MSN TV Blog - Reality TV

'Dancing With the Stars' Recap: Sherri Heads Home

Sherri Shepherd and Val Chmerkovskiy eliminated in a shocker

By Kate Mulcrone Apr 10, 2012 8:18PM

'Dancing With the Stars'/ABC

This was an incredibly tough -- maybe downright shocking -- elimination. Sherri's grace and enthusiasm for dance made her a favorite early on and seeing her in tears as she was eliminated was heartbreaking. Sherri thanked the producers for letting her "live the dream," and gave a shout-out to her partner, Val. She also encouraged everyone to live their dreams. Sherri thanked everyone and said she had the most amazing time dancing.

 

Bing: More about 'Dancing With the Stars' | Photos: Meet the cast of Season 14

 

Here's a quick look at how the remaining stars did this week:

 

Last Night on TV: Watch recaps | Video: Watch clips and more

 

Melissa Gilbert

After a close shave – Melissa suffered a mild concussion after this week's performance round – Melissa is still in the game. Her paso doble actually left Maks with a shoulder injury as well! Nonetheless, it was a good dance. Melissa has great rhythm and this dance really highlighted her stamina. Melissa got off to a rough start in this competition, but she has really brought her A-game the last two weeks. Let's hope the trend continues.


Gavin DeGraw

Gavin's tango was moody and measured, but a bit problematic. He had trouble moving with Karina, though they did pull off an amazing turn-and-roll toward the end of the routine. The judges didn't love this dance, but they did acknowledge how far Gavin has come this season.


Maria Menounos

Maria's tango was a coup, considering that she was dancing on an injured foot. She and Derek moved beautifully together. Bruno was a fan of the staccato action of the routine, which he dubbed "brilliant." Unfortunately, it's not clear how much Maria's injury will affect her performances going forward.


Jaleel White

Jaleel's winning tango was a lot flashier than his other routines have been. He and Kym moved well together and the routine struck a good balance between actual dance and flips and tricks. Jaleel has been strong throughout the competition, but he might need to set aside his cool-as-ice persona if he really wants to win hearts and minds.


Gladys Knight

Gladys' tango was a bit too studied, though, as always, her footwork was very precise. Len said Gladys needs to make her steps a bit quicker and that her posture isn't what it should be. This wasn't Gladys' best performance but everyone has an off week.


Donald Driver

Donald's shirtless paso doble was intense to the nth degree! There were some incredible spins in the routine and Donald kept pace with Peta and made sure his footwork was sharp and precise. The judges loved this one, especially Carrie Ann, who called it one of the most memorable dances of the season.


Katherine Jenkins

Katherine's intense paso doble was a hit with the crowd but wasn't exactly the judges' cup of tea. Bruno commented on a lack of precision and Carrie Ann took issue with the lack of cohesion in Katherine's footwork. Katherine has been No. 1 almost every week, but will she vault back to the top of the judges' leaderboard in the next round?


William Levy

William's rock 'n' roll jive brought out his funny side, though the routine was a bit of a disaster. William got thrown off in the middle of the routine and never quite got his groove back. In judges' critique, Carrie Ann encouraged him to stay focused. Let's hope he listens!


Roshon Fegan

Roshon's Viennese waltz was a real departure from his usual supercharged hip-hoppy routines. Bruno praised his elegant lines and Carrie Ann compared the routine to "watching the climax of a Disney movie." Roshon took a risk this week, and it paid off. I can't wait to see what he does next week.


Who won the week: Donald and Roshon

Who needs to step it up: Gladys

"Dancing With the Stars" airs Mondays at 8 p.m. ET/PT and Tuesdays at 9 p.m. ET/PT on ABC.

33Comments
Apr 10, 2012 9:05PM
avatar
what a shame the sherri  got sent home she was a delight to watch. There were several others who dances where well let's say not that great and they got better scores and are still there. There dance errors were obvious. Oh well derick or mark will probably win again. They need to give the others a chance.
Apr 11, 2012 1:44AM
avatar

I had a difficult time understanding the criticism of William's dance considering Cheryl was dancing on top of her high heels after her shoe was partially knocked off during the fumbled move early in the dance. While Cheryl did her professional best to keep up with the pace, the shoe situation threw her timing off just a hair and William was trying his best to adjust to the loss of Cheryl's lead. Of course, unlike the judges, I have the benefit of a DVR and was able to see just when Cheryl's shoe situation began and how it effected their dance.

 

Apr 11, 2012 1:54AM
avatar
Yes, it was a shame that Sherri went home but I don't think she had many followers that knew her and Val was great with her. But they were great to watch, thru her tears she thank everyone.  She was a good student and Val enjoyed her personality they were a good combination. This has been one close season from the start.
Apr 11, 2012 2:12AM
avatar
My shock was Roshon was one of the Bottom two!! He had the 2nd highest number after Donald, yet wound up at the bottom. Are folks not seeing what I see when he dances? The young guy is nimble, top notch, works really hard to make his dances flow, with a smile always.  Unbelievable!.  Sherry was a shocker, too. She's been positive, sunny, good dancer (little slip up now & then as do all ) but she sure didn't deserve to be the one to go tonight. Her Monday night dance was criticized partly for her "hard" face during her dance, yet it required that of that dance. Also, Val would have been the one to tell her how to look, maintain a sorta sinister look, if you will. Yet the novice always receives the blame. Very sad night all away around. 
Apr 11, 2012 2:14AM
avatar
Sherri should NOT have gone home.  I won't say who I thought should have left but its certainly was NOT Sherri!!!!
Apr 11, 2012 2:47AM
avatar
sherri should not have gotten the ax to go home, in my opinion and this is just my opinion Gavin should have been the one to go, think he is a terrible dancer, and as far as singer goes, do not know, but he is not a dancer in my book. next week he should be the one to go, but who knows, is always the least expected is the one to go. love sherri, she is funny and i loved her. Glady's better step it up, or she maybe next. i don't know, but her and gavin will be either one to go, if they do not do a flawless routine.just my opinion. thanks for listening.
Apr 11, 2012 3:13AM
avatar
Aw, give it a rest you guys. Sherri is endearing and funny, especially in her daytime gig on 'The View' but she's not a great dancer. That's what the show is supposed to be about.
Apr 11, 2012 3:26AM
avatar
Rock week rocked! Monday night may have been their best show ever!!
Apr 11, 2012 4:05AM
avatar

This Rock week thing is the Biggest waste of time and crap I have seen .. Honestly.

 

The music NEVER matches the dance ... none of the dances look right .. none of the dancers had real rhythm (even the pro's) and they all looked lost most of the time ... even the judges had no base to score it ...

 

It should never be repeated ... Dancing and music is suppose to match .. there is waltz, polka and latin music for a reason .... anyone who takes dancing seriously had to find monday a total joke

Apr 11, 2012 4:17AM
avatar

IMHO, I think Gladys was the weakest of them all this week and should of been the one to go home last night.

 

This season is fantastic. In all fairness to the entire dance group,  I think the audiences vote count should be lessened, in order to take away from them voting for the most popular rather then the individuals dance performance. This is a dance contest and not a popularity contest. Too many good dancers were sent home because they had a much smaller fan base ... not fair at all !!

 

Apr 11, 2012 4:23AM
avatar

Let's face it, in the end it is a popularity contest, and certainly not the best dancers.  I do think this is the best cast ever.  I think Katherine is probably the best, but I don't believe that she is not a dancer in addition to being an opera singer.  I doubt Mark would have made her that good.  I think it is sad to see anyone go from this group.

Apr 11, 2012 4:28AM
avatar
If you people ever want to see the best dancers win .. and if you want it REALLY judged on CORRECT dancing for the DANCE done .. then let Len and 2 other like him judge it PERIOD ... until then it is just a joke with 2 judges who aren't very good and there for show and a PR stunt letting the audience judge ...
Apr 11, 2012 5:03AM
avatar
dont u ever get tried of watchung derick have u ever noticee he never gets a fat or old person to dance with talk aboutn the show been fixed when he comes on i turn the channel for 5 mintues i cant stand his cockie attiude
Apr 11, 2012 5:27AM
avatar

...I thought this "SHOW" was taken off the air last year. I hope this "FIXED bullcrap disappears. or moves to late-night. I don't really care. I watch a little FoxFinancial, Antiques Roadshow and

a lot of N.C.I.S and Rockford Files...   God Bless America...AGAIN !

Apr 11, 2012 5:32AM
avatar
I thought Gladys Knight should have gone home instead of Sherrie.  In the beginning it is a popularity vote and finally the best dancer does get left to win.  Still where were the Sherrie voters?????????    The first two voted off were correct but this was a surprise.
Apr 11, 2012 5:43AM
avatar
You know. I heard stuff about Sherri's partner before. He is some dude that used to go to my high school (small private school in Brooklyn, NY). I am glad he is succesful, but what's with the kissing. On show before she was eliminated he kissed her like 20 times. Makes me want to vomit. If he gets this sexually aroused during the dance, he should bring any of his many girfriends ( I am sure ) before the show to relieve him or relieve himself. Painful to watch. If I was a girl and I saw that, I'd be like: no way is this guy my partner. Very unprofessional.
Apr 11, 2012 5:58AM
avatar

My opinion. Sherri needed to go. Why should she have stayed? She was not that good of a dancer. Everyone got a kick out of her because she would go jumping around, shaking her head with that mouth. She is a nice lady, no argument. But you can't keep voting for "she is so funny". Many of us grew up with Gladys. What an amazing icon. But, no big deal in dancing. She should be next. Unless Melissa can't do it. Even the NFL is took a strong stand on concussions. Many players cannot play for weeks until finally cleared.

Surprised about Roshon being one of the bottom 2? Easy explanation. Name 1 disney kid who made. Only (forget her name) the gal who danced with Mark the same time Kirstie Alley danced. She was great. Kyle Massey. Didn't he make 3rd?

In addition, Roshon is to much Hip Hop. Plus he has dance experience. Maybe the viewers are tired of watching that style in Ballroom Dancing? Too cocky? Who knows, but I am not surprised.

Kirstie Alley lost her shoe during the dance and F'Bombed on camera while she struggled to get it back on while Maks improvised. Cheryl losing her shoe is no big deal. They are still good.

Great show this year. What needs to be done is get rid of the non-dancers right away. Then we have a real battle of the dancers. I have been watching since it's been on, and this would be the biggest free for all ever.

Brooke didn't look so good last night.

 

Apr 11, 2012 6:11AM
avatar

The voting was really screwy this week!  I can't believe Rashon was in the bottom 2. Where are all his young fans? He is one of the best non-professional dancers the show has had in several seasons. I thought Melissa would be going this week-unless some gave her the 'sympathy vote'-but I don't think anyone knew she went to the hospital until well after the show aired. But...Rashon???? Bottom 2???? What gives????


Everydude: What about the lovey-dovey actions between Derek and Maria?? Derek is practically making love to her each week! (Well, there ARE rumors they are a couple....)  LOL Most of the pros have their hands and arms all over their partners (and vice versa) during the judges' critiques and when they are 'on the couch'. That's just the way it is!!!

 

 

Apr 11, 2012 6:29AM
avatar

that guy Gavin ought to have gone - Improved?? From a complete stick of wood to one that moves its arms - whippee!

It really doesn't matter because they have already chosen Katherine to win it Eye-rolling

Apr 11, 2012 6:32AM
avatar
I think they should leave the judging to the professionals. The audience has favorites and part of a fan base. They are going to support their candidate. Its about structure and  performance of the dance  not popularity votes.
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

primetime tonight

meet the bloggers

Deanna Barnert

Deanna Barnert | Los Angeles, Calif.

Entertainment journalist Deanna "TVDeeva" Barnert visits sets, interviews industry players and critiques the final product. Buzz's daytime TV queen covers it all for MSN TV, but loves her sitcoms, soaps and any juicy drama that doesn't call itself Reality TV.

Discovered