Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Albert Ammons/Masters of the Boogie Piano

Them Three Kings

By Xgau Mar 30, 2012 4:55AM

Albert Ammons: Boogie Woogie Stomp (Delmark '98)

The canonical recording is The First Day, Ammons's first studio session with Meade Lux Lewis, which launched Alfred Lion's even more canonical Blue Note label in 1938. But its status partly reflects the room it makes for Lewis's blues feeling, which in truth is nothing special‑-there are hundreds of better blues players across the spectrum, from Speckled Red to Otis Spann to Thelonious Monk. For the left-hand speed rolls and right-hand sparklers that are why the world cares about Ammons and Lewis, this knowledgeably annotated excavation tops the Blue Note easily. I'd prefer more duets, but although there may be something better out there, I doubt the improvement would justify the search. Most of it was recorded live at a radio broadcast from a Chicago hotel in 1939, which given how uncomplicated it is to mike a piano is of no sonic consequence; the last four songs are from a stray studio session. Eighteen tracks in all, most under three minutes and three under two, with Lewis taking half a dozen and Pete Johnson a pair. You want blues feeling, try Lewis's "Chapel Blues." You want Ammons to shout for joy, wait till he gets away from those radio guys and lets loose in the studio. A MINUS

 

Masters of the Boogie Piano (Delmark '03)

Or you could settle for the two tracks commandeered from the Ammons album‑-one Ammons, one Lewis, both mastered eight seconds faster‑-on this go-for-the-hips budget comp released to celebrate the Chicago label's golden anniversary. Jumping, as one reviewer wrote, from "fist-fingered old pros" to "lightning revivalists," its most breathless moment comes when Roosevelt Sykes's two-lane "North Gulfport Boogie" is passed on the left by Pete Johnson's four-lanes-and-counting "66 Stomp." And it's topped off by that special thing, an Ammons-Lewis-Johnson trio. A MINUS

 

129Comments
Apr 3, 2012 12:39AM
avatar
'...and I guess would give it an A-.'

I am pretty borderline with this; I thought it was at first, too! IDK, it could well be! I just feel it doesn't have that craftsmanship/tempo; I could be wrong! I guess, I'll keep on spinning! Tongue out


Can all you guys get the new Nicki Minaj, so we can talk about that, please?! Angel Tongue out

Apr 2, 2012 9:26PM
avatar
Jeff M.: I'm almost positive this is it. Civil Wars from 1992, series 1, episode 9.

http://goo.gl/wdb2b

"Sydney tries to keep a psychiatrist from shattering his wife's sanity", Sydney is Mariel Hemingway as the attorney.
Apr 2, 2012 8:41PM
avatar
And it's a lesson in how hard it is to split the rigors of formalism

Well said, Cam. I've been trying to figure out how to give Sonic Youth credit for "Kool Thing" from 1990 and that's exactly it. They've never been limited by any formalism other than their own so it was much easier to break those restrictions at the time of their choosing.


Hairy Irene's Social Hour

My new favorite band name.

Apr 2, 2012 8:10PM
avatar
To answer your question rather late, Teta, my trip was fine and dandy. Woulda been better if I didn't get scared while alone in public, but even my nervous nelly self managed some intensive people and dog watching. Also I did a great deal of analysis of whether I'm cool enough to ever live in Manhattan and I think, with work, the answer is yes. :) I didn't venture outside the upper east except when we went to see Blair (which was awesome and I loved the bar he took us to) but there was plenty of unattainable luxury at which to marvel and once I've moved to Philly I'll be back frequently anyway. On my last night in town I forwent a possible Xgau-sighting at the EMP conference for a cozy date at Sfoglia, recommended by Jason G. I owe him many thanks; it was perfect and the waitress only laughed at our fancy-ish restaurant awkwardness once.

So, what's with the old-->new Greg Teta? Did you find Jesus? Re-invite the Dean into your heart? Dedicate your life anew to his espoused humanism? Spill.

OK, done willfully disregarding the content of this post in favor of Hairy Irene's Social Hour.

Apr 2, 2012 8:07PM
avatar
I echo both Jeffs and everyone else in enjoying the Bruce discussion. A few additional comments:

1. Even though Bruce focused on the past decade in the Greensboro show I saw a couple of weeks ago, spreading the Wrecking Ball material out (and also, let's face it, relying too much on the pennywhistle) was a disservice to some good songs and a tough, true commentary. I'm not all the way there with the album, but I get more from the CD than I did from the show.

2. At said show, "Rocky Ground" was a showstopper that kicked off the extended encore. The triad of Bruce and gospel and hip-hop was and is nuanced, and the rap received more attention live than it gets on the studio version, which is a shame if you only have access to the latter.

3. The obvious comparison with "Rocky Ground" (to me) that I haven't heard mentioned is Lucinda Williams' "Too Cool 2-Be Forgotten", which if I recall correctly was hated by some musicky commentators at the time. But that was almost 15 years ago. And it's a lesson in how hard it is to split the rigors of formalism, even if it's a formalism that artists like Williams and Springsteen don't choose for themselves.

4. Thanks Duke for the extended writing on Dr. John, which you should do more of (if only to please people like me). I recall somewhere in the Rolling Stone Record Guides someone saying that the Stones should do an Armstrong tribute record. But that would be like asking Chipper Jones to pitch. Sending Dr. J to the mound doesn't seem to be such a bad idea though. Glad you shared it with us.

5. Everything Ryan said about Nicki Minaj: true, true that.
Apr 2, 2012 8:04PM
avatar
Ooh, Greg, you have to try to remember the show.  I need to see that.

And yeah, I know "Lift Me Up"--it's funny I was partly thinking of all this because I was reading the Rolling Stone interview with Bruce last week and he talks about "discovering" he had that falsetto voice when he was 40 or so.  He was a little younger I think--if you don't count the yodeling on "Johnny 99"-- more like 38 when he got it down on "One Step Up"


Apr 2, 2012 7:54PM
avatar
Jeff M.: There was this TV courtroom drama in the 90's. One of the main characters was a female lawyer. One episode she is supposed to protect a domestic violence victim from the woman's overly analytical psychologist husband. She fails and the woman dies. The very last scene of the episode is the lawyer sitting on her living room floor, so distraught at her client's death that all she can muster is organizing her CD's and talking to her rather simple minded neighbor who comforts her. "One Step Up" is playing in the background the whole time. One of the all-time most compelling rock and TV mixtures in my personal viewing history.

Wish I could remember the details of the series, but yeah, that's one great song.

Speaking of Bruce's falsetto, are you familiar with "Lift Me Up" from John Sayles' much underrated "Limbo"?

And thank you.

Apr 2, 2012 7:10PM
avatar
Greg: just wanted to join JeffC in saying thanks for that great take on "Rocky Ground."  I'm with you on that song completely--it's the beauty of the bunch.  And I love Michelle Moore's rap.  Among other things the melody and Bruce's falsetto vocal in the background is reminding me of "One Step Up."  And in that context I really like hearing Michelle Moore come in and sing--it's like hearing that earlier song narrated from the point of view of the spouse left behind.

I really like thinking about the "when" you raise:  Bruce did make that first step you describe back at the 9/11 tribute concert (Tribute to Heroes) by singing "My City of Ruins" with some of his usual folks, but also two African American singers, one of whom, Delores Holmes, had been in his band in the late 1960s/early 1970s.  It's interesting to think about how much more mixed his band (and his sound) were in the beginning. 

avatar
I'm definitely in the camp of liking the new Imperial Teen. Originally it didn't feel enough like an Imperial Teen album and that put me off, but after seeing them perform some of the songs I started to understand and definitely really like it, and I guess would give it an A-. It's a lot catchier than I first thought, and I might be freaking out my friends' roommate right now by my singing to "All The Same" and "Last To Know".
Apr 2, 2012 5:33PM
avatar
Will Adele sing the next James Bond Theme?
Is there anybody better suited to shoulder a tradition so nobly upheld by Jack White, Alicia Keys, Chris Cornell, Queen Madge, Scott Walker, Sheryl Crow, Tina Turner, Gladys Knight, a-ha, Duran Duran, Rita Coolidge, Sheena Easton, Carly Simon, Lulu, Paul McCartney, Nancy Sinatra, Tom Jones, Shirley Bassey and Matt Monro?

Next in line: Lana Del Rey.

Your post was blocked for no reason other than to irritate the living daylights out of you.
Apr 2, 2012 4:46PM
avatar
*** for Imperial Teen? It's an A for me. "Out From Inside" is my most absolute favourite song of this early 2012. In fact, if I see this one show up on one of those Odds and Sods recaps it would damn near break my heart.
Apr 2, 2012 3:19PM
avatar
john -- two friends of mine went to that andrew w.k. show.  one left with a sore throat and two broken toes, which according to him meant the show was awesome.
Apr 2, 2012 1:46PM
avatar

Chiddy Bang: Breakfast: A−

Carolina Chocolate Drops: Leaving Eden: A−

Balkan Beat Box: Give: B+/A−

Burial: Kindred: B+

Imperial Teen: Feel the Sound: ***


Thoughts?

Apr 2, 2012 1:38PM
avatar
I should note that after looking into her Telmary is in fact a rapper, by trade. Her delivery, probably because of the context as much as anything, was strange enough that it sounded like several things at once. Musically, it was a very good context for her, live, and with a very big band behind her, but it's not hard to hear the same skill in her recorded work, whose overall quality I can't speak to.

Here's an NPR interview in which the songs they play make it much clearer: http://goo.gl/U8dAx
Apr 2, 2012 12:33PM
avatar
Just realized that the Hunger Games soundtrack has quite a cast: Arcade Fire, Taylor Swift, Pistol Annies, Carolina Chocolate Drops... The movie didn't impress me much but I think I'll give this album a shot.
Apr 2, 2012 12:07PM
avatar
Duke.: Wonderful review of the Dr. John concert! I especially love the way you describe good and bad improvisation. And these phrases: "It takes alot to crack wise when you're kissing a metal tube" and "he took someone else's phrase and made it his sentence," are terrific. As are many others. Bravo sir!
Apr 2, 2012 10:38AM
avatar
Xgau--did a little research...confirmed there is indeed no apostrophe in KDz. Second time in 24-hrs that I butchered his name--he deserves better. Was recovering from too much beer and college basketball. I think/hope Kenny will forgive me. In addition to the O'Douls and weed wacker fuel, I will send him some vintage Chicago Bulls zubaz.
Apr 2, 2012 9:13AM
avatar
Greg: Trenchant analysis, sir. For me the most surprising thing about Wrecking Ball is how it integrates its disparate influences--country & western, Irish folk, gospel, 60s soul, and hip hop--into Springsteen's signature arena-rock sound. It should be a mess but isn't. As music alone, it signifies deeper than anything he's done since Tunnel of Love. And, absolutely, African-American music--and voices--are key.
Apr 2, 2012 8:13AM
avatar
Dr. John & Friends, Part the Second:

Much of the night I got the impression of listening to what must be the world's most prestigious cruise ship band. It was a generalized blues, both emotionally and tonally, and a generalized jazz, and a generalized gospel. The emotional specificity came in specific moments from specific performers, and in the meantime the multiple generalizations bolstered each other's improbable ascent, while the bassist's high mix replaced the types of fun those musics usually give off with a more funky variety. The fellow [note: James Andrews; tall, bald, smiley, and dancing] who was the physical and performative emblem of Pops on stage was not terribly impressive to me as a horn player, but maybe he wasn't trying that hard, I couldn't say. Microwave gumbo, all flash, no pan. Kermit was the real musical evocation of the presiding spirit, out of all else I saw. It has something to do with him being a horn player of quality standing in his shadow, there's a certain amount of cognitive overlap both for him playing and us listening at an event like this, but it also has to do with his ease and fluency. Kermit dug around in notes and melodies with the kind of attention and indifference that was more than reminiscent of the big guy, but his music was also loaded with jokes. And that's crucial. It takes alot to crack wise when you're kissing a metal tube, and it takes alot of good stuff to let your chops be more than just chops. He does what many solo horns don't bother doing, if most of them ever did, and turns the already existing music into a music he wants to exist: he took someone else's phrase and made it his sentence.


The other instance of Louis's presence among us, it seemed to me, was the intra-sex banter of John and his singer. The warm, open sexuality and charisma of both parties, loaded with outrage and relish, was the closest I got to seeing the man's spirit brought to life, or directly paid tribute to. Way out in left field, though, was Ms. Diaz and her concatenating assonance, which probably sounds sexual for a reason. I've listened to spanish island hiphop before, so I was  in whatever small way prepared for what the Spanish language can do in a context which prizes aural density, but since I couldn't say she was rapping, I wasn't all that prepared. What it reminded me of more than anything was listening to Italians read Dante. They're both good examples of the virtue of having languages in which most words rhyme with at least a few hundred other words, but I bet if I were Ms. Diaz, I would have to work just as hard as Dante at shaping that resource into an actual musicality. She was stunning and I thank her mother.


Dr. John held the center admirably, with a wise left hand and a voice that did its duty. I'm not sure if he was asked to do this or he volunteered, but he seemed sheepish enough about the whole idea of it, either way. If I were a musician and someone asked me to pay tribute to Louis Armstrong I wouldn't know whether to cry or declare war.


That covers the bulk of what I experienced most vividly about the event. The parts where I was bored I might have just been skeptical, but most of the parts where I was bored are very nearly gone from me, already, so it's certainly something I enjoyed. The backing horns were really tight.


----


Looking over this I'd only add that Rene (who only gets a mention under intra-sex banter) was lovely, and the Blind Boys underused. The things me and Bob were in most direct agreement about were how impressed we were by Telmary Diaz, and how unfair it would be to hold the event and its members to the standard set by the man it was honoring. I'd never seen Dr. John in concert before, and had never really thought I would, so it was a good way to spend an evening.

Apr 2, 2012 8:12AM
avatar
Re: Dr John. These are the notes and impressions I set down a few hours after returning home the night of. Since they weren't being written to let other people know what went down, a few clarifying details: a from what I could tell mostly packed house of what must have been around a couple thousand; mostly the 40-60 set; the tone on their part, all through the evening, from beginning to end, was one of uncommon enthusiasm; Doc will take his place at the black baby grand center-left, and a revolving door of artists (singers and solo horns) will swing through to accompany him and his slick percussionists. Rickie Lee will be drunk, Roy Hargrove will be short, and the Blind Boys of Alabama will see nothing the whole night through.

Here's the full list:
Featured artists:
Kermit Ruffins [horn, happy, fedora]
Rickie Lee Jones [singer, zooted, smile]
Roy Hargrove [horn]
Arturo Sandoval [horn]
Blind Boys of Alabama [choir]
Wendell Brunious [horn]
Telmary Diaz [singer(?)]
James Andrews [horn]
Rene Marie [singer]

What's immediately clear in my memory is that the music and the performances were confusing and surprising enough. It's also fair to say that more times than should have been plausible the groove took over and the act became more than the sum of its parts. The less it had to do with honoring or even playing Pops, the better the music was. In an off moment while someone shuffled the sheet music I remember Doc John saying a few kind words that he no doubt meant and no doubt didn't really need to say, but for the most part songs were chosen which were either incredibly apt for him to strip for parts and reassemble under the auspices of his own artistic M.O., or simply weren't Louis songs in either style or character, let alone origin. A good specific instance of these points is that stout Latino fellow, Arturo, I believe, who was brought in the first time around under those auspices of Pops-via-Doc, and stank like a fish a few days out of water. Chops, chops, and more chops, with no attachment to the music, so that at one point it sounded like his rapid, taut, skillful arpeggiations and note contortions were excerpts from "The Flight of the Bumblebee" over a pretty vapid boogie. When he's cued up, though, about an hour later, for a Latin toe-tapper, he knows exactly why he's there, and he spends the next five to ten minutes calmly explaining it to us with his horn. 


(to be--)

Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap