Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Royal Band de Thiés/Thiossane Ablaye Ndiaye

Old-School Senegal Lives

By Xgau Oct 23, 2012 6:18AM

Royal Band de Thiés: Kadior Demb (Teranga Beat)

The angel is an Athenian photographer and mad Afropop crate digger named Adamantios Kafetzis, who seems to run Teranga Beat pretty much by himself. In the case of this early mbalax unit from the now disused railway hub where Ousmane Sembene's God's Bits of Wood is set, there turned out to be multiple reels, with this circa-1979 title the first of several unreleased albums. The Royal Band aren't Baobab or Super Étoile, not Kafetzis's Gambian discovery Karantamba either. But their projected debut is intense, gorgeous, and hyperactive without rushing the climax once. With gruff mbalax shouter Secka, still in the vocal ambit of Baobab's dearly departed Laye M'Boup, balanced by high, sweet natural salsero James Gadiaga, who on this record sticks to mbalax's tamas-and-horn-stabs program, they suggest that Baobab and Super Étoile weren't just two very different great bands. They led and inspired a scene. A MINUS

 

Thiossane Ablaye Ndiaye: Thiossane Ablaye Ndiaye (Syllart/Sterns)

In which a strong-voiced, historically-minded, salsa-loving Senegalese guitarist and painter records a suitably impressive elder's debut at 74, with his steadfast gravity the linchpin and the band the reason non-Wolof speakers will listen. With Xalam, OK Jazz, and Africando recruits on board, it's basically an Orchestra Baobab one-off with the focus on saxophonist Thierno Koyaté rather than crazier saxophonist Issa Cissoko and the Xalam and OK Jazz guys pitching in where Togo-based Barthelemy Attisso normally moves heaven and earth. The hypnotic clave of "Bouki Ndiour" and the warm lyricism of "Arawane Ndiaye" might heighten your expectations unduly. But hell‑-take a chance. B PLUS

 

102Comments
Oct 26, 2012 7:46AM
avatar
I always thought that first Gun Club album was really good, and the first Reigning Sound album is excellent.

I'm also very impressed with Rodney's collection of Jorge Ben's albums. I was recommended him by a friend who thinks he's one of the greats, and he sounds that way to me.
avatar
"Of our host, I suspect there are actually few mistakes."

I don't see it as "mistakes", so much as "Xgau and I not having the exact same tastes". Also, in what way do personal discoveries demand a larger upfront investment than Xgau-approved albums?
Oct 25, 2012 9:20PM
avatar

On the poll ballot, I'm torn between listing personal favorites or trying to make a list of what I genuinely think are the best albums Xgau hasn't reviewed or gave B or lower to.  (I decided to exclude anything HM of B+ from consideration, although that cuts out plenty of beauts.)  Keep going back and forth,  Good news is I still have a month to decide.

 

P.S. Since Bradley says OK to campaign, gotta say I've loved listening to Minor Threat/early Fugazi for the first time in years.

Oct 25, 2012 9:09PM
avatar
Please do campaign for any and all albums you cherish and are considering including on your ballot. But maybe save your final ballot for after I post the results. Cool? The website again is ewpoll.tumblr.com. Submission info is available there. Thanks!
Oct 25, 2012 8:57PM
avatar
I didn't mean not campaign, I meant not post our whole list. More campaigning is what I was after. That Black Dialogue commentary the other day was ace.
Oct 25, 2012 8:57PM
avatar
Having now read Bradley's solicitation, I vow only to submit if I can find CG mistakes; otherwise, it does seem to be a kind of crowing over one's own local discoveries. Which will be interesting to read if all of you go that way, but I know my limits, and discoveries frequently demand up-front investment.  Of our host, I suspect there are actually few mistakes.  An exception that mostly pre-dates the era Bradley intends to cover is Fred Neil. I think that work is very rich; Xgau ignored it; nor do I suspect it will ever come in for re-appraisal.  But it does strike me as a mistake. 
avatar
Wait, who said we're not supposed to campaign for specific albums? That's like half the fun of doing this.
Oct 25, 2012 8:24PM
avatar
I love Tom Hull's political columns.

Oct 25, 2012 8:17PM
avatar
Bradley, 

Can you please submit the link to submit a poll again? Thanks
Oct 25, 2012 7:55PM
avatar
Kenny: my ballot will be nothing but evidence that the Village Voice had convincing music critics other than Christgau.  Giddens, Gann, etc.

Plus "My Aim Is True" obviously.
Oct 25, 2012 7:42PM
avatar

 I accept all requests, but ask that language be kept clean, etc.

 Now why do I love punk rock?  I'm not sure who it was that said it but it sounded like something already in my head.  I like both sheets of sound (Coltarne, Rollins, obviously a lot of rock groups) and the drone strum developed  most prominently by the VU but present in music for a VERY long time.
Oct 25, 2012 7:39PM
avatar
If you wish to be my FB friend, send an f request to "Steve Mayer chess bun"  I'm the pic with a redbrick house in the background.


Oct 25, 2012 5:55PM
avatar
Embarrassing to say it was stranded in the album-era of my collecting, Imperial Bedroom will definitely be getting a first-in-years listen in the spare moments of the next few weeks --
Oct 25, 2012 5:55PM
avatar
Ryan: Most of the conversation has been about jazz lists or metal lists or prog lists. Maybe that is because conversation about specific albums Christgau doesn't like violates the don't post your list/don't campaign clause. (There is a touch of campaigning going on, and I'm certainly tempted. But I'm resisting. So far.) Anyway, I'm genuinely curious to see how people go.
Oct 25, 2012 4:58PM
avatar
I'm trying to decide what Peter Gabriel album to include; I enjoy them all but our man has a point with each and every one (including the placeholder points I can conjure up for Up).
Oct 25, 2012 4:53PM
avatar
Bradley: Tell me if this violates a rule and I'll delete it --

While our standard, agreed upon practice is to not reveal our poll choices (Edit: meaning entire 1 through 10 list) before balloting closes, I am intensely curious as to the artists y'all are considering for the Anti-poll. In that regard, I'm gonna list some of the artists I'm working on without also mentioning the specific album title. These are not my Top Ten, since 3 or 4 not listed here are locks that I have already included in other polls. Some of these will make it, some won't. All are under consideration. Alphabetically:

Joan Armatrading
David Bowie
Rosanne Cash
Elvis Costello
J. Geils Band
Iron City Houserockers
k. d. lang
Midnight Oil
Elliott Smith
Rolling Stones
Jimmy Webb
The Who
Johnny Winter

Somewhat Classic Rock Whitebread now that I look at it, but there you go. I'm quite proud of most and deeply in love with about a third.

And also, the culturally perfect moment of the day today was hearing Iris DeMent's "The Shores of Jordan" at lunch at Cracker Barrel. I only hope the whole chain bought the rights and paid her well.



Oct 25, 2012 4:42PM
avatar

On the eternal beauty/art for the ages/genius thread, just wanted to say that it is entirely possible that those living in the future will conclude that the Beatles were s--t and real genius lay with Badfinger, or-um, the Dave Clark Five.  We will be all be dead and, despite much rolling in our graves, churning in our urns, etc., we will be completely unable to do anything about this.  The then-living will make whatever use of the past best suits them, and, if they are at all like us, they will not let our notions unduly trouble their needs/wants/desires.  That's the compensatory power that comes with all of the hassles of actually being alive.   Not sure which, present or future, is the privledged take on things.  Not sure if it matters.  Maybe all that matters is the miracle of finding something present to you that quickens your spirit and makes you tingle and flash and jump around. If it is something from 1823 or something from last week, well then, so be it.  As the CG keeps proving, there is great stuff out there, much of it--but by no means all of it--unjustly obscure, that we, the now-living, can vibrate to, and maybe that's as much as you can know or hope for. 

 

 It's appaling to remember that America at one time had this great treasure--blues music--to me as powerful an art as anything I can think of, and it was, for most white people and for many non-white people, trash, worthless, and it took the far-removed Brits to show us the world-shaking grandure of what we had just down the street. That makes absolutely no sense to me, but it is, damn it,  human all-too-human nature.  Seeing is all, but seeing is often enabled by distances of space and time.   Not sure what uses, for pleasure, edification, release, etc, if any, the yet-to-be-alive will make of Wussey or Pink or the Fab Four.  All we can know, I think, is what they do for us.  Claims to know what will matter to the ages are, well, let's jsut say not very helpful I think. 

Oct 25, 2012 4:41PM
avatar
Kenny, I'd figure that'll be the majority of the ballots.
Oct 25, 2012 4:17PM
avatar
(1) I am going to be delighted to get a look at everyone's list of things they like that are not covered or not lauded by Christgau. That, and nothing more complicated (or precise or accurate or based on review of every album ever recorded) is what I'm looking forward to. That is to say, Jason, there can be no dishonesty of judgment in this regard. Do whatever you feel like. (2) Having started to read the Village Voice word for word at 14, I have effectively no tastes that precede or in anyway circumvent the artists and genres covered by Christgau. I have only local differences. I am starting to get the feeling that I am the only person here whose list is going to be a bunch of albums by artists/in genres Christgau and I both like where he gives the album a B+ or a ** and I just think he's wrong.

Oct 25, 2012 2:50PM
avatar
Jason and Mike: I would love it. I'm not expecting too much consensus overall so I'm assuming this particular poll will be all about the individual ballots. Do what you want and have fun!
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap