Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Plug/Seefeel

Heritage Post-Rock

By Xgau Jun 5, 2012 5:47AM

 

Plug: Back on Time (Ninja Tune)

After I first plucked Plug from my shelves, I assumed he was some new retro-electro guy, but actually he's minor techno legend Luke Vibert, who I've always preferred under his Wagon Christ moniker, just not so's I felt any need to testify about it. (Very) roughly speaking, say Vibert is trancey, Wagon Christ fanciful, and Plug‑-who in the mid '90s released the Drum'n'Bass for Papa album hard upon three EPs, all still findable as a twofer on Trent Reznor's label‑-a necromancer. Although the story is that Vibert stumbled upon 10 old Plug tracks and declared them an album on a whim, I'm betting they stayed in the can because they were just too all-over-the-place for 1997. But for those of us who find electronica too functional anyway, all-over-the-place equals content: the willful structures, sonic shifts, interrupted grooves, and goofy vocal bits are as eventful as a good lyric. For once drum'n'bass's impossible Conlon Nancarrow beats, which Plug does pretty well with on those EPs, are the bed where the real music crinkles, crashes, chimes, swoops, swells, squiggles, gurgles, cracks wise, and just generally hooks you. Start with "Come on My Skeleton" and "Back on Time." Then do yourself a favor and listen fore-to-aft. A MINUS

 

Seefeel: Seefeel (Warp)

The gears that never quite mesh in this disquieting but hardly apocalyptic industrial ambient may be metal and may be plastic but are probably both. Over steady drumming with a martial feel, they evoke two kinds of bum transmission, one automotive and the other an AM station breaking up on a late-night four-lane. Phones ring occasionally. Doors squeak. Pretty people murmur and croon. But that bird you hear chirping isn't‑-isn't chirping, isn't a bird. Think the part of a Tricky album that's no way funky. Stabilized by nary a foolish word, the unease is so unapocalyptic it's almost comforting. B PLUS

 

134Comments
Jun 10, 2012 4:36PM
avatar

Bit on the windy side but Margaret Atwood has some good stuff on Ray Bradbury.

GOOGLE: The Guardian / Margaret Atwood on Ray Bradbury

Jun 9, 2012 8:34AM
avatar
I have to put in a plug for this Bradbury obit, not only because it's the smartest benevolent one I've read, but because it includes a notice of the H.P. Lovecraft antimatter --

http://goo.gl/tpnWl

Jun 8, 2012 4:13AM
avatar
Didn't Call Me originally get a B+?
Jun 8, 2012 12:19AM
avatar
"kevin john, by "late capitalist abundance" do you mean the explosion of the number of billionaires?"

Not quite. More the culture of Napster, torrents, sharity blogs, etc. In short, Adorno would've loved Pan Sonic.
Jun 7, 2012 11:43PM
avatar
gdash- Weren't the Andy Fairweather Lowe and Lynyrd Synyrd debuts B+ to A upgrade? As was Radio City. The only B to A upgrade I recall is the first Wailers Island record. (So much great Wailers before that though).
Jun 7, 2012 11:32PM
avatar
Sorry about being unclear. I blame it on Clankface giving me fever about italics and links.

Anyway, Scott Walker the musician = kitsch

Scott Walker the governor = a stromtrooper

Exclusive Company = crappy WI record store

In addition to Pole (good call, Bradley!), Pan Sonic fans (MBV fans too) might seek out Pita and Oval. Even Greil Marcus liked Oval iirc so...yeah. And Pita helped satiate those of us longing for a Loveless (s(rew italics!) followup. Here's an absolutely gorgeous, tear-in-my-feedback Pita track: http://goo.gl/C1KPz

Jun 7, 2012 11:28PM
avatar
kevin john, by "late capitalist abundance" do you mean the explosion of the number of billionaires?
Jun 7, 2012 11:13PM
avatar
I am so not the person to be asking about doomy stonery cosmicy concept albums. Regarding Ufomammut, the connoisseurs prefer 2010's Eve and i didn't care about that one either. I prefer Holst.
Jun 7, 2012 11:01PM
avatar
Ryan, I always liked the Welch-era Mac. One of my favourite Xgau lines, though, was something about Welch's sounding bored being poetic justice.  Jones125, your comment got me to wondering what the biggest upgrade in the '70s guide was.  I think I know.  Anyone want to guess without looking it up?
Jun 7, 2012 9:40PM
avatar
Tilt's cover makes it look like an out there black metal record, which might explain why Mikael Akerfeldt has claimed Walker as an influence, although apparently he likes Drift the most.   
Jun 7, 2012 9:25PM
avatar

I find the weird Scott Walker you can listen to without the guffaws is Tilt. Strange creature it is. A newer one called Drift is supposed to operate in the same territory, but I thought it fell way short. Needed a blood transfusion.

Jun 7, 2012 9:10PM
avatar
Multiple re-readings, and I still can't determine if Kevin's talking about the governor or the former Walker brother.  I'll admit that I've kind of enjoyed Scott 4 the few times I've played it.  I think it might help that I'm young enough that his style of non-rock crooning seems almost exotic, rather than the commonplace dull music of my elders.  

Pulling up something from earlier in the thread, Brad, should I take it that you did not care for the Uffomammut?  I was thinking of checking it out because Ben Ratliff wrote some nice stuff about it in the Times.  On the other hand, Decibel's review was more middling, and I figure their critics would be more inclined to dig a good doom-plod epic.  I have been getting into the Royal Thunder album, gradually.  Still skeptical about those song lengths, though.  
Jun 7, 2012 8:05PM
avatar
Kevin John mentioned Pan Sonic; if I may, I would further recommend Pole's album 2 (2 is the red one). It's like Pan Sonic but with a dub underbelly. Very cool. Also short--more like an EP. Just the right amount of clicking and cutting.
Jun 7, 2012 6:53PM
avatar
P.S. I started to derive pleasure from Scott Walker once I allowed myself to guffaw at him as pure kitsch. Sorry but that was my only way in. Wish that worked with the stormtrooper clomping all over my former place of residence (oh btw - I loathed The Exclusive Company. Their buyer never read a Consumer Guide in his life!).
Jun 7, 2012 6:45PM
avatar
Been Plug tunin' non-stop since Tuesday. Terrific album. But yo - drum'n'bass was perfectly capable of all-over-the-place abundance before 1997. As always, check The History of Our World Part One: Breakbeat & Jungle Ultramix By DJ DB where fierce functionality kicks up more content than any mix CD in electronica's heyday. And with the genre showing signs of a$$ rot by 1998, someone like Hrvatski shredded even the kitchen sink (i.e. those Nancarrow beats) in the kitchen sink. Spring Heel Jack Fans should dig him: http://goo.gl/YsAl9  Remember – dying cultures are always eclectic (thank you Jon Savage in The Rock Yearbook 1983).

Those seeking the opposite (and a possible critique of late capitalist abundance) should check Pan Sonic and hear how minimal things could get. And I do mean "things" - their music sounds like an industrial landscape ineffectually scrubbed of various noise objects.


Jun 7, 2012 6:18PM
avatar
"to avoid cluttering up the posts, when I get the results ready, if people want to post their own Wussy best ofs, maybe they could do it as a reply to my post rather than as a new post.  Then they would be easily avoided by anyone who's not interested.  Just a thought."

Brilliant!

I love that it turns what was a negative feature into a positive, at the same time curtailing alienation factor. Hearty endorsement.
Jun 7, 2012 6:08PM
avatar
Every once in a while I like to pull out "Sentimental Lady", coz it's schlocky fun.and earlier today I did just that. As such I ended up pondering the little information I have over Bob Welch -- to me and surely nobody else, he's a fascinatingly odd figure, at least in the context of Fleetwood Mac, a band for which he was the unlikely headliner from '71 to '74 and in which he never really made sense. The French Kiss stuff and beyond is all grotesque notion, but in his, er, prime, Welch was curious charm. So I figured when I got back I might check up on interviews and see just what, say, Mick Fleetwood thought of him. If there isn't a comment now, I guess there will be soon. Strange.

Like the Beatles' work in the early 70s, I find the Welch-affiliated period of the Mac's existence fascinatingly inconsequential; those five or six post-Pete pre-juggernaut albums are more or less completely undiscussed. That's a lot of work from one of the great groups to completely write out of history, and one which crucially documents things like their gradual transmogrification from blues-rock to eccentric radio-pop, Christine McVie's (er) development as a songwriter. Our host's reviews are probably the probingest insight anybody's ever provided. I've always wanted to spend some time in them, but could never really work up enough interest, which as I understand it is their overall effect anyway. Maybe as a kind of tribute I'll finally listen to the rest of Bare Trees.
Jun 7, 2012 4:55PM
avatar
Thanks for the update on the book, Bob. Hope they gave you a decent advance.
Jun 7, 2012 3:52PM
avatar
I guess compulsive editing is a lot easier when reviews are in transition like this, as opposed to finalized in print. I'd be tempted to replace words and redirect the flow of a phrase or sentence too, which makes me wonder how often you've regretted how a review turned out and how often you then changed it around to your liking. I could probably site a few I know of - anyone interested in this stuff should consult the What's New? section of Christgau's awesome, compendious (couldn't think of a better word. Encyclopedic? Thorough-going?) and immensely resourceful site - the review/s of the American Spring album for example, but I'm not sure if anyone's quite as interested as I am in the minor details of your output (so did the two-disc reissue of Here, My Dear get marked an A or what? Did A Salty Dog really get marked down to a B+?). I'm very curious about lots of things.

On the topic of the book, I'm very much looking forward to it whether I visit New York or not, here's hoping I do. But I also wonder at the latest installment of the Consumer Guide, if it's coming. Thank you!

Jun 7, 2012 3:50PM
avatar
Clankface must be of an apolitical persuasion today or a big time Sheldon Adelson fan, because three concurrent attempts to post a Scott Walker recall-related screed was denied. Which might in the end not be a totally bad thing, unless you're really curious to see how many donors to Walker's successful campaign to destroy unions were out of state billionaires.

But maybe I can sneak this by. Add this blow to labor to the recent spectacle of every single Republican voting against equal pay for women and to the upcoming health care law decision by the same Supreme Court that brought you Citizen's United. I haven't been through nearly as many election cycles as some of you here, but it sure seems to me this ("this" I guess being the last ten years) is one of the worst moments in recent history to be politically conscious.
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap