Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Spoek Mathambo/Big K.R.I.T.

Think Positive--Or Not

By Xgau Apr 10, 2012 1:14AM

Spoek Mathambo: Father Creeper (Sub Pop)

Although I slotted this Soweto-raised 27-year-old's 2010 Mshini Wam as promising kwaito electro, I never imagined it promised a hip-hop record so dark it reveals his labelmate Shabazz Palaces for the arty pothead we can assume he is. Contra the nervous crits who claim to hear a "palpable feeling of hope" or "summery highlife melodies" (highlife, eh? I've heard of that‑-African, right?), even the sweet opener about the sexual maturation of a guy who was feeling it before his pubes came in ends ominously. After that come evocations of oppression only more brutal because they're sometimes dissociated‑-blood diamonds, why we hate our crap jobs, the deadening surrender of the tricking American hip-hop makes light of. The music suits because it's also dissociated‑-beaty enough to keep your foot tapping and your subconscious involved, but devoid of the escapist joy that is the miracle of so much Afropop produced from equally horrendous daily struggles. A

 

Big K.R.I.T.: 4Eva N a Day (free download)

He was just Kritikal, but the Mississippi underground had trouble pronouncing that word‑-check out the consonant-averse "1986" intro to understand why‑-so he made it Big K.R.I.T., claimed it stood for King Remembered in Time, and continued a rapping career that imagined high school coaching as a fallback. No hip-hopper has ever been bigger on getting up when you're down and making every minute count. Could get tiresome, but on a no-cameos mixtape Def Jam couldn't clear, his proudly drawled, lucidly conceived preachments go undefeated. Almost every soulful track grew on me, with the clincher "Down & Out," one of his periodic explanations of why sometimes he sips and smokes instead of trying yet again. A MINUS

 

232Comments
Apr 12, 2012 1:17PM
avatar

in the interest of liking to advertize lists i've made, voila!

 

1. OutKast - Hey Ya!
2. R. Kelly - Ignition (Remix)
3. Drive-By Truckers - Marry Me
4. Fountains of Wayne - Stacy's Mom
5. Todd Snider - Beer Run
6. Lil Jon - Get Low (Remix)
7. John Mayer - Daughters
8 . Missy Elliott - Is This Our Last Time?
9. The Postal Service - The District Sleeps Alone Tonight
10. Black Eyed Peas - Let's Get Retarded
 
11. The Wrens - This Boy Is Exhausted
12. The Black Eyed Peas - Where Is the Love?
13. 50 Cent - 21 Questions
14. Brad Paisley - Mud on the Tires
15. Justin Timberlake - Rock Your Body
16. Panjabi MC feat. Jay-Z - Beware
17. John Mayer - Clarity
18. Beyonce feat. Jay-Z - Crazy in Love
19. OutKast - The Way You Move
20. Brad Paisley - Little Moments
 
21. Lucinda Williams - Righteously
22 John Mayer - Bigger Than My Body
23. Kelis - Milkshake
24. Chingy - Right Thurr
25. 50 Cent - In Da Club
26. OutKast - Roses
27. Missy Elliott - Pass That Dutch
28. The Roots feat. Cody Chesnutt - The Seed (2.0)
29. The Postal Service - Such Great Heights
30. Alicia Keys - You Don't Know My Name

 

 

Apr 12, 2012 1:14PM
avatar
1. I enjoyed the Kay Huntington in a way similar to the Mars Attacks! aliens enjoyed Slim Whitman.

2. Now that I think about it, the alien disguised as a woman is rather draggy, right?

3. I'm a few tracks into Father Creeper--so far so good. I do like the dark-but-uptempo business. "Beaty enough to keep your foot tapping and your subconscious involved" hits it on the head.

4. Nicky told me that Xgau gave the Spoek album an A because "Kites" features an under-appreciated woman character named Irene. (As far as I can make out, she puts on a dumb girl pretense and her man doesn't treat her nice, so Spoek comes to the rescue wanting to make an honest woman of her cuz she's pretty.) Somehow I imagine the Dean wouldn't back such a claim. :)

5. I should always take my amphetamines when EW needs more comments....

Apr 12, 2012 12:38PM
avatar
Yeah, the Chiddy Bang (lame name) is good! :)
Apr 12, 2012 12:30PM
avatar
Hahahahahahaa ok Mitch, now that you say that it seems obvious and I feel like a weirdo....
Apr 12, 2012 12:24PM
avatar
Kevin:
we know you're trying to uphold your social order as the natural one.
Isn't "natural" a little bit on the assumption side? Wouldn't something like "commonly recognized" or at worst "familiar with" be more accurate? And less blaming? My point being, don't we all do that? Don't your comments do the same thing, with "preferred" being the substitute word?  Maybe? Maybe not, I don't know. And better, how would we not do that? Other than to take it on as a full-time project?

Not intending to be critical but more like curious since this is way beyond any field of study I've engaged in. And also not apologizing for my full-time efforts at chipping away at the inequities of the currently existing social order where I find and recognize them.
Apr 12, 2012 12:19PM
avatar
Hairy Irene: OMG, no! LOL. I was thinking more of SJP's status as gay icon on a dog many gay men own.
Apr 12, 2012 12:07PM
avatar
After three plays I seem to be tracking closer to Tom Hull than Christgau on Spoek Mathambo's album--a bit buzzy and atmospheric for my tastes, but then it took me forever to warm to Shabazz Palaces, so I'll keep at it. Big K.R.I.T., on the other hand, sounds so decent and approachable I want to take him out to lunch (and while we're at it, let's hear it for free rap albums!). And if no one minds, can I put in a good word for the more legible and catchy (and less buzzy) end of the rap spectrum? Chiddy Bang's Breakfast sounds even better today than it did the last time I mentioned it here. BBU's bell hooks (another free one!) is filling the loud political rap-rock void nicely (I also like the real bell hooks, and an album with her picture on the cover gets an almost automatic thumbs-up from me). As for Plug 1 and Plug 2, what can I say? I like everything they've ever done (I even liked that weird workout tape thing they put out a year or two ago). I've said it before and it bears repeating: listening to Pos and Dave rhythm-talk is like listening to Dr. John play the piano (or Lester Young play the saxophone)--pure effortless pleasure, and First Serve is pretty great. As always with these rap-opera concept albums, I can't follow the story (something about childhood buds reaching for fame and fortune in the rap game and straining their friendship in the process) but the guys sound pumped and thrilled to be surrounded by all the disco beats, and if there were any justice in the world "Must B The Music" would be a worldwide smash (but there isn't and it won't be). Good goddamn album.

And hey, speaking of legible (and disco beats), what do people get out of hating on Roman Reloaded? I just can't bring myself to resist anything this filthy and funny and clever and alive (like Roman himself, I also beez in the trap). I know people are a little taken-aback by all the dancefloor anthems, but I'll just point out that these are as chewy and lovable as anything I've ever heard by Robyn. This is Nicki's time--let's bask in it.

Apr 12, 2012 11:45AM
avatar
Mars Attacks! was my favorite movie when I was 9.
avatar
The main song I'm mad I forgot was "The Seed 2.0" I'm mad that I just skipped by that, don't know how I did that. The other songs I see people listing that I like I skipped due to attempting to stick to singles as singles.
Apr 12, 2012 11:38AM
avatar
As I recall you associated him with the "twisted little cult that wastes time fawning over [the] deeply wretched." Then a page or so later you complained about claims that you're rude or obnoxious, which makes your request for mercy a bit funny.

I will let everyone else decide if this is an accurate representation or not.

Apr 12, 2012 11:33AM
avatar
Not disputing, just unsure: what makes SJP-chihuahua splicing a queer image? The only thing I can come up with off the top of my head is the age-old equation of homosexuality and bestiality...am I crazy?
Apr 12, 2012 11:27AM
avatar
Hairy Irene: Mars Attacks! Good one. Sarah Jessica's head on the body of a chihuahua is a queer image but the 90s SFXs stitched onto the 50s sci-fi plot feels very camp, but not queer.
Apr 12, 2012 11:11AM
avatar
And I tried listening to Kay Huntington this morning. At first, it seemed like campy fun, but that vibrato is an affected drag by the third track. And our host is right. "The Right to Poverty" sounds so misguided. She's never been poor, huh?
Apr 12, 2012 11:07AM
avatar
Mark--totally didn't realize that tAtU song was 2003. It can be my #20!

Mitch--I thought about including a Postal Service or Death Cab single, but I think I wore them out with all my wistful sophomore year mix CDs that coincided with the entire 365 day period I was grounded in high school.

Also Mitch (and k j)--is Mars Attacks! camp? If so, is it queer? Maybe I just haven't noticed it because despite its silliness it still terrifies the heck out of me.

Apr 12, 2012 11:00AM
avatar
kevin john: And thanks for those (combatative) notes on camp. I look forward to reading those books. One question though I've haven't seen these books: what's camp that isn't queer? Plan 9 from Outer Space seems to be a great example, but I'm hard pressed to mention something more recent. Also, is it primarily a visual medium at this point? A lot of music seems to have camp elements, like say Deee-Lite or Madonna, but they don't really seem camp.
Apr 12, 2012 10:44AM
avatar
So in the interest of getting the comments up to 200, here's my list, roughly in order of preference.

Crazy in Love, Beyonce feat. Jay-Z
Rock Your Body, Justin Timberlake
Hey Ya, Outkast
House of Jealous Lovers, The Rapture
Everyone Choose Sides, The Wrens
Bright Future in Sales, Fountains of Wayne
Outfit, Drive-By Truckers
Beware (Jay-Z Remix), Panjabi MC feat. Jay-Z
Entropy, MC Hawking
Me and Guiliani Down By the Schoolyard, !!!
Such Great Heights, The Postal Service
The Way You Move, Outkast feat. Sleepy Brown
Beer Run, Todd Snyder
The Seed (2.0), The Roots & Cody Chestnutt
Hurt, Johnny Cash
Cameltoe, Fannypack
Maps, Yeah Yeah Yeahs
A.D.I.D.A.S., Killer Mike feat. Big Boi
Gay Bar, Electric Six
He War, Cat Power

I should have added a bunch of also-rans, but it would have been overwhelming. Wish I remembered "Wicked and Weird". It's the one thing on that album that works out of context.
Apr 12, 2012 10:36AM
avatar
This one goes to 13. I had to cut out some stuff (I do like the Wrens, etc.) cuz of dating, and I really did get lost in is-it-a-single? semantics. That said, there's plenty of good songs I have now seen listed that I didn't even remember to consider, so I could've done better. Two more notes: Not remotely surprised that my #1 didn't make the top 40 (also not surprised that Ryan was the other voter; hey man). Also, I lived in Italy for the first half of 2003, and experiencing the t.A.T.u. phenomenon in Europe was filching amazing. You'd walk in to get your coffee in the morning and the old man at the cash register would have his eyes glued to the lesbian psychodrama video playing on his tiny little screen while this screechy chorale literally swallowed all other conversation in coffee bar. I experienced this for weeks, and it never got tiring. I do think that song still seems rather intense and desperate for teen pop.

Jens Lekman, “Maple Leaves”

The Roots and Cody Chestnutt, “The Seed (2.0)”

The Postal Service, “Such Great Heights”

White Stripes, “Seven Nation Army”

Panjabi MC with Jay-Z, “Beware of the Boys (Mundian to Bach Ke)”

Yeah Yeah Yeahs, “Maps”

Raveonettes, “That Great Love Sound”

t.A.T.u., “All the Things She Said”

Outkast, “Hey Ya”

Belle and Sebastian, “I’m a Cuckoo”

Justin Timberlake, “Rock Your Body”

New Pornographers, “The Laws Have Changed”

50 Cent, “In Da Club”

Apr 12, 2012 10:30AM
avatar
Fiiiiine Milo, make me feel guilty why don't you. It certainly stokes the fire around here though wouldn't you say? If the discourse continues apace we may break 200 comments for the first time since Todd Snider/Mag Fields! For the record that is the last set of reviews onto which I excreted an appreciable quantity/quality of comments, aside from last one's sci-fi talk. (Predicting >5 thumbs down for making that observation.) *Curtsies*

I pledge to cease and desist my mindless Milo-heckling and save my sass for the next time you truly bother me. You might try to be more agreeable to make this less of a challenge. On that note, your wish for Kevin's alternative phrasing might have been an option for him had you phrased your argument more pacificly in the first place. As I recall you associated him with the "twisted little cult that wastes time fawning over [the] deeply wretched." Then a page or so later you complained about claims that you're rude or obnoxious, which makes your request for mercy a bit funny.

Also wrt Alan's list, surely I'm not the first to note its phallocentrism, in addition to its gleaming whiteness. 
Apr 12, 2012 9:55AM
avatar
But that's cuz I like bloodsport
For the record, I absolutely don't. I do not enjoy arguing with people, online or in real life. I find it upsetting and depressing.

I really wish at the outset, Kevin John could have said "you're misunderstanding where I'm coming from" and there would never have been any conflict.
Apr 12, 2012 9:49AM
avatar
aahhhh goddammit.  we we're considering "Through the Wire" as 2003?  I mean, i know it was released as a single then, and so was "Slow Jamz," but the album was 2004 (which i thought was our governing criteria) and it was prevalent in P&J's 2004 poll, not 2003.

I've got to think a few voters decided they were 2004 singles, because I was surprised neither made the top 30.
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap