what context), but Lapham's served as a rare voice of reason and courage for me during the past decade. Looking back over ten years of articles and essays that Lapham has penned, edited or simply sanctioned, I'm struck by how many times the guy was just fcking right.
Aug 4, 2011 10:29PM
avatar
 On second thought, it's my understanding that Plastic People have a new compilation out that should be easy enough to get, so I won't post those.  Still, I could put up Pulnoc, City of Hysteria, P.S. 122, and Nedved Frantisek.
Aug 4, 2011 10:25PM
avatar
 Shady, do you have any Pulnoc or PPoTU at all?  I have four albums by each and could post them on my mediafire account, though it wouldn't be taking place tonight.
Aug 4, 2011 10:21PM
avatar
ShadyShack-- Maybe if Xgau weighs in on the Plastic People comp we can visit all that stuff. But maybe he won't either. The Pulnoc Live at PS 122 showed up in a long-ago thread here with a great story that you really should check out. The Plastic People catalog was reissued in toto in the Czech Republic a while back, so I think everything they've done is digital. If there is something you have questions about, you can probably find me through another outlet. Me, one of my most cherished LPs is Egon Bondie's Happy Hearts Club Banned, with it's zillion-page insert. Smuggled out from behind the wall. I got it for $3 via a Goldmine ad. Life was simple then.
Aug 4, 2011 10:21PM
avatar
Holy cow, all these lost Mofungo records suddenly fell in my lap. Just when I was gonna rock that great new Dave Alvin cd, or was it those 2 Staple Singers cds that came in the mail this week. Oh wait I forgot, I said I was gonna give A Treasure another try. Come to think of it, I have downloads of Belalo, Dark City Sisters and Zaire Choc! I'm so overwhelmed. Doesn't look like I'm going to bed any time soon. Sleepless in Seattle indeed. Seriously though thanks again to all who shared.
Aug 4, 2011 10:17PM
avatar
Jason: I know you're too modest to toot your own horn, but your blog entry for today deserves to be read by everyone here. Absolutely brilliant.

http://goo.gl/i57VL

I should mention that my wife insists I ration my reading of Thomas Frank--something in his combination of calm analysis and righteous outrage causes my blood pressure to spike every time (Krugman has the same effect--I'm allowed to read his column, but can only dip into his blog every other day).

Aug 4, 2011 10:03PM
avatar
Cam and sharpsm, Big thank you to both of you for sharing the Mofungo. I've never heard it before and I really like these.  Tin Huey comes to mind for some reason ...I don't know why. Thrilling stuff. Now I need to find some more rarities like Pulnoc and Plastic People of the Universe. Anyone?? :::wink, wink::: Nudge, Nudge:::
Aug 4, 2011 10:00PM
avatar
Aretha Franklin played her first-ever show in Brooklyn tonight as part of a long-running free concert series orchestrated by Borough President Marty Markowitz.  (Five bucks for the primo seats, free if you bring your own.)  From the get-go, she was engaged, enthused, sassy and soulful.  The most memorable highlight among many was when she commandeered the piano chair to do "Bridge..."  It ended with a five-minute gospel coda that -- and here you'll just have to believe me unless youtube clips appear -- was a minor miracle.  In a bit of serendipity that mirrored the whole evening, the concluding fireworks at the neighboring Coney Island Cyclones stadium shot up exactly as Aretha was exiting the stage after her encore of "Respect."
Aug 4, 2011 9:56PM
avatar
Be careful though. Sometimes the video allows the ear to tolerate incredibly crappy sound, so once the video is gone the appeal may diminish.
 True.  I'm willing to put up with 128k when necessary, which means I'm getting only about 9% of the music in that situation.  I guess I'm a pig- I'd rather have tens of thousands of mp3s than thousands of songs in flac (or tens of thousands of flacs on a zillion externals that I know in advance I wouldn't label properly).
Aug 4, 2011 9:28PM
avatar
Have any of you ever used an flv conversion program on Youtube videos? 
I used that for the PBS "Mr. Rogers/Wonderful Day in the Neighborhood" thing that I've never seen anywhere else other than on Youtube (and almost refused to believe existed until the video appeared). it works well if the sound quality is reasonable, as it did for that. Nice to have that MP3 in my Best of 1986 folder. Be careful though. Sometimes the video allows the ear to tolerate incredibly crappy sound, so once the video is gone the appeal may diminish.
Aug 4, 2011 9:26PM
avatar
Did someone say they don't like "Bridge Over Troubled Water"?  Aretha positively tore Brooklyn down with that tune tonight.
Aug 4, 2011 9:16PM
avatar
 Thanks to Cam and filetram, I'm up to five Mofungos.  I think I passed on one (Bob's B+). Therefore, if anyone wants to hit FT, they should be able to get up to at least six.

 Have any of you ever used an flv conversion program on Youtube videos?  They allow you to convert the videos to mp3 (or other formats).  The point is that you can make your own portable live albums of that obscure punk group from 1981 that has grainy live videos someone shot and that later got posted to YT.
Aug 4, 2011 8:46PM
avatar
Cam and sharp - above and beyond the call of duty with those Mofungo drops. Many thanks.
Aug 4, 2011 8:38PM
avatar
I still think Mick could have saved himself a lot of grief if he'd just joined that all-midget Kiss tribute band. Those guys rock.

Aug 4, 2011 8:11PM
avatar
Wanna see something even crazier than the House budget deficit debate? Go to You Tube and type in "Super Heavy" and you'll see studio footage of said band featuring the WTF-lineup of Mick Jagger, Dave Stewart, Joss Stone, Damian Marley, and A.R. Rahman. 
Aug 4, 2011 7:42PM
avatar
Two days ago picked up The Rough Guide to Boogaloo.  What a fun album.  If you don't have it, pick it up right away.  I may not be able to dance to it, but I can move to it and laugh at the same time. 
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap