Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Odds and Ends 016

The Young Songsters, Band Division

By Xgau Oct 2, 2012 5:26AM


The Dirty Projectors: Swing Lo Magellan (Domino)

Melodies you want to hear again for their shapes and harmonies alone, lyrics of discernible emotional import that include the cheerful verbal preset "that doesn't make any sense what you just said" ("Maybe That Was It," "Dance for You") ***


The D.A.: You Kids! (self-released)

Driving, melodic, engaged, humane, disillusioned v-k-g-b-d-trumpet from El Paso, which emerges as one of the cities David Byrne ended up living in ("We Hungry," "Orange & Black") ***

 

Leland Sundries: The Foundry EP (L'Echiquier)

Not Lou meets Leonard, children, Eef meets Jonathan, and just as dark and droll ("Giving Up Redheads," "Apparition") **

 

The Soft Pack: Strapped (Mexican Summer)

Out on their own, g-g-b-d survey the song-friendly precincts of the big wide indie-rock world and try a little of this and a little of that ("Saratoga," "Bound to Fall") **


Carolina Chocolate Drops: Leaving Eden (Nonesuch)

Novelty revivals yes, theme statements no‑-please, I'm begging, no-o-o-o ("Boodle-De-Bum-Bum," "Ruby, Are You Mad at Your Man?") **

 

Swearin': Swearin' (Salinas)

As her sister Katie toegazes with her Waxahatchie side project/one-off, Allison Crutchfield dons the grrrl-punk mantle with less musical, verbal, and vocal distinctness ("Movie Star," "Hundreds and Thousands") **

 

The Very Best: MTMTMK (Moshi Moshi)

They'd be better off not being Bloc Party if they didn't wish they were ("Rumbae," "We OK") *

 

Phineas and the Lonely Leaves: The Kids We Used to Be (lonelyleaves.com)

Memories of a Dutchess County puberty ("Come Back to Peekskill," "The Bros. of Summer") *


93Comments
Oct 5, 2012 2:01AM
avatar
 Thank you all for the views on Hickey.  And also for not biting my head off re: my preliminary diss of him based on an out of date and inaccurate Wiki-P. 

 I want to add some thoughts on that this topic over the w/e, though- outside of the various authors and books mentioned.

 Cyclops703
Oct 4, 2012 10:53PM
avatar
The Rock & Roll Hall of Fame nominees are out, and all the random people on the Internet put together get a ballot (on Rolling Stone's website, natch). Congratulations in advance to Rush for receiving this vital 1/600th of the vote.
Oct 4, 2012 9:01PM
avatar
"The embossed Liberace lettering came off in the dishwasher within a year."

My Liberace Museum Xmas-tree ornament is doing just fine, as is the Elvis-themed diner-style napkin dispenser from the defunct Elvis Museum, thenkyou, thenkyou, thenkyou verra much.

Billed as the second best outside of Graceland, it wasn't much of a much. The Plain Dude supermuscle limo-car he had before the marvels at Graceland was fascinating. There were other trinkets. You had to pay extra to hear the Elvis imitators. Oh, man. Place got burglarized, which led to the downfall. We can't go on together with suspicious bottom lines.
Oct 4, 2012 6:50PM
avatar
Anybody read the new Junot Diaz, "This Is How You Lose Her"?  I really liked the flow of conversations, quite musical in a way.  While each story/chapter had its own charms, in the end I felt a bit underwhelmed.  I didn't expect another "Oscar Wao," that's not realistic, but I'm wondering if I'm missing something.
Oct 4, 2012 6:13PM
avatar
I love Hickey too. Here's a juicy promissory note:

His forthcoming books include Pagan America from Free Press, Pirates and Farmers: Essays on Culture and the Marketplacefrom Karsten Schubert, London, and Connoisseur of Waves: More Essays on Art and Democracy, from the University of Chicago Press.
Oct 4, 2012 4:54PM
avatar

Nice (and kind of sad) part of Neil's book is page 45 when he talks about Bruce losing Clarence and him Ben Keith, and how there's like an empty place where their parts were; they are irreplaceable personally but musically also: "Those parts are not going to happen again. They already did. That takes away a lot of our repertoires."

 

Gary Johnson for Pres.

Oct 4, 2012 3:45PM
avatar
I teach the Liberace essay and got to the museum before it closed. It was a trip, including a full-scale imitator playing piano from his wheelchair. I bought a tapered lavender coffee mug there. The embossed Liberace lettering came off in the dishwasher within a year.


Oct 4, 2012 3:03PM
avatar
"Hickey's essay on Liberace is one of his best."

Indeed. There's a sad footnote, though. The Liberace Museum, which ends the essay on a note of triumph with its grand opening, shut down in 2010. Two big problems: it was built on land Liberace owned, but it was out in the middle of nowhere, a good ways from the big Vegas action (this was also a liability for the Elvis Museum in Vegas, which likewise closed); the museum undertook an expensive renovation/expansion with exquisitely bad timing just before the economy hit the dirt. A shame -- the revamped place was as glam and glory as anybody could want.
Oct 4, 2012 2:46PM
avatar
Hickey's essay on Liberace is one of his best. It's so easy to go all-out academic with Mister Showmanship, or all-out camp, or all-out glamor. It's so easy to sneer. It' so easy to get it all wrong. Hickey manages to avoid condescension while never forgetting that what was great about Liberace was his bad taste, or, more accurately, his "bad taste". What was the quote Xgau singled out in his review?  "Good taste is the residue of someone else's privilege".
Oct 4, 2012 2:22PM
avatar
Milo: His wife is tenured at UNM, though. He seemed glad enough to get out of LV. He's a few years older than me and has better things to do than teach. Let's hope he does them. He is slow.


Oct 4, 2012 1:27PM
avatar

"Air Guitar is a better book than I Lost It at the Movies, Against Interpretation, or, sh!t, Grown Up All Wrong. "

 

Peter Schjeldahl's Let's See: Writings on Art also belongs in that stellar company...

Oct 4, 2012 12:36PM
avatar
"Hickey hasn't been tenured at UNLV for years"

Somehow I did not know this. That sux -- thought that teaching gig was one of the rare examples of just rewards in the arts-writing world.
Oct 4, 2012 12:35PM
avatar
Public Enemy jamming with Rush = the Rock and Roll HOF Induction Ceremony of my dreams
Oct 4, 2012 12:23PM
avatar
Greel
Air Guitar is a better book than I Lost It at the Movies, Against Interpretation, or, sh!t, Grown Up All Wrong. See the LA Times review I wrote on my site. When I taught it at Princeton, several students said their lives were changed. Hickey hasn't been tenured at UNLV for years and currently resides in Albuquerque. Politically he's kind of a centrist Democrat only ten times smarter and less predictable, as he is about everything. He looks like he should play a deputy sheriff in Hud.



Oct 4, 2012 12:22PM
avatar

The Yankees, of course, are the GOP of MLB.  They use their built-in financial advantages to keep others locked out of the post-season and lure away talent from less wealthy teams.  Trickle-up economics in action.  (The Red Sox are hardly better for that matter.)  So go ahead and hate my Rangers--I sure do today--but don't pretend for a second that the Yanks are somehow morally superior.

 

Now the A's?  I'd love 'em if they weren't in the AL West, and will root hard for them when (not if, I fear) the Rangers are knocked out.

Oct 4, 2012 12:10PM
avatar

"New Dylan album-much better than a B+."

 

I concur. But only if you skip the last two songs.

Oct 4, 2012 12:09PM
avatar

so please don't kill me because I've always wondered something.

 

Is Greil pronounced as grail, greel or greil ( rhymes with style and "Heil!")

Oct 4, 2012 11:50AM
avatar
I agree with Bob that when Dave Hickey is on, there's nobody more penetrating, concise, even lyrical at times. *Air Guitar: Essays on Art and Democracy* is where to begin. A marvelous recent essay that folks might not know about appears in *Zephyr: Paintings by Gajin Fujita* (pub. by Kemper Museum of Contemporary Art).

And Dawg-gonnit, I've been inspired to finally pick up his very vintage collection of short stories, *Prior Convictions.*

"I had a similar experience to Milo's re seeing The Corin Tucker Band, in that their CD sounded even better after seeing their show."

Yeah, to reiterate, for me the effect of shows on albums has been contained though coherent:

An album I like already can sound better after a good performance

A good performance can make me give an album I can't decide about a serious second chance

A lousy performance does not drag down an album I like already -- the more humane conclusion is that the performers can't bring the recording to life just yet, or that they had an off night.

Finally -- and this is the one that drives PR people crazy -- I have never had a strong performance change my mind about an album I truly did not like -- the more sane conclusion is that the performers can't translate the stage to the studio just yet. The PR pitch is strictly a one-way avenue: if you like the show, the album is better than you think; if you don't like the show, well, they just had a bad night.
Oct 4, 2012 11:18AM
avatar
Very informative Q&A with Greil Marcus on the new Dylan album over at thenation.com. Here are some fun facts I wasn't aware of:

--Dylan's band sucks ("not a strong band. They’re not a challenging band, except for Charlie Sexton, the lead guitar player. There’s no one with an individual sensibility, with his own grasp of a song and where to take it, to challenge Dylan as a singer. The music for the most part is backup. It’s often a repetitive figure played over and over again"). Hats off to Charlie Sexton, and back to rock and roll high school for the rest of those hopeless losers. Repetitive figures played over and over again? On a Dylan album? Good lord.
--The album's a mixed bag, with four cuts "that seem very repetitious, songs with a kind of overblown emphasis that don’t give back what they pretend to contain". Which four? "Duquesne Whistle", "Soon After Midnight", "Narrow Way", and "Pay In Blood". The John Lennon song is one of the good ones. I got that completely backwards.
--The fourteen-minute title cut "doesn’t get boring, and that’s because his engagement with the story he’s telling is so complete". Complete engagement and not boring--always the key to Dylan's greatness.
--The John Lennon song is one of the good ones.

I was going to post some thoughts on the new Van Morrison album, but I'd hate to make a fool of myself again. I can wait.

Oct 4, 2012 10:48AM
avatar
 BT, I listened a bit to the Iris DeMent in the car today- sounds reasonable, but not good music for driving around the SW in the morning.  Maybe iPod music or at least some thing to mellow a soul out.
 I was intrigued by Bob call on Dave Hickey, who I'd never heard of.  Interesting Wiki-P entry.  As a Contrarian, I'd say he sounds far more conservative than I am and- being tenured in Nevada- has a chair because of what I regard as the Western (U.S.) version of political nihilism, i.e., Might makes Right.  
 I haven't read the man, though, so naturally I'm already on the look-out for his books.

 On a purely musical note, I'd really enjoying hearing Iggy on the legacy edition of _Raw Power_.  Dinky? Yes.  Pure, essential Iggy (if you have the dough).
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap