Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Lobi Traore/Sorry Bamba

Mali Gets Loud

By Xgau Jul 26, 2011 3:57AM

 

Lobi Traore: Bwati Kono "In the Club" (Kanaga System Krush)

Although I've never heard this Malian guitarist's Bamako or Bambara Blues, I admired his quick, clean, tightly hypnotic 1996 Segou‑-which hardly prepared me for either of the two albums to appear since he died last year at 49. Rainy Season Blues is one of those solo acoustic sitdowns that authenticity fetishists pine for and I'm too crass to get through twice when the songs are in English. This is the opposite‑-loud, electric band jams from a late-night club in an early-to-bed city and "a well-known Nigerian `Hotel,'" whatever that means. I do ask myself why I'm more likely to enjoy the form from the number five Malian guitarist than from, say, Jeff Beck. Intensity of self-creation, partly, plus I remain a big Hound Dog Taylor fan. Traore cuts Taylor. But the 10-minute "Ya Time" ("Someone who has lost their mother and father") could actually pass for blues in the land of Ali Farka Toure, which claims blues a lot more often than it gets within 3000 miles of them. A MINUS

 

Sorry Bamba: Volume One 1970-1979 (Thrill Jockey)

Before there was a Rail Band, this nobly born singer-trumpeter-flutist led a dance troupe and a musical ensemble in the provincial Malian city of Mopti. The Rail Band was more elegant and complex‑-Bamba was no Salif Keita or Mory Kante vocally, and when Rail Band stalwart Kanté Manfila steps up for a track here, the delicacy of his guitar technique makes for a nice change. Bamba doesn't put forth a consistent sound. He was in show business, and though his core audience was more provincial than the travelers who came through Bamako station, they liked having clave and Ethiopian horns and baby-got-back mixed in with their griot-approved staples. But that's a positive--fun, really. Combined with amenities only Bamba could provide‑-his trumpet, his flute, his specialty in Dogon culture, and most spectacularly a thousand-year-old showpiece featuring an impossible hectoring chant for a long-departed emir‑-the groove that asserts itself has crude satisfactions all its own. A MINUS

 

169Comments
Jul 28, 2011 10:23PM
avatar
Thanks to all for the suggestions about San Fran. Much to my surprise, my visit got extended so I'll be in Palo Alto all evening Friday. Bummer. But I may be coming back and if so will try to do a little more planning ahead to get into the city. See you then folks.
Jul 28, 2011 5:30PM
avatar
Has anyone heard Buck 65's newly posted tribute to Toronto slugger Jose Bautista?

http://soundcloud.com/buck65/joey-bats

It's likely most relevant to Blue Jays fans like me, but it's worth a listen.

Jul 28, 2011 5:11PM
avatar
Current listening:  A Jill Scott/Raphael Saadiq combo of 94 songs (including 19 from Tony! Toni! Tone!, which would upset the brothers but sure sounds good to me).  On random.
Jul 28, 2011 4:44PM
avatar
Has anyone seen Los Van Van recently?  They are playing next weekend at a jazz club and I have never seen them.  Are they still worth seeing?  I've missed them every time they've come around.
Jul 28, 2011 4:29PM
avatar
Spotify and eMusic both have Sorry Bamba's Le tonnerre Dogon, reputedly his best studio album. It's less overtly Malian and more in the international Afropop style of the Eighties, but I'm a big fan of the international Afropop style of the Eighties.
Jul 28, 2011 3:15PM
avatar
I thought I remembered reading in one of Kerouac's biography's that Snyder had sent Kerouac an angry letter after Dharma Bums was published--something about a special circle of hell for mendacious or dishonest poets. But maybe I've confused him with Kenneth Rexroth, whose dislike of Kerouac and his work (apparently, the feeling was mutual) was a matter of some public record.
Robert - You may well be right, as I'm sure there was some back and forth on the whole matter. Still, it's worth pointing out that Kerouac himself was always pretty upfront about his own shortcomings regarding Buddhism - he never claimed to be much more than an interested bystander. This comes out in an interview he did with Ben Hecht in 1958, which I first heard on Rhino's The Beat Generation box set (that thing is a walking definition of a mixed bag). The interview is interesting partly because there's a degree of animosity between Hecht and Kerouac, which is kind of a shame, as Hecht was no conformist himself. Hecht presses him a bit on, among other things, his description in Dharma Bums of the Yab-Yum ritual, which in the book seems little more than just a good excuse to get naked with a bunch of ladies. Kerouac somewhat sheepishly admits that his interpretation was "sloppy Yab-Yum," which I've always found kind of endearing.

**edit - I believe "the old anarchist fud" giving a reading at The Six Gallery in Dharma Bums was a thinly veiled portrait of Rexroth, and the impression definitely infuriated him.
Jul 28, 2011 3:03PM
avatar
Cy: You are very correct. Looks like they did misname & thus switch those two tracks. I've corrected the metadata, transposed the tracks in my playlist, and re-burned the disc. CDDB also recognizes the change as being correct. Glad you caught this.
Jul 28, 2011 2:55PM
avatar
Milo--had this kicking around: https://dl.dropbox.com/s/8vts5rgeksg1kgv/the%20blue%20estuaries.aif?dl=1
Jul 28, 2011 2:48PM
avatar

Jason, thanks for the correction. I thought I remembered reading in one of Kerouac's biography's that Snyder had sent Kerouac an angry letter after Dharma Bums was published--something about a special circle of hell for mendacious or dishonest poets. But maybe I've confused him with Kenneth Rexroth, whose dislike of Kerouac and his work (apparently, the feeling was mutual) was a matter of some public record.

Jul 28, 2011 2:29PM
avatar
Beginning to read Steve Knopper's Appetite for Self-Destruction.  I'm only on the first few pages, but I enjoy it a lot.  Noticed a little hiccup, though.  "[Neil Bogart of Casablanca Records] presented Donna Summer, when she flew from Germany to New York to promote her Love to Love You Baby album, with a life-size cake that looked exactly like her.  It was even the same size."
Jul 28, 2011 2:06PM
avatar
Cam,

the others made good points about the walk that I regrettably failed to mention.  Sorry about that.  If you decide to go, cabbing to and from the Mezzanine is better.
Jul 28, 2011 1:55PM
avatar
Gary Snyder was so ticked at Kerouac's portrayal of him that it basically ended their friendship, to the point where I don't think he's ever commented on Kerouac (someone please correct me if that's untrue. I went through my Kerouac phase almost 30 years ago and haven't read much of or about him since).
Robert, I can't say for certain reports of Snyder's annoyance is untrue, but he has gone on record several times about both Kerouac and Dharma Bums, and it hasn't always been unpleasant. He certainly took issue with Kerouac's rather creative interpretation of Buddhism, being particularly bothered by the way the religion was used by Jack to prop up some of the more blatant misogynistic tendencies of the Beat collective. But he also apparently corresponded several times with Kerouac and thanked him for his portrayal. I suspect that Snyder was bound to grow more frustrated with the book as he continued to delve deeper into Buddhism - both Kerouac's interpretation and perhaps even some of Snyder's own reported dialogue must have started to seem simplistic. As it is, Kerouac seemed most interested in Zen as a way to explore his own interests and explain/justify some of his own tendencies, whereas Snyder really can be credited with helping to spread the "gospel" (wrong term, definitely) of Zen to the states. That is, he really was a true believer, which might be why his translation of Buddhist poetry stands as some of the finest examples we have in English.

I think much of this is discussed in John Suiter's book Poets On The Peaks, which is a lovely photography book with text that any fan of Beat-era writing would probably enjoy.
Jul 28, 2011 1:23PM
avatar

This has been a great conversation, so let me just add that whoever said that Dharma Bums is superior to On The Road has my full agreement (both books stop off in my wife's hometown of Rocky Mount, NC, where Kerouac's sister lived for years--in On The Road it's disguised as "Testament, Virginia"), even though Gary Snyder was so ticked at Kerouac's portrayal of him that it basically ended their friendship, to the point where I don't think he's ever commented on Kerouac (someone please correct me if that's untrue. I went through my Kerouac phase almost 30 years ago and haven't read much of or about him since).

 

And, hello Milo, we will have an upright piano in our house sometime soon--my wife just inherited one from her late grandmother. Doubt we'll have any singalongs, though...

Jul 28, 2011 1:12PM
avatar
 The cover gives what I assume was the original and intended running order.  However, on my d/l, "They Called It Rock" (the Nick Lowe  song that xgau references) is mislabeled as "Cry One More Time" (the J. Geils song) and vice versa.

 In addition to songs Bob didn't go into detail on, I like her "Cry One More Time" and the live "Las Vegas" (Gram Parsons) is on fire.  Speaking of Parsons, he also covered "Cry One More Time", which may be how Linda came to do it.
Jul 28, 2011 12:51PM
avatar
"What makes you think those crowd noises [on "Sekou Amadou"] are canned?"

The starting and stopping of the noises. In particular, the applause at 3:26 on sounds to me to reduce like someone sliding a fader instead of dying off organically. I might be wrong: maybe it's just a disciplined audience, in which case (and I'm sure I'm the millionth person to say this): sorry Sorry Bamba.

Anyway, re-listening has let me decide that I like the song after all.
Jul 28, 2011 12:34PM
avatar
Cy: CDDB doesn't seem to think any songs are reversed, and the line-up seems to jibe with the album cover (or is that the back cover?) shown in the JPG. Or are the songs wrongly named? I need to listen to it now (and to Together). Can't wait!
LATER: Turns out songs are wrongly named and thus reversed in MP3 download.
[I use print-outs of Xgau's reviews as liner notes in the other side of the CD sleeve. Makes even the C-minuses worth having? If I'm curious for more info, I can find plenty of it online.]
Jul 28, 2011 12:06PM
avatar
International Affair sounds good.  It has an interesting "genre" attached to it by the artist: "country and folk", when there's practically no folk at all and a good deal of rock.  Also, the track names for songs 3 and 4 need to be reversed, as does the number of total tracks, which is ten and not eleven.  Cover art is included but no liner notes, so I dug up the following listing of musicians, composers, etc.:

 ROSE238 - LINDA GAIL LEWIS - International Affair - LP/CD
I can help (Billy Swan)
We were both wrong (B.Murray)
Cry one more time (Wolf, Justman)
They called it rock (N.Lowe + D.Edmunds)
Clean cut kid (Bob Dylan)
A.I. on the jukebox (D.Edmunds, W.Birch)
Suddenly single (Butch Hornsby)
Tongue and cheek (D.Gillepsie)
I feel so bad (Temple, Johnson)
Las Vegas (live) (Gram Parsons, Rick Grech)
Linda Gail Lewis, vocals, piano - Maury O'Rourk, guitar, vocals on Las Vegas - Doug Garrison, drums, Jim Spake, baritone sax - Doug Easley, lead guitar - Ron Easley, bass, bull fiddle - James Eddie Campbell, guitar, dobro - Buddy Church, lead guitar - Ray Gann, bass - Fred Normann - drums, Alex Greene, organ - Robert Tinsley, vocals on Cry One - Steve forbert, harmonica - Swain Shaeffer, piano, organ - Mary Jean Harrelson, vocals - Robbie Turne, steel guitar - Misty White, percussion
recorded and mixed at Easley Recordings, Memphis, TN / produced by Maury O'Rourk

Jul 28, 2011 12:00PM
avatar
Finished Love Is a Mix Tape last night.  Probably my favorite thing I've ever read.  Hilarious, devastating, fulfilling.  The way Rob loves his wife, the way Rob loves music, the way Rob just plain love**** close to home for me.

Nice touch at the end, calling The Hold Steady a local bar band (I think that part was written in 2005, so maybe Separation Sunday hadn't even hit).  It's great knowing that the band he adored at the end would become something special.  I bet he knew back then, too.
Jul 28, 2011 11:53AM
avatar

I just downloaded International Affair last week.  i was happy to get it after all this time.  The website is not exactly high touch, but I had no problems paying by paypal and being issued a download link to my email account.

 

I have Together on vinyl only, so i may have to follow the link Cyclops graciously provided when I am at home.

Jul 28, 2011 10:17AM
avatar
 Chris:  Thanks for the pointer.  I've been on a "Lewis family" kick lately, though not to the extent of Mickey Gilley or spoken word Jimmy Swaggart.
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap