MSN TV Blog - TV Buzz

'One Life to Live' producers sue ABC for $25 million

Prospect Park files suit over licensing agreement breach and reboot sabotage

By TVDeeva Deanna Barnert Apr 18, 2013 5:15PM



With the "All My Children" and "One Life to Live" reboots set to premiere online April 29, Prospect Park has apparently filed a $25 million breach of contract suit against ABC. The tussle over actors Roger Howarth, Kristen Alderson and Michael Easton and the "One Life to Live" characters loaned to "General Hospital" seems to be at the heart of the case.

Bing: More about "All My Children" | "One Life to Live"


Back when ABC cancelled "All My Children" and "One Life to Live," Prospect Park acquired licensing rights to both soap operas with the intent of rebooting them online. Now, word is Prospect Park is filing a complaint with Los Angeles Superior Court, charging ABC with breaking the 2011 licensing agreement and sabotaging reboot efforts, even though the network is poised to benefit financially from the shows' success.


"These shows will go forward, and Prospect will address its rights in Court," said the suit, uncovered by Deadline. "Regardless of how successful Prospect may be, the fact remains that ABC did not deliver what it promised, Prospect did not get what it paid for, and Prospect is now entitled to recover millions of dollars in damages for ABC's egregious conduct."

Plus: Left-field reality stars | 10 new gigs for Jay Leno | Reality shows that sound fake 


The tension between ABC and Prospect Park over the last year has been no secret, but things came to head, apparently, after "General Hospital" announced Howarth, Alderson and Easton would be back on screen May 10. Their "One Life to Live" characters Todd, Starr and McBain are not Prospect Park's only concern, however. Prospect Park loaned 7 characters to ABC while working to get the reboots off the ground and claims the network failed to give them approval over their characters' storylines, as promised in the agreement.


"In the ultimate act of bad faith, ABC inexplicably killed off two 'OLTL' characters on loan to 'GH' by having their car forced off a cliff. ABC effectively killed another major 'OLTL' character, who was not even licensed to ABC, by revealing that this long-standing 'OLTL' character is in fact another character (alter ego) on 'GH.'"


Also at issue are the web domains and, which ABC is supposed to release to Prospect Park, and ABC's threat to hold back on running "One Life to Live" ads because Howarth is heavily featured in them. 

Prospect Park paints these disagreements as outright sabotage, claiming one ABC exec is "openly" rooting for the failure of the reboots and charging ABC with a "basic fear of embarrassment if Prospect succeeds."

When MSNtv reached out for comment, Prospect Park didn't quite confirm the suit, but made it clear something was afoot. 

"Prospect Park has been and continues to be committed to creating and delivering exceptional episodes of 'All My Children' and 'One Life to Live,'" said Prospect Park executives. "We have overcome each and every obstacle in an effort to make this dream become a reality. Over and over again our effort to bring these shows to audiences has faced challenges, and yet we, along with the actors, the writers, producers and the directors as well as our fans, have confronted and then overcome these challenges, and we have every confidence that we will prevail again. We look forward to our April 29 launch now more than ever."


This story is certainly a negative turn after weeks of juicy, fun press for the reboots. In addition to generating casting and guest performance buzz, Prospect Park released the first "All My Children" and "One life to Live" trailers, as well as teasers for the first week of shows.  


It also bears mention that while ABC apparently threatened to not air any ads for the reboots, Vincent Irizarry, Thorsten Kaye ("All My Children") and Erika Slezak ("One Life to Live") are currently slated to appear on ABC's "The View" Thursday, April 25. 


Shortly after this story broke, the websites and began redirecting visitors to Prospect Park's

"All My Children" and "One Life to Live" premiere Monday, April 29, on Hulu, Hulu Plus and iTunes.

Apr 21, 2013 10:47AM

I also had moved on until I read that OLTL was coming back.  I'll give it a chance because I used to enjoy it.  Actually, I plan to watch both AMC and OLTL.  As for ABC, I think the powers that be knew they were taking a chance by replacing two iconic soaps with more contemporary programming.  It is all about the money, right?  And after the ratings began to come in for both The Chew and The Revolution, they may have realized they made a mistake.  Doesn't anyone think it is rather appropriate that Brian Frons is no longer in the position to make such detrimental decisions?  Whether ABC has purposely or blatantly undermined Prospect Park's agenda will be left up to the courts.  Certainly, ABC did everything possible to sooth the irritated viewers who felt their soaps were taken away by inserting some key characters into General Hospital and then wisely renewing it!  Personally, I hope they find ABC guilty because they should not have been so greedy.  Sometimes change is not always for the better. 

Apr 20, 2013 5:30PM

u.s. soaps are terrible. they should end. come up with another show and go from there. BUT END!!!

Just silly.


Apr 20, 2013 5:29PM
I was planning on going back to both shows, but PP's greed has left a bad taste in my mouth. I don't think I'll waste my time. The shows have been gone so long now, I am used to it. I think what PP did to GH is a shame. PP knew that GH killed Cole and Hope over a year ago and now they are have a lawsuit? GMAB....
Apr 20, 2013 3:28PM
I think that ABC is trying to whatever they want to because they are part of Disney and frankly, Disney is too big to fail. If I were the Disney stockholders, I would replace everyone at ABC Daytime, especially that "B" Anne Sweeney and anyone connected to her, all the problems lie with her.
Apr 20, 2013 12:36PM
I have been a fan of AMC since the beginning & was heart broken when the show ended so suddenly, with no finallization. I do hope that both shows wll do well on line.
Apr 18, 2013 9:22PM



Apr 18, 2013 8:02PM

just plain old publicity stunt so people will tune in and watch.........oh brother. 

Apr 18, 2013 7:20PM
just plain stupid it is a half hour soap both abc and prospect park can still use them and I'm sorry but their carreers are better suited for tv not online tv whos to say the two soaps will even last especially when both soaps dobn't even use all of the old cast sorry once cancelled you should stay cancelled
Apr 18, 2013 7:18PM
its not like they can later just bring the characters gh killed off when this lawsuit started back from the dead though now given all this mess they may wind up recasting them for todd got recast before. plus the fact the actors took the gh jobs because amc and oltl had been canceled as in no more with those soaps.
Apr 18, 2013 7:09PM
Not like dead characters have not been breought back from the dead with no explanation before! PLEASE!
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?