Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Louis Prima/Carmen McRae

Armstrong and Monk Revisited

By Xgau Mar 8, 2011 3:48AM

 

Louis Prima: Zooma Zooma: The Best of Louis Prima (Rhino '90)

A Vegas fixture for a quarter century before he died at 67 in 1978, this Storyville-born Sicilian singer-trumpeter shared his entertainment philosophy as well as his Christian name with Armstrong and Jordan. He crossed over r&b with 1950's "Oh, Babe!" but it was the honking tenor and rough vocal cameos of his compatriot Sam Butera that added rock and roll anti-class to a jazz act that pitted Prima's jocular leads against the sensible musicality of his consort Keely Smith. Prima was a go-for-the-gut clown whose signature musical tactic was to intersperse flat-out novelties like "Robin Hood" and "Jump, Jive an' Wail" with two-song medleys that moved the crap-shooting punters on to "I Ain't Got Nobody" before "Just a Gigolo" got old. Since 1990, when Rhino assembled these 18 tracks (14 on cassette, remember that one?), there have been more straight reissues, reshuffled comps, radio transcriptions, and live exhumations than I want to hear or count. More likely to cost four bucks than the 40 some chiselers are charging, this out-of-print 18-track laff-fest is probably the best, probably because it keeps the rock market in mind. The best alternative I've heard is the 1991 Capitol Collectors Series, which has eight more tracks but omits the nostalgic "Robin Hood" and the fat "Them There Eyes"/"Honeysuckle Rose." Forget Capitol's 26-track 2007 Jump, Jive an' Wail: The Essential Louis Prima, with its non-NAACP "Civilization (Bongo Bongo Bongo)," pre-IIADL "Luigi," and bored run-throughs of "Hello Dolly" and "Cabaret." The pura the zooma the betta. A

 

Carmen McRae: Carmen Sings Monk (Bluebird '02)

For those of us who admire the eminently capable McRae primarily for what she isn't‑-that is, a self-aggrandizing improvisor like Betty Carter or a nightclub hack like Nancy Wilson‑-this expanded reissue of the 13-track 1988 original is welcome because it honors Monk the melodist. Believe me, Johnny Mercer is not on board here; more than half the lyrics are by Jon Hendricks, who thinks "body loose" is a dandy rhyme for "loose goose," although his biographical takes on "Monk's Dream" and "In Walked Bud" speak enjoyably to what he knows best, which is music. The same goes for McRae, who burnishes and reshapes these great tunes subtly enough to let you know how deeply she's thought about them. Although pianist Eric Gunnison gets through way too many notes, the Al Foster-George Mraz rhythm section adds more than most of those the master gigged with, and longtime Monk saxophonist Charlie Rouse is so intimate with the material that there are times when he tops the headliner even though he never tries to upstage her. Note if you like that when I loaded this onto my iPod, where it certainly belongs, I omitted the five perfectly acceptable alternate takes, which have the effect of making the music go on too long. For an hour, it's a gift to the dead. A MINUS

 

133Comments
Mar 8, 2011 9:41AM
avatar
Tried a lot of Prima on Rhapsody before I wrote my review--bits of eight or ten collections--but the only other record I owned was Captiol Collectors Series, and as I wrote, I came to prefer the shorter Rhino, partly for the specifics mentioned, but also partly, I think, because it was shorter. May well be true of this big one too, but I'm downloading it to my Sansa player as I write. Who knows, maybe in six months or so I'll be checking in with some news.
Mar 8, 2011 9:39AM
avatar
Thanks Jimmy, for the ULTRA LOUNGE mention. Looks like I might have to do a little revamp on my playlist too.
Tom: my trial with Rhapsody ended a couple days ago, but in actuality a couple weeks ago, when every time I tried to play anything there was an unexpected error. I wanted to at least give a listen to the xgau Dynamic Playlists and JYY's. Ones I did hear the sound seemed thinner than MOG's but that's not based on much real listening.

Mar 8, 2011 9:27AM
avatar
Skylark is brilliant, a lovely sweet sad little thing.
Mar 8, 2011 9:26AM
avatar
To pick on some literary threads from the previous thread. If you're starting with Bolano, don't start with 2666. The fourth section is punishing and meant to be. (The reality may even be worse. Read Charles Bowden.) I started with By Night In Chile and that's a good entry point.

A bad entry point to Doris Lessing is the five book science fiction series which I forced myself through when it first came out. The second book was the one people liked because it was the least like science fiction. The one that resonates with me is the fourth book where everyone freezes to death. I thought of it this morning on the walk between the bus and work.

I wanted to second a recommendation for Skylark by Dezso Kosztolanyi, neither lost or forgotten but available in a spiffy reissue from NYRB classics.

Personal to Xtrapnel: if we're taking nicknames from there, can I call dibs on Sillery?
Mar 8, 2011 9:23AM
avatar

JimmyCook is right - all of the Zooma Zooma tracks are on the Wild, Cool & Swingin' set.  I could have just trimmed that one - oh well.  Some time is well killed.

Mar 8, 2011 9:08AM
avatar
Hey Bob, what about Capitol's 44 track Ultra-Lounge: Artist Series Vol. 1? It seems to include Robin Hood and Honeysuckle as well as dropping the more egregious tracks from the 26 song comp you mention.  Of course, it could all be too much but these days so easy to edit, and...it's available!
Mar 8, 2011 9:01AM
avatar

cdrum - We're thinking alike.  I just created Zooma Zooma as a playlist on Rhapsody.  Should be available in a half hour, so says the computer.

 

Everything I needed was on Capitol Collectors Series and the 2CD Wild, Cool & Swingin': The Artist's Collection, assuming I got the right versions, which, who knows.

 

One might suspect that I am avoiding an unpleasant task or something.

Mar 8, 2011 8:55AM
avatar
Thanks Jeff for reminding me what originally prompted me to pick up CARMEN SINGS MONK too.
Mar 8, 2011 8:53AM
avatar
If you are having trouble, like me, even finding a track list for Zooma Zooma -- much less a reasonably priced (cheap) copy of the CD -- I finally did find one (a track list) at http://goo.gl/Ag2NG. And I was able to put together a MOG playlist with all the songs (hopefully the correct versions) at http://goo.gl/G0ewf. I did find a lot of the songs on CAPITOL COLLECTORS SERIES.
Your post was blocked because it appears similar to spam or automated messages. If this is not the case, revise your post and try again.

Mar 8, 2011 8:44AM
avatar
...and I'll have whatever Walter's having.
Mar 8, 2011 8:18AM
avatar
Have owned and enjoyed Carmen Sings Monk since Xgau's mention in his review of Tom Moon's 1,000 Recordings to Hear Before You Die a few years ago. It's now my go-to disc when I want to introduce newbies to Monk's unique approach to melody. For some reason, it seems having words attached to the notes makes it easier to follow their shifting contours and abrupt left turns.
Mar 8, 2011 7:09AM
avatar
Wow. An 21-year old compilation and an expanded album originally from '88. What a delightful left turn! I was at a jazz listening party in Harlem a few weeks ago at the home of an audiophile friend and he was playing a Carmen McRae live album on vinyl. Since I had no formal opinion of her work and rarely have listened to her, I was curious to hear what Mr. Christgau thought. I'll give this a spin and see if I can borrow that live album from my friend.  - Blair
Mar 8, 2011 5:30AM
avatar
Glad to see you've gotten ahold of the Carmen/Monk album. Glad too that it's won another fan! I've loved it since it came out. Have you heard heard her 60s album Bittersweet? That's one that could really do with a decent reissue; some mind-blowingly tasty guitar work on there in addition to the wonderful (and understated) singing.
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap