Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Odds and Ends 008

Rock After 55: Wise Maybe, Weary Definitely

By Xgau Apr 17, 2012 1:40AM

 


Lee Scratch Perry: Rise Again (MOD Technologies)

Surrounded by such coequals as Tunde Adebimpe, Sly Dunbar, and Hamid Drake, he‑-uh-oh‑-behaves himself ("Orthodox," "House of God") ***

 

Wanda Jackson: The Party Ain't Over (Nonesuch/Third Man)

Jack White hits the geriatric Christian hottie with songs and horns that remind us what a weirdo she must be ("Thunder on the Mountain," "Shakin' All Over") **

 

John Hiatt: Dirty Jeans and Mudslide Hymns (New West)

Decades past his last outright keeper and 60 this year, he continues to roll out listenable collections like he'll never stop ("Don't Wanna Leave You Now," "Damn This Town," "Detroit Town") **

 

Bonnie Raitt: Slipstream (Redwing)

Bartholin's glands don't fail me now ("Used to Rule the World," "Million Miles") **

 

Dr. John: Locked Down (Nonesuch)

"For my next trick I will shuck my jive and generalize indignantly over a declarative rock beat" ("Big Shot," "Locked Down") **

 

Rick Berlin: Paper Airplane (Hi-N-Dry)

"And Sean looked grim and said, `Suicide'" ("Sean Penn on Charlie Rose," "If I Wasn't Such a Bum") **

 

Steve Earle: I'll Never Get Out of This World Alive (New West)

There'll never be too many songs about death or George W. Bush ("Little Emperor," "Waitin' on the Sky") *

 

Marshall Chapman: Big Lonesome (Tall Girl)

Breakup album about a musician who up and died on her ("Big Lonesome," "I Love Everybody") *


 

169Comments
Apr 18, 2012 9:13AM
avatar
Happy Birthday, Bob--mazel tov. You've not only opened my ears to many things I definitely would have missed but also put me in touch with a bunch of generous, open-minded fans whose insights astonish me on a daily basis.
Apr 18, 2012 8:37AM
avatar
Like Andrew Sarris in film, RC has been the best guide for anyone looking for great music for the last 40 years. I remember reading Rolling Stone Record Guide in my late teens and wondering how Let it Bleed and Exile on Main St only garnered 4 stars. While in B.Daltons I picked up the RC Guide to the 70's and turned to the Stones, whereupon I read the classic review on Exile that kinda changed my life. Thank you for guiding and informing us these past years and Happy 70th! Here's hoping MSN keeps Expert Witness longer than the NY Observer kept Sarris.
Apr 18, 2012 8:27AM
avatar

At the risk of breaking topic -- topic being, of course, birthday wishes -- I would like to second the suggestion someone made yesterday that this community would be much better served by a discussion board format than by this comments section. In an ideal world the discussion board would be prominently linked from the blog, but in a completely different technological shell. The thread system not only means you can follow what you like and ignore what doesn't interest you, it also means you can find past threads easily (very important for new participants, folks interested in looking at old polls, and people with new thoughts to add to old conversations). It would of course eliminate the anomaly where the comments have no relationship to the blog post, as well as the one where comments at the end of a blog period (Monday night and Thursday night) tend to get lost by the community. Such a board could also, depending on where it was housed, get us out of the MSN censorship problem.

Oh, and before I forget: congrats on your milestone, Robert Christgau.

Apr 18, 2012 7:50AM
avatar
I'll let everyone else wish you a happy 70th, christgau. Myself? I'll mourn the fact that you're no longer 69. 
Apr 18, 2012 7:26AM
avatar
Happy 70th Bob, I hope you have a great time!
Apr 18, 2012 7:22AM
avatar
Many happy returns, Bob.  Hope you're enjoying your getaway.
Apr 18, 2012 6:34AM
avatar
Bob: Congratulations on the milestone. And here's to many more.

You have improved our lives and we are thankful.
Apr 18, 2012 4:51AM
avatar
Last year I essentially drafted a birthday novel for our host, the decent pieces of which were well-merited, but in the spirit of ECONOMY this year I'll keep it to seven carefully considered words:

bon 70ème anniversaire to the Great Communicator
Apr 18, 2012 4:28AM
avatar
I don't know why, but I never listen to music when I hike - it just doesn't seem right for some reason

Same here. I listen to music all over the place, but in the wilderness I prefer to hear the wilderness.

Apr 18, 2012 4:25AM
avatar
Did spring really come early enough to the northeast to allow you to sleep in the mountains in early April?

Yes and no. Nighttime temperatures dropped to the mid-20s, but my friend and I had anticipated this and brought along down sleeping bags from a company called Western Mountaineering. I mention them by name because, if you like to backpack, their bags are well worth checking out (although they aren't cheap). The bags we bought were rated to 20 degrees. They kept us toasty warm every night, even as we woke up to discover our water bottles frozen solid.

Apr 18, 2012 12:07AM
avatar
The world could use more souls like the Spirit of Alex Wilson. 
Apr 17, 2012 11:32PM
avatar
*** WARNING: Earnest discussion of 1980s cartoon girl group music follows, those who don't care can go listen to "Master of Puppets" for a few minutes ***

The episode of Jem I remember best was the sales competition between the Holograms and the Misfits, which oddly prefigures the Blur/Oasis Britpop war - well, they never showed Pizzazz telling Jem and Kimber to f-ck off and die but we can assume it happened off camera. In both cases the wrong group won: the "good" band was difficult to enjoy because of the posh lead singer's combination of self-righteousness and narcissism, while the "bad" band were at least upfront about their egotism. On the other hand, Britta had a way with a love song. "Love Is Here" (not the TV edit but the version on the "Glitter 'n Gold" cassingle DON'T JUDGE ME) might be one of the best Mann/Weil-style ballads of its era, if only because it's over in a minute and a half.

*** your regular poll meta-discussion and making fun of Pitchfork resumes here ***
Apr 17, 2012 9:56PM
avatar
Thanks, Cam - your Chapman sketch captures a tough artist who, we can all be thankful, remains committed to being heard.  And the book she wrote that IS about her - Goodbye, Little Rock And Roller - further explores how challenging  that was and is. 
Apr 17, 2012 9:54PM
avatar
I use the polls as a kind of course curriculum.  It allows me to focus my listening and causes me to pull out discs that have been too long neglected and make new discoveries. I have been reading Xgau since 1992, but there are a lot of things he reviewed that I never heard and a lot of things he did not review that I want to hear for myself.  I do a lot of new and comparative listening.  At times it feels like work, but an enjoyable labor, especially with the guidance many of you provide.

I get how some might not get into polls and I think that is fine.  I like having at least three weeks to make my selections, so if it got too frequent, I would probably bow out.

I don't see how it is off-putting to new readers and think those who dislike it can easily ignore it.  I don't think it swamps the blog except on a result day or the announcement of a new poll subject or year.  Most days, it is one of many topics briefly touched upon and left by the wayside by this ADHD collective of obsessive compulsives.  If the matter is put to a vote, I say keep them and I thank Patrick, Bradley and Nicky for their efforts.

Now, off my soapbox and back to lurking.  
Apr 17, 2012 9:25PM
avatar
I'm working through and loving the choice cuts above. Marshall Chapman is an old friend. She was just breaking through in Nashville when I was there, early 80s. Marshall was pure failed country going punk in attitude, where Jason and the Scorchers were punk going country right at the same time-- the schizophrenia of Nashville revealed. Marshall had huevos grandes-- she played in all the punk clubs, especially my alterna-home Cantrell's, which was a shockingly dissonant venue for a country artist in Nashville at that time. And she scared me. I'm pretty sure the first time I heard the phrase "fire crotch" was coming out of her mouth. That she's a lifer on the fringes of every rock movement that touches country music since then is a testament to her art and a sad statement about when the world will be ready for a female champion of a mas macho discipline. And she writes too. They Came To Nashville is not about her, it's reportage, so it varies based on the subjects. But the chapter about chasing Willie Nelson down and finally getting on stage with him is a School of Rock climax in real life. 
Apr 17, 2012 9:12PM
avatar
On the subject of M83, I read at Spin that M83's Anthony Gonzalez offered to write Katy Perry's next album.  And apparently Katy Perry was front row and center in the audience at M83's Coachella show.  So that could happen.
Apr 17, 2012 9:11PM
avatar
My wife and I saw Brad Paisley last month, and he performed the "Remind Me" duet with a hologram of Carrie Underwood.  The quality of the hologram (perhaps aided by our extremely remote seats), and Brad's carefully coy stage patter ("ladies and gentlemen, Carrie Underwood!") fooled us, as well as most of the audience in our vicinity it appeared. (Perhaps they were wiser down in front?)  Afterwords, contemplating the unlikelihood that a bigger pop star than Brad Paisley had time to wander in to his concert and look radiant while singing a perfectly auto-tuned duet in Baltimore of all places (hey, maybe she was just in town and decided to swing by), we got wise and Googled this and found others discussing his use of the hologram at previous concerts.  Also, the tour was called the Virtual Reality tour, which should have tipped us off.  It wouldn't surprise me if the tour was named to justify that particular gimmick.  Anyway, we felt kinda stupid for having even been duped by this temporarily, not really the kind of communal experience that Maura Johnston is imagining.  (Admittedly, when the person hologrammed is widely known to be deceased, this is a less likely reaction.)  

Also, hot tip to the generationally disadvantaged, Brad finished that post with a sly reference to a certain cartoon rock band from the '80s.  Britta Phillips provided the vocals for this character more than a decade before becoming Luna's bassist.  
Apr 17, 2012 8:17PM
avatar
Not musical, Fabien!  What about the M83 vs. Marie Le Pen controversy? (Pitchfork link: http://goo.gl/jJVNc)

Ah the endless problem of politicians with paying for copyright -the same story happens at each election-, if only they could be as liberal for us... But I hadn't heard this story, given how little I care about M83 I didn't miss much, Pitchfork you've done it again !

Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap