MSN TV Blog - Reality TV

'Dancing' cutting back to one season a year?

Report: Ratings for 'All-Stars' season has producers considering changes

By Corey Levitan Dec 7, 2012 10:30AM

'Dancing With the Stars'/ABCABC's "Dancing with the Stars" is doing the half step. According to the New York Post, producers are considering cutting it from two seasons a year to just the spring season.

 

Bing: More about 'Dancing With the Stars' | Photos: See 'Dancing With the Stars: All-Stars' highlights


"They have to figure something out," the Post quotes an unnamed production source. "Maybe change the judges. The show needs a total makeover."

Whatever that "something" is, it's not an all-star version. For Season 15, which wrapped last month, the show brought back past champs for the first time (including Drew Lachey, Shawn Johnson and Emmit Smith). Viewership was off 20 percent, while the finale was watched by a million fewer viewers than last season's.

 

Also: Canceled and renewed TV shows | Memorable TV moments of 2012


"Turns out people didn’t want to see people who could dance," said executive Jay Rasulo of Disney (which owns ABC), according to the Post. "They wanted people who couldn’t dance."
 

Season 16 of "Dancing with the Stars" will premiere Monday, March 18, on ABC.

177Comments
Dec 11, 2012 11:09AM
avatar
People complain all the time that there are no "celebrities" on this show. Do they expect people like George Clooney or Julia Roberts to do these kind of shows?? It's not going to happen. Besides, if you saw these people that you don't call celebrities on the street I bet you'd be jumping up and down and telling everyone that you saw them.  I actually don't care who the celebrities are. I think it's a wonderful show, a lot of fun and at least it's not ANOTHER cop show.

I have been saying that they need to get some new professional dancers though. Time for some of these people to move on now. I wouldn't mind seeing Derek, Mark, Cheryl, Karina and Max go. Some fresh faces would be nice. I also agree that Carrie Ann is very inappropriate and she can also be really snotty. Why embarrass the dancers like that? If not for them, you, Bruno and Len wouldn't have jobs now would you? I think Brooke is unnecessary. Tom Bergeron can carry this show by himself.

Please don't go to once a year. I love that this is on twice a year. It's something fun to watch for a change.

Dec 9, 2012 10:18AM
avatar
The fact that the show is a polularity contest is evident by the length of time the football players stay around while the good and great dancers get sent home.  Emmit Smith for example didn't really do much except stand in one spot while his partner Cheryl danced around him.  Her beauty and her sexy moves camoflaged his lack of movement.  In addition, he had the entire state of Texas voting for him which gave him a huge edge over the other competitors.  Same thinghappened with Jerry Rice, Chad Johnson, and Donald Driver. They had the entire states of California, Ohio, and Wisconsin padding their vote totals. 
avatar

The voting via phone and computer, twitter, etc. is not controlled at all.  In some of the message boards on ABC.com I saw where some people were bragging about creating multiple email accounts so they could load the voting for the person they wanted.

Maybe they should limit the voting to just after the couple has danced.  Give the home audience just 10 minutes to get their votes in.  That would eliminate any cheating. One time I voted using my celll phone, my daughter's cell phone, my land line and my daughter's land line.  Then I got on the computer and voted there too.  Me--1 person was able to vote way more than the stated limit.  If the time was cut short for voting, people wouldn't be able to jump from email to email or phone to phone. Or if the vote was not based on the number of dancers.

avatar
I think many people (including me) are tired of listening to Bruno's off the wall extravagant mouthings and Carrie Ann Anaba's snarkiness.  Neither of them have a real history of ballroom and both of them seem to feel they must show off how much they [think] know.  Len is the only judge with a real history of ballroom dance.
Dec 7, 2012 9:04PM
avatar

This has been an election year and people were distracted by the fall election and debates, and all of the pre-election

campaigning and news documentaries, etc that took up the viewing hours on Monday and Tuesday evenings.  That would

account for the reduced viewer-count.

 

I think the Judges are fine, but whomever is telling the Judges how to "act up" or demonstrate hostility toward certain dancers

or harsher than normal criticism in order to gain audience re-action is not doing the program any favors.

 

If the Judges are not be "directed" in order to cause ratings to go up, then by all means, someone needs to shake up Carrie Ann

and Len and get them to come down off their high horses and be a bit more positive than negative; especially if the dancer(s)

deserve it.

 

Also, why screw with the program as it is one of the few left than one can actually enjoy and get a "feel-good" reaction from.


There are not many good programs such as Dancing With The Stars to watch on TV any more and personally, I'm fed up with

violence, cops, detectives and stupid acting young people shacking up in apartments and having stupid acting young people

playing bedroom roulette and neighbors that do nothing but party all night every night and girls running around in their skimpy

undies or skirts or guys in their undies trying to get a laugh.  It takes no acting talent to produce those shows and even less

writing talent and if this is what sells coffee, personal items, shampoo, makeup, then please take it elsewhere and give me

something to enjoy on television at night.

Dec 7, 2012 5:32PM
avatar
It's about time, even the host said once a year is enough.
Dec 7, 2012 5:32PM
avatar
Add 2 more judges and drop the call in Voting, that's the talk among all my friends and customers! Too Much of a popularity contest!


Dec 7, 2012 5:21PM
avatar
Why not end this really crappy show altogether? Of course, this is true of all "reality" shows, especially "American Idiot," I mean "American Idol." A show where the no talents are judged by those with little to no talent themselves.
avatar
Are you kidding me???  This is a good show and had helped to bring back dance.. The best show is So You Think You Can Dance .,  This is a marvelous s show.  and not all pleas want to watch Survivor,Kardashains, or The Great race  Pleas don't take this off the aire......You've already cut it down to a show a week.  Keep it coming. I',m 74 and used to be.  Can't dane anymore but iot sure bring tear to my eyes.   Sincerely, Motherbond
Dec 7, 2012 5:17PM
avatar
too much time between eliminations!!! And, it's gross how much skin is showing. That is totally unecessary.
Dec 7, 2012 5:15PM
avatar
A good reality show and I am so glad it is back is Little People Big World the Wedding. I loved that showed and was sorry to see it end. Now it is back and I watched that from the beginning. I like the Roloff family. I also like Little Couple though that hasn't been back in awhile. Dancing is danced out. Like I said look who they get to compete from other seasons. I mean Pamela Anderson shouldn't have been asked back either. She stunk the first time as did I agree with one person who wrote below Bristol Palin and how long she on there COME ON... These reality shows have gotten out of hand I agree to with Survivor. I NEVER watched that show.. Yes, keep to one season.. It is getting OLD...
Dec 7, 2012 5:12PM
avatar
My wife and I loved the show at first, but now would never watch it. The votes from the home viewers can be very political, having nothing to do with dancing. You also occasionally get the idea that the show's bosses are pushing a particular political ideology. The judges comments became so rude we were embarrassed for the dancers, I recall Michael Bolton and Billy Ray Cyrus as examples of this.The judges' scores appeared to be more about tv drama than the dancing.   Anyway, it became painfully obvious this was a bogus "reality" show and our interest turned to contempt. Hey, no problem if people disagree, just our impressions.
Dec 7, 2012 5:12PM
avatar

x709, Your useless comment says a lot about your character as well as your IQ. You must be a huge fan of Jerry Springer.

Dec 7, 2012 5:11PM
avatar
I get tired of Bruno's and Cary Ann's lewd comments. They vote with their hormones and are not very professional. I quite watching because it was boring. Len is the only professional judge and I believe him to be unbiased. Keep him and add a couple of other professional judges to make it more fair and less of a personality contest.
Dec 7, 2012 5:07PM
avatar
You need  to have real "STARS" on the show.  The show seems to consist of" has-beens", business people, friends of stars, daughters of has-beens (Palin, and you had her in the all-star show, why?)  You have some Stars.  But, many of them are not.  I think it's time to change the judges. We almost know the scores that will be given before they are given.  There needs to be more ethnic diversity among the professional dancers.  I am certain that there are some professional dancers who are of other ethnic groups.  There is an Asian judge, but no Asian, African-American, or Hispanic professional dancers.  There should also be more diversity among the stars.  Most of the African-American male dancers are football players.  To maintain the interest, there should be diversity.  The Republicans learned that the hard way.  One other suggestion:  The public should not be the final judge.  It should be a combination of professional & public judges.  Otherwise, the outcome becomes a popularity contest, not based on dancing ability.
Dec 7, 2012 5:05PM
avatar
I agree that this show has gotten worse and there are no one's to dance anymore. Who else can you ask. I did like the All Stars and thought that was a good idea. Only hearing it wasn't drawing anyone. These reality shows loose something after awhile. They cut back on So You Think You Can Dance which is a MUCH better show. I lost interest in this the past three years. My sister and I use to be on the phone picking who we liked and were really into watching it. Now neither of us care if we miss one or two or more. I do admit that I did watch it more this time than the last few seasons. Alot of good dancers and I picked that one right down to the last. I knew Melissa was going to win though I think Shawn Johnson earned it. I liked the dances they did and expected more from them with different things mixed in than the normal shows. I would cut it back to just the spring shows not two.. Sorry... Maggie Mae
Dec 7, 2012 5:04PM
avatar

The is a great show it's the people you choose to dance on the show, I have watched the show every season until this all star line up.  The all star line up should have been people that came in 3rd 4th 5th place. I also agree with the comments about Bristol, she is not a dancer nor a celebrate. She can not and I do mean can dance at all.  Making two appearances on the show, totally turned most people off Also the face that you had formal winner on, It was not fair to those that did try and made it to like I said, 3rd 4th 5th place. Shawn Johnson also should not have been back on the show. she did more of her moves than dancing.  All the ones that won in the past no way they should have been back. That is really where you lost people with previous winners then  Bristol really made the rating go down.  PLEASE DO NOT BRING HER BACK.

Thanks for Lousey season this time. Hope to see better people next time

Dec 7, 2012 4:57PM
avatar
What do you mean "people don't want to watch two seasons a year"?  I do!  Now if the professionals are getting burned out, I would understand; but, if that is not the case, I absolutely LOVE the show!
Dec 7, 2012 4:53PM
avatar
the only thing that sucks more than the show are the people who watch it!!!!!
Dec 7, 2012 4:52PM
avatar
I have watched DWTS from the beginning.  I agree that audience votes are the ones that help to push "uncoordinated" dancers over the top. I was disappointed with the All Stars because Melissa Rycrofft is not a Celebrity and neither is Bristol Palin.  There are some dances that were most unforgettable during all the seasons and I hope others might agree, and that being the beautiful "Viennese Waltz" done by Mel B.  That was true grace as well as the "Passe'Doble" she performed with Max.  To me that was real ballroom dancing at its best. Do they audition the dancers?? If they did, they would not have wasted time dealing and begging Master P to wear the proper shoes because he would have knowledge of this before making the final cut.  Things must change, and in order to hold your TV audience,  I agree it should be cut to a hour's showing.  We don't need to see all the back stage rehearsals.  That's wasted fluff!! 
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?