Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Low Cut Connie/Andre Williams & the Sadies

Dirty Deeds Done Cheap

By Xgau Sep 28, 2012 7:13AM


Low Cut Connie: Call Me Sylvia (lowcutconnie.com)

Trying to make ends meet as the bar band of their dreams, they add muscle to their sound and lose a smidgen of edge in their writing. But that doesn't stop them from preserving 15 songs for posterity instead of the 10 they settled for on their equally self-financed debut. Adam Weiner shouldn't feel obliged to prove he's got big ballads in him, and "Cleveland" proves it. Right afterwards, fortunately, the final five tracks turn out to be where the edge takes over: two simultaneously lively and soulful Dan Finnemore love songs and three Weiner numbers, one stranger than the next and all redolent of a piano man's bar-band life. "Scoliosis in Secaucus" breaks up the love songs. The low-key voice-and-guitar envoi "Dreams Don't Come True" speaks for itself and Frank Sinatra. And done as a final-call blues, "(No More) Wet T-Shirt Contest" is Weiner's most twisted fable of the down-and-dirty life to date: "I feel like my Christian phase is comin'/My fans are gettin' pretty bored/But meanwhile I just keep on hummin'/Here in the bosom of the Lord." A MINUS

 

Andre Williams & the Sadies: Night and Day (Yep Roc)

Despite the occasional charms of albums on such indie-roots imprints as Bloodshot and In the Red, I've never trusted this 75-year-old "legend"'s legend. And indeed, although research indicates that the writing credits on "Twine Time" and "Shake a Tail Feather" check out, the rumored plethora of r&b hits add up to just two as per Joel Whitburn. So he's one of those old bullshit artists young musicians love because they're such great bullshit artists; he's an authenticity marker all the more convincing because he's also a known fraud. Unsurprisingly, his current Bloodshot album, featuring actual Motown-funk legend Dennis Coffey, isn't even worth a check-out. But these 13-songs-in-35-minutes, cut half in 2008 when he was drunk and half in 2010 when he was sober, are shockingly strong for the first eight or nine, which unfortunately include all the drunk ones. Songs about getting your friend out of jail and about moving in on your friend's wife while he's there. Songs about how Africa's even worse than America and how Joliet is Mississippi's sister. A pounding song that begins "The worst thing in the world is a black man being bored." Long beloved of 2010 guardian angel Jon Langford, Ontario's Sadies prove just as rowdy and adaptable under 2008 overseer Jon Spencer, especially with Sally Timms and Kelly Hogan shoring up that young bullshit artist's cred by singing backup. A MINUS

 

158Comments
Oct 2, 2012 8:46AM
avatar

Kenny-someone should right a book about the 2012 Oaland A's.

I'd call it Money Ball. Just a thought.

Oct 2, 2012 3:42AM
avatar
I saw the Afghan Whigs at ATP, Shady, and totally agree with your review. I've seen them dozens of times through the years, dating back to my Ohio college years when they were just starting up, and I've never seen them tighter either. And that's not nostalgia talking. They were a mighty force at ATP. I was surprised how the "Black Love" stuff has improved for me over time. And at ATP, we got to see Marcy Mays do "My Curse." But you got stuff from "Congregation." They're here in Chicago in October with Wussy opening. That'll be a show.
Oct 1, 2012 11:27PM
avatar
OK, that might have been a little overexcited. As you all have seen, I get that way.
Oct 1, 2012 11:26PM
avatar
The Oakland A's, with the 29th largest payroll in the major leagues, and as the season drew to a close, due to injuries and a suspension, five out of five rookies in the starting rotation, just clinched the last playoff birth in the American League. The revolution is upon us, friends.
Oct 1, 2012 9:16PM
avatar
The Afghan Whigs were in top form last night in Cleveland. Greg Dulli was more svelte and less fat than the last time I saw him. Now,  I've seen them several times before and I've never seen them rock harder or tighter. John Curley and Rick McCollum and Greg Dulli melted my face off. Fresh off of curating the ATP in NYC they're doing a big "reunion"  tour so catch them while you can.

Observations: Demographically it was what you'd expect...70/30 men to women. Most men there, like me , are fighting the mid-life waist expansion and receding hair lines. Enthusiasm was plentiful.

Started off playing/ vamping on "Who Do You Love" which morphed into "Fountain and Fairfax"
Here's the rest-
Slave
Uptown Again
Jail
Somethin Hot
We Two Parted/Dead Body
Gentleman
You, My Flower
Crazy
My Enemy
See and Don't See
Love Crimes
Debonair
Faded

Encore-
Retarded
66
Omerta

No "Honky's Ladder" or "Miles Iz Dead" but no worries. Not much talking between songs, was hoping to hear about a new album in the works but most likely Greg will go his way and I'll go mine, because there were no new material either played or mentioined during the concert.

Final analysis- A great live band worth your hard earned consumer dollars. Also, I'm old  and I can't party like I used to. My friends and I got a car so we could imbibe and that was a smart move. Why are the lights so loud today?

Oct 1, 2012 5:57PM
avatar
"Also, still hoping for reports of the Corin Tucker Band, assuming some of you caught them in Manhattan/Cambridge/​Brooklyn.  Were those shows as exhilarating as DC?"

[Peter Lorre voice]
"How the HELL should I know? I vasn't AT the DC show. Vhat do you VANT from me?"
[/Peter Lorre voice] [nb Billy & Mandy ref]

All I can say is that I was very, very (very very) tired and had to leave after 50 minutes. Quite a rockin' show, Tucker a natural as ever. Sound miserably bad in that club, as ever.

Have to add though, re-listening to the album, thought it was a standout workout before. Now it sounds like one of the year's best.
Oct 1, 2012 5:54PM
avatar
I should have used quotes, as I was replying to DRLSteve - I haven't heard "Lenny Bruce" but just read the lyrics. What's the connection besides the car ride?
Oct 1, 2012 5:32PM
avatar
Species of folkie bull****:  When we were good we played people's music and when weren't so good we burnished our legends in guitar rounds playing rava music no record company could love.  
Species of rock and roll bull****:  folk music sucked and needed to be pummeled.  

Species of pop bull****: bandwagon fallacy, or more discursively, positivism viz. the market or, more vernacularly, your opinion is subject always to a market test.  
Oct 1, 2012 4:32PM
avatar

FWIW, i was pleasantly surprised to learn that our host rated Freewheelin so highly among '60s Dylan releases.  I really should replace my worn vinyl with a remastered CD on that one.

Trying to come up with a list of similar drumless acoustic warriors i enjoy, i came up empty after Ani DiFranco (who I know realize is one of the greats), Dan Bern and of course the aforementioned Phil Ochs.  Acoustic Neil too I guess, but I prefer Electric Neil.

Oct 1, 2012 3:55PM
avatar
There's a lot of folk music I like that seems to have a lot of life and gritpacked into it, but I admit that I also treasure the scene in Animal House in which Belushi is listening to a pretentious pure-toned fokie singing about giving his love a cherry, a stone, etc, and he just can't take it anymore, grabs the guitar, smashes it, and then sheepishly apologizes--just a little shug and a quiet "sorry"  Perfect. 
Oct 1, 2012 1:20PM
avatar
" Thinking about what, generically, separates the wheat from the chaff seems like an interesting inquiry."

To oversimplify: when the material on *Anthology of American Folk Music* was new, it wasn't understood as "folk music." It was just music. The more music in those modes becomes self-consciously "folkie," the more it needs bashing. Seems to me certain performers like Fred Neil would have been the same no matter was going on in the world. Peter, Paul and Mary would have been singing waiters without the movement.

I can't add anything important to Bob's guide to the Fugs.

Other folks associated with the folk-music era who have worthy sarsaparilla punch include Koerner, Ray & Glover ("Blues Rags and Hollers," "Lots More Blues, Rags and Hollers") and don't overlook the superb one-off, "Running Jumping Standing Still" by "Spider" John Koerner and Willie Murphy. (Though I would argue all of these albums have at least as much to do with acoustic blues as any other mode of rural tunes.)
Oct 1, 2012 12:25PM
avatar
"I was wondering this same thing - is it one of those made up stories that gets repeated as fact or not."

Let me be more specific. I'm taking "Lenny Bruce" to indicate that the taxi ride with Ochs was not apocryphal.
Oct 1, 2012 12:12PM
avatar
On the question of good folk music, the discussion here has me thinking about the boundaries of "folk music" as a category we generally deride.  The stuff many of us here tend to bash is, I think, post-folk revival acoustic music, mostly aimed at the pop market, performed by white people who don't sing with a drawl, along with later stuff that treats the earlier stuff as an aesthetic ideal.  But there's a lot of other acoustic music that we rock and rollers generally like: country blues, solo Hank Williams, Anthology of American Folk Music, etc.  Thinking about what, generically, separates the wheat from the chaff seems like an interesting inquiry.  Within the bash-boundary, I picked up Fred Neill's "Bleecker and MacDougal" a while back and kind of liked it.

A few other things:

I happened to listen to "Tempest" and "Conversations With Kenny / Legacy of Lee" for the first time on the same day, and with the likely exception of Sufjan Stevens' "Illinois," they may be the only two rock and roll albums to mention Carbondale.  Weirdest musical juxtaposition I've heard since both Dinosaur Jr. and Girl Talk played "Just Like Heaven" in their otherwise not-from-the-same-planet sets at Loufest.

More on geography -- I love how the first three songs on the Dylan Hicks record are place-name songs and the fourth one is about a postcard.  As a grandson of rural Ohio, however, I must report that he mispronounces "Wapakoneta."  The "e" is pronounced like "let" or "get."  I checked with my mom.

Sorry if this has already been discussed and I missed it, but holy **** the Bob Mould album.  It's like his other solo albums never happened.  I share Xgau's (apparent) view that "Egoverride" was the best solo song he ever released.  Was.  Because the worst song on "Silver Age" -- I'll go with "Steam of Hercules" at the moment -- blows "Egoverride" out of the water.  I wish he had never stopped doing this, but I'm glad he's back at it.
Oct 1, 2012 11:17AM
avatar
I was wondering this same thing - is it one of those made up stories that gets repeated as fact or not. The song is Todd Snider's 'Thin Wild Mercury'.
avatar
I enjoy Ariel Pink's Before Today. The songs probably don't mean much, but as usual, as long as I'm given catchy toons, I don't much care.  I haven't heard any of his other stuff.
Oct 1, 2012 10:45AM
avatar
gdash, Right, and  I thought the story also went that Dylan, while throwing Ochs out fo the car, said, "You're not a folk singer, your're a journalist."  And didn't someone (Todd Snider?) memorialize this momentous event in a song?  Or am I making that up?  My grasp on the specifics of Dylanology admittedly very hazy today. 
Oct 1, 2012 10:28AM
avatar
Is Dylan's "Lenny Bruce" really about Phil Ochs (at least partly)? I only just realized the Ochs connection.
Oct 1, 2012 10:27AM
avatar
Phil Ochs fans should check out the bio-documentary "There But For Fortune." Very nicely done. Minimum bull. Smartly selected tunes and performances.
Oct 1, 2012 10:19AM
avatar
DRLSteve, I thought Dylan threw Ochs out of the limo for telling him "Can You Please Crawl Out Your Window" wouldn't be a hit.
Oct 1, 2012 9:45AM
avatar
The only RC-certified Phil Ochs anthology I'm aware of is Chords of Fame the double vinyl from 1976 on A&M. 
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap