Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Odds and Ends 017

The young(ish) songwriters, pop/rock division

By Xgau Oct 26, 2012 5:19AM

JD McPherson: Signs & Signifiers (Rounder/Histyle)

Reformed Oklahoma art teacher nails rockabilly originals like he's writing haikus ("North Side Gal," "Signs & Signifiers") ***

 

John Mayer: Born and Raised (Columbia)

Grammy-crushing craftsmen can be damned good at saying something in 80 words or thereabouts‑-say 61, or 116 ("Love Is a Verb," "Speak for Me") ***

 

Jens Lekman: I Know What Love Isn't (Secretly Canadian)\

Lost affair leaves him mooning, melodic as ever but too crestfallen to do anything about it ("The World Moves On," "The End of the World Is Bigger Than Love") ***

 

M. Ward: A Wasteland Companion (Merge)

Sad singer-songwriter loses his marbles one marble at a time‑-says so himself ("Primitive Girl," "Clean Slate (For Alex and El Goodo") **

 

Roxanne Potvin: Play (Black Hen)

Clean-cut Canadienne tops shows of intelligence with novelty cover ("I'm Too Sexy," "Barricades") **

 

Stew & the Negro Problem: Making It (TNP)

Back to writing show-tunes-sans-show‑-rock and roll show tunes, sometimes, but always set pieces ("Black Men Ski," "Speed") **

 

Carsie Blanton: Idiot Heart (Carsie Blanton)

Clever gal will sell you impeccably catchy collection of coy songs about her sexual peccadillos for whatever you think they're worth ("Chicken," "Little Death") **

 

Carole King: The Legendary Demos (Rockingale/Hear Music)

Just '60s reference tracks, many piano-only, but the young mother sings the words, especially the ones she didn't write, with such innocence and hope ("Take Good Care of My Baby," "So Goes Love") *


 

45Comments
Oct 30, 2012 6:00AM
avatar
 Washed away with the rain...I hope all is well with those of you in the Mid-Atlantic on Up.
There are many free resources for news if you must get out, but stay in if you can and have the supplies, etc.
Oct 29, 2012 12:01AM
avatar
GIANTS SWEEP!!!! Hope everyone is safe and ready for the storm. I'm reveling in the second World Series championship in 3 years.
Oct 28, 2012 7:09PM
avatar
I also like the way Carole King’s demo turns “Pleasant Valley Sunday” back into a hook-filled pop song. The vocal connects for me in a way that whomever sang the Monkees version never did. This inspired me to look for her own version of “I’m Into Something Good” - didn’t find it though.
Oct 28, 2012 4:35PM
avatar
testing, testing …

I knew of two guys in their late teens, neither of whom had the least interest in fiction, saying they were surprised by how much they enjoyed reading Townshend’s synopsis/story that came with the Quadrophenia album. I’ve no idea if it spurred either of them to seek out fiction to their liking, but I think it was the first indication to me that Townshend was a really good writer - or could be. I then read his short story collection, which was uneven. The good stories were direct, about specific subjects, while the bad ones were vague and pretentious, no different really from his songs in that way. I noted that the three celebrated albums in the Rolling Stone database of his solo career (referenced in the NY Times Review) include two demo collections of future Who songs, and one live album. Though I should add that Who Came First - his first solo - is generally regarded as better than a three star (B) album, and Rough Mix is also favorably reviewed most elsewhere (and is no one’s definition of a solo album). So that leaves a solo career of Who Came First and then work tapes. 

Agreed that Roger Daltrey comes off well in Townshend’s book. He's depicted as hard working and loyal among other attributes. Townshend needed Daltrey (and Moon and Entwistle) to both reach great heights and keep him in check. When it worked it was exceptional.
Oct 27, 2012 4:42PM
avatar
Oh, it might as well rain until September...
Oct 27, 2012 3:28PM
avatar

Michael, Neil Young is a great artist and a great crackpot. If he had his way, Chief Running Sore would be president and we'd all be wearing moccasins, riding mules, toking whacky tobacy all day. So I admit to ignoring chatter about him and his pal Steve Jobs conspiring to make the world safe for audiophiles. Until now. Don't know what claims he makes for Pono in WAGING HEAVY PEACE, but the reporting done by James Trew, Jared Newman, John Biggs, Chris Davies, and Duncan Geere certainly raises hopes. If it's not a pipe dream, it might be something classical, jazz, pop and every other kind of recorded music fan can join hands on.

Oct 27, 2012 9:04AM
avatar
In English-where is the Wussy tribute? Google?
Oct 27, 2012 1:30AM
avatar
Saw Wussy open for Afghan Whigs tonight.  Fourth or fifth time I've seen them this year.  Every time has been different, and every time has been great.  They are extremely tight now, no doubt because of the extensive touring this year, but also seem tired, no doubt because of the extensive touring this year.  There were lots of little embellishments that were new to me, always full-band arrangements rather than individual-solo bits. There was a pretty sizable crowed at the large (for Wussy) venue because of the Afghan Whigs, and they were riveted.  I did not see a single person drift away during Wussy's opening act set.  Instead the crowed seemed to grow in size, focus, intensity as the too-short set built melody on riff on harmony.  Unfortunately, the mercy table at the Metro is placed in a distant room hard to fine and impossible to stumble across and it was not very busy when I stopped by after the show.

Wussy did a couple of songs I had not seen before (one of the pleasures of this band is how much their set lists vary night to night), including "Mountain of Tires" and, Lord help me, "Breakfast In Bed", which left me an utter wreck.  Apparently, singing that song trashes Lisa's voice for a couple of days so they cannot do it every night.  I had never seen the bad do any covers before, but Chuck told me that they play a fair number in rehearsal anyway and have been toying with the idea of an all-covers album (e.g., unnamed Joy Division song, "Gimmie Shelter", sadly no "You Like Me Too Much").   


Oct 26, 2012 11:01PM
Oct 26, 2012 10:53PM
avatar
"a decent surprise showing (#87!) on the Kiwi R&B charts"

Ryan: my download pushes you comfortably Top 40. With a motherf***ing bullet.
Oct 26, 2012 10:14PM
avatar
Ryan: Of course we're speaking to you. We love it, especially--but not exclusively, dammit--as an idea and a thing that exists in the world. Special props to the actual female person, and to the dedication.



Oct 26, 2012 10:02PM
avatar

a quick public service announcement from Jamrag Records:

 

so remember when Cam said: “I gave each of [the members of Wussy] an EW-related gift (about which you’ll hear more later) that totally blew their minds and led into a discussion about our host and EW”? Remember?

 

well this is that gift, and it’s probably not quite what you expected.

 

after seven months of (extremely lazy) toiling, seven Witnesses (in order of appearance: Joey the D, Dr. Cam, Dan “Freelance Hellraiser” Weiss, me, Jacob Swift-Bailis, Juan “jcarru” Carruyo & Minister Gubbels), with immeasurable assistance from brilliant actual female person KT Lindemann and an aes-tot you may know about named Mingus, have finally finished constructing this outsider art tribute to seven years of Wussylove – dubbed by Jason “a perfect combination of reverence and ****-all”. Damn straight.

 

it is with semicompromised pride that I present to you the first full-length example of the fleeting craze ‘EW-rock’...

 

FUNERAL DRESS III: goo.gl/qQ6Zb

 

Dan, the cat behind the quip that engendered the concept, drew up a guide for yez:

 

airborne is joey and kt
funeral dress and don't leave just now are cam
soak it up is me
shunt is cam and ryan
conversation lags is jacob
humanbrained horse and motorcycle are ryan
crooked and bought it again are juan
yellow cotton dress is jason and his son

 

in addition to Wussy (who have officially bumped it up to Funeral Dress II), it has also been pitched, with love and apologies, in the direction of preeminent Wussy proponents Carola and Robert (who are no longer speaking to us). Despite a decent surprise showing (#87!) on the Kiwi R&B charts, it is humble work. But we hope you think it’s cute.

Oct 26, 2012 7:17PM
avatar
All this poll talk inspired me to finish up an EW vs. Pitchfork poll comparison I'd gotten started on.  I dropped that over on the Hood / Hicks thread where the EWIUPPL results were posted (http://goo.gl/68ncH) so it wouldn't clutter things up over here.  Curious to see how many Pitchfork faves show up in the AD-L poll.
Oct 26, 2012 6:58PM
avatar
And also, I think Cam should be allowed like, 3 lists.
Oct 26, 2012 6:48PM
avatar
"On the poll ballot, I'm torn between listing personal favorites or trying to make a list of what I genuinely think are the best albums Xgau hasn't reviewed or gave B or lower to."

Since I'm not sufficiently qualified to know the diff between the two, and certainly not qualified to go on the record about Christgauvian mistakes of all things, I'm rolling it all into one big ball called "Things I Play A Lot And Have For Long, Long Time; Loved Them Then And Love Them Now aka Meanwhile, I Was St-i-i-i-i-l-l Thinkin'"

4 B+'s
2 B's
1 *
and 3 not reviewed.

Chronologically they go 70, 73, 76, 77, 78, 78, 81, 83, 98, 06. I was born in 1950. The obvious mathematical conclusion (6 before I turned 30) is also tied to Christgau access, Christgau commitment (my commitment to his work, meaning, not some reflection on him) and some elements of what is frequently called personal maturity, although any list of the greatest rockandroll songs of all time that doesn't include "Hot Rails to Hell" is flawed by def'n, imho.

Oct 26, 2012 6:42PM
avatar

If someone told me the XX were playing tonight-a few subway stops where I attempted 

to grow up- in the Bronx-I'd tell them bllsht. But it's true.

As regards Robert Christgau's review of Pete Townshends autobiography

in this Sundays' NY Times-buy the freakin' paper will ya please. The

newspaper industry needs all the help it can get. Jeez.

 

Oct 26, 2012 6:33PM
avatar
"go on a binge of Slade to kick the cobwebs out of the head!" -- I did that for a year once. 1973 I think. Yep, that was it.

And as for Carole King, I'm just glad to see her on a "young(ish)" list again.

Oct 26, 2012 6:10PM
avatar
It was nice to see the Carole King demos make an appearance, a really charing recording I've been enjoying since June. Some of the numbers featuring drums and very basic band arrangements ("Pleasant Valley Sunday," "Yours Until Tomorrow") reminded me a little bit of Belle and Sebastian - slightly rickety folk-rock with a hint of twee. Except there's nothing twee about King's voice. 
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap