Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Odds and Ends 011

Been Through a Lot, These Guys

By Xgau Jun 15, 2012 5:25AM

Otis Taylor: Otis Taylor's Contraband (Telarc)

Colorado bluesman finally figures out how to split the difference between gravity and taking yourself too seriously ("Yell Your Name," "Blind Piano Teacher") ***

 

Ahmad Zahir: Hip 70's Afghan Beats! (Guerssen)

Assassinated by the Russians in 1979, Afghan rocker was too gifted vocally and melodically to sink into schlock ("Dar Kunj Dilam Eshqi Kasi," "Uoba Darta Rawarem") ***

 

Gregg Allman: Low Country Blues (Rounder)

The reason the only one he wrote is called "Just Another Rider" is that he's finally content to let better songs than his own carry him home ("Floating Bridge," "Devil Got My Woman") **

 

William Michael Dillon: Black Robes and Lawyers (Flying Free)

Learned a skill while doing 28 goddamn years for a murder he didn't commit ("Black Robes and Lawyers," "Chasing a Dream") **

Stephen David Austin: A Bakersfield Dozen (StephenDavidAustin.com)

The kind of writer who remembers the day Buck Owens died, the kind of singer who hopes someone covers his song about it ("Best Ex I Ever Had," "The Cage") **

 

Waco Brothers & Paul Burch: Great Chicago Fire (Bloodshot)

Ever collegial and craving new blood, Jon L. and the gang take in a fortysomething alt-Nashville lifer ("Great Chicago Fire," "Someone That You Know") *

 

Jimmie Vaughan: Plays Blues, Ballads & Favorites (Shout! Factory)

He knows the tradition & also the difference between a traditionalist and a remaker ("The Pleasure's All Mine," "Wheel of Fortune") *

 

Jerry Lee Lewis: Mean Old Man (Verve)

The Killer's many wives etc. (those who are alive, anyway) will tell you he's not really mean‑-that's just Kristofferson kidding around ("Mean Old Man," "Sweet Virginia") *

 

156Comments
Jun 19, 2012 6:03AM
avatar
Okay so this summary thing is gonna be quite a bit of effort and I have lotsa other things to do, so I may not end up doing it... we'll see...
Jun 19, 2012 2:16AM
avatar
A few quotes from a post I made a few years back on another board regarding my affection for McCartney's solo stuff:

"It's a slightly more formal pleasure than a passionate one, but that hardly means that passion is absent...it's just a little more abstract. The lyrics are throwaway a lot of the time, but that never really bothered me that much, because even with the Beatles he was only sporadically great in that regard."

To which I'd now add, I just spent most of the day listening to a number of my favorite PM albums (a list of the ones I'd happily put on any time appears at the end of this post) and think he's even better than I thought - still far from the greatest, but the best of his plainspoken ones carry some real power, and the nonsense ones are often pretty fun. As Xgau noted in his Memory Almost Full review, his lyrics have even gained a bit in thoughtfulness and wisdom.   And apropos of the discussion in the last thread, there are often times where what exact words are coming out of his mouth don't make the slightest difference.

"For me the magic comes through in the melodies, the hooks, the singing, the playing, the production."

  This we can pretty much agree on, but it bears repeating, because for me his magic in these departments is up near the top of the line.

"I've actually warmed much more to "Silly Love Songs" over the years - from the multi-movement structure  to the darn lovely arrangement of voices in the middle part (with Linda integrated to the point where even she sounds good) to the lyrics, which, used to bug me but now feel like an actual statement of purpose. A polite statement (because that's his way),a somewhat defensive statement (because after years of bad reviews that's almost second nature, too), one that you might find irritating or unworthy of his talent (I used to), but one which he's held true to for years now. Silly love songs aren't everything, but they're hardly nothing."  

 A somewhat defensive statement itself, but I'll stick with it.    As for silly, see my comments in the last thread.

Obviously this is a place where I differ fairly significantly from Xgau.  I've just never had that feeling of sharp irritation that he mentions, and while Red Rose Speedway isn't my favorite I think it's a long ways from the worst album put out by a rock and roller of the first rank.
Ryan, the fact that I think more highly of him as a person (Like us all he's had his crass and dickish moments, some widely known about and discussed,  but in general I don't think he's either. From the interviews I've read and listened to he comes off as someone I'd be happy to hang out with ) probably has something to do with where you and I differ, but probably not that much.  I think we might have to chalk it up to the pure mysteries of taste, or, as the guy who sparked my original post puts it, "the particular things he does he does so much better than anyone else, and though I can't exactly say what those things are I wouldn't be without them."  Are-we-hearing-the-same-thing?  Obviously not.  To me that's just the way of things, and it's actually pretty fun.  I'm sorry that it seems to bother you so much sometimes.

To complete the coming-out process, PM fave raves: McCartney, Ram, Band on the Run, Venus & Mars, an EP containing the best parts of At the Speed of Sound, Wings Over America, London Town, Back to the Egg, McCartney II (I've learned to love the best parts of this one, and I mean love), Tug of War, Flowers in the Dirt, Off the Ground, Unplugged, Run Devil Run, Wingspan (Hits & History), Chaos & Creation, Memory Almost Full, Kisses on the Bottom

Jun 18, 2012 10:37PM
avatar
Iconoclastic around these thinking man's parts, which is not to suggest that stb is anything but the most thinkingest b-boy; I know that out there in the real world, people think Neon is some kind of nadir, though I always assumed that's because they didn't pay attention to the lyrics (which are not hard to pay attention to, but how in the world could you walk away thinking it's about "religion", which one prominent reviewer actually suggested? Got right away that Funeral was about childhood though, boy howdy). In any case, the record took me no time at all to hear, and I am miles from the most thinkingest b-boy. Sharp, focused attack (every song pounds and soars), nuanced-**** lyrics for a band whose defining skill is heart-on-sleeve passion (probably the most clearheaded personal-political statement by any of the rock 'n' roll kids who came to fame in the Bush years), beauty that's never overwrought (none of Funeral's Salinger-defined sentimentality, i.e. caring about something more than God does; when Butler wails on Neon it's not about the pains of growing up and the death of the elderly, it's about dead soldiers and the safety of his family) and message-punk that's never half-baked or sarcastic (when he sings about that black wave of oppressive others it's criticizing the evils of the movement rather than essaying unfair individual caricature, while the one that does zero in, "Antichrist Television Blues", is astoundingly complex and palpably sympathetic). Also I've never noticed any problems with the production, as Patrick suggests; in fact they throw a lot more gonzo goodness at you than on their other two (like the strange fizzy vignette title track or the beautiful basslines rolling through Ocean of Noise or the gothic [grandeur of Intervention/horror of My Body is a Cage] or all of my favorite, the wildly wonky Black Mirror, which introduces the album's flavor of pomp as consciously silly, which the danger of the lyrics then lends an edge of unhinged).

Seriously, the others sound peurile and proggy at their worst by comparison, and in any case there's falloff. I know subjectivity is the only rockcrit reality and I have no interest in being one of those (lil'-older-than-)millennials who swears by AF. But that's an incredible record, & when folks even implicitly disparage it it's one of the most confounding cases of are-we-hearing-the-same-thing for me.
Jun 18, 2012 10:09PM
avatar
Clank**** once let me post only after I removed my favourite clause in the paragraph, a clause it suspected of being lunch meat.

Ryan, I meant to ask you before, why is it iconoclastic to like Neon Bible least of AF's records? Most people I know prefer Funeral.

Of course Ram beats Straight UpStraight Up was made by a worse band than Pablo Cruise. (My

own favourite BF is Wish You Were Here. The lyrics hadn't improved any, though the phrase "should I smoke or should I die" is catchy.) 


Semi Mike, Split Enz was my first-ever show outside of local bar bands, the True Colours tour.

HAPPY BIRTHDAY, Irene!  Enjoy 25 - your next birthday you'll no longer be half my age.

Roger Clemens found not guilty.

Jun 18, 2012 8:42PM
avatar
..."I get error messages that posting is not allowed at this time..."
 
Definitely save anything you write before trying to post, which I learned the hard way. 

And since I'm having my own issues with posting right now, I'll keep this super short -- stuff I'm enjoying that our host has not endorsed: Usher (good dumb fun, emphasis on dumb), Patti Smith (sharpsm, yes you heard me right), Killer Mike (El-P doesn't get in the way too much), Carole King (whew, if only everybody's old demos were as fun to listen to), Steve Lehman Trio (Tom Hull's right, contender for Year's Best), and Philadelphia International Classics: The Tom Moulton Remixes (4 discs of extended Philly soul, with Harold Melvin shining bright).

The list of stuff I'm enjoying that our host has endorsed would be a long and familiar list, so I'll just say Francis Bebey yes yes yes.
Jun 18, 2012 8:28PM
avatar
I've been reading more and posting a lot less here for one simple reason. Clankface!  It can be so glitchy that half the time my post is rejected for spamalicious reasons, which leads to the purgatory of self editing the pi$$ out of a post you spent some time on only to have it lost to the nether world, and the other half of the time I get error messages that posting is not allowed at this time. I resolve to try a little harder in the future hopefully clankbuttface will do the same too.


Gotye's "Somebody That I Used to Know" is a Beurre Blanc sauce, a nice warm buttery pop song without a lot of spice or flavor. For comparison a Split Enz record seems like a Lemon -Dill Beurre Blanc a little more flavorful and tasty. Both are a nice side accoutrement to the main course...

Gregg Allman's disc is fantastic it just missed my best-of list for 2011 and wanted to thank Milo for first mentioning it last year in a poast.

Current Listening:
Augustus Pablo- East of the Nile River
Augustus Pablo- King Tubby Meets Rockers Uptown
The dB's - Like This
The Go-Betweens- Freakchild (Grazie Ryan!)



Jun 18, 2012 7:21PM
avatar
I do think Ram is too scientifically pleasurable to totally write off -- just coz Paul's a crass dick doesn't mean he meant to be while laying the record down, and the crassest tracks ("Too Many People", "Dear Boy", "Smile Away", "Monkberry Moon Delight", "Uncle Albert" if you look at it a certain way) are actually the tastiest. Additionally, I feel like maybe Paul's misuse of his own power was probably partial fuel for that fire back when critics were first preparing the spit. Nowadays he's so irrelevant ("basically harmless" by 1979 according to the Great Communicator, although McCartney II remains a menace to society) slamming his craftiest-in-retrospect confections just seems pique. But I guess there's a revisionist consensus just as worth fighting -- still isn't worth a 9.whatever, and i'faith, a play of Imagine right afterwards does serve to put things back in perspective. (Still beats Straight Up, tho.)
Jun 18, 2012 6:36PM
avatar
To wrap up a small discussion from a while back ... I recall that Cam said Masses was the Spring Heel Jack + jazz cats that he still played. It's my winner, too. (The other two titles I checked out were snoozers.) Nice compare-and-contrast with the SHJ regular releases. Still not what I would play for an introduction, though.
Jun 18, 2012 4:52PM
avatar

Sharpism-that's not my thumbs down btw-not my style-

but you must admit you deserve one or two-no?

Jun 18, 2012 3:23PM
avatar
Thanks Joey. I was just wondering about her.

The tracklist is worth mentioning --

01. Groundhog Day
02. Kill My Blues
03. Neskowin
04. I Don’t Wanna Go
05. Constance
06. No Bad News Tonight
07. Summer Jams
08. None Like You
09. Joey
10. Outgoing Message
11. Blood, Bones, and Sand
12. Tiptoe

because Neskowin is a small town on the Oregon coast, just like Nehalem is. 55 miles south of Nehalem to be exact, both in Tillamook County connected directly by Highway 101. Which means that when they "came running for" Todd Snider "down 101/Lights flashing on [his] tail" on that unfortunate day that he ended up with "One phone call/Two Tylenol/Four cold gray walls closing in" at the Tillamook County Jail, he was metaphorically driving from Everclear to Corin Tucker.

You don't get good stuff like this just anywhere now do ya'

Jun 18, 2012 12:05PM
avatar
ALSO (via Pitchfork): "[Corin Tucker] has announced her next record, Kill My Blues, to be released September 18 via Kill Rock Stars. According to a press release, the record finds Tucker 'returning to her riot grrrl sonic roots.'"

So get excited, EW.  Get very excited.
Jun 18, 2012 12:02PM
avatar
My prediction last week based on no reviews that Fiona Apple's (wonderful!!!) new album will win Pazz & Jop is being supported by reviews.  Everyone should seriously go check it out.  Still streaming at NPR, I believe.
Jun 18, 2012 9:56AM
avatar
I'm never in a bad mood, Greg T. Always Merry And Bright: that's my motto. And I think Dylan is the very best kind of corpse--one that reanimates itself every few years.

Jun 18, 2012 9:32AM
avatar
A sharp stick to the critics of 1971, you mean...my (admittedly informal) spin around the critical net reveals a lot more Ram love than there used to be.  I'm still spinning it as happily as I did way back when.  A very happy brithday to Irene and Pwaulie.
Jun 18, 2012 9:27AM
avatar

Late to the dance as usual-that's what happens

when you're on-line once a day. But here goes.

1) Bob Dylan-"the old corpse". Jeez- Sharpism- I'd hate

to catch you in a bad mood.

2) Anyone for the Berkely Barb and the East Village Other-

now that was music criticism.

3) Not paying attention or giving black music it's due-referring to best of lists or whatever--

in the 70's and 80's -is not racist by definition.. It is what it is.Like possibly just

not paying attention.

4) Like BB King said (I think it was BB-maybe Muddy))-thank god for bands like The Rolling Stones etc. who by

playing their own version of the blues- put my music in the public eye-the ones actually spending money

on music-and thus food on my table.

        

 

Jun 18, 2012 8:26AM
avatar
Besides the monthly Consumer Guide reprints, the things I remember most about Creem are our host's longform review of On The Beach and the hilarious Bangs vs. Reed series.

What say you, Witnesses? Is the new Fiona Apple more Brecht/Weill or more Tori Amos? (After three spins, I still can't decide.)
Jun 18, 2012 7:10AM
avatar
Happy Birthday to Irene and condolences to Michael!
Jun 18, 2012 6:04AM
avatar
Happy Birthday Irene!   Twenty-five is a good age....

And on the white music/Black music on the radio question I just wanted to throw in that Greil Marcus is quite wonderful on this in his Sly Stone section of Mystery Train when he just sorta stops to say: did you notice what happened in 1972-3 when all this great Black political pop took over the radio?



Jun 18, 2012 5:42AM
avatar
Friends, Jason is being modest so I will share for him: http://youtu.be/NIFa50tirr8 I've found this video seems to best illustrate the universe-bending nature of Mingus's cranium--science has yet to explain why he doesn't fall down. I think he's around the age where the head-to-body ratio is at its peak. Mingus has been dancing since he was a teenier tot, but he was slightly more proportional back then.

I say all this with the utmost fondest. Were it feasible, I'd babysit Mingus for free on the daily. I was once a big-headed, blond-haired, round-eyed baby myself. NOW I'M A TWENTY-FIVE YEAR OLD WOMAN. (As of today. :D Couldn't help but include that because yes! I want your tidings.)


Jun 18, 2012 4:58AM
avatar

The cute one turns 70. Keeps on truckin' with wife Nancy and - just to poke a sharp stick into every rock critic's eyeball - brings out a Special Edition of RAM! Cheeky to the end.


Copyright, 2012 / Puppymaster, Inc.

Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap