TV Recaps Blog

'The X Factor' Boot Camp 2: Tears and Fears

Contestants cry, fight and forget lyrics as they pair up and battle head-to-head

By MSN TV Oct 4, 2012 7:53PM
'The X Factor'/FOXBy Jilliane Johnson

Buddy TV 

 

Wipe those nightmarish memories of the presidential debate from your mind, folks! This is Night 2 of boot camp at "The X Factor"! Wednesday night (the first of boot camp), the judges found that they made a few mistakes when choosing some of the 120 acts who made it to boot camp. At the end of the day, a group of hopefuls were eliminated. And more will make the long journeys home after Night 2, as well.

 

Bing: 'The X Factor' | Photos: See the hopefuls | LNOTV: Watch recaps

 

The competition heats up even more as the remaining contestants battle one another head-to-head for those coveted plane tickets to the judges' homes. With so much on the line, emotions will be running rampant, as expected. Many will cry. Many will forget their lyrics. And many just might do both!

 

More: 'The X Factor' on BuddyTV | Video: Watch clips and more


It's Day 2 at the Mondrian Hotel in Miami, Fla., and there are only 60 acts remaining. Each act will be paired up with another and battle for a spot at the judges' homes. Each pair may end up going or leaving together. Simon explains that the breakdown of the songs is completely up to them. After this, there will only be 24 acts in the competition. There is a lot of pressure riding on this day.

Tara Simon has been paired up against Jennel Garcia. And, of course, Miss Résumé is calling all the shots. Jennel better speak up or she'll be kicked out before showing who she really is.

Tara Simon vs. Jennel Garcia, "Landslide" by Fleetwood Mac

Jennel is obviously nervous, but Tara is over-singing her portion of the song. "I don't know why you chose that song," says Simon. Looks like Tara shot herself in the foot, taking Jennel down with her.

Carly Rose Sonenclar vs. Beatrice Miller, "Pumped Up Kicks" by Foster the People

Should these young teenage girls be singing something with such content? Actually, if this were "The Voice," no one would realize that they were underage. While both are good, Carly Rose is the obvious winner. Demi is worried about their being so young in the business: She's been there.

Vino Alan vs. David Correy, "What's Going On" by Marvin Gaye


David means well. But before the music starts, he tells Simon, Britney, Demi and L.A. that they represent the four roadblocks keeping him from his dream. On to the singing. David has a great voice, but Vino holds so much emotion in his voice. Britney's eyes tear up, but Vino doesn't see this because he believes he's messed up his chance. I think he's in for a big surprise.

Diamond White vs. Dinah Jane Hansen, "Stronger" by Kelly Clarkson

The girls have taken the pop song and stretched it into a mellow ballad. Dinah starts it off really great but quickly forgets the lyrics. She knows immediately that she's messed it up. Diamond comes in next, singing her out of the water. L.A. calls her last move "genius."

It's about time for a montage! This next group shows us that those who sing second come out on top. Lauren Jauregui outshines the Sister C trio. Reed Deming is younger and better than Brandon Hansen. Rocker Julia Bullock is put to shame by Ally Brooke. And they don't even give the name of the guy Jeffrey Gutt battles.

And now for something very random ...

Wade, the lucky "X Factor" assistant, presents the judges with the official "X Factor drink," which Demi previously selected: Dragon. The drink is appropriately named Pepsi X.

Willie Jones vs. Tate Stevens, "Nobody Knows It But Me" by Babyface


This is probably the most painful to watch yet. A kid with such talent, Willie gets choked up and completely forgets the lyrics. He improvises, but it's all downhill. Tate comes in and gives a mediocre performance. However, standing up against pretty much nothing will probably ensure that he gets to the next leg of the competition. L.A. inquires about the song choice. It turns out that Tate picked the song after knowing that Willie had never heard it. Strategic or competitive? Either way, it was a low blow.

Normani Hamilton vs. Arin Ray, "What Makes You Beautiful" by One Direction

These two are cute and apparently crushing on each other. Arin tells the cameras in the previous package that he has to stay focused. Onstage, I think they may both see themselves at the judges' homes. "I wouldn't want to perform with anyone else," says Arin as he and Normani stand backstage. Demi's and many other Americans' hearts just melted.

Jillian Jensen vs. Latosha Robinson, "Stay" by Sugarland

Latasha's attitude takes over, I'm guessing, and the lyrics flee her mind. Jillian attempts to help her, but Latasha is too busy running her mouth to listen. Jillian steps up and out of her shell and kills the song. So much passion and emotion.

Forgotten lyrics have been a recurring theme on this night, unfortunately. Four more contestants freeze on stage. Freddie Combs, Jessie Bryant, Nick Youngerman and Jordan Shane are among those that we probably will not see moving forward. Next time, try writing the words on your hand or something. Anything is better than repeating the same "oohs" and "aahs" over and over.

By the way, Britney cries again because the last girl ran offstage crying.

CeCe Frey vs. Paige Thomas, "Secrets" by One Republic

This is it -- the battle everyone has been looking forward to. CeCe already has the upper hand, walking out on stage with leopard prints down her thigh and knowing the song beforehand. While explaining why she should be the winner, Paige begins crying. CeCe gives her explanation along with rehearsed tears.

This is more than a singing competition. These hopefuls have to stand up for themselves and understand their comfort levels and what they can actually sing. Paige breaks down admitting in front of CeCe that she didn't want to sing the song. She mumbled through it, allowing CeCe to hit all the high notes and shine in front of the judges. Or perhaps the judges see through it?

Next week, the names are called. Some will go home, probably crying more tears, and others will get the chance to work one-on-one with their celebrity mentor at their home. Which judge will get which group? Tune in to "The X Factor" next Wednesday night.

 

"The X Factor" airs Wednesdays and Thursdays at 8 p.m. ET/PT on FOX.

7Comments
Oct 5, 2012 8:20AM
avatar

No one person chooses the song, you can't say it's a low blow by Tate.  There were a lot of people who didn't know their lyrics, most of them blamed the other contestant for choosing the song.  Accountability has to start somewhere..  If Willie didn't know the song, no one was forcing him to sing, they chose the song together.  I think the way they made Tate look was very, very unfair and I think your statement is even worse.  Looks like Tate's taking the fall because he's the older one, tacky.  They are both great singers, Willie just could not peform and that's the bottom line.

Oct 5, 2012 8:10AM
avatar

OMG slim-ster.... i will be agreeing with u again.    someone hide the sharp knives. 

 

like i said, i hope they keep the last 2.  whoever allows them to even attempt some of those songs shud get a cranial enema. 

 

the "peek" for next week was sly.....not showing any faces. 

Oct 5, 2012 7:58AM
avatar

   "Many will cry, many will forget their lyrics, and many just might do both!"   Well, done Jillian.  How about kick off the ones that 'did both' right away, save time and trouble?

   I'm looking at darkhorses at this point of the season.   The Huntington Beach guys, the girls harmony group, the very young/skinny black girl who kneeled in front of the judges at the end of her song, and the little Justin Beaver boy.  The pumped up kicks girls are strong, probably favorites, they don't need my support.   It is a TV show, though, so what's the guess?  1/2 of the 24 will be TV-drama-conflict choices.  AND of course, there will be either/or both the 'rockers' for the Josh Kratchet fans (who won't ever buy new songs again), Ole Tat-face and Mr. Earring Lip, are probably shoe-ins, sorry to say... 

Oct 5, 2012 5:21AM
avatar

CHOKE!   the word of the night!   some of the "battles" were downright boring - retooling songs does not help their efforts - those should both go home.  others forgot the lyrics which should make their departure easy.  NERVES?  most assuredly.  they saved the best for last but one didnt show up.  which one of the last 2 should go?  both should STAY AND GO ON. 

Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?