Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Karantamba/Rolling Stones

Rocking the Vaults

By Xgau Mar 13, 2012 6:37AM
 

Karantamba: Ndigal (Teranga Beat)

Gambian guitarist Bai Janha is best known as the leader of Guelewar, whose murky 2011-reissued Halleli N'Dakarou is slotted "psych" because some striver scored himself an organ. Much better this previously unreleased testament of Janha's last band, recorded in 1984 by the Malian-Danish bassist Moussa Diallo during Karantamba's residence at his club in Thiès, 35 miles east of Dakar. The personnel are unidentified young proteges of Janha who I surmise are mostly Senegalese, because no matter what Janha does or doesn't call it, these kids are playing some kind of mbalax‑-Islamic singing over sabar drums rattling away, horns adding sour decoration and commentary, Janha wailing. There was only one Étoile de Dakar. But this is a find, well-rehearsed yet bold and untamed. A MINUS

 

The Rolling Stones: Some Girls: Deluxe Edition (Universal Republic)

A major album, you knew that. But my grade is for the bonus disc, which‑-as I'd never have guessed after those drab Exile extras‑- has dibs on major as well. It outstrips not just It's Only Rock 'n Roll and Goats Head Soup but Tattoo You and probably Emotional Rescue (which several advisors insist I revisit). Where the regular album is musically quirky and lyrically either risky ("Some Girls," "Far Away Eyes") or generalized ("Respectable," "Beast of Burden," damn right "When the Whip Comes Down"), the bonus disc is musically classic-Stones and lyrically small-scale, including NYC specifics that warm my heart. Beginning with the Stu-does-Jerry-Lee bootleg fave "Claudine" and ending with the atypically near-political "Petrol Blues," its star player is a horny guy who just got divorced‑-a familiar character the classic Stones were made for. Mick's Hank Williams cover trumps Keith's Waylon Jennings cover. His Freddy Cannon cover trumps them both. A MINUS

 

171Comments
Mar 14, 2012 9:15AM
avatar
I had a great time at Balkan Beat Box, I'm really enjoying their new album Give. Next up Magnetic Fields and Drive-By Truckers on back to back nights. I waited too long and now the George Clinton show was sold out. Sorry Kenny, maybe I'll see you at T. Snider.
Mar 14, 2012 8:24AM
avatar
P. S. Daydream Nation is my sixth fave album of all time.

u lie!


(i know cause senor Eddy told me so)

Mar 14, 2012 7:54AM
avatar
So glad to get my coat pulled about this Stones release.   This won't rise to the level of Funeral Dress II for me, of course, but it is another one I ignored at first because I stupidly thought I knew better: "This means I was an idiot," as the feller said...

What a great record...

That said, and just to get Edgar's back (from a few pages ago): I too continue to find "Faraway Eyes" a grotesque bit of class/regional minstrelsy--we fought this one out on EW some months back--and I'm pretty sure I was on the Losing End. 

But this new release has me thinking thoughts about how much greater Some Girls would have been (for me anyway) with "You Win Again" in the spot where "Faraway Eyes" is. 

Mar 14, 2012 7:38AM
avatar
One thing I love about Wussy and a lot of great rock and roll is that even if they are just singing about a bridge, a fair, or a flashlight, it feels like they're really singing about something much bigger and more significant.
Absolutely. I think their best material is comparable to prime Richard & Linda Thompson ("Wall of Death," say, or "When I Get to the Border") in that it can be interpreted on multiple levels.
Mar 14, 2012 7:18AM
avatar
C***sucker Blues is On Youtube in 10 parts.  Not sure if any of it's censored.
Good to know, John. Although if it's anything like I've heard, I'd be surprised if it hasn't been edited. Anyway, I aim to find out, so thanks.
Mar 14, 2012 7:13AM
avatar
In my opinion, when Lisa Walker sings words like "it's the end of you," it's never just the bridge or whatever else it's literally the end of. Same goes for Cassie Gaines.


Mar 14, 2012 6:47AM
avatar
C***sucker Blues is On Youtube in 10 parts.  Not sure if any of it's censored.
Mar 14, 2012 5:54AM
avatar
Innocuous? Not at all. When I saw that title in college it was the main reason I wanted to see it.
Oh, that word. (Aren't there more than four letters in it?) Anyway, I've never seen C---sucker Blues, either, but have long wanted to. Have never known it to be available anywhere, though, legally or not.
Mar 13, 2012 10:54PM
avatar
So when Lisa sings “it’s the end of you” and maybe you is just the bridge.
O_o
Mar 13, 2012 10:53PM
avatar
The Wyman piece is brilliant. Thanks to Duke and the thread for getting me to that. 
Mar 13, 2012 10:49PM
avatar
It occurs to me that I never said thanks to the Dutch fan who posted such a generous compliment a few boards ago. Thanks, Joris. There's nothing a good critic likes to hear more than that. Maybe Pauline Kael or somebody got too much of it. But more likely not.


Mar 13, 2012 9:05PM
avatar
More Wussy minutia: OK this is not on topic and a few days late but I wanted to follow up on the discussion of "Little Miami".

The tallest bridge in Ohio is the Jeremiah Morrow Bridge which crosses the Little Miami River. According to Wikipedia,

“The Little Miami Scenic Trail passes under the bridges on the east bank, close to river level, providing an impressive view from below. Trail users, especially first-timers, may stop to gaze before proceeding. There is no sign on the trail to identify the bridges nor give their height. There is no obvious path to ascend to the rim of the gorge from below the bridges, so trail users view the bridges from only one perspective.”

 This makes me think of the line “the sky breaks in two”. And from the Cincinnati Enquirer,

“Sometime next summer, Ohio's highest bridge will be blown to bits.” 

 So when Lisa sings “it’s the end of you” and maybe you is just the bridge. It also fits with the "ruins", "rocks" and "falling". One thing I love about Wussy and a lot of great rock and roll is that even if they are just singing about a bridge, a fair, or a flashlight, it feels like they're really singing about something much bigger and more significant. It's up to the listener to make their own connections to the bigger thing. 


In addition, I found a one-page Wussy article in the Needle by Michael Pelusi magazine which is available online at http://goo.gl/kEHeT. In fact, it may be the same article Ryan mentioned earlier from Magnet Magazine. It talks about “Magnolia” and Cassie Gaines. It also has Chuck describing “Grand Champion Steer, as ”going to the fair with somebody you’re really digging and you just know that it’s unraveling”. 


 

Mar 13, 2012 8:37PM
avatar
As for the Pavement reissues, they put the B-sides of each album on first CDs and second CDs are more obscure stuff, outtakes, live... So in general the actual bonus disc goes from a bit weak (Wowee Zowee) to awesome (Slanted & Enchanted) but the first CD is always top rate.
Mar 13, 2012 8:19PM
avatar
The deluxe edition of Diana Ross' Diana includes the original Chic mixes of all the tracks from the album, which are significantly superior to the released versions (which are also included).  The whole album runs about 4 minutes longer in this version.  The band is mixed far more prominently.  

The bonus material also includes many of her other (non-Chic) disco singles.  They're a mixed bag, but it does include a 10 minute mix of "Love Hangover."
Mar 13, 2012 7:57PM
avatar
Joe -- the takes on the 1997 reissue are alternate takes.  The takes on the 2 cd version are the ones they would have used on the record proper had Lee Hazelwood not been such a dick.  They're way superior. 
Mar 13, 2012 7:33PM
avatar
"Nicky- What doesn't kill you, makes you stronger."

xoxoxoxo, Cam! (speaking of which, who else watched all three One Direction featured videos under Music News?)

P. S. Daydream Nation is my sixth fave album of all time. But the Deluxe Edition live tracks found their way to my trash after two listens. Sooo don't get 99.99999463627% of deluxe editions, box sets, etc.


Mar 13, 2012 7:32PM
avatar
Innocuous? Not at all. When I saw that title in college it was the main reason I wanted to see it.
Mar 13, 2012 7:23PM
avatar
Thanks, Phil. And sorry about whatever probably innocuous word that didn't make it past the MSN robo-censor.
Mar 13, 2012 7:10PM
avatar
What's the consensus on the Velvet Underground's Loaded: The Fully Loaded Edition? It was a big deal back in the day. I never listen to much beyond the original (and slightly expanded) album proper. I do remember "Ride Into the Sun" being lovely, but the second disc that recreates the whole album with alternate performances is super spotty. Out of rhythm, out of tune, etc. I need to listen back, though; it's been several years and my ears change all the time.
Mar 13, 2012 7:07PM
avatar
Greenfield's STP isn't particularly probing with regards to the Stones music, but in many ways it's exactly what you want from a tour diary, and definitely lives up to its reputation. Since most of us will never get to see **** Blues it's the next best thing and Greenfield isn't afraid to call 'em as he sees 'em. He's frankly pretty turned off by some of the excesses, most of which were perpetrated by the entourage rather than the group itself, but he holds the group responsible. More significant is the way he follows the money. It's the best part of his reporting and I don't think he got enough credit for it.
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap