TV Recaps Blog

'Downton Abbey:' The road less traveled

The season finale ends with a shocking twist

By Kate Mulcrone Feb 17, 2013 9:59PM

Downton Abbey | PBS


The Season 3 finale was the most shocking episode of "Downton Abbey" to date – and ended with the sudden death of another Crawley. We last saw the Crawleys in September 1921, when they hosted the village's annual cricket match. The finale opened a year later, in September 1922. In the first scene the staff at Downton was busily packing for a family trip to Scotland. We saw at once that Mary was pregnant, and soon learned that something else was cooking between Edith and her editor Michael Gregson.


Bing: 'Downton Abbey' | More on Dan Stevens


With the gentry gone for 10 days, Carson asked the staff to polish the silver and clean the house from top to bottom. New maid Edna quizzed Mrs. Hughes on Sybil and Tom's past – "She was a wonderful person. And a beauty," Mrs. Hughes told her. In other words, back off. Tom was the only Crawley to remain at the abbey, and so Edna wasted no time in trying to get close to him. And she wasn't the only one with a crush – village grocer Mr. Tufton took a shine to Mrs. Patmore.


Rose had obviously cleaned up her act in the year since we saw her pawing at a married man. Susan and Hugh (a.k.a. Shrimpy), Rose's parents, are even stuffier than Lady Violet at her worst, and it soon became clear how strained their marriage was. Anna, Bates, Mosley, and O'Brien bristled at the stiff formality belowstairs at Duneagle Castle, where the MacClares' servants addressed them by their masters' names rather than their own. The Bateses, at least, had a pretty good time in the end. Anna learned to reel, and she and Bates were even able to sneak away for a picnic.


Shrimpy told Robert that he was about to take a post in India while the men were out hunting, and Susan told Lady Violet, her aunt, that she wasn't too enthusiastic about the plan. O'Brien listened eagerly to Miss Wilkins, Lady Susan's maid's, complain about her future overseas, and then managed to wheedle her way into Lady Susan's bedroom to set her hair for dinner.


Edna followed Tom to the village pub and suggested that he should join the servants for dinner instead of eating alone. Meanwhile, Mrs. Hughes did her best to persuade Carson to let the staff attend a fair in the next village.


Michael Gregson came to Duneagle Castle and had to run the Crawley gauntlet. Mary disapproved of the attention he paid to Edith, whereas Matthew seemed pleased for his sister-in-law. Gregson admitted to Edith that he came to Scotland for the sole purpose of getting to know her family – remember that he is not free to marry, since he has a wife in a mental institution. Gregson told Edith that he loved her and wanted to be in her life, but she told him she just couldn't see how that would work.


Robert and Shrimpy went deer hunting before joining the ladies for a picnic lunch on the day before a ball to be held at Duneagle Castle. Meanwhile, Matthew and Gregson went fishing. Gregson told Matthew he was in love with Edith but unable to divorce. Matthew was sympathetic, but encouraged Gregson to tell Edith goodbye at the ball since he couldn't see Edith "throwing herself away" to be with him.


Tom did finally join the staff dinner and ended up offering to drive everyone to the fair. Mrs. Hughes took him aside and told him the gesture wasn't necessary, but it was certainly appreciated. "If someone is trying to make you feel awkward, that person is in the wrong, not you," she said.


At the fair Jimmy won a bit of dough by betting on the Downton crew to win a tug-of-war – and Mrs. Patmore and Tufton get quite friendly. Unfortunately, Mrs. Hughes saw Tufton flirting with other women at the fair. Jimmy flashed his money around and stumbled into a culvert, where two of the men from the losing tug-of-war team jumped him. Thomas came to his aid, but got badly beaten up for his trouble!


Dr. Clarkson and Isobel Crawley also went to the fair together. Over lemonade the doctor asked Isobel whether she ever thought of marrying again. She cooly declared she was happy on her own, but he seemed about to press on with a proposal until their cozy chat was interrupted by Jimmy.


Susan gave Rose quite a dressing-down as she prepared for the ball at Duneagle, and then Susan and Shrimpy got into a screaming match just before the festivities began. Susan also gave Miss Wilkins a hard time about not being able to do hair as well as O'Brien did. Miss Wilkins spiked O'Brien's punch as revenge. What goes around comes around, right? Unfortunately it was Mosley, not O'Brien, who drank it and then distinguished himself ball's token drunken idiot.


Over billiards, Hugh told Robert that he was about to lose Duneagle Castle because he failed to modernize the estate the way Robert – actually Matthew! – did at Downton. Later, Robert admitted to Cora that he had finally realized how invaluable his son-in-law was to the family, and that he was sorry he had been the last to see it.


After the ball, Mary told Matthew she wasn't feeling well and that she would return to Downton early the next day, but that she wanted him to stay so that the rest of the family would stay put.


When Mrs. Patmore came to tell Mrs. Hughes that Mr. Tufton had declared his love, poor Mrs. Hughes had to set her straight. Mrs. Patmore seemed pretty relieved not to be boiling the man's cabbage, so all ended well there. 


Edna barged into Tom's room while he was undressing, on the flimsy pretext of telling him that Thomas was much better. He asked her to leave and she...brazenly kissed him! Less than 24 hours later Mrs. Hughes gave her the boot. When Tom asked Mrs. Hughes to give Edna a good reference She told him how well he had done fitting into his new role as estate manager and how proud Lady Sybil would have been of him. Tom burst into tears, confessing to Mrs. Hughes how much he missed his wife.


The morning after the ball Susan asked Cora if Rose could live at Downton when the MacClares headed to India. 


Mary felt labor coming on and went straight to the hospital from the train station. At the hospital, Isobel held Mary's hand in a sweet moment between two women who haven't always gotten along well. She gave birth to a baby boy, the first little boy to be born at Downton for a long, long time, and the heir that Lord Grantham had always hoped for. Matthew told Mary how happy she made him, and that he had fallen more in love with her every day of their marriage, as they cooed over their new son. But happiness never lasts long for the Crawleys – on the way back to Downton from the hospital, distracted Matthew drove straight into a truck and was killed instantly. In the last scene, Mary, knowing nothing of her husband's fate, smiled down at her new baby.


This season brought more sorrow – and change – to Downton Abbey than any other. Two members of the Crawley family have died, but a new generation was founded as well. And it wasn't all bad news -- Bates found his way back to Anna, and Edith found an unconventional love after her disastrous aborted wedding. Will the next season bring more hope than heartbreak? We'll have to wait a year to find out.


Want more TV? Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.

44Comments
Feb 19, 2013 12:54PM
avatar
As much as I enjoy "Downtown Abbey," it's just a TV show.  Matthew Crawley's untimely end at the end of season 3 was explained away when the actor playing him decided not to come back for season 4, which seems a reasonable explanation for a character in the series.  After all, when any of the staff characters don't come back, they're just sent packing to new jobs, but not so with family members, who have to be dispensed with a bit more creativity.  I was really looking forward to seeing more of Shirley McClaine in season 3, but apparently her story arc was rather short-lived, which is also a creative choice.  I'll be back to watch season 4 when the "Abbey" returns, but it's still just a TV show. 
Feb 19, 2013 12:32PM
avatar
I think this was a very uncreative ending for Downton Season 3.  I am very disappointed that Julian Fellowes and the writers resorted to killing off another major character to create a new dramatic theme for Season 4.  I really didn't need Matthew Crawley dead to motivate me to watch Season 4.  Seems like a creative cop-out as they could not come up with anything else to keep the Downton high drama moving.  I am so disappointed that it puts a damper on the series for me.  I really love it and hate to critisize more creative individuals than myself, but this really struck me as a melodramatic cop-out.  I will of course watch Season 4 and I am sure I will still like the show, but this took the series off of the pedestal for sure! 
Feb 19, 2013 10:42AM
avatar

I sure hope Dan Stevens knows what he's doing.  I never saw him in ANYTHING else; he's perfect as Matthew Crawley and should kiss Julian Fellows' _ _ _ to get back on in time for Season 4.  He's going to fall flat on his face.

 

Feb 19, 2013 10:37AM
avatar
Maybe like on all soaps Matthew can return as a ghost......or the evil twin......remember boys and girls he was only contracted for 3 seasons.....and yup 3 seasons was all they let him play......I cannot think of any more plots they can come up with that will make it entertaining.....but please PBS let the dowager live.....please!!!!!!
Feb 19, 2013 10:09AM
avatar

Too much tragedy.  WIth the death of Matthew, I will not continue to watch. 

Feb 19, 2013 9:43AM
avatar
NOT AT ALL HAPPY WITH SEASON 3 DEMISE OF MATTHEW.   THIS CHARACTER AND THE ACTOR THAT PLAYED HIM WAS A KEY PART TO THE DOWNTON ABBEY SUCCESS.  LET'S HOPE THAT LADY EDITH GETS A BREAK AND O'BRIEN GETS "ONE'S JUST DESSERTS" AS SHE PUT IT TO TAKE AWAY THE STING OF HAVING MATTHEW KILLED OFF.   WHAT A LET DOWN TO SEE HOW THE STORY UNFOLDED - SYBIL GONE, NOW THIS.  YES, I HAVE A LIFE BUT THIS SHOW WAS GREAT FUN TO WATCH - NOW IT WON'T BE AS MUCH.  MR. STEVENS, HOPE YOU KNOW WHAT YOU'RE DOING..........
Feb 19, 2013 9:03AM
avatar

Doesn't anyone care about the car?

Feb 19, 2013 4:10AM
avatar
Devastated!!! First Sybil, Now Matthew. It feels like a big chunk of the heart, of the show has been cut out.
Feb 18, 2013 9:48PM
avatar

 I have enjoyed the last two seasons very much, I have watched some episodes over and over again,

loved the dresses and the way people behaved in mid 1900, however the end of season three was very melodramatic. I am sure that the directors/producers could have invented a better ending to keep

us all viewers eager to watch the next season. We all loved cousin Mathew, however his tragic and sudden death really leaves a very bad feeling to all of us. Are you people ready to watch

the next season full of so much melodrama?

 

I believe I may not be watching the next season......

 

  

Feb 18, 2013 7:28PM
avatar
I think all of us are just in shock this show is  incrediable you feel like your part of the family the servants love them to bits after the shock I thought today how is next year going to be cant wait love granny thought that mathews mother was reallly going to marry the ol doctor and the cook my heart went out to her and the ladys maid when she spiked that drink and the other ladies maid knew about it I alway thought she was a kind of villan but i tip my hat off to her for not drinking the cup of booze
Feb 18, 2013 6:17PM
avatar
Say it isn't so.  He cannot be dead!  Maybe his life flashes before his eyes and he is in a coma for 3 months.  The love story between Mary & Matthew is the key to the future and makes the show so fun to watch.  The development of these characters from shallow young people to coming into their own as heartwarming adults has been an enjoyable experience.  Not sure there is much story left without Matthew! 
Feb 18, 2013 6:05PM
avatar

Last night's ending was a major bummer.  I couldn't sleep.  I stayed up watching TV and guess what came on...again?  A rerun of the same episode.

Feb 18, 2013 5:39PM
avatar
I am a sixty nine year old male who has seen a lot over the years and the ending last night absolutely broke my heart and it moved me to real tears.  This is such a masterpiece of storytelling and so compelling as it takes the viewer into another world and folds them so tightly into its warm and uplifting embrace.  It is like I lost a member of my own family.  Matthew turned out to be the center of the wheel, a figuarative catalyst for the others and their stories as they became its very compelling spokes.  The heart of the story and a good portion of its "magic" has gone with his passing.  Please bring him back, whatever it takes. 
Feb 18, 2013 4:41PM
avatar
Do what all of the soaps do- just get another Matthew look alike to play the part. This was an extremely unhappy ending for a much loved character. I refuse to believe he's dead. Let's have another miracle!
avatar

its the best show on TV all so real,after spending 3yrs in England I just love the English,can't waif

for the new season.

Feb 18, 2013 3:54PM
avatar
I have to say I was taken by surprise at the end of the show last night. I first started watching Downton this season. I liked it so much i wanted to catch up and i ordered season 1 & 2.  This show even though Matthew dies was brilliant because it was unexpected.  So much happens on each showing. Love Masterpiece for creating such a masterpiece of a show. I haven't seen such a show since Brideshead.
Feb 18, 2013 2:15PM
avatar
I felt the writer's hit the nail on the head and that what must be must be. After bringing my partner up to speed about past show's, at the end of the season finale he said, WHAT? We have to wait till next season to see what happens. LOL. Great way to end the season and love where the show is going!
Feb 18, 2013 1:54PM
avatar
By the way, PBS has NOTHING to do with this show.  They buy it straight from England as is.  All the creative decisions are made in England.
Feb 18, 2013 1:53PM
avatar
People, get a grip.  The actor who plays Matthew didn't want to renew his contract.  He only signed on for three seasons and now he's done.  How else should they have written him out?  Would you have been happier if a) he divorced Mary for some other woman, b) was simply replaced by another actor playing the same role, or c) "went missing" ala some stupid daytime soap opera?  Besides killing him, those are basically the only ways to carry on the show without that actor.
Feb 18, 2013 1:39PM
avatar
I just went to pbs.org to let them know how I feel.  Look for programs, click masterpiece, click FAQ's, scroll to the bottom and click feedback.  It's hard to find but they need to know they screwed up.
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?