Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Ani DiFranco/Bhi Bhiman

Two Albums That Begin With Excellent Songs About Homelessness, and There Will Be More

By Xgau Jan 24, 2012 5:58AM

Ani DiFranco: ¿Which Side Are You On? (Righteous Babe)

After a decade of futzing around, of music so overthought that even her best-of couldn't make a case for it, this one's like re-encountering a friend who drifted away after she took a bad job or married a jerk. Both of which might have happened‑-nobody she signed to Righteous Babe did much for her bottom line, and the nuptials that ruffled her feminist faithful in 1998 ended badly in 2003. Now, finally, her first album since she married her five-year-old's father is as fresh as Lisa Lee at the top of the key. With Uncle Pete signing on via banjogram, the title song announces a political renewal so focused on the three-syllable F-word that it includes an E.R.A. anthem. But for DiFranco the political has always been personal, which doesn't mean private and can mean intellectualized, as in "Promiscuity." The singing on the homelessness tale that opens is as emotionally accomplished as its assumed first-person is formally atypical. The one that reads "If yr not getting happier as you get older/then yr fucking up" is her true credo. A MINUS

 

Bhi Bhiman: Bhiman (Redeye)

In an unruffled show of assimilative will, this Sri Lankan American 29-year-old channels John Hurt and the Staple Singers into sweet, firm folksongs about injustice's cruelty and love's confusions‑-and is funnier about both than, as a random instance, Van Morrison. The stolid beats define the limits of his Americanization. But from the first strums of "The Guttersnipe," the melodies are universal language at its most outgoing. A MINUS

 

223Comments
Jan 24, 2012 7:23AM
avatar
As one who feared DiFranco's true gifts were lost forever to psuedo-jazz formlessness, I'm surprised--and gratified.
Jan 24, 2012 10:24AM
avatar
Have to admit that I never "got" Ani. I'm sure I bought one of her records; can't remember which one and checking the shelves, it seems to have disappeared.

So I did what I always do, play previews while I re-read Bob's previous findings. And this piece is so weighty (no pun intended) and well-stroked that it needs to be re-considered by more than just me, imho. http://goo.gl/8gWeA

"banjogram" is a great word, and here's hoping the sub-head is prophetic.
Jan 24, 2012 10:34AM
avatar
'If yr not getting happier, as you get older/then yr ****ing up.'
+1,000,000!
Jan 24, 2012 10:57AM
avatar
So after we heard Strawberry, I was discussing its Pazz & Jop prospects on Facebook, projecting that even optimistically, it wouldn't make top fifty.  Cam said he'd take that bet, and I agree.  We never agreed on anything, but I kept it in the back of my mind.

Wussy came in at slot 109, and I (half-jokingly, actually) reminded Cam of our "arrangement."  He asked for my address, I gave it to him, and by Friday I found a FedEx package had been delivered to my P.O. box.  I picked it up yesterday: Big Star's Keep an Eye on the Sky collection and Bruce Eaton's Radio City 33 1/3.  A fantastic gift, as all three (THERE ARE ONLY THREE) of Big Star's albums are hugely important to me.  I think Cam is the most consistently and inarguably outstanding guy here, and I value him a lot as a friend.  So here's a shout out.  Thanks, Cam.  I'd like to think my end of the bargain would have been as impressive.

Now, imagine how the present would be even better if I had not yet discovered Big Star.  Since I first heard them, I think I've made it a point to be the guy to introduce them to all my best friends.  Carrie Brownstein agrees: “Musicians and fans have always passed around Big Star songs and albums like a secret handshake. When you found out someone hadn’t heard #1 Record or Radio City, you were so excited to provide that missing link, to pass on all the glimmer, the jangly guitar, the big chords, the melodies, the American anthems that let you keep your teenage self — for some of us long since faded — close, etched upon your skin. And suddenly, you realized that every great band or musician you love also loved Alex Chilton and Big Star; it’s certain.”
Jan 24, 2012 11:49AM
avatar
Unfamiliar artists are afforded a tiny margin of error as openers - at least in the part of NC I know.  Basically, you  click or you clunk and you'd better have at least one song that sticks and holds. Frank Fairfield managed that with (seeming) ease Friday night and a few months ago, Bhi Bhiman did too. In Bhi's case it was the voice and that song - Guttersnipe. Here's hoping the EW notice will address the "Whodat" problem and open ears to some very good music that I'da missed had I hung out on Franklin Street a bit too long.
Jan 24, 2012 11:56AM
avatar

Klosterman wrote a piece at Grantland on Tune-Yards winning Pazz and Jop, just fyi.

Jan 24, 2012 12:26PM
avatar
One thing, Chuck. Choosing not to use gender-specific pronouns does not render anyone "androgynous." PC, maybe--but you can't say PC anymore because it sounds kinda square, right?
Jan 24, 2012 12:42PM
avatar
a somewhat androgynous American woman named Merrill Garbus.

Androgynous? Uh, sorry, no, not at all.

Jan 24, 2012 1:03PM
avatar

I couldn't agree more with Brownstein regarding Big Star. A decade ago or so a dear friend put several of their songs on some mixtapes for me and you can't put a price on that gift.

 

Also, I'll second Joey in that Cam does rock!

 

-Blair

Jan 24, 2012 1:07PM
avatar
This has nothing to do with anything, but: I get a lot of music via my university's Inter-Library Loan service, and though they were able to find such hard-to-find items as Are You from Dixie? Great Country Brother Teams of the 1930s and Zaire Choc! African Connection Vol. 1, I was just informed that they were not able to furnish Talking Heads' Little Creatures. Really? How bizarre. Libraries--you just never know.

EDIT: Don't worry, I've certainly heard Little Creatures, but I'm upgrading my MP3 collection to a higher bitrate, and this one's on the list. I don't want to lose any cred I may have with my EW peeps!
Jan 24, 2012 1:12PM
Jan 24, 2012 1:21PM
avatar
 In fact, if you effortlessly understood 100 percent of this article's opening sentence, you can probably skip the rest of the piece. 
I took Chuck's advice.
Jan 24, 2012 1:25PM
avatar
Thanks for directing me to some Charlie Pierce pieces I hadn't read. I agree with every word he wrote about the Patriots/Ravens game.
Jan 24, 2012 1:26PM
avatar
There's another track ("You Yes You") where she repeatedly screeches the phrase "What's that about?" and it might be the single most grating musical moment of 2011.
That was one of my most favorite musical moments of 2011.
Jan 24, 2012 1:30PM
avatar
Chuck Klosterman is an idiot.

this is funny. Klosterman seems to say, we'll know how good whokill is in about 15 years after Merrill has, or has not, asserted herself as musical genius. This does seem idiotic. In 15 years the legitimacy of whokill winning Pazz and Jop in 2011 should be determined by how whokill sounds in 15 years, not how Merrill's career plays out. And if I had to guess, it will sound fantastic.

 

edited will to should to clarify.

Jan 24, 2012 1:34PM
avatar
Chuck Klosterman is an idiot.
An idiot who writes a keen memoir, though.
Jan 24, 2012 1:38PM
avatar
this is funny. Klosterman seems to say, we'll know how good whokill is in about 15 years after Merrill has, or has not, asserted herself as musical genius. This does seem idiotic. In 15 years the legitimacy of whokill winning Pazz and Jop in 2011 will be determined by how whokill sounds in 15 years, not how Merrill's career plays out. And if I had to guess, it will sound fantastic.
Hrm.

I actually disagree.

I couldn't be happier about whokill's victory, but think about some of the least celebrated P&J winners: Imperial Bedroom, Arrested Development Ragged Glory, Live Through This (shockingly not spoken of as enthusiastically these days, but maybe blame Courtney's PR), and a few more.  In a lot of these instances, these artists have not followed their wins with achievements that are thought of as particularly remarkable (though Costello and Young had solid careers after their wins, without a doubt).

I don't think that this would what happens to whokill, but I don't think that his claim is too far off base.  It's a neat observation regarding how we see past winners.
Jan 24, 2012 2:02PM
avatar
Klosterman is not an idiot. He's very smart. But like Ellen Willis, of all people, only with a lot lower success ratio (partly because he's not that smart and partly because he's not that serious either), he generates theories off the top of his head almost at will. Most of these are wrong. But that doesn't make him an idiot. More like an intellectual entertainer. And to be fair, he's about 10 times funnier than Ellen Willis, who failed to nurture that aspect of her talent in part because she was that serious.
Jan 24, 2012 2:10PM
avatar
More like an intellectual entertainer
I think that very aptly describes what Klosterman does, and why a lot of what he writes doesn't hold up to serious scrutiny. That said, I really enjoyed Sex, Drugs & Cocoa Puffs.
avatar
Yeah, Klosterman is not wondering whether people will still be *enjoying* Whokill 15 years from now, but rather how today's fans will perceive Merrill Garbus' career (and Whokill's P&J win) by then. It's a legitimate point, and Arrested Development is an excellent example. His notion that innovative music is doomed to date faster because it allegedly responds to today's trends doesn't make much sense to me though (unless innovation is the only thing that's good about it, and he doesn't imply that that is the case with Whokill).
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap