Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Thomas Anderson/Craig Finn

Heartland Tales

By Xgau Feb 7, 2012 7:23AM

Thomas Anderson: The Moon in Transit (Four-Track Demos, 1996-2009)  (Out There)

By electing to expend his Dutch East India advance on a fancy tape recorder instead of the Velvet Underground reunion, this Austin singer-songwriter acquired the means to preserve his songs in analog form, and here's the fruit. There were two good albums and then three marginal ones over two decades, so who'd expect a grab bag to be his best? Yet it is. With all four tracks laid down DIY, it's even squarer rhythmically than his norm, and his calm drawl verges on the spectral. But it also verges on the hypnotic, and the guy can write stories and work up tunes. After a brief fanfare, there's an opener about the Donner Party so gruesome and precise I sometimes skip to the merely spooky "Heckling Houdini." Also featured are a 33-year-old groupie-turned-granny, a cross-dressing uncle, Ubangi-stomping Warren Smith, a painfully slow lunch with Nefertiti a few years or millennia too late, driving till you're dizzy in a dumbshit town, and the one about lost love and "Antihistamines": "Chlorpheniramine, Diphenhydramine,/Doxylamine, Phenindamine,/ Tripolidine and Pheniramine,/I can't cure my pain with antihistamines." A MINUS

 

Craig Finn: Clear Heart Full Eyes (Vagrant)

On a wittingly laid-back solo debut where the declamatory Hold Steady frontman knows he can't bring off the country vocals his best songs deserve, he nails three flat-out anyway: "Terrified Eyes" (couple destroyed by their hospital bills), "When No One's Watching" (snazzy scuzzball seeks needy women), and "Balcony" (she does with her new man what she did with her old man back when he was new). The rest tend more, how to say it, evocative. But at least they evoke specifics‑-Middle American dramatis personae as marginal as Wussy's. B PLUS

 

188Comments
Feb 9, 2012 8:11PM
avatar
Oh Bob, no matter what excuse you have to give to keep the peace, I still feel like a cool guy. There's gotta be others around here who woulda liked to have been mentioned about a thousand times more tho. :) Too bad for their gender. 

I would gladly meet you were I up New York way, and soon I probably will be! JockRothko moved there a week ago (though I hate to say it—still adjusting). Pluuusss I'll be schooling in Philadelphia relatively soon. So watch yer back! You'll be able to see that I'm not thaaaaat hairy in the flesh, if that guy succeeded in scaring you. 
Feb 9, 2012 7:57PM
avatar
On my iPod the Wrens are between World Famous Supreme Team (you know which song) and Wura Fadaka from Kings of Highlife. On the Cd shelves, Wreckless Eric & Amy Rigby and Charles Wright. A good reminder that I need to get some Betty Wright.
Feb 9, 2012 7:38PM
avatar
Bill O'Reilly defends Ellen DeGeneres, compares organized homophobia to McCarthyism. I can't believe it. It's awesome: 

http://goo.gl/bXZD8
Feb 9, 2012 7:33PM
avatar
Fun podcast!  If I'm not mistaken, the Gary Lewis & the Playboys song Yo La Tengo sometimes cover is Count Me In - a tune for which I've always had an irrational fondness.  I think Gary himself still performs it on occasion.
avatar
He also gave shout-outs to EW commenters in general, Hairy Irene in particular, and early Smiths albums

Haha, that digression on Irene is pretty long too. I think Xgau was right about early Smiths the first time (that James Taylor comparison!), but I would love to read his re-evaluation. 


Your post was blocked because it appears similar to spam or automated messages. If this is not the case, revise your post and try again.

Feb 9, 2012 7:03PM
avatar
Am I missing something? Podcast? Irene? Hm. Someone link me, please. EDIT: Nevermind, I see the link. Listening now. Thanks.

Carnival is underway. The snow sculpture is a disgrace. A 'cupcake' beat out a 'ruined Mayan Temple.' And why? It's 2012, the end of times. Is no one paying attention?! 

Anyway, I overheard a junior girl the other day referencing this controversial cupcake: 'Seriously--it's a chode on top of a box. It's the worst.' And yeah, she's right. Laziness on the part of the underclass. I promised pictures, but you wouldn't get much from them. 

Forty ballots and counting. Interesting list. The young-ones break up what Cam predicted is otherwise a Rolling Stone mag recap. Two albums in particular have cracked the top twenty that--to be honest--reflect no critical wave I've seen. And who knows--maybe that means we're watching the tide rise before us. One day left!


Feb 9, 2012 6:51PM
avatar
re the podcast: pretty sure the only thing "Hotel California" is good for is the CIA's enhanced interrogation techniques.
Feb 9, 2012 6:49PM
avatar
I've got the Wrens bookended by Wreckless Eric and Wu-Tang, unless you count artists that only appear on compilations, in which case it's Wreckx N Effect and Wrong Kind of Stone Age (there's one for ya).  If I had my last names sorted out, though, Charles Wright would figure.
avatar
Just finished Eric Weisbards Use yr Ilusion and.now I'm cranking The Spaghetti Incident which sounds the best it ever has

You should play Use Your Illusion! Both volumes are too long, but Vol. 2 in particular has lots of great stuff on it (great songs that no one ever talks about: "Breakdown", "Locomotive").


Feb 9, 2012 6:19PM
avatar
My only fear about that podcast is that some hater--I have my share--will come in and start flaming. Those who don't bother to listen should know that the lovely Irene got namechecked because I called you all guys and felt obliged to make the exception.
PS Moe Willems was great despite his professed distaste for all contemporary pop culture. The host's kids started the interview. I didn't stay for the taxi driver who was trying to break whatever Guinness record he was trying to break.

Feb 9, 2012 6:11PM
avatar
Yes, fun podcast, and congrats to our namechecked Irene. It's too bad the hosts talk over Xgau just as he's making one of his funniest comments about EW: "They follow everything I do, and we agree about everything - they all love Have Moicy!"
Feb 9, 2012 6:04PM
avatar
Re: that very entertaining podcast.  So odd that "electronic Pygmy music" is dismissed reflexively out of hand in a way that, say, Jackson Browne is not.  Go figure.  Thanks, Glen.
Feb 9, 2012 6:02PM
avatar
I'm just as excited to hear Mo Willem's too. He's kind of a god in our household. If you have chillun's then you know what I mean.
Feb 9, 2012 5:57PM
avatar
Had to wait until I got home to check: The Wrens are shelved between the Voice compilation Wish You Were Here: Love Songs for New York and Wussy's Funeral Dress.

Thanks for the heads up on the next Rock & Roll & column, Glen. The subject has certainly been getting a lot of play around our house of late.
Feb 9, 2012 5:38PM
avatar
The next Rock & Roll & column will be about Etta James, so says Xgau who appeared on WFMU's Seven Second Delay yesterday. He also gave shout-outs to EW commenters in general, Hairy Irene in particular, and early Smiths albums, as well as calling Lana Del Ray "pretty good". You can find the stream here: http://goo.gl/5G92l 
Feb 9, 2012 4:53PM
avatar
Agreed about the redundancy with the Young box.  The worst thing wasn't reprising album tracks that I don't need reprised, it was that they issued entire live discs from the box as separately available CDs first, and then duplicated them in the box!  That's too much of a consumer rip off for me to partake. 
avatar
Going back to the Neil Young box, I saw it in a shop today and got tired just looking at it.  I'm sure it's great but I don't know if I'm ever going to find out.  I don't really want to pay again for a lot of stuff I have already.
avatar
Thumbs up for Mike Imes' avatar!  Was that in response to the question about what was next to the Wrens, or is that just coincidence?
avatar
Re shuffle, my Rio Karma has a feature where it will select stuff you haven't played for a while, which I like.  I had a Creative Zen with a similar feature ("rarely played" or something it was called) but that's broken now.  I hardly ever use shuffle on my iPod, don't know why.

Meadowlands is as great as everyone says! 

Paul, re Betty Wright best of, there is a 2LP on 1 CD with Danger High Voltage and This Time for Real.  She was on Jools Holland's Hootenany on the BBC last New Year's Eve and sounded great, sang "Shoorah! Shoorah!".  Cyndi Lauper was on it too and was absolutely fantastic, might be on You Tube.

I heard "Andrew in Drag" by the Magnetic Fields again the other night, I think it's going to be my song of the year.

avatar
I got that Stern's box set, but it was only 18 CDs when I got it.  I was a bit annoyed when they reissued it with 20 CDs.  Some of them are a bit short, too. I think there's a maximum of one track per artist.  To be fair, I got one of the first copies at a reduced price.

A couple of countries aren't represented - no Libyan music, if I remember correctly.

The version of "N'sel Fik" is different to the one on You Are Mine - more synthy (and not as good) but that song is widely available.  If you don't know it, there are very few things in the world as amazing as "N'sel Fik", go find it.

Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap