Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Thomas Anderson/Craig Finn

Heartland Tales

By Xgau Feb 7, 2012 7:23AM

Thomas Anderson: The Moon in Transit (Four-Track Demos, 1996-2009)  (Out There)

By electing to expend his Dutch East India advance on a fancy tape recorder instead of the Velvet Underground reunion, this Austin singer-songwriter acquired the means to preserve his songs in analog form, and here's the fruit. There were two good albums and then three marginal ones over two decades, so who'd expect a grab bag to be his best? Yet it is. With all four tracks laid down DIY, it's even squarer rhythmically than his norm, and his calm drawl verges on the spectral. But it also verges on the hypnotic, and the guy can write stories and work up tunes. After a brief fanfare, there's an opener about the Donner Party so gruesome and precise I sometimes skip to the merely spooky "Heckling Houdini." Also featured are a 33-year-old groupie-turned-granny, a cross-dressing uncle, Ubangi-stomping Warren Smith, a painfully slow lunch with Nefertiti a few years or millennia too late, driving till you're dizzy in a dumbshit town, and the one about lost love and "Antihistamines": "Chlorpheniramine, Diphenhydramine,/Doxylamine, Phenindamine,/ Tripolidine and Pheniramine,/I can't cure my pain with antihistamines." A MINUS

 

Craig Finn: Clear Heart Full Eyes (Vagrant)

On a wittingly laid-back solo debut where the declamatory Hold Steady frontman knows he can't bring off the country vocals his best songs deserve, he nails three flat-out anyway: "Terrified Eyes" (couple destroyed by their hospital bills), "When No One's Watching" (snazzy scuzzball seeks needy women), and "Balcony" (she does with her new man what she did with her old man back when he was new). The rest tend more, how to say it, evocative. But at least they evoke specifics‑-Middle American dramatis personae as marginal as Wussy's. B PLUS

 

188Comments
Jul 16, 2012 5:46AM
avatar
Both of these albums blow goats..25 songs that are poorly written garage band musicianship and horrid vocals
Feb 10, 2012 1:20AM
avatar
Hatful of Hollow may finally get its A minus? Johnny Marr never thought Morrissey would live to see the day.
How about Singles getting an A?
Feb 9, 2012 11:44PM
avatar
I haven't yet seen the clip, only read about it from you all while I was working.  But that's....illuminati​ng.  And extremely sad. 
Michael, I'll note that one could take issue with my final pull quote - O'Reilly might simply be agreeing with his guest so he can rush on to the real point ("yes, yes, maybe it's a threat, but listen.."). But why even agree on such a noxious point? 
Feb 9, 2012 11:43PM
avatar
Hatful of Hollow may finally get its A minus? Johnny Marr never thought Morrissey would live to see the day.
Feb 9, 2012 11:42PM
avatar
I wouldn't separate them at all. That 'additional' was added in to show that I think not everyone feels the need to treat their music as an exploration of human endeavor, not that I think people who explore music as something other than pleasure or personal identification are doing so without pleasure or personal identification. I think there are plenty of people, as well, who approach movies or books or what you will as pure pleasure, and don't spend a great deal of time intermingling their identities with them.
avatar
I think it actually is rather nefarious. That's a few too many glowing references to "traditional" values in a segment about gay rights for me.

Well, he's still Bill O'Reilly. But he's in a better position to affect public opinion on this than practically anybody else - he's planting a seed that you can treat gays as equals (and think McCarthyism was bad!) while still being a Fox News-loving "real American" with "traditional values" - sounds like progress to me! If his views on gay equality and his ways of discussing them fell in line with more left-wing ones, he wouldn't be on Fox in the first place, and even if he was, he would have zero credibility, and therefore zero impact, with their viewership.

Feb 9, 2012 11:41PM
avatar
When he notes early on in the segment that his employer, Fox News, has "made a tremendous contribution to the country by respecting traditional opinion," midway through mentions attacks on himself by "far-left loons" because he "stands up for traditional values," and ends the sequence by agreeing that homosexuality "may be a serious problem in our culture," I think it actually is rather nefarious. That's a few too many glowing references to "traditional" values in a segment about gay rights for me.

But I'm glad he said what little he said, and I'll stop complaining.
I haven't yet seen the clip, only read about it from you all while I was working.  But that's....illuminating.  And extremely sad.
avatar
their taste in music is specifically bound up with their sense of themselves, rather than negotiating that additional sense of 'music' as a field of human endeavor

Duke, I'm not sure I understand. In practice, what would be the difference between the listening habits of someone whose taste is bound with their sense of themselves vs someone who conceives of music primarily as a field of human endeavor? How do you tell between one and the other?  Can you separate the two that neatly?

Feb 9, 2012 11:23PM
avatar
Not terribly nefarious, that. 
When he notes early on in the segment that his employer, Fox News, has "made a tremendous contribution to the country by respecting traditional opinion," midway through mentions attacks on himself by "far-left loons" because he "stands up for traditional values," and ends the sequence by agreeing that homosexuality "may be a serious problem in our culture," I think it actually is rather nefarious. That's a few too many glowing references to "traditional" values in a segment about gay rights for me.

But I'm glad he said what little he said, and I'll stop complaining.
Feb 9, 2012 11:12PM
avatar
He's obviously not mounting a defense of homosexuality, as Jason notes, but I'm not terribly given to this 'clever deflection' theory, either. The word I hone in on is 'American'. He points out that she is a legitimate American citizen, deserving of every respect we should accord to such individuals, and from this man I know no plainer mark of equitable esteem; so I wouldn't be too quick to assume that there is craft involved in his argument beyond making an argument--on his own terms, and also on the grounds which matter most to him, grounds which clearly place her rights and standing as a citizen over anything to do with her sexuality.
Not terribly nefarious, that.
Feb 9, 2012 11:00PM
avatar
I saw the O'Reilly clip and Jason brings up a good point. Still, it was a little weird seeing Bill "defending" Ellen.
Feb 9, 2012 10:51PM
avatar
My first Smiths' was 1986's The Queen is Dead. I liked it pretty well. Never bought their first two in large part because of Bob's less than glowing reviews. Then Louder Than Bombs got a B+ also and my interest started to grow. I stayed with Morrisey through Your Arsenal than moved on. I have fond memories of that era and those songs but rarely play them these days. Still, Bob's comments got me thinking. The Queen is Dead is now on the iPod. I was kinda shocked it wasn't already but there you go.
Feb 9, 2012 10:40PM
avatar
Bill O'Reilly defends Ellen DeGeneres 
People are getting a little too ebullient and teary-eyed over what is a defense of the free market and the right of a business to do what they see fit. There is zero support of gay rights under discussion in this interview - just a clever deflection of the real issue. O'Reilly plays this card from time to time.
Feb 9, 2012 10:29PM
avatar
Bill O'Reilly defends Ellen DeGeneres, compares organized homophobia to McCarthyism. I can't believe it.
I'm surprised he actually cited McCarthyism as a bad thing -- what will Ann Coulter think?
Feb 9, 2012 10:18PM
avatar
Bill O'Reilly defends Ellen DeGeneres, compares organized homophobia to McCarthyism. I can't believe it.

Well, if there is an apocalypse that's surely got to be a sign of it!

 

P.S.  Friend and I decided to go spend money at JC Penny even though we don't need to and saying 'Thank you for keeping Ellen.'

Feb 9, 2012 9:16PM
avatar
really enjoyed the podcast!

also, upon recommendation by N.F. and J.G., got Cloud Nothing's new record, which yes is awesome.  and J.G. nailed it's allure.

Feb 9, 2012 9:00PM
avatar
Testing; Section Two, Continued: The Mix

Okay. That determines it. Not that I can claim to understand it. MSN apparently doesn't like me posting an enumerated list, of songs with their authors, for the purposes of instigating a musical-if-not-aural understanding in my readers. I am confused, but not vanquished.

Edit: Okay, I think the latest problem is that I'm now copying and pasting things into the box, which it is taking as a sign that I'm a spamhead, if not also an egghead.

I will try re-typing all of it, sans list.

No.

Well.

This is what losing feels like.

Section Three:

3. I think shuffle plays best for two kinds of people, and was probably invented with the first of these in mind: 1) People whose collections are not necessarily vast, expansive, or stupidly disparate, with an important stipulation that, even if they own different types of music, their taste in music is specifically bound up with their sense of themselves, rather than negotiating that additional sense of 'music' as a field of human endeavor, so that to randomly explore their collection is in some way akin to randomly exploring themselves. 2) People whose collections, no matter their size, are pruned, in whatever way, to be almost totally comprised of things they can reliably enjoy listening to.
Feb 9, 2012 8:50PM
avatar
testing

Edit: Mhm. Either my post is too long or MSN's "There's a problem creating posts right now. Please try again later." is a tactful sidestepping of my including a spliff in my post.

Edit: Okay, spliff flew: joint, marijuana, THC, stoned, sky-high, zooted, rooted, shoot it--

Edit: Let's see about length. Section One:

1. "an arduously boring task" Sure is. I remember when I had to make the decision to go digital, after a long story made off with the bulk of my collection. It was vexing and beyond my comprehension to upload the cds that were left to me--only a few hundred--while also thinking about ways to ease the Reconstruction Period. But man did I ever wish for a workman's zen to fall upon me, and man did it ever not, slotting those cds and listening to them whirr until such a time as they should be returned to me, awaiting a replacement. Hellish and cruel.

Edit: Hooray for Empiricism. Section Two: Okay, that didn't work. The problem is in section two. Perhaps a truncated version.


2. "I enjoy listening to albums just fine, but I also love the idea of them serving as raw material for playlists." There's no doubt that this has been one of the fundamental relationships between myself and music in the course of my life. It's part of why I'm so sensitive to Milo's quite 'venerable' track listings: having made mixes almost my whole musical life has made me an opinionated if not exactly vocal exegete of proper tune placement. Here's a recent example of my quarreling with contingency:

To be continued.
Feb 9, 2012 8:38PM
avatar
Liam- Thanks, that avatar change was inspired by the LiLiPUT , and I had just loaded Germ Free Adolescents back onto my i-type device.

When you get a chance can you post the information on how and where I can catch your radio show?


Feb 9, 2012 8:26PM
avatar
That was amusing, with a grateful minimum of talk-radio grabassery. [Personally, I was glad to hear about the 600 words -- that's approx as much as I can turn out in decent shape per day, 800 if I'm really rompin'. And 30 years ago I resisted like hell doing more than around twice that per 24 hours.]
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap