Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Ani DiFranco/Bhi Bhiman

Two Albums That Begin With Excellent Songs About Homelessness, and There Will Be More

By Xgau Jan 24, 2012 5:58AM

Ani DiFranco: ¿Which Side Are You On? (Righteous Babe)

After a decade of futzing around, of music so overthought that even her best-of couldn't make a case for it, this one's like re-encountering a friend who drifted away after she took a bad job or married a jerk. Both of which might have happened‑-nobody she signed to Righteous Babe did much for her bottom line, and the nuptials that ruffled her feminist faithful in 1998 ended badly in 2003. Now, finally, her first album since she married her five-year-old's father is as fresh as Lisa Lee at the top of the key. With Uncle Pete signing on via banjogram, the title song announces a political renewal so focused on the three-syllable F-word that it includes an E.R.A. anthem. But for DiFranco the political has always been personal, which doesn't mean private and can mean intellectualized, as in "Promiscuity." The singing on the homelessness tale that opens is as emotionally accomplished as its assumed first-person is formally atypical. The one that reads "If yr not getting happier as you get older/then yr fucking up" is her true credo. A MINUS

 

Bhi Bhiman: Bhiman (Redeye)

In an unruffled show of assimilative will, this Sri Lankan American 29-year-old channels John Hurt and the Staple Singers into sweet, firm folksongs about injustice's cruelty and love's confusions‑-and is funnier about both than, as a random instance, Van Morrison. The stolid beats define the limits of his Americanization. But from the first strums of "The Guttersnipe," the melodies are universal language at its most outgoing. A MINUS

 

223Comments
Jan 24, 2012 4:17PM
avatar
Thank you, Xgau, for putting pompous Ryan in his place. You're right - Chuck Klosterman is not an idiot. I mean, I'm no fan, but the man is a fine writer. And I'd rather read Klosterman than Ryan's (a barely post-teen wannabe) "writing". Has anyone else read his meandering, lumbering diatribes against Adele, Gags etc. in his latest 5Records blog post? Ugh, that was an endurance test I never want to suffer through again.
See, I was able to do that without calling him an idiot.
Jan 26, 2012 12:22AM
avatar
OK, who broke your heart? Get it out. We can help you through this. 

It has nothing to do with broken hearts. It has everything to do with her appeal being nothing more than how "cute" she is. Her songs don't stick and her voice is monotone and dull. I honestly don't know what justifies her musical existence other than the fact that Interscope pumped all the money they had left over from the Born This Way budget and groomed themselves another pop-star with below average talent and below average looks. 

What did Daisy say in The Great Gatsby? Something about how a girl should remain dumb in life? Welp, seems to work out just fine for Miss Del Rey. 
Jan 26, 2012 2:20PM
avatar
Good job, Jon. I think you've made lots of progress today. You must be taking Irene's remedial woman loving lessons. You were able to say a woman is untalented without adding that she has "below average looks" or a "fem-stache," and you didn't even need to talk about how icky pussy is when you mentioned Rihanna. These are large strides for just one day of lessons. 

I really don't follow you in your idea that Miss Dumbpoutyface is a big regression in pop music. Is it because she has big lips? You don't like sexy music performed by women, so surely you don't think Madonna, Britney Spears, Christina Aguilera, Janet Jackson, etc. had much to offer. I'm wondering, Miss Dumbpoutyface is a regression from what? From pop music created by men? Or is it that pop music before her was represented entirely by Amy Winehouse for you? And she talks about drugs more than sex, so it's all good. 

I love fluff when fluff is fluffy. 
Here are some ladies you might actually like. http://goo.gl/Mj1wD
Jan 26, 2012 10:45AM
avatar
I don't hate women 
I think you need to really examine your views a bit more, Jon. Just saying you don't hate something doesn't make it true. It also doesn't make me believe you when there is so much evidence to the contrary. And why does facial or body hair on women make you apprehensive about their music? My guess is misogyny.
Jan 24, 2012 1:12PM
Jan 24, 2012 2:40PM
avatar
Jon, considering that DiFranco first performed the song with Pete Seeger at his Madison Square Garden 90th birthday celebration back in May 2009, that she's performed the song in her live shows ever since, and that this album was recorded between 2010 and mid-2011 - yeah, I do think she'd make such an anthem regardless of  who gift-wrapped it for her (and this coming from a DiFranco agnostic).
Good point sir. I translated your paragraph to essentially saying that DiFranco is a Seeger ****-kisser, and that I was wrong.
Jan 25, 2012 11:22PM
avatar
Wow. Lana Del Rey's voice is obnoxious. What makes it worse is I can visualize her giving a silly pout-face while she sings as well. Surely I'm not alone on this.
Jan 26, 2012 2:33PM
avatar
Madonna, Britney Spears, Christina Aguilera, Janet Jackson
Each and everyone of those artists certainly has their moments. I was on a big "Like a Prayer" kick a few weeks back.

But I find LDR a regression from pop with soul, meaning, and purpose. I realize not all pop stars or pop songs have those ingredients, but for someone who enjoys pop with a side of personality, LDR's eye-batting-and-lip-pouting-as-substance is insulting to me. Just buy a vibrator and leave me alone. I like girls with confidence and brains, not neediness and a lackluster voice.

Oh, and pussy certainly isn't icky - like Rihanna's music is. Now Beyonce? Her music is just as awesome as her pussy must be. Wait... did I just step on a few more toes? Sorry I'm not sorry.
Jan 24, 2012 2:15PM
avatar
Two things:

1) I can't for the life of me get into Ani DiFranco's record. Her political leanings are too obvious and I find the title track too opportunistic to take seriously. You think she'd make such an anthem if Occupy Wall Street never showed up with a song idea neatly gift wrapped for her? (and this coming from an Obama voter)

2) Klosertman brings up good points in his article, especially how WHOKILL is something a listener can dance to, but has probably never (but in all reality, rarely) been danced too. It's too smart, too busy and not organized enough to be danced too. This in no way makes the album a bad or album or even a mediocre album. But it is interesting to note a feature to an album that has seldom, if ever, been executed on the part of the listener. Also, I almost tossed off WHOKILL by the way "tUnE-yArDs" was spelled. Oh and the Fem-Stache. So what? I gave in. It's excellent.
Jan 24, 2012 9:38PM
avatar
Ryan: Give me 8 minutes and I'll be there.

Never been sold on "Beyond Belief". A first track should punch harder.

"The Loved Ones" is also right on the cusp of four stars to five.

Jan 27, 2012 9:20AM
avatar
yes. she's acting out a role she herself isn't entirely certain makes for a good fit (thus her obvious discomfort on SNL); she knows the lines but her delivery isn't quite as convincing as she might hope. i like the uncertainty of it all. her uncertainty.
Jan 26, 2012 5:01PM
avatar
Walter: Thank you so incredibly much!!! I am sitting here applauding the computer screen like an idiot. And it should be said that I had to pause "Biznezz" which was playing on my bigger system so as to watch and listen to this version of "Bizness".

It's still hard to turn w h o k i l l off once I click Play. Repeat is more like it.

Thanks again.

Jan 24, 2012 4:27PM
avatar
People in charge of the MSN spam filter: What the hell is so wrong with using captchas?
Jan 24, 2012 3:12PM
avatar
Xgau, IDK if these are all on the Blow Your Head album you reviewed or not—I'm pretty sure it's an ongoing release—but my friend has been linking me each new release for the past few months! Here is the latest one: http://goo.gl/YduuG (I'm pretty sure it's A minus or B+ material!)
Jan 26, 2012 6:08PM
avatar
Which come out when, exactly? I want to mark it on my calendar.
It's released, uh, tomorrow, so says Wiki.
Jan 25, 2012 9:13PM
avatar
I see and respect that the Todd R. playlist is sticking to him as performer (and not player or producer) but can I get a ruling on "Bat out of Hell"?
Jan 26, 2012 1:50PM
avatar
but your snide comments about female musicians definitely belie some sort of...issue.
Rihanna and Lana Del Rey are puppets - not musicians. Snide is all I can be towards them and their hollow, insipid music. Tune-Yards, on the other hand, has all the respect I can give - which is plenty enough.  And as far as my comparison between the Gatsby "women-should-remain-fools" quote and Miss Del Rey, I was merely making note of how big a regression she represents in pop music. Amy Winehouse (to come up with an example off the top of my head) had perspective, depth and a personality to her music - even if all three of those elements had some limitations to them. While Winehouse is (er.. was?) out and about in the world getting miserable and dirty and learning a thing or two about living, Del Rey stays in her room and writes in her diary about nothing more than fluff - which isn't a bad thing in particular. I love fluff when fluff is fluffy. But what's fluff without a personality or point of view? Really bad fluff. It's made even worse when a stupid facial expression (ie: pouting) is supposed to embody substance or dramatic depth.
Lucky for you I give remedial lessons in woman-loving. Hahahaha as if you'd ever wanna be within 10 feet of me...or I you
I'd more than happily come within 10 feet of you, or anyone on this blog. Hell, I'd even buy you (or anyone else) a drink should we ever have a chance meeting in person - it's called Hoosier Hospitality. Maybe I'd ask the bartedner if there is such a cocktail as a Chauvinist's Delight? Bet it tastes like repression. I certainly wouldn't know.
Jan 26, 2012 9:39AM
avatar
Well we'll cross that off the list of potential reasons you hate women. Back to the drawing board.... 

Jesus Christ... really? Do I really have to respond to that? Or does your ignorant, simplistic view of me speak for itself? I don't hate women nor do I hate Tune-Yards. If you kept reading my earlier post, which you quoted, you'll see that I say I enjoy her album. My reference to her fem-stache was simply my way of stating how apprehensive I was when I first gave her a spin. I thought it would be nothing more than cheap hipster fodder. Turns out it was upper class hipster fodder. 

Oh, and I've given Lana Del Rey a sixth chance. Nope. Still nothing there. 

::waits for the thumb bombs to commence::
Jan 25, 2012 3:05PM
avatar
New Nicki Minaj single: http://goo.gl/T72zz

'I am the female Weezy.' Well, you heard it!
Jan 24, 2012 9:59PM
avatar
I remember now, "Kid About It" starts well but settles into a choppy feel for a waltz and then ends abruptly. The "So what if this is a man's world/I want be a kid again about it" is pretty good. A guy's got to know his limitations after all.
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap