Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Serengeti

Complicated and Underrated

By Xgau Jul 22, 2011 4:20AM

Serengeti: Noticeably Negro (Audio 8 '06)

In which Chicago alt-rapper David Cohn, a red diaper baby on his African side, explores the conundrums of race and the hidden injuries of class. His woozy flow gathers a musicality that combines Biz Markie and Posdnuous‑-half wigged-out clown, half unassuming postcollegiate, neither of which Serengeti is or pretends to be. This kind of confusion is intrinsic to how he conceives hip-hop. A song called "Negro Whimsy" is speckled with gunshots; a song called "T.R.I.U.M.P.H." celebrates cabernet and Lucille's rack of lamb. Occasionally, he stumbles into the gentility he parodies. More often he blurs goofy and brilliant so organically that he's both at once. A MINUS

 

Serengeti: Family & Friends (Anticon)

Where other rappers claim mere personas are "characters" (sometimes inhabiting more than one on the very same album!), Serengeti writes playlets with something like dramatis personae‑-not just a few slightly confused rappers, although he has several of those, but white working-class superfan Kenny, black garbage man Lee, hip-hop dilettante Derek. Over beats supplied by Yoni of Anticon rap-rockers Why?, who must envy his lyrics, and Advance Base, formerly known as Casiotone for the Painfully Alone, he raps as or about 11 different losers possibly including himself on 11 songs that last barely half an hour. These include a son shooting up with his formerly absentee dad, a bigamist who couldn't resist that 17-year-old, a privileged jerk who lost his job and started a blog, and an ultimate fighter who blows his knee out. Sure the tone is often depressive or satirical. But it's also often kind, pained, silly, unhinged, and other things. On Noticeably Negro, Serengeti asked: "Serengeti's very ill very understated/Why'd you have to go and make things so complicated?" The answer is that the world is complicated and he damn well knows it. A MINUS

 

205Comments
Jul 26, 2011 12:22PM
avatar
Woops -- late to the party. Gotta comment anyway.

install Adblock Plus!
Wow -- works great! Yay! I'm a big fan of all things Firefox. Including that they don't push a bunch of products on you. But I'm glad I heard about this.

Into the Unknown is about the only recording I can think of offhand that richly deserves a guilt-free download or bootleg purchase. Keeping it out of circulation is exactly the sort of self-serving, posterior-protecting gesture Bad Religion would denounce in a different context. So screw 'em. I've always thought a bit less of them because of it -- Ohmigawd, we did something outside the sacred dictates of hardcore! Repent! Repent!

Finally, one aspect to consider when doing business with a shady operation like the Russian site is that, while some of what they do might be merely in legal limbo, it's quite likely that they are engaged in outright criminal activities behind the scenes or in other guises. About a dozen years ago, a not-dissimilar, pre-digital-age operation in Eastern Europe did serious damage to the legitimate music business I was working for at the time. Like I say, just something to think about.


Jul 26, 2011 2:00AM
avatar
'Oh, I see—one "improvement" is that you're forced to watch a little advertisement (or at least be aware it's going on), when you switch modes now. Pricks.'
Depending on how tech-savvy you are, download Firefox, and install Adblock Plus! Job done! *Cleans hands. (This includes all adds—Youtube and such.)
'(Insert one of Alex's smileys here.)'
Open-mouthed DevilTongue out Angel Party Thumbs up Sick Crying
'...but I'm wondering if maybe we could get a dozen or so people together to fork over, say, fifty bucks each to buy Cam that 40-disc Todo Caetano box?'
I'm up for that! Thumbs up

(More music-related posts shortly, I apologise! Speaking of which, super excited about Watch the Throne and Tha Carter IV, as I know we all are! Aren't we?! Baring teeth)
Jul 25, 2011 10:59PM
avatar
Say, did that Serengeti-on-LSD album ever drop?
According to Christgau's BN piece, that was to have been called Human To Human--can't find a trace of it (or of the label/website mentioned, radiobelly.com). I notice that an album came out last year called Standing Steady (with two fine foxy ladies on the cover)--never heard of it until I looked at Amazon today, and allmusic doesn't mention it. Anybody heard it? For what it's worth, I really like both versions of Dennehy and the Don't Give Up collaboration with Polyphonic, and Gasoline Rainbows, but have found it impossible to get into either Friday Night or Conversations With Kenny. Beyond that the guy's stuff gets sort of blurry. A wide-ranging compilation (or at least a playlist) might help put him into focus.

Anybody else blown away by the new Bootsy album? 

Jul 25, 2011 10:47PM
avatar
but you should be aware that it's unlikely any of the money you spend there goes to the copyright holders.
You know Jeff, I figured that. I went to the website to find stuff not easily obtained or grossly overpriced and got seduced into purchasing the current stuff. Why I don't feel as guilty ripping stuff into iTunes that I get free from the public library I'm not sure. As a music junkie I must get 5 or 6 new titles a week, and I would say that half of these I pay the going rate for. Maybe that's my justification. Besides in the case of Into the Unknown by Bad Religion, I would have purchased it legally years ago had the band in question not disowned it and refused to release it on cd.
Jul 25, 2011 10:35PM
avatar
Do me a favor though, if this is worth it to you, send a few bucks on behalf of the victims in Oslo.
Guys, the compassion for the victims and families of Norway is admiral, but it's not your money they need right now. Norway is one of the most democratic and wealthy (per capita GDP) welfare states on earth. As dreadful as recent events are, it's but a blip compared to the famine unraveling in the Horn of Africa as we speak. Well upwards of 10 million at risk. If your feeling generous: Mercy Corps, Oxfam, UNICEF -- take your pick. I really don't mean to belittle the Norwegian tragedy, but that's exactly what it is -- a tragedy, not a crises.
Jul 25, 2011 10:34PM
avatar
Phew!!! Probably would have been a logistical nightmare anyway. Valiantly trying to latch onto something Cam wants for once rather than the other way around, I guess.
I wonder if the other Amazon seller (the $1475 one: Joseseis) is Joe Six-Pack (of slipcue.com).
Jul 25, 2011 9:59PM
avatar
that 40-disc Todo Caetano box
I was very joking about that! (just amazed at the price tag at you-know-where.) Believe me, there is so much great Brazilian music that I'm finding right now, it's like an open well. I truly appreciate all the kind remarks, but I want you all to know that it really makes me feel good to know that other people enjoy all this music that I've been gifted with in large part to paying attention to our host for so long. Everything that you all have to say about what you are listening to and thinking about more than makes up for the time and effort I put in here. That makes my day, over and over.
Jul 25, 2011 9:49PM
avatar
Maybe this is foolishness, but I'm wondering if maybe we could get a dozen or so people together to fork over, say, fifty bucks each to buy Cam that 40-disc Todo Caetano box. I see it available for $650 at http://goo.gl/mIjDF. If we could form a consortium to buy this box for Cam, maybe we could each who contribute also get the music files in the box on a few DVD-Rs. A lot of you think packaging matters (not me), but couldn't you too use 40-discs worth (probably not overly long ones, since they reproduce the lps) of the man who, according to Xgau: "... if some polyglot wanted to call him the greatest popular musician of our era, I wouldn't be inclined to argue. I'd just shrug."? I'd be willing to try to administer this scheme, if there is interest, or we could have the box sent staight to Cam and let him burn and send out the DVD-Rs (or put them up in the cloud, if there's enough room up there).
Jul 25, 2011 9:41PM
avatar
Just how good is that Pokey Lafarge and the South City Three album("Middle of Everywhere) streaming at NPR first listen? I'd say right up there with that Carolina Chocolate Drops album Xgau A-listed way back, whose music terrain they share: up tempo old-timey, ministrely blues stuff. Great musicianship.
Jul 25, 2011 9:17PM
avatar
John: I think what you've come across is one of the services that operates on the basis of a loophole in Russian copyright law that allows sites to sell an unlimited quantity of MP3s for a flat license fee. Soundsbox.com is registered in Luxembourg, but this page goo.gl/zbVGn suggests that it's a Russian site.  An old BBC article about the phenomenon: goo.gl/3lLYl.  The legality of these services in the U.S. still hasn't been tested in court as far as I know.  I wouldn't worry too much about getting in trouble for using it, but you should be aware that it's unlikely any of the money you spend there goes to the copyright holders.
Jul 25, 2011 8:38PM
avatar
Cam, your gift is most appreciated.  Thank you.  If Christopher has a suggested charity fund of choice, I am ready to contribute.
Jul 25, 2011 8:26PM
avatar
 If you'd like I can burn you some Caetano.
That would be so cool. (insert one of Alex's smileys here)
Jul 25, 2011 8:08PM
avatar

Happy to say my daily playlist will now include Zaire Choc! - Thanks Cam

Haven't picked up the Serengeti cds yet but plan to soon.

An online search for The Three Johns' World By Storm led me to the Soundbox.com website which was offering cds the download for between 1 or 2 bucks, or 14 cents a song. It sounded too good to be true but I gave them 25 bucks and come away with some good to great lost classics or simply stuff I didn't have on cd. Here are a few, World By StormMoby Grape, T-Bone Burnett's Proof Through the Night, George Adams & Don Pullen's Breakthrough, Bad Religion's Into the Unknown, as well as some Elton and Marley that I only have on vinyl. Not only that I picked up the recently reviewed here cds by The Battles, Jerry Lee Lewis, Gold Panda, and the Garland Jeffery's comp Wild in the Streets. All that and more for 25 bucks, still seems too good to be true, but sound quality seems fine to these ears. Anyone else gotten music this way, I'm curious? Thanks again Cam.

Jul 25, 2011 7:58PM
avatar
Oh, I see -- one "improvement" is that you're forced to watch a little advertisement (or at least be aware it's going on), when you switch modes now. Pricks.
Jul 25, 2011 7:10PM
avatar
Cam: If you'd like I can burn you some Caetano. I may have some that you don't and would love to help you on your way.
Jul 25, 2011 7:07PM
avatar
Cam, thank you again for your unceasing generosity.
Jul 25, 2011 7:01PM
avatar

Sky Full of Holes: Heard the singles, heard the songs at the show, resisted the download but had to do the stream. One listen in, it kills from the heart. Signs of maturity from a band that was mature enough on arrival. Chris is clearly writing more, which is good because his tongue is always less in his cheek and his chord changes less saturated in homage. Don’t get me wrong: Traffic and Weather was as terrific a manifesto as we could hope from American jewel Adam Schlesinger, but the absence of that novelty feel it took on when you weren’t quite in the mood is welcomed by these ears as an encouraging development from a band that just keeps improving. I like Michael’s imagined scenario of them not having taken over the world and being bummed about it, but think they’re too modest to have ever been much more ambitious than just making the living they probably aren’t; since most of this country isn’t either, I figure they’re simply tapping into the people’s pain. I wonder if Christgau won’t take to the slight retreat from clarity, but predict a DL spot either way.

 

The belt-tightened production is perfect for the material, too. Still, it sounds like it demands (& deserves) serious growing time. I cannot wait to spend money on it.

Jul 25, 2011 6:42PM
avatar
Thank you muchly Cam - I've been tracking that particular disc for years and it's always been - for no real reason - one of the worst of the price-gouges for out-of-print discs.

I'll gladly search out a relief for Norway fund and contribute.  Spiting Glenn Beck in the process? Bonus!

Jul 25, 2011 6:22PM
avatar

Thanks for the heads-up, Richard. I've really been looking forward to it.

 

EDIT: Just finished listening to it. Wow.

Jul 25, 2011 5:57PM
avatar
New Fountains of Wayne streaming on their facebook page.
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap