MSN TV Blog - Reality TV

'American Idol' Judge Steven Tyler: 'I'm always ready to take it up a notch'

The singer-turned-TV star spills on Jennifer Lopez, Aerosmith demise rumors -- and why he's no Simon Cowell

By Sona Charaipotra Jan 19, 2011 12:10PM

Photo Courtesy FOX

One of the biggest changes you’ll see on “American Idol” tonight? Aerosmith frontman Steven Tyler will be rocking the judges panel. And while he admits that he’s no Simon Cowell, Tyler promises he’ll be bringing his own signature style to the show – and that he’s not going soft for the sake of TV. We caught up with the singer and burgeoning TV star to chat about his judging style, his feisty co-panelists and the rumored death of Aerosmith.


On His Panel Style: “Will I bring a rock element? Yeah. But I've also got a good ear for all music, and that's why I thought I would take this. It's not a one-thing type judging. I'm good for all different [types of] music and listening to voicing and the spirit of it and the imperfections of someone's voice -- because not all singer make great rock stars. Some of the voices that aren't the best, they make the best rock stars. So, it's been fun.”

 

On Why He’s No Simon Cowell: “The part that is a little difficult is judging the young kids. I take what I’ve grown up with, which is being a very harsh judge of myself, my own vocals, my own band, and lay that across the talent I come across. I made some harsh comments first week, and they snap back and say, 'What do you mean?' I only did two of those. There were only two of those because I didn't want that to happen again. I couldn't say that you were 'no good' without substantiating why, and the couple times that I said, 'You know, you just don't have it,' they did ask me why. And I couldn't tell them why. It's just that I'm looking for that certain something, and I heard that certain something in a negative way. I didn't see a star. I didn't see this, and I didn't have the goods to tell him that. I hadn't ever really watched the show and I wasn't really versed in that type of judging. I got three daughters, so it was hard for me. Those few times after that, I was ready to go and I jumped right back in both feet."

 

On His ‘Idol’ Commitment: “I have more than a one-year contract, but things are what they are. Can I elaborate? No, I can't. I'm always ready to take it up a notch. It used to be my frivolity. I'm addicted to adrenaline, and I still like a good challenge. Someday I'll have my own show, a different type of ‘Survivor.’ They'll put me in a barrel and throw me into the ocean, so it'll be called ‘Message in a Bottle.’ They'll put me in a giant bottle and see what shore I land. Then I'll marry the person and we'll see what our kids look like.”

 

On Fellow Judge Randy Jackson: “I think it's funny. I think there's love up there that you've never seen. Certainly, there's camaraderie that you haven't seen in 10 years. About that, I'm really happy that I get along with Randy so well. I met Randy first and Randy was the s**t. I love Randy. We got on in the first five minutes we met. It was like we were separated at birth. And we had so many similarities. Whatever he's been through, I've been through. And we mentioned names and we knew everybody and how we hadn’t met before was beyond me."


On Fellow Judge Jennifer Lopez: "J.Lo is a fox -- she's also got a good big heart. On the way from England to America I saw J.Lo's movie ‘The Back-Up Plan,’ and I fell in love with her. I was watching going, 'Oh my God, it's Jennifer Lopez!' The way she played her part, I could so relate to her. And I thought, 'Anybody that could be this open and honest -- even acting, she had to go for it -- all I can tell you is that when I met her, she was exactly all that and I'm grateful that she got the part.”

 

On Aerosmith’s Rumored Demise: “I'm ready for anything, and nothing has been more convincing that I'm ready for anything than this last year with Aerosmith. Yes, we're getting ready to launch a tour in November or December. It's already booked. The songwriting starts next week. So, everything you hear is a lot of hearsay and a lot of muck that's been thrown around and there's no validity to it. I'm here to tell you that."


Catch Steven Tyler's "American Idol" judging panel debut on the tenth season premiere tonight at 8 p.m. on FOX.  

 

21Comments
Jan 21, 2011 4:41AM
avatar
I told several friends I'm not interested in Season 10 with Steve Tyler on the show.  I wanted to puke when I read he was hired.  The premiere, to my great surprise, was actually very entertaining and Steve Tyler was pretty good.  I guess I've never heard him talk before but he has a sweet sensitive side that I appreciated.  More of the contestants, although they weren't the cream of the crop, were way more tolerable than some of the characters AI auditions in the early weeks.  Jennifer seemed a bit shy and self-conscious in the beginning of the hour but began to act more real and sincere as she became more comfortable.  I think I will keep checking it out for a few more weeks.
Jan 20, 2011 1:42PM
avatar

Well, we had top watch just see what it would be like with the new panel......J-lo has to learn to say NO! And be more critical if she's going to judge......Steve Tyler surprised me and was quite good, plus his knowledge of all kinds of music will be a great addition and Randy was, well Randy only a bit more on the edgey side!

As far as talent on the first show there wasn't any at all. I spent 40 years as a radio deejay, talent manager, booking agent and concert promoter in every field of music, rock, country, middle of the road and there were maybe one or two that could sqeak by on a lower level, but there was absolutely nothing impressive at all that made me want to hear them again.

We'll give it a look tonight, but to be honest I am not expecting much!

I will give the producers credit for one new change in the show and that is NOT making the final 12 equal, if it's 9 guys and 3 girls so be it or whatever, but glad the 6-6 is gone!

Jan 20, 2011 1:00PM
avatar

Idol made a genius decision inviting JLo on the show!

She has such a great personality, she's fun, real and warm.

Tyler is also going to be lots of fun.

Finally, Idol Judges who are sensitive and encouraging to the contestants!

There is no need to be cruel to any of these young kids, just for RATINGS!

Both Lopez and Tyler have so much experience in the business and are very qualified.

Jan 20, 2011 12:44PM
avatar
It did not hold my interest at all.  Poor Randy!  Having to sit next to those two, must have been hard!  What an afterthought!  Out of all of the reputable people that could have been picked to replace Simon and Paula, and the AI execs came up with these two?!  And, by the way, where were  the adults?!  I don't recall seeing more than one performer(?!) 21 or older.  I'm done.  It's ridiculous!
Jan 20, 2011 12:44PM
avatar
Steven...Really..... leave the botox or what ever it is you are doing alone.  Don't be one of those old guys who we all giggle at.  You will look GREAT.
Jan 20, 2011 12:25PM
avatar

Without a voice of reason....they passed too many contestants....Cowell would never have let some of these people through (and his opinions would have swayed the other judges)......J-Lo doesn't have the stomach to do the right thing. Tyler is pretty full of himself, and over confident....he was funny, sometimes...but his mannerisms are those of a annoying stoner....he acts like he's perpetually on stage...an act thats going to get old quickly. Randy......well, what else does he have to do( LOL, just kidding)??.....The formula is well oiled, and most of us would have watched to the end, regardless of who is on the panel....it's entertaining. But it doesn't have the punch it used to.....Cowell, no matter what your opinion of him, was the reason the show was/is so successful.....because he was, 99.9% of the time, right on the money.

Jan 20, 2011 12:18PM
avatar
I thought I was not gonna watch American Idol this year and also alot of my relatives, including my 76 year old mom.....actually we luved it! I luv the judges. It's not all about the judges, cause we are watching for the next American Idol and we vote on the finalist! Steve Tyler is awesome, luv J Lo and have always enjoyed Randy! AMERICAN IDOL LIVES ON!
Jan 20, 2011 12:15PM
avatar
I said after last years vote.,I would not watch American Idol again, but you know I could not wait for it to start this year. I am sure it will be hard to say no..I think Randy will set the tone for the no's. My concern is how  will the vote be different then in th past I have not been told for sure how the vote will actually be counted, I sure hope it is not by phone or text.
Jan 20, 2011 11:56AM
avatar
After last season I said I would not watch another American Idol show. I do,however, enjoy the auditions and so I watched last night's premiere show. I'm glad I did. I don't know Arrowsmith from arrowroot but I enjoyed Steve Tyler so much. I actually laughed out loud. He was hilarious! He doesn't take himself seriously but when it came to the music he took that very seriously and his critiques were spot on. Jennifer Lopez was funny too. I believed her when she said to Randy "how did you do this for ten years?" I never liked Randy so I am glad to see these new judges. I believe Steve will bring more musical knowledge to the show then Simon who sometimes was so obvious about his lack of understanding of American music and what Americans like. Good riddance!
Jan 20, 2011 11:45AM
avatar

We watched the show without judgment, without comparing with prior seasons, without comparing prior judges.  we really enjoyed it!  Steven Tyler is not only talented but VERY funny.  Jennifer Lopez is sweet but not loopy, flaky and can tell the truth without smashing someone's dream.  Randy is still Randy - maybe a bit more edgy - more candid with the contestants.

Last season we watched one episode and changed channels because of the judges.  Their personalities didn't mesh, there wasn't a cohesive group, none of them made their decisions based on the premise of the show - it seemed very personal.  Even Simon wasn't himself.  This season we a looking forward to a revitalization and from the first viewing, we are going to get it.

Jan 20, 2011 11:22AM
avatar
I'm telling you; I'm a HUGE Aerosmith fan!  Good old Steven and I had an encounter when I was 16 when I got back stage at Red Rocks.  Why I didn't save that piece f clothing I have no idea! He is so funny on the show and I think he's a HUGE benefit. Randy is again outshined and while I appreciated J. Lo, she's a wimp like Paula and Kara were.  She needs to buck up and deliver the news like she should.  I loved the off the cuff comments from Steven about seeing some nice T&A and he is just sexy as hell!  I was pleasantly surprised by him and now I'm looking forward to watching the remainder of the season.  It will be interesting to see how this season unfolds for certain.
Jan 20, 2011 11:15AM
avatar
An avid watcher of the show since season 1 I will simply say this is the beginning of the end (or at least I hope so).  I could barely make it through the entire show...between Steven screaming and trying be the constant center of attention, JLo trying to be "so sweet" and not able to say the word no, give me a break.  Soon the show will be a faint memory only to be seen on a network that no one watches with no name judges.  So long Idol, it was fun while it lasted, I will miss you.
Jan 20, 2011 11:13AM
avatar
I have never watched this show and probably never will. I don't understand why so many people subject themselves to ridicule, are they that dumb to not see they just don't have it. I know I can't sing, so why would I try. I guess it must be the water they drink, makes them think they can do more then they really can. Sorry to say but I could give good insults to those that are terrible and would do it for just $50 a show, can I be a judge.
Jan 20, 2011 10:23AM
avatar
Are these people KIDDING??? They were all horrible. What a joke this show was. I didn't hear one person, aside from the very first contestant, who could sing at all. What the heck are these judges hearing? I like Jennifer Lopez, but she doesnt not belong on this show.  And Steven Tyler, well, he should retire and save himself this embarrassment. He looks like the crypt-keeper and After 15 min I thought he was the most annoying person on the planet. He's a spotlight hog, and obviously lost the talent that once backed that up. He can not sing anmore but he keeps trying to inject his little tortured cat screams in there. Its over Steven, you lost it! And Randy can not hold his own without Simon. He's just boring and bland. Can't wait till this show is gone for good.
Jan 20, 2011 9:20AM
avatar
I hope american Idol bombs and goes bankrupt!!!!
Jan 20, 2011 8:46AM
avatar
I disagree..Simon is definitely missed!  It's funny watching JLO sit there judging people who can actually sing when she absolutely cannot.  Also I felt she was insincere and exaggerating how hard it was for her to say no.  Steven Tyler was just being himself and he's a legend who is extemely talented that is qualified to be a judge. 
Jan 20, 2011 8:30AM
avatar
I didn't think I would like the new judges, but I was absolutely wrong.  This was a great show and the judges were great, they all do well together and each has their own unique style and personality to add to the dynamics.  I will miss Simon, but the show will be  just a new show now, although I am very glad Randy stayed.
Jan 20, 2011 8:24AM
avatar
OMG, Steve Tyler sounds incoherent!  Did he actually say the thing printed in this interview?  He makes no sense.  If this is how he speaks while judging on Idol, the show may be doomed.
Jan 20, 2011 7:51AM
avatar
I thought the panel had a great relationship with each other and did their jobs with good judgments and good humor. I still enjoyed the process of elimination without all the mean comments that Simon used. I believe brutal truth does not have to be told with brutal words.  I hope this new Idol can be just as successful as the old Idol, only with a different tone to it.  We do need to get back to the good standards of treating all people with respect.
Jan 20, 2011 6:48AM
avatar
I loved it!  I thought I'd miss Simon but it felt like a new show without him.  Randy is lost with JLo and Steven Tyler...his dawg days are overSmile
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?