Robert Christgau's Music Criticism Blog - Expert Witness - MSN Music

Gil Scott-Heron and Jamie xx/Gorillaz

Tinkering With the Funky Homosapien

By Xgau Jan 10, 2012 2:47AM


 

Gil Scott-Heron and Jamie xx: We're New Here (XL)

The Richard Russell-produced original of the revolutionary-poet-turned-brokedown-crack-addict's first studio album in 16 years strove respectfully to put a good face on‑-who exactly? The "survivor"? The "outsider"? The "revolutionary"? The hip-hop godfather? The colorful old black guy? Granting that the moving force was Russell, my Honorable Mention stands: "The premise isn't `I'm new here,' it's `I'm not dead,' and he strains mightily to get 28 spare minutes out of it." A year later Scott-Heron was in fact dead, and a year after that came this radical remix, which to my mind respects Scott-Heron more truthfully by chopping him to bits. This Scott-Heron is a drug fiend of considerable perversity and tremendous intelligence who's gonna be dead soon. Jamie xx hears in his last testament an irreversible disintegration that he translates into heavily sampled minimalist electro marked indelibly by Scott-Heron's weariness, arrogance, and wit. In part it's just a young man's bad dream about mortality, and of interest as such. But the snatches of Scott-Heron's voice, cracked for sure but deeper than night nonetheless, delivers it from callow generalization and foregone conclusion. A MINUS

 

Gorillaz: The Singles Collection 2001-2011 (Virgin)

Their synthbeat-meets-comix concept got over as pop because it found a mildly playful and pleasurable way to enact well-meaning self-effacement, which was how Damon Albarn disarmed the world well before designing a virtual band for the era of electronic interpersonal multi-tasking between unknowable avatars. As far as he's concerned, that isn't humanity sitting up "On Melancholy Hill"‑-it's a manatee, who got there by means only a cartoonist could grasp. Note, however, that he invokes real-life humanity in an all too traditional way: via such living persons of African descent as Bobby Womack, Neneh Cherry, De La Soul, and the affably virtuosic Del the Funky Homosapien. A MINUS

 

241Comments
Jan 10, 2012 4:57PM
avatar
A bunch of my friends are long-time Gorillaz fans, so I've been exposed to their tunes for a while now. None of that exposure has made me enthusiastic about any of their records, but I do hold close a few songs ("Tomorrow Comes Today," "Starshine," "Dracula," "M1 A1") that are intertwined with dear memories from my high school years. They're a band I appreciate in small doses.

Nicky: I hear you. The candidates among whom we may "choose" this year are remarkably alike in their desire to preserve the status quo. (For those of you who don't know, Obama's brand new chief of staff, Jacob Lew, was a former Citigroup higher-up who made millions off the housing crisis.)

I was a Ron Paul fanatic during the last election cycle. My, how I've grown since then! Even so, I believe I will (with many more reservations than I once harbored) probably vote for him again. I do not share his relatively radical views on returning to the gold standard, deregulating the market, and disassembling the federal government. The list goes on. However, no other candidate (aside from Gary Johnson, who of course has even less a chance of winning than Paul does) has shown any willingness to reform foreign policy or the drug war, both of which inflict death and misery upon untold numbers of human beings.

For me, it boils down to the lesser-of-the-evils argument. Paul's failings are serious and multiple. But they strike me as a (slightly) less awful compromise than what we'd get from rest of the warmongering, power-hungry corporate stooges flashing their pearly whites at us from the stage. Including Obama.

That said, I have not given up considering withholding my vote entirely. Not voting is a kind of vote in itself, a vote for a different way of doing things. Occupy the elections! I'll be at the polls with a big sign when the Connecticut primaries roll around.

And... thumb-bombs away!
Jan 10, 2012 11:38AM
avatar
Primary day today here in New Hampshire. I despise every one of the candidates so much that I can't even think of a way to cast a sabotage vote. Part of me suspects anyway that the inevitable choice will be trucked by Obama's enormous campaign machine. Er, not suspects. Hopes. 

So no voting for me today. It'd feel little more than pointless and a lot more than dirty.
Jan 10, 2012 9:50AM
avatar

Can't recall the last time our host reviewed an album in this venue

that I was more than vaguely interested in. Give me a second to duck-here come the bad thumbs.

Jan 10, 2012 11:39PM
avatar
Current feeling: Rage.

Which is to say that the year-end list (and analysis) does its job just right.  Couldn't have called that one.
Jan 11, 2012 9:05PM
avatar
Okay, I resign. But I still think Xgau likes Fleet Foxes, Adele, and Bon Iver, even if just a little bit (and not just empathetically).

EDIT: Pending a re-reading of the essay and/or a mind-reading of Xgau.
Jan 12, 2012 10:26AM
avatar

Basically what I want is for Xgau to review the albums I want him to-and then I can

buy them or not buy them. I ask you is that asking so much? I ask you.

Jan 12, 2012 6:09AM
avatar
And a, very rough, honourable mentions list:

  1. F*cked Up: David Comes to Life *** (‘Running on Nothing’ & ‘A Slanted Tone’)
  2. PJ Harvey: Let England Shake B+
  3. Adele: 21 B+
  4. Lil Wayne: Tha Carter IV B+
  5. DJ Shadow: The Less You Know, the Better *** (‘Border Crossing’ & ‘I Gotta Rokk’)
  6. The Rapture: In the Grace of Your Love B+
  7. Moby: Destroyed *** (‘Be the One’ & ‘Lie Down in Darkness’)
  8. Lil Wayne: Sorry 4 the Wait *** (‘Hands Up (My Last) [Freestyle]’ & ‘Sorry 4 the Wait’)
  9. The Vaccines: What Did You Expect from The Vaccines? *** (‘Wreckin’ Bar (Ra, Ra, Ra)’ & ‘Nørgaard’)
  10. The Kills: Blood Pressures *** (‘Future Starts Slow’ & ‘DNA’)
  11. The Strokes: Angles *** (‘Machu Picchu’ & ‘Gratisfaction’)
  12. Cults *** (‘Most Wanted’ & ‘Rave On’)
  13. St. Vincent: Strange Mercy *** (‘Strange Mercy’ & ‘Neutered Fruit’)
  14. Ghostface Killah: Apollo Kids *** (‘How You Like Me, Baby?’ & ‘Street Bullies’)
  15. Bad Meets Evil: Hell: The Sequel *** (‘Fast Lane’ & ‘Lighters’)
  16. Metronomy: The English Riviera *** (Not sure which tracks yet.)
  17. Wretch 32: Black and White *** (‘Traktor’ & ‘Breathe (Sha La, La)’)
  18. New York Dolls: Dancing Backwards in High Heels ** (‘I’m So Fabulous’ & ‘Kids Like You’)
  19. The Drums: Portamento * (Not sure which tracks yet.)
  20. Radiohead: The King of Limbs * (‘Morning Mr. Magpie’ & ‘Little by Little’)
  21. EMA: Past Life Martyred Saints * (‘Coda’ & ‘Breakfast’)
  22. The Weeknd: Thursday * (‘Lonely Star’ & ‘The Birds Part 1’)
  23. The Weeknd: House of Balloons * (‘The Morning’ & ‘The Party & the After Party’)
Jan 12, 2012 6:04AM
avatar
Right, worst albums of 2011 (in order of preference):

Iceage: New Brigade (B−)

Bon Iver (C+)

Red Hot Chili Peppers: I'm with You (B−)

Destroyer: Kaputt (C+)

Fleet Foxes: Helplessness Blues (Dud)

The-Dream: 1977 (Dud, although, could be a *)

M83: Hurry Up, We're Dreaming (Dud)

Tyler the Creator: Goblin (Dud)

Death Grips: Ex-Military (Dud)

Jan 11, 2012 5:05PM
avatar
Yeah, I think Xgau said he still doesn't like that genre (Fleet Foxes/Bon Iver/etc.)—what I am now replacing emo. with—just that he's learnt to read between the lines. Very mature, I think.
Jan 10, 2012 3:58AM
avatar
I've never really been one for the debut (bar the scattered glorious tracks), but I've always thought that Demon Days and Plastic Beach were two brilliant records.  Missing from this collection are some serious gems, particularly the ones from plastic beach like "White Flag," "Rhinestone Eyes," and my favorite, "Empire Ants."

Also brilliant: Jamie xx and his late buddy Gil.

Also also brilliant: Drake's song "Take Care," which takes Gil's refrain on We're New Here's closer and hands it to Rihanna.  Makes you realize there's real emotion in that rapper's initially off-putting monotone.
Jan 12, 2012 9:55AM
avatar
Anyone who makes a worst albums list for 2011 and doesn't include Chris Brown in the mix, doesn't go far enough. 
Jan 11, 2012 9:11AM
avatar
After much deliberating, I put Lekman over Ocean—although, it was hard to do so, as it's an EP— because the songs are better, IMO. I have been unsure about Gaga; she's rattled around a bit in my brain. Are her songs strong enough to be top ten, or are they more of a ~17th number? I settled halfway. I was itching, too, to put SebastiAn higher, but I don't think the songs individually hold up, to as much as I'd like. I'm sure some of you will complain that Black Up should be higher—I'm sure Xgau would, too—but I really don't feel it at all, although I wish I could. Although I have swung on David Comes to Life—an album so close to an A minus it hurts—it would still, heartily, be my recommendation of the year—just to open up people to the possibility of screaming in a good record—regardless of whether I think it's technically good enough to praise or not (I dropped it to an HM [***]). Note: The 'Favourite Songs' list is due to Joey, as he insists that songs do not have to be singles to be listed (something I don't agree with, in terms of serious list-making, but am not tight-arsed enough to head-butt against. I'm kidding, Joey). Also, I am British; Teddybears and Withered Hand won't be listed.

The top 5 I am pretty sure about, and they are, by far, some of the best records I have heard in ages. There are, obviously, a lot of records that I still need to listen to—mostly, including: Hell on Heels, Four the Record, Todd Snider Live—The Storyteller and Western Teleport.

Albums Best-of List, 2011:

1. tUnE-yArDs: w h o k i l l (13)
2. Paul Simon: So Beautiful or So What? (12)
3. Jens Lekman: An Argument with Myself (12)
4. Frank Ocean: Nostalgia, ULTRA (11)
5. Wussy: Funeral Dress II (10)
6. Kate & Anna McGarrigle: Tell My Sister (10)
7. Wussy: Strawberry (10)
8. Jay-Z/Kanye West: Watch the Throne (8)
9. Carolina Chocolate Drops/Luminescent Orchestrii (7)
10. Blaqstarr: The Divine EP (7)

11. Wild Flag
12. Das Racist: Relax
13. Lady Gaga: Born This Way
14. Low Cut Connie: Get Out the Lotion
15. Saigon: The Greatest Story Never Told
16. Brad Paisley: This Is Country Music
17. Fountains of Wayne: Sky Full of Holes
18. Buck 65: 20 Odd Years
19. Pietra Montecorvino: Napoli Mediterranea
20. Drive-By Truckers: Go-Go Boots
21. TV on the Radio: Nine Types of Light
22. Those Darlins: Screws Get Loose
23. The Baseball Project: Volume 2: High and Inside
24. Terakaft: Aratan N Azawad
25. The Lonely Island: Turtleneck & Chain
26. Poly Styrene: Generation Indigo
27. Jeffrey Lewis: A Turn in the Dream-Songs
28. Generation Bass Presents: Transnational Dubstep
29. Serengeti: Family & Friends
30. Rave On, Buddy Holly
31. Tinariwen: Tassili
32. SebastiAn: Total
33. Jill Scott: The Light of the Sun (IE: Shame, I'm a Racist)
34. Eric Church: Chief
35. Raphael Saadiq: Stone Rollin'
36. Dave Alvin: Eleven, Eleven
37. Neil Young International Harvesters: A Treasure
38. Mates of State: Mountaintops
39. Rainbow Arabia: Boys & Diamonds
40. Let's Wrestle: Nursing Home
41. Middle Brother
42. Fruit Bats: Tripper
43. Girls: Father, Son, Holy Ghost
44. Beastie Boys: Hot Sauce Committee, Part 2
45. Shabazz Palaces: Black Up
46. Battles: Gloss Drop
47. Yuck
48. Gang of Four: Content
Jan 11, 2012 9:11AM
avatar
Personal Favourite/Most Listened to Albums:

1. tUnE-yArDs: w h o k i l l
2. Jens Lekman: An Argument with Myself
3. Frank Ocean: Nostalgia, ULTRA
4. Wussy: Funeral Dress II
5. Wussy: Strawberry
6. Jay-Z/Kanye West: Watch the Throne
7. Wild Flag
8. Das Racist: Relax
9. Saigon: The Greatest Story Never Told
10. Low Cut Connie: Get Out the Lotion
11. Those Darlins: Screws Get Loose
12. Jeffrey Lewis: A Turn in the Dream-Songs

Personal Favourite/Most Addicted to Songs (in Alphabetical Order and not including the entirety of Funeral Dress II):

'6 Foot, 7 Foot'
'An Argument with Myself'
'Be Your Bro.'
'"Big Thighs" NJ'
'Bizness' (Almost any song from w h o k i l l, really.)
'Born This Way'
'Cult Boyfriend'
'Fly, Fly, Fly'
'Full of Joy'
'Gangsta'
'Georgia'
'Getting Ready for Christmas Day'
'Grand Champion Steer'
'Hit 'em Up Style'
'I Just Had Sex'
'If I Keep On Loving You'
'It Takes Time, to Be a Man'
'Judas'
'Michael Jackson'
'Otis'
'Preacher'
'Rainbow in the Dark'
'Remind Me'
'Rider Girl'
'Romance'
'Some Other Time'
'Songs for Women'
'Superstars Don't Love'
'Swim Good'
'Talikoba'
'The Afterlife'
'The Joy'
'Threw It on the Ground'
'Waiting for Kirsten'
'Used to Be a Cop'
'Will Do'
'Zombie Delight'
Jan 12, 2012 6:12PM
avatar
Very good book review in today's NY Times of "Fug You" by Ed Sanders. For those who don't know who Ed Sanders is -look it up. Briefly, he was a member of the band The Fugs-among his other pursuits- like writing.  An Xgau kindred spirit if I may. And The Fugs received many A-'s if not a couple of  A's in past Consumer Guides. Saw them in concert a few times. A good time was had by all.
Jan 11, 2012 10:16PM
avatar
What are you all doing right now besides quibbling about lists?

Got the munchies because, you know. Now I'm gonna watch the Metal Show , because , you know.


Who wants to say a recording released in your birth year that you like*?


The Velvet Underground- The Velvet Underground & Nico






Jan 10, 2012 3:32AM
avatar
Wow I getta be first, a perk for being in Australia. I'm in the outback right now and thankful to even have wifi. Purchasing these will have to wait till I return to Perth. G'day mates.
Jan 10, 2012 5:32PM
avatar
seems there was  lot of Shopping center visiting in Dallas town lately?
Christmas!
Jan 12, 2012 7:03AM
avatar
Wow, after catching up with a few, I might have listened to 80+ albums this year!

same thing backwards, I tend to rate anything lower than B+ badly. There are rare contradictions. I hear something good in The-Dream, but, on the surface, it seems shallow, crass and bad, but that might be what makes it good. I'll give it more time. I still think David Comes to Life is the best HM this year, but, after listening to it over and over, I realised the tracks, individually, don't stand up; as a whole, the album is good, IMO.
I wonder, if the male singer's resemblance to Ricky Martin is intentional.

Yeah, I thought that, too!

Jan 11, 2012 4:06PM
avatar
Wild Flag was far better, IMO; far lower than I expected, also!
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

about the blogger

Robert Christgau

Starting in 1967, Robert Christgau has covered popular music for The Village Voice, Esquire, Blender, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and many other publications. He teaches in New York University's Clive Davis Department of Recorded Music, maintains a comprehensive website at robertchristgau.com, and has published five books based on his journalism. He has written for MSN Music since 2006.

find concert tickets

 
Find more tickets. Powered by FanSnap