Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Eric Church/Dirt Drifters

Hey, Compared to Hank Williams Jr. . . .

By Xgau Oct 11, 2011 4:59AM

Eric Church: Chief (EMI)

I know the idea is that the studly barfly who kicks the album off grows up as it progresses, but that doesn't help me feel the big dog who wants to beat up my buddy in "Keep On," or convince me that the morning-after sex of the last verse isn't a literary lie. Still, grow up he does. Church has always known how to write, and he's blowing here‑-check how the reworked title of "Homeboy" obliterates one's faint reservations about its moralism, or for that matter how the reworked title of "Keep On" mans up that sex scene. Jack Daniels (apostrophe omitted) and Springsteen (teen-sex soundtrack) are also title-cited, as is Jesus, twice‑-as a woman he doesn't deserve and a Johnny Cash imitator country music could use. Be nice if this bright, basically decent guy was him. A MINUS

 

The Dirt Drifters: This Is My Blood (Warner Bros.)

Five red-bloodeds from Greater Nashville‑-which here encompasses Oklahoma, where the Fleener brothers did what their mechanic dad loved and not what he did, and New Jersey, where Garth Brooks showed Jeff Middleton where he could stick his knack for words‑-escape the working-class rut they'd be lucky to be grinding down right now with capitalism running amok. The strong songs about labor breaking your back are outnumbered by the sharp ones that prescribe alcohol for the pain. But these dudes know honky-tonk hoo-hah for the doomed escape it is‑-a real-life option they understand better than they do the women they drink with. Just as well that their protest song‑-"All the good politicians are dead," "Radio plays the same 10 songs," etc.‑-is called "I'll Shut Up Now." But they won't and they shouldn't, because whenever they just look around a little they have the skills to tell us what they see. B PLUS

 

199Comments
Nov 4, 2011 11:39PM
avatar
Count me in as liking Crazy Ex Girlfriend better than American Saturday Night.  I still think that record holds up and still earns that A grade I gave it a few years ago.
Oct 17, 2011 6:47AM
avatar

Also, Steve Earle Guitar Town and yes, Hank Williams , jr. And Friends.

 

The first Rodney Crowell was a frequent flyer for me too.

Oct 14, 2011 10:11AM
avatar
2. "Welcome to Mali," Amadou & Mariam (Nonesuch)
3. "Fortress 'Round My Heart," Ida Maria (BMG/Sony)
10. "Light of X," Miranda Lee Richards (Nettwerk/Imperial)

who? ?

Oct 13, 2011 11:42PM
avatar
Hmmm...Just realized an alternative P&J was done last month for 2009, one of my favorite years. Little late, but FWIW here's a list I wrote for a local (Tokyo) magazine. All releases are for 2009 Japan.

1. "It's Not Me, It's You," Lily Allen (EMI)

Having been driven to the wall by the hype surrounding her debut, Allen reemerged with a surer grasp of what's important in her life and how to make her point musically. Once you get over how good the songwriting is you can relax and laugh at her jokes, none of which are at her own expense.


2. "Welcome to Mali," Amadou & Mariam (Nonesuch)

Amadou Bagayoko and Mariam Doumbia have too much experience as professional musicians to fall victim to some producer's idea of "crossover," and they treat the rock guitars, the synths, even the occasional English lyric as if all of it were theirs to begin with. Then they casually blow everyone away. 


3. "Fortress 'Round My Heart," Ida Maria (BMG/Sony)

This Norway-to-Sweden transplant makes punk music about the largeness of emotions. There's as much meaning in the way she inserts a hearty chuckle into a chorus as there is in her references to God as someone she talks to as an equal. She's not larger than life, but she seems more full of it.


4. "The Eternal," Sonic Youth (Sonik Tooth/Hostess)

As if to reassert their priorities, the greatest noise-rock band returns to indieville with their most commercially accessible album since the first one they made for Geffen. All the usual touchstones seem fresher. Could it be the new bassist? Kim Gordon not only sounds liberated, she sounds out there.


5. "Revolution," Miranda Lambert (Columbia)

Nashville's best album artist continues to keep one foot planted in Music City and the other in that suburb where country journeymen like John Prine and Julie Miller toil. But her own songs are getting better, funnier, more piercing, especially the one about being prettier than the Republican debutante.


6. "Black Diamond," Buraka Som Sistema (Fabric/Hostess)

The best dance album of the year may, in fact, be impossible to dance to for most people. Angolan kuduro, which this Lisbon-based trio plays, features intense club rhythms, intense sonics, and intensely concentrated raps. When the beats and lyrics flow at the speed of thought, the feet haven't got a chance. 


7. "In Love & War," Amerie (Def Jam/Universal)

In which American R&B's most rhythmically interesting singer busts out the loud guitars and does unholy damage to her vocal cords in order to vent her frustration at a music scene determined to keep her hidden. Most telling line: "Wonder what it takes to be my lover? First you gotta be my drummer." 


8. "Wilco (The Album)," Wilco (Nonesuch/Warner)

No matter how much he hates the term "alt country" it's Jeff Tweedy's to do with as he pleases since he invented the genre. If this album's title sounds like a bid at reinvention after years of experiments, its directness as a collection of well-written, well-played songs makes it an extremely successful one. 


9. "Fever Ray" (Rabid/Hostess)

Since Karin Dreijer Andersson is from Sweden, where the sun doesn't shine so much, it's natural to expect a darker soul-searching sensibility, but just because her spare electronica is slow doesn't mean it isn't playful. She can sing a haunting siren song about dishwasher tablets and make Bjork sound like a tightass.


10. "Light of X," Miranda Lee Richards (Nettwerk/Imperial)

This new millennium flower child is overly fond of late afternoons, wide fields of grass, sandy beaches, and men who smile a lot, but the beauty of her immaculate soft-rock melodies and limpid voice conveys these images with alacrity and no vacuous emoting. It's an album you bathe in.


Honorable mentions: "Seya," Oumou Sangare (World Circuit); "Crack the Skye," Mastodon (Reprise/Warner); "Troubadour," K'naan (A&M/Universal); "Sainthood," Tegan and Sara (Vapor); "Art Brut vs Satan," Art Brut (Cooking Vinyl) 

Oct 13, 2011 10:50PM
avatar
Spinning Around The Sun
Saw Jimmie at the Backstage in Ballard on that tour. One of my favorite shows ever. Butch's "Just a Wave" still gives me chills ever time I hear it. Seeing it done live was amazing, I miss that venue. Saw LW III there that same year.
Oct 13, 2011 10:44PM
avatar
Top of my head:

Willie Nelson--Phases And Stages
                       Shotgun Willie
                       Willie And The Wheel
Asleep At The Wheel--The Wheel
Rodney Crowell--The Houston Kid
George Jones--Alone Again
                        I Am What I Am
Gary Stewart--Out Of Hand
Johnny Cash--At Folsom Prison
Jimmie Dale Gilmore--Jimmie Dale Gilmore
                                 Spinning Around The Sun
Dolly Parton--My Tennessee Mountain Home
                      Coat Of Many Colors
Buddy Miller--Universal United House Of Prayer
Rosanne Cash--Take your pick
Oct 13, 2011 10:26PM
avatar
Also, does Stardust count? (Guess not.)

Stardust deserves it's on category, and while we're at it let's put it at or near the top. As I said last week, this is Mom's favorite
Oct 13, 2011 10:14PM
avatar
C'mon, in Nashville a hip-hop hat is a backwards baseball cap.
I don't think so, but anyone who wanted to say that Crazy Ex-Girlfriend is as good as ASN wouldn't be crazy. Also, does Stardust count? (Guess not.)


Oct 13, 2011 10:08PM
avatar
I'm finding the Dirt Drifters' album more pleasurable than Church's. This Is My Blood often sounds received, but half of it is really good or weird enough to pass for really good (like when Willie shows up). Chief is consistently kinda good, but too smoothed out - I mean this figuratively about the compact lyrics and literally about Church's vocals.

Also I'm not sure what a "hip hop hat" is. Does Church just mean a baseball cap? Or a tangerine-flake T-Pain chimney pot?
Oct 13, 2011 9:50PM
avatar

Further research seems to indicate that Bob underrated Bobbie Cryner and overrated Mandy Barnett. Bob's words on the first Bobbie C.

Cryner at No. 27, on the other hand, was too low

Check out "Leavin' Houston Blues" off the debut for starters.

Oct 13, 2011 9:19PM
avatar
Honky Tonk Masquerade, Grievous Angel and the Gilded Palace of Sin are up there too.
Oct 13, 2011 9:15PM
avatar

I seriously doubt the good doctor is wrong, and I'd be curious to read what he said.

Jacob I have your back. As far as non-compilation albums of original material go, nothing can touch American Saturday Night. Tom T. Hall's In Search of a Song might be second.

Edit- It's tricky but I don't consider Joe's above 3 (all great btw) to be country as such. I do hate this need to label stuff by genre.

Oct 13, 2011 9:01PM
avatar
Bobbie Cryner- Girl of Your Dreams (her debut is swell too)

John--  Unless I'm completely mistaken, Xgau had some comments after relistening to Cryner early on in Expert Witness.
Oct 13, 2011 8:51PM
avatar

Before this thread comes to an end as well as the country theme, I'd like to give a shout out to a couple favorites from awhile back

Bobbie Cryner- Girl of Your Dreams (her debut is swell too)

The Kinleys- Just Between You and Me

Both were xgau picks and long time readers should remember them, and maybe even cherish them as much as me. Kind of a head scratcher as to why neither got the airplay or recognition they deserved. Great writing, mostly by self, great voices, looks, etc

On the guy side, Dennis Robbins and Stacey Dean Campbell come to mind.

Oct 13, 2011 8:25PM
avatar
Holy moly. I just noticed that Tune-yards' "Fiya" is spookily similar to "Lekeleke" by Olu Right Time Orchestra-- chords, tempo, and she repeats the first two lines of melody over and over. Is this known by everybody? Awesome.

"Lekeleke" is on the John Storm Roberts' Azagas and Archibogs compilation. It's available here http://goo.gl/cf8Ma in relatively low (192 kbps) fidelity. If anyone prefers higher fidelity I can dropbox the CD, which is almost impossible to find now.
Oct 13, 2011 8:11PM
avatar
the singer values Jesus, family, and flag?

Lesse, just from scratch here ...

Grand Prize Winners for Exemplary Values and Attitude

Toward Jesus: Leonard Cohen, Randy Newman, Mahalia Jackson

Toward family: Loudon Wainwright III, the Roches, the Staple Singers

Toward the flag: Neil Young, James Brown, Grandmaster Flash and the Furious Five

Oct 13, 2011 8:08PM
avatar
It could also depend on how narrow of a definition of country you have.  Sweetheart of the Rodeo? Iris Dement?  I also haven't done a close comparison to James Talley or my beloved Honky Tonk Masquerade
avatar
Then he made the greatest country album ever.
Whoa, captain.

Oct 13, 2011 7:23PM
avatar
Jose, that phrase, at least the first line, does have a nice ring to it. Xgau, permission to wield your slogan if I make it to the New Haven protests this weekend?
Oct 13, 2011 6:37PM
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap