TV Recaps Blog

'The Voice' top 6 results: A favorite goes home

Amanda Brown eliminated in a shocker, luck runs out for Melanie Martinez

By MSN TV Dec 4, 2012 8:45PM

'The Voice'/NBC

By John Kubicek

Buddy TV

 

It seems like only yesterday the coaches on "The Voice" were hitting their buttons and turning their chairs in the blind auditions. Now, here we are on the verge of the Season 3 semifinals, as the top 4 singers are revealed.

 

Bing: 'The Voice' | Photos: See more of the action from Season 3 | LNOTV: Watch recaps
 
Will another coach join Christina Aguilera on the sidelines, with nothing to do but sing Fiona Apple songs and desperately try to jump onto Blake Shelton's bandwagon?

 

More: 'The Voice' on Buddy TV | Video: Watch clips and more

We'll also find out if being in the iTunes top 10 continues to ensure safety. This week, half of the artists achieved that honor, with Terry McDermott, Nicholas David and Cassadee Pope all cracking the top 10. To their credit, Trevin Hunte reached 11 with his "Dreamgirls" cover, and both of Melanie Martinez's songs were in the top 20.

Still, I'm predicting Trevin and Melanie as the two going home, though I acknowledge there's a decent chance that, in a surprise upset, Amanda Brown might go home. We'll find out soon enough.

This is "The Voice"!

Wardrobe Watch: Xtina is in a pink wig. C'mon, girl, stop trying so hard. You have nothing else to do on the show, so bust out the sweatpants and a bag full of cheese puffs. Cee Lo Green is adorned in a sequined black suit jacket.

It turns out there were four artists in the top 10 for iTunes. This means four of the contestants get their iTunes votes multiplied by 10. So does that mean the other two (Melanie and Amanda) are automatically gone? If so, I think "The Voice" needs to change this stupid x10 rule.

 

"Let Me Love You" by Ne-Yo and Amanda Brown

 

All I know about Ne-Yo is that this is the same song I fast-forwarded through while watching "90210" last week. Also, I'm pretty sure the rest of California is suffering a smoke machine shortage, because "The Voice" is using all of them this season.

Carson Daly commends Cee Lo Green because, during the blind auditions, he pushed his button for everyone who made the top 10. That says less about his good taste and more about the fact that he's a button slut who gives it away for everyone.

 

Want more TV? Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.

 

Duet No. 1: Terry McDermott and Trevin Hunte ("Feel Again" by OneRepublic)

 

We get three duets to fill time tonight. This is an odd pairing, but I kind of like it. The song definitely benefits Terry's style, but Trevin adds some nice soul to it as well.

 

Results: Part 1

 

The first singer in the final 4 is ... Terry McDermott!

Good for him. His Foreigner performance was stellar, and now I think it's safe to assume Team Blake will have two singers in the semifinals, since Cassadee Pope is going to win the whole thing.

 

Duet No. 2: Amanda Brown and Cassadee Pope ("Breakaway" by Kelly Clarkson)

 

This song doesn't really fit Amanda's style. It's decent for Cassadee, as it highlights some of the country twang that Blake desperately wants to drag out of her. Maybe it's just me, but neither of them sounds particularly good. I feel like they're phoning it in.

 

Results: Part 2

 

The second singer in the final 4 is ... Trevin Hunte!

Ugh. I can't believe America fell for that "Dreamgirls" performance of desperation. Why isn't everyone else as over Trevin as I am? This also kind of killed the suspense, because I'm almost 100 percent certain Cassadee and Nicholas will be safe, so it seems like it's gonna be curtains for Team Adam.

 

"Overjoyed" by Matchbox 20, Nicholas David and Trevin Hunte

 

Rob Thomas is a whore. And that's all I have to say about that.

 

"The Voice" confessional

 

Everyone does impressions of the coaches. Melanie is by far the best at impersonating everyone. And Terry's mocking Adam's overpriced T-shirts with holes in them was great, too.

 

Results: Part 3

 

The third singer in the final 4 is ... Cassadee Pope!

No surprise there, since I keep saying she's gonna win the whole thing. Team Blake is looking very strong. Now I'm just crossing my fingers that Nicholas David somehow goes, since he has been a thorn in my side ever since he beat out my beloved Mackenzie Bourg in the live playoffs. Yes, I'm still bitter.

 

Duet No. 3: Melanie Martinez and Nicholas David ("Criminal" by Fiona Apple)

 

Congratulations, Xtina, you got your wish. This is one weird combo of voices, but I kind of love it. They're both so out there that it works. The only problem is that we know at least one of these two is going home soon, so it's a little uncomfortable.

 

Results: Part 4

 

Things are being changed up, as they're eliminating one singer earlier than usual. Good, now the eliminated singer can actually get a little screen time.

 

Melanie Martinez is eliminated!

 

Not much of a surprise. I honestly believe the only reason that she made it this far is because she made it into the top 10 on iTunes for the past two weeks, and got her votes multiplied by 10. To her credit, she's the last singer left from the four contestants the judges saved during the live playoffs. Maybe if she and Adam had focused more on her singing and less on creating a magical stage performance, she wouldn't be going home.

 

The final results

 

Then there were two. Will Adam Levine join Xtina on the sidelines, or will my own personal nightmare come to an end?

The fourth singer in the final 4 is ... Nicholas David!

 

Amanda Brown is eliminated!

 

That's a damn shame. So now Team Adam is done, and the semifinals will pit Team Cee Lo against Team Blake.

I think now is definitely the time to reevaluate the iTunes top 10 voting rule. The fact that the four singers who made the top 10 -- and therefore got their iTunes votes multiplied by 10 -- are safe, while the two who didn't are going home, clearly suggests it was probably an important factor in the decision.

 

BuddyTV: Check out John Kubicek's pre-show predictions and analysis

 

BuddyTV: Don't miss another episode! Keep up with your favorite shows, like "The Voice," using the BuddyTV Guide app!

 

"The Voice" airs Mondays and Tuesdays at 8 p.m. ET/PT on NBC.

17Comments
Dec 6, 2012 8:41AM
avatar

cassadee OVER amanda?   no way.   cassadee has a limited vocal range....amanda does NOT!   cassadee is one style cooker cutter....amanda is NOT!

 

FYI... an "adele sized" singer won THE VOICE UK because of her VOICE....not cute but could truly sing.   the show is called THE VOICE.... not THE CUTESY. 

 

stop with the "times 10".... it ruins the voting.. 

 

 

Dec 5, 2012 6:26PM
avatar
Adam Levine offers a contract to Melanie and not Amanda? I would buy a CD from Amanda in a heartbeat. Come on Adam - step up and give a contract to Amanda. She is so AWESOME!!!!
Dec 5, 2012 12:33PM
avatar
You are a terrible critic!  First of all get your facts straight - Amanda Brown was also a contestant saved in the playoffs!  The artists should be rewarded for making top 10 on the ITunes chart and by all means they should keep going in the competition because America likes their music/voices.  Again you are a terrible critic!
Dec 5, 2012 12:05PM
avatar
Oops..forgot Nicholas. No, he´s not my cup of tea, but that´s only because I´m not into the soul thing. I do like his voice and the fact that he´s very definitely one-of-a-kind. He´s in the top 4 because he deserves to be. The whole point of The Voice is to find someone with true talent, not worry about whether or not he/she is going to make the fashion mags.
Dec 5, 2012 12:00PM
avatar

I liked Melanie. There was no way she was going to win, but her voice was different and she usually put a neat spin on cookie cutter songs.

 

If Cassadee Pope wins, then you´ll soon see her CDs in the 99 cent rack. I´m sorry. Good voice, but boring. There is absolutely nothing special about her that would make me rush out and buy anything she does.

 

Amanda Brown was robbed. No, she didn´t have a chance to win, but she could have easily been second. What a voice!

 

I´m not a fan of Trevin. Yes, when he´s serious, he can sing, but again...it gets old listening to singers think they have to sing an entire scale for one note. Having said that, I think he´s definitely going to go far long after the show is over.

 

So...I´m rooting for Terry. He actually has a voice and puts a unique spin on the songs he sings. And the cute Scottish accent doesn´t hurt! Seriously, I hope he wins. I´d buy his music because I think he truly is talented.

 

 

Dec 5, 2012 8:53AM
avatar

Nicholas David   looks like the guy that plays  captain spalding in rob zombies "night of a thousand corpses"

The whole show is a worthless piece of crap. in 3 seasons it hasn't produced anyone with a name people can remember let alone something worthwhile musically.

Dec 5, 2012 7:41AM
avatar

While I'm crushed Amanda was eliminated, I really can't argue with the iTunes rule.  When you look back on all the singers and bands who became famous, its the ones that were commercially viable that stood the test of time.   The iTunes rule proves that in the world that is this show.

That said, I hope Amanda does get the success she truly deserves.

Dec 5, 2012 3:56AM
avatar
Oh, John Kubicek, you're so low on the totem pole of entertainment blogging -- hell, on the totem pole of blogging in general -- that it's actually pretty comic at this point to hear you bitching like a little brat who thinks anyone who's listening actually cares (**psst** no one does). You are such a pathetically bad "critic." Have an opinion, but at least have one with substance instead of one with the immature subjectivity of a child.

I've never really rooted for him, but Trevin killed it yesterday. He brought his A-game, and even though he was once again in his comfort zone, doing nothing different or groundbreaking, he earned his keep. However, there seem to be lots of Trevin types out there in the music industry already. His voice is, in my opinion, thrilling but a dime a dozen.

Cassadee's save was a given. No further comment. Terry's save I saw coming and feel he deserved.

And I'm thrilled -- THA-RILLED! -- that your "nightmare" continues. **fist pump** I hope "it" gives you frequent heart palpitations and makes you wet your bed at night. You deserve it, considering your "nightmare" has done nothing but give consistent, vocally solid performances while instilling each with a raw, visceral, and unique quality that I can confidently bet money most of today's musical "artists" wouldn't stand a chance of emulating. But we get it, John, we get it. You don't like the way your "nightmare" looks or dresses. He doesn't fit your cookie-cutter, generic-pretty-boy fantasy. And that's of course OBVIOUSLY the deciding factor when it comes to judging true vocal talent. Totes. Like, duh.

Melanie's elimination didn't surprise me, but I was astonished and a little sad that Amanda was nixed. Yet somehow, I feel she'll rise from the ashes at some point. She got herself noticed on this show, proved to be versatile, and Adam, as douchey and slimy and, quite frankly, irrelevant to the music industry in the long run as he is, this time might just mean what he says (to all of his contestants, every single season) when he says to Amanda that he will always have her back (i.e., that he'll hook her up, if not by signing her, then at least by introducing her to people who will). ... Even though it will probably be in the hopes of getting in her pants.

So, John ... I'm wondering ... are you a pedo? Because your taste for little boys is weird and unsettling. Dez. MacKenzie. Even Cody. I bet you like Justin Bieber and One Direction, too.
Dec 5, 2012 1:32AM
avatar
Amanda was robbed by an old hippy...serious talent and incredible beauty was ousted by an old Dr.John  wannabe what has America done???????
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

primetime tonight

meet the bloggers

Deanna Barnert

Deanna Barnert | Los Angeles, Calif.

Entertainment journalist Deanna "TVDeeva" Barnert visits sets, interviews industry players and critiques the final product. Buzz's daytime TV queen covers it all for MSN TV, but loves her sitcoms, soaps and any juicy drama that doesn't call itself Reality TV.