Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Ray Wylie Hubbard/Father John Misty

Faster is better

By Xgau Jan 29, 2013 6:20AM
Ray Wylie Hubbard: The Grifter's Hymnal (Bordello)

At 66, this fringe Texas outlaw has been making records for 42 years even though, as he says himself in the quotable "New Year's Eve at the Gates of Hell," "the truth of the matter is I really can't sing." That's why I never checked him out seriously, shelving his first album on his wife's label even though it showcased a Hayes Carll co-write I relished. Reaccessing that record now‑-its sobriety-inspired title: A: Enlightenment B: Endarkenment (Hint: There Is No C)‑-I decided the problem wasn't the vocals, but Hubbard's decision to prove that he considers Muddy Waters "as deep as Blake" by grooving his blues downtempo. The follow-up is his party record, and deeper as a consequence, dark and hilarious and gone so fast you're too busy tapping your inner foot to cavil about pitch or timbre. So permit me to complete that "Gates of Hell" couplet: "But I can quote Martin Luther King." And then add another one: "They're burning over there with the Fox News whores/Oh look is that the singer for the Doors?" (BTW: it isn't.) A MINUS

 

Father John Misty: Fear Fun (Sub Pop)

Right, he has played and may yet again play drums in Fleet Foxes, whose beat means so much to us all. But that's not the good part, for goodness sake. The good part is that, under the influence of organic psychedelics and the American road, he figured out how to deploy words, as in the deathless couplet: "And I'm writing a novel! Because it's never been done before!" Whereupon, presumably, he also figured out that novels were a losing proposition. And though he dumbs up his songwriting half the time by fearing fun literally as regards forward motion, don't give up. Beyond "I'm Writing a Novel" itself, the four best tracks are the four last tracks, where he picks up the tempo and looks fun in the eye. He could use a more outgoing drummer, though. B PLUS

 

136Comments
avatar
Hand of Kindness maybe a little low but not up at #4 for me as I have played the albums above much more over the past 20 years.  Also, and probably because, the best tracks are available on the live albums in their best incarnations. I still have great memories of singing along with the crowd on Tear Stained Letter at Port Fairy FF.
Feb 1, 2013 12:56AM
avatar
Cam, I can't argue with you too much about either Loudon or Simon, only to note that Simon has now created three albums over a period of 40 years that, while too controlled and uptight, can rival the best of RT, including one that also has the virtue of being incredibly popular, while Wainwright is making his best music currently, with the prospect of more to come. I see no indications of RT waking up. Of course I would have said the same about Simon two years ago. I'll also admit to underrating Hokey Pokey.

Paul, why Hand of Kindness so low? Seems like # 4 for me, excluding Fairport stuff.
avatar

Richard, maybe two R+L albums, but very good point.  A comp of the last six RT albums would make a good album (A- anyone?).

 

To expulge my RT tic, here is my list or RT (plus Linda, but not Fairport, FFKT, or the Bunch) in descending order of preference:

 

Hokey Pokey

I Want to See the Bright Lights Tonight

Shoot Out the Lights

Rumor and Sigh

Amnesia

More Guitar

Across a Crowded Room

Industry (With Danny T)

Henry the Human Fly

Mirror Blue

Watching the Dark (for the new live stuff)

Mock Tudor

Pour Down Like Silver

2 Letter Words

Daring Adventures

Celtshmertz (live)

Hand of Kindness

Electric

Sweet Warrior

Dream Attic

You Me Us

Live at Crawley (With Danny T)

 

The Old Kit Bag

Front Parlour Ballads

Faithlesss (live)

Sunnyvista

Guitar Vocal

Sweet Talker Soundtrack

1000 years of Popular Music

Strict Tempo

New Light

Grizzly Man Soundtrack

 

Thanks for the indulgence.  I own all except the last two, but do own a couple of box sets in addition.

Feb 1, 2013 12:19AM
avatar
I'm in agreement that while there have been a few peaks for RT in the studio post-Linda, he holds up far better as a live act.

But Richard, I have to disagree with you a bit about the overall stature of Thompson. In my perhaps idiosyncratic view, the whole of Thompson's career up to and including "Shoot Out the Lights", especially if you include Fairport, is pretty staggering. There are only 3 albums in there (his last with Fairport, Sunnyvista, and First Light-- which has great songs but bad production) that I don't still listen to regularly. I'm not going to argue that this is a better run than 60s Dylan (even if I listen to it as much), but sum this up and I place him well ahead of Loudon or Paul Simon (who I really don't fancy much at all).

Also, a shout out for the great odds and sods collection "Doom and Gloom From the Tomb".

And lastly, my favorite bit of Linda Thompson between-songs patter: "Oh, I get fired so often."
Jan 31, 2013 11:43PM
avatar
"No Richard Thompson hating from around these quarters, I just wish he could come up with a late career 'Love and Theft' or 'Americana' or 'So Beautiful or so what' or 'Wrecking Ball' or 'Older Than my old Man' or...."

Well, part of the problem is that RT is not quite at the level of the other artists, with the exception of Wainwright, who is easily surpassing his previous output. The other albums are career highlights from artists who have each made more than one other album that someone could easily argue as top ten all-time great albums. Thompson on his own has never made an album like that in 30 years, and only one with Linda. 
Jan 31, 2013 11:14PM
avatar
On RT, Cam posted a plug a few weeks ago for "More Guitar" one of Thompson's live CDs that emphasizes guitar.  I bought it on his recommendation and it is great.  I also agree with the comment below that his music has often been best live and would add my own recommendation for the double disc live "Two Letter Words" set.  It is from 1994 and has some of his best material from the Rumor and Sigh/Blue Mirror phase performed with great verve and passion.  Like "More Guitar" it is available at Ama*on.
Jan 31, 2013 10:08PM
avatar
I like the 5th disc idea too, and other than Milo's suggestions am also no help.

Paging Michael Tatum ... Tatum ... Michael Tatum. A call is waiting for you ...

Jan 31, 2013 9:59PM
avatar
Go away Vauche, we know you can use a search engine in order to make a snide comment but you have no business being near a conversation about my beloved Richard and Linda Thompson.
Jan 31, 2013 9:55PM
avatar
I like your idea Jason, just not sure I could be a lot of help on that one.
Jan 31, 2013 9:54PM
Jan 31, 2013 9:46PM
avatar
Just an idea -- a quasi-poll designed around creating a fifth disc [post-1993] addition to Tougher Than Tough might not be a bad idea.
Jan 31, 2013 9:44PM
avatar
Mongo want to see bright lights too.
Jan 31, 2013 9:29PM
avatar
I'll quote Bob's entire review from 1994's Mirror Blue: "I thought she loved me but she didn't--why does this keep happening?"

That was probably a little before it started wearing on me, but nails the schtick real neat and tidy nonetheless.

And yes, I like the new one a bunch too. In fact, it occurred to me that it might be his best break-up album since Shoot Out The Lights. Which is what led to all this commentary from me, aka If you're so genuine and modest and spiritual as a person, why do you have to be such a grouch in your love songs ALL THE DAMN TIME!
Jan 31, 2013 9:20PM
avatar
I'll certainly check out the David Rodigan, though I do feel part of a DJ's skillz is to make songs not so much on their own become killer parts of a whole. I find scattered cuts every year that I like, but they don't cross over any more. And it does seem like the JA industry is back to concentrating on singles. I can't even think of a recent (last 5-6 years) best-of that I enjoyed. But I'm not on lists like I was (and hell, JA distribution in the US ain't what it was, either).


EDIT: I should take it back a little bit: *Welcome to Jamrock* and yes, *Distant Relatives* were huge with me. But they hardly suggest the wave of the future, y'know?
Jan 31, 2013 9:10PM
avatar
I too am a very confused person.  So I'm going to assume Greg means, when he says RT does only one thing,  in RT's love songs.  Perhaps Greg's experience with that mode in RT leads him to perceive that, and if that's so, I'll have to pay more attention to that.  

Notwithstanding, there are more RT modes, which I think I hear Greg saying.  "52 Vincent Black Lightening"?  Another great song.  "God Loves a Drunk?"  Another mode.  To me, the real issue with Thompson is that so often -- as with Rumor & Sigh, which is where I'm obviously going to the well, here -- the recordings aren't up to the songs, and it's only in concert where you're really hearing the songs put over persuasively.   Though I gotta say I do like this new one  -- 
Jan 31, 2013 9:05PM
avatar
I know what you mean, Milo. But every time I start thinking Jamaican music is in decline, I find evidence to the contrary. David Rodigan's set for FabricLive (#54, to be exact) in 2010 was an eye opener, since he effortlessly mixed in classics from the golden age (King Tubby, Sly & Robbie, Big Youth) with 80s/90s stars (Pinchers, Tenor Saw) and the new guard (Mr Vegas & Konshens, Million Stylez, Collie Buddz). It all runs together wonderfully.

[btw, Collie Buddz's "Come Around" is good stuff . Actually, last year's "Running From The Law" and the Tenor Saw-channeling "119" from Busy Signal were great, too.]
Jan 31, 2013 8:57PM
avatar
"Not even Red Rat's "Dwayne," Milo?"

Went right by me. I remember his debut. And I remember being interested in his family connections to the music industry there. I also remember I didn't keep the album.
avatar

Brett: Or "There's no such thing as a great wine, just a great bottle". Bad analogy, I know, especially now most wine comes with a screw cap.

 

No Richard Thompson hating from around these quarters, I just wish he could come up with a late career 'Love and Theft' or 'Americana' or 'So Beautiful or so what' or 'Wrecking Ball' or 'Older Than my old Man' or..........., esp. as his shows are so good.

 

And "I Misunderstood" is track two on my RT comp for unbenighted friends (RT joke in there).  "Turning of the Tide" or "Read about Love" is usually track one.  Most friends like this comp, but turn up their noses at the R+L comp.

 

Ham: I guess Elizabeth Cook is gonna cost me $27+ EP tonight (thanks for the heads-up).

Jan 31, 2013 8:53PM
avatar
Yes, relationship bile. And I'm a fan.

Others too, obviously. But others do other things also. And he almost never does. His Book of Love has only one chapter. With lots of great songs in my opinion because, after all, I'm a fan.

Jan 31, 2013 8:39PM
avatar
Not even Red Rat's "Dwayne," Milo?
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap